Francois Benjamin Courvoisier was a Swiss-born valet in the service of an elderly former member of Parliament in London. On the night of May 5, 1840, or in the early hours of May 6, his employer, Lord William Russell, was killed in London. Within days the valet was under arrest. In June he stood trial at the Central Criminal Court, the Old Bailey, pleaded not guilty and was convicted of murder. He was executed in London on July 6, 1840.
The verdict alone would have made the case a large story in 1840. The dead man had sat in the House of Commons at intervals between 1789 and 1830, and the accused came from his own household. What kept the case alive long after the execution was something that happened in the middle of the trial, when Courvoisier told his own leading counsel that he had committed the murder.
Courvoisier was born in Switzerland in 1816. By the spring of 1840 he was valet to the old politician, a post of trust in a household of servants with no family living in it. The man he served had been out of the House for ten years.
The death was discovered on the morning of Wednesday, May 6, and the police inquiry began the same day. Officers soon came to believe that whoever was responsible had been inside the household all along, and attention turned to the servants. On May 7 the government published a notice from Whitehall in the official Gazette, promising a pardon to any accomplice, other than the person who had actually committed the murder, who would give up the others, and announcing a reward from the Lords Commissioners of the Treasury.
Courvoisier was taken into custody on Sunday, May 10, 1840, and held at Newgate.
His trial opened at the Central Criminal Court on Thursday, June 18, 1840, with the Chief Justice presiding. The prosecution's case was circumstantial, and the defense spent its effort attacking the police inquiry and calling witnesses of standing to the prisoner's character. Several former employers came to the Old Bailey to speak for him.
During the trial Courvoisier told his leading counsel that he had committed the murder, but he would not change his plea and urged the barrister to carry on. Counsel did carry on, and his conduct of the rest of the defense became a lasting public argument over what a lawyer owes a client he knows to be guilty. The jury found Courvoisier guilty of murder, and the presiding judge passed sentence of death.
On June 22, 1840, Courvoisier confessed to the murder, and the confession was published in the London press on June 26. He made further statements in the days that followed, the last of them on July 5. The next morning, Monday, July 6, 1840, he was executed in London.
The reason for the murder was never settled. After his conviction Courvoisier blamed, in turn, envy and the influence of a popular crime story he had read, then drink, and in a further version of his confession, fear of being dismissed for forgetting to collect his master from his club. None of these accounts was tested in court, because each came after the verdict.
The confession to counsel is told in more than one way: one account places it on the evening after a household servant's cross-examination, while another places it on the last day of the trial and holds that Courvoisier then admitted the theft of his master's property but not the murder. All accounts agree that by June 22 he had confessed to the murder.
1789 to 1830: The future victim sits in the House of Commons at intervals.
1816: Francois Benjamin Courvoisier is born in Switzerland.
Night of May 5 to 6, 1840: The murder in London.
May 7, 1840: A Whitehall notice in the Gazette offers a pardon to any accomplice and a Treasury reward.
May 10, 1840: Courvoisier is arrested and held at Newgate.
June 18, 1840: His trial opens at the Central Criminal Court.
June 1840: He confesses to his leading counsel during the trial; the jury convicts him of murder, and he is sentenced to death.
June 22, 1840: He confesses to the murder; the confession is published in the London press on June 26.
July 5, 1840: He makes a further statement on the eve of his execution.
July 6, 1840: Courvoisier is executed in London.