Feodor Fedorenko spent most of his adult life as a factory worker in Connecticut. He kept out of trouble and, in April 1970, became a citizen of the United States. Behind that quiet record lay a year he had left off every form he ever signed for American officials. In September 1942 the Germans had posted him, a captured soldier of the Red Army, to Treblinka, the killing center in occupied Poland where an estimated 925,000 Jews were murdered. He served there as a guard until the prisoners' revolt of August 1943 brought the camp toward its end.
Federal prosecutors went after his citizenship in 1977. They lost at trial in Fort Lauderdale, won on appeal in New Orleans, and in January 1981 won again in the Supreme Court of the United States, which held in Fedorenko v. United States that his citizenship had been "illegally procured" and had to be revoked. It was the first case involving an alleged Nazi war criminal that the Court had heard. Ordered deported, he chose to go to the Soviet Union, and in December 1984 he became the first Nazi war criminal sent from the United States to that country. In June 1986 the Crimean Regional Court, sitting in Simferopol, found him guilty of treason and of the mass execution of citizens of many countries at Treblinka and sentenced him to death. On July 27, 1987, the Soviet Union announced that he had been executed. He was 79.
Fedorenko was born in 1907 in Sivasch, in Ukraine. For decades he gave American officials a different birthplace, Sarny, in Poland, and the Supreme Court later set out the true one in a footnote to its opinion. In June 1941, as Germany invaded the Soviet Union, he was drafted into the Red Army.
His service lasted weeks. He was captured by the Germans shortly after he was called up and passed through prisoner-of-war camps. From there he was taken to Travniki (Trawniki in Polish), a camp on the grounds of an abandoned sugar refinery in the Lublin District of occupied Poland. In the autumn of 1941 the SS had turned it into a training camp for auxiliary guards. Fedorenko was trained there as a camp guard.
In September 1942 he was assigned to Treblinka and issued a uniform. The killing center lay near the village of Wólka Okrąglik (Wolka Okraglik), in the Warsaw District of the General Government, about a mile from a separate labor camp of the same name. It was one of three killing centers built for the German program to murder the Jews of occupied Poland, and its construction had been finished only that July. Between late July 1942 and the autumn of 1943, Jews were deported there from the Warsaw ghetto, from the Radom, Białystok (Bialystok) and Lublin districts, from Theresienstadt, and in smaller numbers from Bulgarian-occupied Thrace and Macedonia, Germany, Austria, France and Slovakia. Unknown numbers of Poles, Roma and Soviet prisoners of war were killed there too.
Fedorenko served at Treblinka through 1942 and into 1943. When he later described his time there under oath in a Florida courtroom, he did not deny the camp's purpose. He testified that he had known that thousands of people were being murdered there. He insisted that he had been only a guard on the perimeter. He conceded that the Germans paid him a stipend, that they gave him a good-service stripe, and that he was allowed to leave the camp regularly and never tried to escape.
On August 2, 1943, the prisoners rose. More than 300 escaped; about two thirds of those were later tracked down and killed. Fedorenko admitted that during the revolt he had followed orders against the prisoners who were escaping. The uprising led to the closing of the camp. German officials ordered the killing center dismantled that autumn, and it was liquidated in November 1943.
He was not done with German service. After Treblinka closed he served as a guard at Poelitz, and later as a guard at a warehouse in Hamburg. Before British forces reached the city in 1945, he threw away his uniform.
For four years after the war he worked in Germany as a laborer. In October 1949 he applied to enter the United States as a displaced person under the Displaced Persons Act of 1948. The story he told was simple. He said he had been a farmer in Sarny until 1942 and had then been deported to Germany and forced to work in a factory. He swore to those claims in a signed statement, was granted a visa, and entered the United States for permanent residence. He said nothing about Travniki, Treblinka, Poelitz or Hamburg.
He settled in Connecticut. For roughly three decades he lived the life the Supreme Court would later call uneventful and law-abiding, working as a factory hand. Much of that time he spent at a plant in Waterbury, where he worked for about 20 years.
In 1969 he petitioned for naturalization in Hartford. Again he said nothing about his service as a guard, and the Immigration and Naturalization Service relied on his visa papers. The Superior Court of New Haven County granted his petition, and on April 23, 1970, he became an American citizen. In time he retired and moved to Miami Beach.
Seven years after his naturalization, the United States sued in the federal court for the Southern District of Florida to revoke it. The complaint alleged that Fedorenko had hidden his service at Treblinka when he entered the country in 1949 and when he applied for citizenship. The government also alleged that he had taken part in the abuse and killing of Jewish prisoners in 1942 and 1943. He was never charged with any crime in an American court; the suit was civil, and its only question was whether he could keep his citizenship.
The case was heard in Fort Lauderdale in June 1978. The government's six principal witnesses were survivors of Treblinka, found in Israel, and each testified to having seen Fedorenko commit violence against prisoners at the camp.
Fedorenko took the stand. Beyond the admissions about the camp, he conceded that he had lied on his visa application. He denied the survivors' accounts of brutality, and he said that he had been forced to serve.
The district court ruled for him in a decision dated July 25, 1978. It found that he had lied in 1949 and that he had served as a guard. But it accepted his account that his service had been forced, and it rejected the survivors' identifications of him as unreliable. Each witness had first identified him from an array of photographs that included his 1949 visa photograph, and the court found the arrays impermissibly suggestive. It held that the identifications in the courtroom had been tainted by the photographs and by discussion of the case among the witnesses, and that the government had not proven that he committed war crimes or atrocities at Treblinka.
On the law, the court held that his false statements were not material under the Supreme Court's earlier decision in Chaunt v. United States. As an alternative ground, it held that even if the statements were material, equitable and mitigating considerations required that he be allowed to keep his citizenship. It counted among them the inconclusive evidence of atrocities and the life he had led in the United States.
The government appealed. On June 28, 1979, the Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, sitting in New Orleans, reversed the district court in a unanimous decision of its three-judge panel. It held that the trial court had misapplied Chaunt, and that a court had no discretion to excuse citizenship obtained by fraud. By concealing his past, the appeals court found, Fedorenko had kept the government from carrying out an investigation that "might have produced evidence that would have warranted denial of his entry or granting of citizenship." It also rejected his defense that fear had driven him to lie: "Immigration law does not allow a defense in a naturalization case, that a material misrepresentation was motivated by fear of what might have resulted if the applicant told the truth." It directed the district court to enter judgment for the government and to cancel the certificate of naturalization issued to him in 1970. The Supreme Court agreed to hear his case in February 1980.
The Court decided the case on January 21, 1981, and affirmed the Fifth Circuit on different grounds. Five justices joined the opinion of the Court, two more concurred in the judgment, and two dissented. The majority did not decide whether the Chaunt test governed visa applications at all, because it found a simpler rule sufficient. A misrepresentation in a visa application, it held, "must be considered material if disclosure of the true facts would have made the applicant ineligible" for a visa.
That turned the case on the text of the Displaced Persons Act. The law excluded anyone who had "assisted the enemy in persecuting civilians." The majority read those words literally. Congress had written the word "voluntarily" into another clause of the same provision but had left it out of this one, and the Court held that the omission was deliberate. Service as a concentration camp guard, it held, made an applicant ineligible for a visa whether the service was voluntary or not. Fedorenko's lies had therefore been willful and material. Under section 10 of the act, a person who willfully misrepresented facts to gain admission "shall thereafter not be admissible into the United States." His visa was invalid, so he had never been lawfully admitted for permanent residence, a condition of naturalization, and his citizenship had been illegally procured.
The Court also closed the door the district court had opened. It held that "district courts lack equitable discretion to refrain from entering a judgment of denaturalization" against a citizen whose citizenship was illegally procured or obtained by willful misrepresentation. Once the government met its heavy burden of proof, the trial court had no power to weigh a good life against a bad visa.
One justice who concurred in the judgment would have decided the case under Chaunt. One dissenter would have sent the case back for the appeals court to review the district court's findings; the other read the act to exclude only those who had helped the persecutors voluntarily.
On March 18, 1981, the district court in Fort Lauderdale entered the order revoking Fedorenko's citizenship.
Deportation was a separate proceeding. A federal immigration judge heard the case in New Haven, beginning in July 1981. By then Fedorenko was a retired factory worker living in Philadelphia. In an order announced at the end of February 1983, the judge found that as a guard at a Nazi death camp in occupied Poland he had "assisted in the persecution of persons because of race or religion," and ordered him deported to the Soviet Union, the country of his birth. At the time it was not certain the Soviet Union would accept him. He appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals, which decided his case in 1984.
The appeals ran out late that year. In December 1984, a week after a last-minute appeal to the Supreme Court to stop his removal was rejected, he was put on a flight from New York to the Soviet Union. He was 77. The Soviet Union had been his own choice of destination, and the Soviet authorities had approved it. He became the first Nazi war criminal deported from the United States to the Soviet Union, ending a seven-year effort by the government to strip him of his citizenship and remove him.
The trial came in June 1986, before the Crimean Regional Court in Simferopol. He was 78. He pleaded guilty to treason, to having gone over to the German side during the war, and to mass executions. The court heard testimony that he had served in the Red Army until the German invasion, had surrendered to the Germans and had later been recruited as an SS camp guard. Witnesses who had themselves served as guards in the German camps told the court that they had seen him mistreating and killing prisoners. The prosecution's account placed his gravest crimes at Treblinka, and also named the camps of Stutthof and Bełżec (Belzec).
Fedorenko's own testimony was narrower than his plea. He told the court that he had never mistreated anyone or treated anyone harshly, and that he had taken part in executions on two occasions. The trial dwelt above all on his betrayal of the Soviet Union and on the charges of treason.
On June 19, 1986, the court found him guilty "of treason and the mass execution of citizens from many countries at Treblinka" and sentenced him to death.
He appealed. On April 30, 1987, a spokesman for the Soviet Foreign Ministry said that a final appeal was still pending before the Supreme Soviet, the country's parliament. On July 27, 1987, the Soviet news agency Tass issued a brief statement that the sentence passed in June 1986 by the Crimean Regional Court had been carried out. It did not say when. Fedorenko was 79. He was the first Nazi war criminal deported from the United States to another country to be executed there.
No American court ever found that Fedorenko killed or harmed anyone. The district court in 1978 rejected the survivors' identifications and held the atrocity charges unproven; the later rulings against him did not rest on them, because the government needed to prove only that he had lied about his service. The immigration judge's 1983 order found that he had assisted in persecution as a guard, which is the language of the immigration law, not a finding of murder.
The Soviet verdict is the only judgment that convicted him of killings. It came after a guilty plea, and the charges of treason weighed heavily at the trial; the witnesses who described his conduct were former guards of the German camps. His own testimony there admitted executions on two occasions and denied any brutality.
The Soviet announcement of July 1987 gave no date for the execution, and none was published afterward.
1907: Fedorenko is born in Sivasch, Ukraine.
June 1941: He is drafted into the Red Army and is captured by the Germans soon afterward.
1941 to 1942: He is held in prisoner-of-war camps and trained as a guard at Travniki, in occupied Poland.
July 1942: Construction of the Treblinka killing center is finished; mass murder begins there late that month.
September 1942: He is assigned to Treblinka as a guard.
August 2, 1943: The prisoners' revolt at Treblinka; he later admits acting on orders against the escaping prisoners.
November 1943: The Treblinka killing center is liquidated. He is then posted as a guard at Poelitz and in Hamburg.
1945: He discards his uniform before British forces arrive in Hamburg.
October 1949: He applies to enter the United States as a displaced person, concealing his service, and is admitted for permanent residence.
1969: He petitions for naturalization in Hartford, Connecticut.
April 23, 1970: He becomes a citizen of the United States.
1977: The government sues in the Southern District of Florida to revoke his citizenship.
June 1978: Trial in Fort Lauderdale, with six Treblinka survivors among the witnesses.
July 25, 1978: The district court rules that he may keep his citizenship.
June 28, 1979: The Fifth Circuit reverses and orders his certificate of naturalization canceled.
February 1980: The Supreme Court agrees to hear the case.
January 21, 1981: The Supreme Court holds that his citizenship was "illegally procured" and must be revoked.
March 18, 1981: The district court enters the order revoking his citizenship.
July 1981: Deportation hearing opens in New Haven, Connecticut.
February 1983: An immigration judge orders him deported to the Soviet Union.
1984: The Board of Immigration Appeals decides his appeal.
December 1984: He is deported from New York to the Soviet Union.
June 19, 1986: The Crimean Regional Court in Simferopol finds him guilty "of treason and the mass execution of citizens from many countries at Treblinka" and sentences him to death.
April 30, 1987: A final appeal is reported pending before the Supreme Soviet.
July 27, 1987: Tass announces that the sentence has been carried out, without giving the date.