On the morning of Thursday, April 30, 2009, an attacker entered the second building of the Azerbaijan State Oil Academy in central Baku, a school with which, officials said, he had no affiliation of any kind: he was not enrolled there and did not work there. Before the morning was out twelve people were dead and thirteen more were wounded. That evening the Interior Ministry and the Prosecutor General's Office named him, identified by a document in his own name, as Farda Gadirov, a 29-year-old Georgian citizen who had grown up in a village in southern Georgia and spent most of his adult life near Moscow. He died by suicide inside the building as police arrived, and the criminal case opened against him was closed because he was dead.
He was never tried, and nothing he intended was ever tested in a courtroom. What the state of Azerbaijan established, it established through other men. On August 10, 2010, the Baku Court of Grave Crimes convicted four men from his home district of helping to prepare the killings, sentencing three of them to life imprisonment and the fourth to eleven years. The man prosecutors named as the organizer was never brought to Baku, and the account of why twelve people died that morning remains the one the investigators gave.
Gadirov was born in 1980 in Dashtepe, a village of the Marneuli district in the south of Georgia; his full name, in the Azerbaijani style, was Farda Asad oglu Gadirov. Years before 2009 he left the village for Russia and settled in Podolsk, a town just south of Moscow, and it was there, rather than in Georgia or Azerbaijan, that he spent his formative years.
In October 2008 he came back to Dashtepe, and investigators later said that in this period he lived for a time in both Russia and Georgia. Over the winter he moved on to Azerbaijan and took lodgings in Baku. There, investigators found, he kept in regular contact with a former neighbor from Dashtepe who was living in the city, and in March 2009 another man from his home district arrived in the capital. Both would later stand trial.
The official list gives each of the twelve dead with a year and a place of birth, and those years show how wide a cross-section of the academy's daily life was cut through that morning. The eldest was Ramiz Abdullayev, born in Baku in 1940. Majnun Vahidov was also a native of Baku, born in 1946, and Tamilla Azizova was born in the capital in 1951. Ayna Gurbanova was born in Salyan, on the lower Kura, in 1957.
Shafa Mammadova was born in Baku in 1978 and Taleh Mammadov in Sumgayit in 1980. Savalan Jabbarov was born in Baku in 1987. Jeyhun Aslanov was born in Shirvan in 1988, and Ayaz Baghirov in Baku the same year. Yusif Bandaliyev came from Jalilabad, in the south, and Emin Abdullayev from Dashkasan, in the west; both were born in 1989. The youngest of the dead, Ruslan Babashov, was born in Sabirabad in 1990.
Among the thirteen wounded were three young men from abroad, two from Sudan and one from Syria; the other ten were Azerbaijanis. In the days that followed, eight remained in hospital, three of them in grave condition.
The day after the killings, the Prosecutor General's Office announced that Nadir Aliyev, the former neighbor from Dashtepe, had been detained in Baku as a suspect. On May 4 the Interior Ministry and the Prosecutor General's Office said in a second joint statement that the killings had been planned in advance. Aliyev was charged as an accomplice, and so was Javidan Amirov, the man who had arrived from the Marneuli district in March; both were ordered held in custody.
Against Gadirov himself, the case had been opened in the first days for murder for hooliganism purposes, brutal murder, murder of more than one person and attempted murder of more than one person, together with an arms offense. It could go no further than the opening, and the proceedings were terminated on account of his death. By the middle of May a team from the two agencies had gone to Russia and to Georgia, the two countries where he had lived, and the search of his home village was carried out jointly with Georgian law enforcement.
By the spring of 2010 the investigators had settled on a fuller account, in which the killings were the work of a group rather than of one man. According to the indictment, its founder was a Georgian citizen, M.G., who early in 2009 had conspired with Gadirov and with men from the district to carry out a terrorist attack in Baku and had promised payment, part of which went to Gadirov. Investigators described the motive as ethnic hatred. In 2010 Azerbaijan declared a search for M.G. through Interpol and asked the government of Georgia to arrest him. He denied knowing Gadirov, and he has never been tried in Azerbaijan.
Four men from the Marneuli district, relatives or fellow villagers of the dead man, faced the Baku Court of Grave Crimes: Nadir Aliyev, Javidan Amirov, Najaf Suleymanov and Ariz Gabulov. Aliyev, Amirov and Suleymanov were charged with terrorism, with murder and attempted murder as accomplices, with organized smuggling and with arms offenses. Gabulov was charged with smuggling and arms offenses.
Every defendant pleaded not guilty. They told the court that the confessions they had signed during the investigation had been extracted under torture, and they retracted them; the prosecution answered that a medical examination had not borne out the claims.
On August 10, 2010, the court found the four guilty of conspiracy, terrorism, smuggling and illegal possession of arms. Nadir Aliyev, Javidan Amirov and Najaf Suleymanov were sentenced to life imprisonment. Ariz Gabulov received eleven years.
The motive was never settled in any proceeding where Gadirov could answer. On the day of the killings officials said it was unclear, the first charges against him spoke of hooliganism, and investigators at one stage described him as mentally ill; the conspiracy set out in the indictment came later. The court that convicted the four men accepted that conspiracy, but no court ever examined Gadirov's own state of mind, and the man named as its organizer has never answered the charge in any court.
1980: Farda Asad oglu Gadirov is born in Dashtepe, Marneuli district, Georgia.
October 2008: He returns to Dashtepe from Russia.
April 30, 2009: Twelve people are killed and thirteen wounded at the Azerbaijan State Oil Academy in Baku; Gadirov, named by investigators as the attacker, dies by suicide there the same morning.
May 1, 2009: Nadir Aliyev is detained in Baku as a suspect.
May 4, 2009: Investigators announce that the crime was planned in advance; Aliyev and Javidan Amirov are charged.
May 15, 2009: Investigators report the joint searches in Georgia and the inquiry in Russia.
May 2010: Prosecutors announce a search through Interpol for the man they name as the organizer.
August 10, 2010: The Baku Court of Grave Crimes sentences Nadir Aliyev, Javidan Amirov and Najaf Suleymanov to life imprisonment and Ariz Gabulov to eleven years.