Faleh Almaleki

Victims
1 woman killed in Peoria, Arizona, 2009; second-degree murder. His daughter, Noor Faleh Almaleki; also guilty of aggravated assault on a family friend; acquitted of first-degree murder
Years active
October 20, 2009 (offense); November 2, 2009 (death); February 22, 2011 (verdict); April 15, 2011 (sentence).
Location
Peoria, Arizona (offense); Phoenix, Arizona (trial).
Method
Second-degree murder; aggravated assault; leaving the scene of an accident (two counts).
Status
Sentenced on April 15, 2011, to a total of 34 and a half years in the Arizona Department of Corrections.

On October 20, 2009, in Peoria, Arizona, Faleh Almaleki left his daughter, Noor Faleh Almaleki, with injuries she did not survive, and seriously injured a family friend who was with her. His daughter died on November 2, 2009. The friend recovered.

Prosecutors in Maricopa County took the case to trial as a killing meant to restore the family's "honor," and asked a jury for first-degree murder. In February 2011 the jury declined to find premeditation. It convicted him of second-degree murder, of aggravated assault for the injuries to the second woman, and of two counts of leaving the scene of an accident. On April 15, 2011, a Maricopa County Superior Court judge sentenced him to a total of 34 and a half years in the Arizona Department of Corrections.

Almaleki was arrested by U.S. Marshals in Atlanta at the end of October 2009 and returned to Arizona. On October 31, 2009, he was charged with two counts of aggravated assault, one for each woman, while his daughter remained in serious condition.

After her death on November 2 the case became a homicide, and about six weeks later he was charged with her murder. By the time it reached trial, the charges were first-degree murder, attempted first-degree murder, aggravated assault and leaving the scene of a serious injury accident. He pleaded not guilty.

The trial opened on January 24, 2011, in Maricopa County Superior Court in Phoenix, and lasted about four weeks.

The question before the jury was intent. The state said the act was deliberate and premeditated. The defense did not dispute that he was responsible for what happened; it called the event an accident with no intent to kill and asked for a lesser verdict. It called no witnesses. The family friend who was injured testified for the prosecution.

On February 22, 2011, the jury returned its verdicts. It found Almaleki not guilty of first-degree murder, which meant it had not been persuaded that the act was premeditated. It found him guilty of the lesser offense of second-degree murder in his daughter's death, guilty of aggravated assault for the injuries to the second woman, and guilty of two counts of leaving the scene of an accident.

The jury also found aggravating factors that would bear on the sentence: multiple victims on the second-degree murder count, and on the aggravated assault count multiple victims, serious physical injury, and emotional, financial and physical harm.

He was sentenced on April 15, 2011, in Maricopa County Superior Court, and the judge built the term count by count. He received 16 years for the second-degree murder of his daughter and 15 years for the aggravated assault on the family friend, the two terms to be served consecutively, along with two concurrent terms of 3 and a half years on the counts of leaving the scene. Together they came to 34 and a half years in the Arizona Department of Corrections, and he was committed to its custody that year.

The central dispute at trial was intent. The state said he meant to kill his daughter; the defense said he never meant to kill anyone. The jury took a middle course. By acquitting him of first-degree murder it rejected premeditation, and by convicting him of second-degree murder rather than a lesser homicide it rejected the claim of a pure accident. The word "honor" belongs to the prosecution's theory; it was not a separate finding of the jury.

Timeline

October 20, 2009: The victim and a family friend are injured in Peoria.

Late October 2009: Almaleki is arrested by U.S. Marshals in Atlanta and returned to Arizona.

October 31, 2009: Charged with aggravated assault in Arizona.

November 2, 2009: His daughter dies.

Mid-December 2009: Charged with murder.

January 24, 2011: The trial opens in Maricopa County Superior Court.

February 22, 2011: Not guilty of first-degree murder; guilty of second-degree murder, aggravated assault and two counts of leaving the scene of an accident.

April 15, 2011: Sentenced to 16 years for second-degree murder and 15 years for aggravated assault, consecutive, with two concurrent terms of 3 and a half years for leaving the scene: 34 and a half years in all.