A confession is the most persuasive thing a prosecutor can put in front of a jury and the easiest thing for a defendant to take back. Between a Paris killing in 1920 and a São Paulo prison in 2026, fourteen murder cases turned in one way or another on words the accused later withdrew, denied or blurred. In some the courts held the first account against the defendant and convicted. In others the words produced nothing at all until laboratory work or a witness supplied what the confession could not. In a few the accused died before any jury heard the case, and the account was left exactly where it had stopped.
Arnfinn Nesset, a trained nurse, became manager of the nursing and old people’s home in Orkdal, in Sør-Trøndelag, in 1976. He was arrested in January 1981, after it emerged that he had ordered large quantities of the muscle relaxant Curacit for the home. Over months of questioning that ran close to a thousand hours, he confessed to killing residents. How many is reported differently: NRK has given 27, United Press International in 1983 and the Norwegian news agency NTB in 2025 gave 30, and the journalist Simen Sætre titled his 2025 book on the case after 31 confessions.
Shortly before the trial, or at its start, by differing reports, he withdrew all of them. He told the court he had confessed only to escape the pressure of the questioning, UPI reported, and he pleaded not guilty to every count. There was no technical evidence. The prosecution rested on the confessions, the purchases of the drug and the testimony of witnesses. In March 1983 a jury at Frostating lagmannsrett, sitting in Trondheim, convicted him of 22 murders and one attempted murder and acquitted him of two further murders. He was sentenced to 21 years, then the maximum under Norwegian law, and 10 years of preventive detention.
Nesset was moved to supervised release in 1993 and freed in 2004. He lived under a new name and never stopped saying he was innocent. In 2024, at 87, he told NRK he had been worn down until he confessed, and that a man questioned day after day might come to believe he had done what he described. "I remember well that I confessed," he said. The police and prosecutors denied pressuring him and said he had often volunteered details. His first defense lawyer, Morten Gunnes, told Advokatbladet that he had never been present at any interrogation. The trial prosecutor, Olaf Jakhelln, said the verdict should stand. In autumn 2025 Sætre published his book arguing that several of the confessions were probably false. Nesset died in a nursing home that December, aged 89, before any court looked at the case again.
Jenny Ann Wright was 11 when she died in Clayton County, Georgia, south of Atlanta, on February 21, 1982. She was the fourth of Martha Ann Johnson’s children to die in five years; the deaths of the three younger children, Wayne Bowen, Tabitha Bowen and J.W. Taylor, had been certified as natural. The case was reopened in 1988, and on July 3, 1989, in a recorded interview at the Clayton County Police Department, Johnson admitted killing Jenny and her son J.W. She denied causing the deaths of Wayne and Tabitha.
At trial she testified that she had not killed Jenny. The jury saw the recording, and she was convicted of murder and sentenced to life; the jury returned its sentencing verdict on May 5, 1990. On July 9, 1991, the Supreme Court of Georgia upheld the conviction. It ruled that the recorded interview had been properly admitted as voluntary. It also held that a biostatistician should not have been allowed to give the jury his estimate of the odds against so many natural deaths in one family, but it called the error harmless because of her confession. The statement she later contradicted from the witness stand was the evidence that carried the verdict. She has not been tried for the deaths of her three other children. In January 2020 WSB-TV reported that the State Board of Pardons and Paroles had confirmed a tentative grant of parole, which the Clayton County district attorney opposed.
In February 2001 a 24-year-old nurse on an internal medicine ward of the Nyírő Gyula Hospital in Budapest was taken into custody after a junior colleague reported that she had boasted of helping patients die. At her first interrogation, Index reported, she said she had helped 30 to 40 elderly, critically ill patients "pass over" since January of the previous year. Police had already installed hidden cameras and microphones on the ward; according to the Népszabadság account relayed by Index, they recorded nothing. A forensic psychiatric examination judged her mentally healthy. Her lawyer, József Szőgyényi, maintained that her guilt was unproven, and hospital staff held a protest in her support. The psychiatrist Sándor Funk said publicly that no crime might have occurred at all, and that drug use on the ward had not risen.
The indictment, as Index reported when the trial began at the Budapest Metropolitan Court in May 2002, charged Tímea Faludi with homicide over the deaths of eight elderly patients between May 2000 and February 2001. In court she said she had never believed her injections caused any death. Pressed by the presiding judge, Zsuzsa Sándor, on contradictions in the seventh case, she said it was possible that her entire statement to investigators had been made up. The verdict has not been reported.
In March 1998 Efren Saldivar, a respiratory care therapist on the night shift at Glendale Adventist Medical Center in Glendale, California, told police he had caused the deaths of 40 to 50 patients since 1989. He was held for about two days and released. Nothing else connected him to any death, and the district attorney’s office said more investigation was needed before a charge could be filed. The state Respiratory Care Board suspended his license, and the hospital fired him.
Within weeks he took it back. On ABC’s 20/20 he said he had invented the confession because he was depressed and suicidal and wanted the state to execute him. "I was looking to die," he said. The case then moved to a task force of detectives, the Los Angeles County coroner and a chemist at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, whose forensic work on 20 patients who had died at the hospital linked six of those deaths to poisoning. Saldivar was arrested in January 2001 and, according to the Associated Press, confessed again, this time saying he had killed 60 people by 1994 and then lost count.
On March 12, 2002, he pleaded guilty before Judge Lance Ito in Los Angeles County Superior Court to six counts of first-degree murder and one of attempted murder, admitting the special circumstances of multiple murder and murder by poison. The prosecution gave up any attempt to seek death. On April 17, 2002, Ito sentenced him to six life terms plus 15 years to life. Detectives later told 60 Minutes II they believed he had killed 100 to 200 patients. None of those figures was ever charged. The 1998 confession had named dozens and produced no case; the convictions rested on six laboratory results and a surviving patient’s testimony.
Ottis Toole, a Jacksonville drifter, was questioned while in prison on another charge about a boarding house fire on January 4, 1982, that killed a resident, George Sonnenberg, 64. He confessed in two statements. At trial he testified that he had not set the fire and had signed the confession only so that he would be sent back to Jacksonville; his lawyer told the jury the confession was the only thing tying him to the fire. In April 1984 the jury convicted him of first-degree murder, returning a felony murder verdict, and he was sentenced to death. In November 1985 the Florida Supreme Court affirmed the conviction and vacated the death sentence because the jury had not been instructed on extreme mental or emotional disturbance.
By then Toole and Henry Lee Lucas had become the most prolific confessors in American policing. UPI reported in October 1984 that Toole was charged in five states with ten murders besides the Jacksonville case. Lucas, held in Texas, claimed hundreds of killings. The Deseret News reported in 1990 that a Texas Attorney General’s inquiry under Jim Mattox had concluded that Lucas could not have committed all the murders he confessed to, and Lucas told the reporter Beverly DeVoy on death row that he had committed none of them. WJCT reported in 2017 that investigators had confirmed Toole’s part in some of the 108 murders he confessed to but had no evidence linking him to most.
Toole also confessed to the 1981 killing of six-year-old Adam Walsh in Hollywood, Florida. He first did so in October 1983, Time reported, and he recanted, UPI reported, before confessing again to The Florida Times-Union in May 1984. ABC News counted 24 documented admissions. He was never charged. He died in prison in 1996 while serving five life sentences, according to Time. Twenty-seven years after the boy’s death, Time reported, the Hollywood Police Department said it was satisfied that Toole was responsible and apologized to the family.
On October 26, 2005, a jury in Mobile County, Alabama, convicted Jeremy Bryan Jones, an Oklahoma native, of four counts of capital murder in the death of Lisa Marie Nichols, a grocery store worker who had raised two children alone, in Turnerville in September 2004. Circuit Judge Charles Graddick sentenced him to death on December 1, 2005, and the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed on August 31, 2007. His lawyers argued that investigators had drawn statements from him while he was on drugs, in exchange for food, telephone use and release from suicide watch. The appeals court held that those circumstances went to the weight a jury might give the statements, not to whether they could be admitted.
In the Mobile jail Jones had told investigators of killings in several states. A week after the verdict the authorities said he had confessed to at least 12 more in four other states, among them a couple and two 16-year-old girls in Welch, Oklahoma, in 1999. He then denied most of it. In June 2005 he told The Joplin Globe from his cell that he had never killed anyone. Records reported by News On 6 showed that he had been in a holding cell at the Ottawa County jail on the morning the Welch couple’s deaths came to light. In 2006 an agent of the Kansas Bureau of Investigation noted that Jones had recanted some confessions and that other states had disproved some of his claims through forensic evidence. He was charged with murder in Georgia, in the death of a 16-year-old neighbor, Amanda Greenwell, and in Louisiana, in the death of a New Orleans woman, Katherine Collins; no trial in either has been reported. In 2020 WPMI reported that he had admitted the killing of a Georgia hairdresser, Patrice Endres, and later taken that back. He was on Alabama’s death row as of July 2020. His one conviction is for the death of Lisa Nichols.
In November 1975, at the Old Bailey, Patrick Mackay pleaded guilty to three counts of manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility, covering the deaths of two elderly women and of Father Anthony Joseph Crean, a Roman Catholic priest from Shorne, in Kent, who had once befriended him. Two murder charges were ordered to lie on file for lack of evidence and were not tried. He was sentenced to life. A 1977 review in the Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, by the psychiatrist David J. Barry, recorded that Mackay had admitted five homicides and that both the authors of a 1976 book on the case and the police suspected him of six more. The review described the manslaughter pleas as the product of plea bargaining. No retraction is reported. What separated his admissions from his convictions was proof, and the gap was closed by negotiation rather than by trial. He spent his first 27 years in Category A conditions, moved to an open prison in 2017, and in May 2021 the Parole Board refused to release him, the Press Association reported.
Francisco das Chagas Rodrigues de Brito, a bicycle mechanic on the island of São Luís in the northern Brazilian state of Maranhão, was taken into custody after a 15-year-old boy from São José de Ribamar went missing in December 2003. The legal news site ConJur reported in 2006 that he first denied the charges, then confessed to 42 killings of boys, 30 in Maranhão and 12 in Altamira, in Pará, and later gave versions that his own lawyer, Erivelton Lago, dismissed as inventions. Maranhão police told a committee of the Chamber of Deputies in November 2004 that 30 deaths of children in the state between 1989 and 2003 had been attributed to him.
Investigators told the broadcaster Band in 2024 that a confession alone was not considered enough, and that the convictions rested on the common pattern of the crimes and on forensic findings. Juries in Maranhão convicted him in trial after trial between 2009 and 2014, of homicide, with other charges, one or a few boys at a time; the state prosecutor’s office put his combined sentences at 580 years and 10 months in 2018. The Pará deaths were never tried against him. Other men had already been convicted there, and in December 2004 two of them asked Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court for release, their lawyers arguing that Chagas was the real culprit, according to the court’s news service. He was held at the Pedrinhas prison complex in São Luís as of August 2024.
Francisco de Assis Pereira, a motorcycle courier, was arrested on August 4, 1998, in Itaqui, in Rio Grande do Sul, after police in São Paulo linked the deaths of several young women in the south of the city. Brought back to São Paulo, he confessed. His accounts did not hold still. His mother has said he told her, while in police custody, that he had not committed the crimes, Rádio Itatiaia reported in 2024. Band reported that after his arrest he denied the killings outright, saying, in translation, "I didn’t kill. Whoever killed is out there, free." The Santos newspaper Diário do Litoral reported that he later told investigators he had killed nine women, and that at trial he maintained his confession while blaming the devil, and then, on his lawyers' advice, said he could not remember how many victims there had been.
The defense argued that he was not fully responsible for his acts; a psychiatrist classified him as semi-imputable. The juries rejected that and held him fully responsible. In four trials between 2001 and 2002 he was convicted of the murders of seven women, with other charges, and his sentences are reported at about 285 years. Brazilian law at the time capped the time actually served at 30 years, and the Gazeta de S.Paulo, citing the state court, gave August 2028 as the expected end of his term. As of October 19, 2026, NC News reported, he was in closed conditions at the penitentiary in Iaras, and a procedure launched by São Paulo prosecutors on possible compulsory psychiatric internment had produced no decision.
On July 3, 2003, Alfredo Galán Sotillo, a former army corporal who had served in Bosnia, walked into a police station in his hometown of Puertollano, in Ciudad Real province, and said he was responsible for a series of shootings in and around Madrid that spring. He repeated the confession before the Guardia Civil and the duty judge, the Diario de León reported, and he gave details that had not been made public.
On September 10, 2003, before the Madrid investigating judge, he retracted. He said two acquaintances, whom he described as skinheads, had committed the killings with a pistol he had sold them, had told him the details, and had threatened to kill him and harm his sisters unless he confessed. He refused to name them unless he and his family were given official protection. Police gave more weight to his first account.
In March 2005 Section 16 of the Audiencia Provincial de Madrid convicted him of six murders and three attempted murders and sentenced him to 142 years and three months, with an effective limit of 25 years. The Diario de León reported that the Puertollano confession was the main evidence on which the judgment rested. The court even counted it in his favor, as a mitigating factor: he had confessed before he knew the proceedings were aimed at him, and that confession, the court said, had made the trial possible. It nonetheless imposed every penalty in its highest grade. Telecinco reported in March 2026 that he was still in prison, with release expected around 2028.
Fred West admitted killing his eldest daughter, Heather, when he appeared at Gloucester Magistrates' Court in February 1994, the Press Association reported. Police interviewed him 151 times, according to SoGlos, and the recordings released in 2025 show him admitting some deaths while denying others; he denied any involvement in the 1968 disappearance of Mary Bastholm, 15. He was accused of ten murders jointly with his wife, Rosemary West, and faced two more charges alone, over the deaths of his first wife, Catherine Costello, and of Anne McFall. On January 1, 1995, while in custody awaiting trial at Winson Green prison in Birmingham, he took his own life, as the European Commission of Human Rights later recorded. No court ever tested any of his statements. Rosemary West, who denied any part in the deaths, was convicted of ten murders at Winchester Crown Court in 1995 and sentenced to life.
Between 1975 and 1979 seven young women in state care disappeared in the Auxerre area of Burgundy. Émile Louis, who had driven the bus that took one of them to school, was questioned in 1979 and denied any part. More than 20 years later, after the families of the missing women pressed the courts to look again, gendarmes arrested him on December 12, 2000, in Draguignan, in the Var, where he had retired. In custody he admitted killing all seven. On January 17, 2001, at his first full questioning by the investigating judge, he retracted the confession entirely, according to the Inspection générale des services judiciaires.
The retraction did not save him. In 2004 he was convicted of the seven murders, with other charges, and sentenced to life imprisonment with an 18-year minimum term; the Paris appeal assize court confirmed the sentence in 2006. Politis summed up the sequence in 2020: he admitted the facts in police custody, then retracted before the judge. Louis died in custody in a hospital in Nancy in October 2013, aged 79.
In late November 1999 letters reached the Lahore police and the Urdu daily Jang claiming that the writer had killed 100 boys, the Turkish broadcaster TRT World and Dawn reported. The writer was Javed Iqbal, a businessman in his early forties. He was arrested in December 1999 and confessed. By the time of trial he had changed course. TRT reported that he retracted his confession and claimed the whole affair had been staged to draw attention to the plight of runaway children; Dawn reported that at times he said the children were still alive. The boys named in his records came mostly from the city’s poorest families, the Associated Press reported, and Time gave their ages as 9 to 18.
On March 16, 2000, Additional Sessions Judge Allah Bakhsh Ranjha convicted him on 100 counts of murder, with other charges, and sentenced him to death. The form of the sentence drew condemnation from the interior minister, the human rights lawyer Asma Jahangir and Pakistan’s Council of Islamic Ideology, CBS News reported. On October 9, 2001, with his appeal still pending, Iqbal and a co-accused man died in adjacent cells in Kot Lakhpat jail; prison officials called both deaths suicide, Dawn reported. In April 2007 the Federal Shariat Court recorded that his appeal had become infructuous because of his death, so no appeal court ever ruled on his guilt. In the same judgment it acquitted two juvenile co-accused, holding that one boy’s confession had no value as evidence and that the other’s confessions had been neither voluntary nor free of coercion. Both had retracted them at trial.
The oldest case in the group is also the thinnest on the question of confession. Georges Bessarabo, a commission agent of Romanian origin, was killed in Paris on July 31, 1920. His wife, Louise Grouès, a poet who wrote as Héra Mirtel, was charged with his murder, and their daughter was tried as her accomplice. In June 1922 the mother was convicted and sentenced to 20 years of hard labor; the daughter was acquitted, according to Criminocorpus, the museum of the history of justice, and the Paris site Paris ZigZag. She had earlier been suspected in the death of her first husband, which had been ruled a suicide. What she told investigators has not been reported.
Set side by side, the cases divide cleanly along one line: whether anything stood beside the confession. Where nothing did, the withdrawal mattered only if the court let it. Nesset’s jury and Johnson’s both convicted on statements the defendants had repudiated, and the Supreme Court of Georgia said in terms that Johnson’s confession was what made an evidentiary error harmless. Galán’s judges went further and treated his first account as a mitigating factor even after he had disowned it. Louis’s retraction came a month after his arrest and changed nothing at either of his trials.
Where investigators could find independent proof, the confession dwindled into background. Saldivar’s 1998 statement produced no charge at all; his convictions came three years later from laboratory work and a surviving patient. Chagas confessed to 42 killings, but the Maranhão juries heard cases built, in the investigators' words, on pattern and forensic findings, and the Pará deaths were never tried against him. Toole’s single jury verdict for murder came in a case where his lawyer called the confession the only link, and the hundreds of other killings he and Lucas described largely came apart, in Lucas’s case under a state inquiry.
And where the accused died first, the account simply stopped. Fred West never reached trial, and no court weighed a word he said. Javed Iqbal died with his appeal pending, and the higher court recorded only that it had lapsed. Arnfinn Nesset spent more than four decades denying the confessions that convicted him and died before any court looked at the case again. Words said and, in most of these cases, later unsaid brought a life sentence in Georgia, a plea bargain in London, nothing at all in Glendale in 1998 and, in Lahore, a conviction no higher court would ever examine.
• 1975 to 1979: Seven young women in state care disappear in the Auxerre area of the Yonne.
• November 1975: Patrick Mackay pleads guilty at the Old Bailey to three counts of manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility; two murder charges are left on file.
• January 1981: Arnfinn Nesset is arrested in Norway and confesses during months of questioning.
• February 21, 1982: Jenny Ann Wright, 11, dies in Clayton County, Georgia.
• March 1983: Nesset, having withdrawn his confessions, is convicted of 22 murders and one attempted murder.
• October 1983: Ottis Toole first confesses to the killing of Adam Walsh, then recants.
• April 1984: A Jacksonville jury convicts Toole of first-degree murder in the Sonnenberg case.
• November 25, 1985: The Florida Supreme Court affirms Toole’s conviction and vacates his death sentence.
• July 3, 1989: Martha Ann Johnson, in a recorded interview, admits killing her daughter Jenny and her son J.W.
• May 5, 1990: A Clayton County jury returns a life sentence for Johnson.
• July 9, 1991: The Supreme Court of Georgia affirms Johnson’s conviction.
• 1996: Toole dies in prison, serving five life sentences.
• March 1998: Efren Saldivar tells Glendale police he caused 40 to 50 deaths; he is released and soon retracts.
• August 4, 1998: Francisco de Assis Pereira is arrested in Itaqui and confesses in São Paulo.
• December 1999: Javed Iqbal is arrested in Lahore after letters claiming 100 killings.
• March 16, 2000: Iqbal is convicted at trial on 100 counts of murder, with other charges, and sentenced to death.
• December 12, 2000: Émile Louis is arrested in Draguignan and confesses in custody.
• January 2001: Saldivar is arrested and confesses again.
• January 17, 2001: Louis retracts his confession before the investigating judge.
• February 2001: Tímea Faludi is taken into custody in Budapest after describing 30 to 40 deaths.
• 2001 to 2002: Pereira is convicted in four jury trials of the murders of seven women, with other charges.
• October 9, 2001: Iqbal dies in Kot Lakhpat jail with his appeal pending.
• March 12, 2002: Saldivar pleads guilty to six murders and one attempted murder.
• May 2002: Faludi’s trial opens; she says her statement to investigators may have been made up.
• July 3, 2003: Alfredo Galán surrenders in Puertollano and confesses.
• September 10, 2003: Galán retracts and blames two other men.
• 2004: Louis is convicted of seven murders, with other charges, and sentenced to life.
• March 2005: The Audiencia Provincial de Madrid convicts Galán of six murders and three attempted murders.
• October 26, 2005: A Mobile County jury convicts Jeremy Bryan Jones of capital murder; a week later he is reported to have confessed to at least 12 more killings, most of which he later denies.
• 2006: The Paris appeal assize court confirms Louis’s life sentence.
• April 2007: The Federal Shariat Court records Iqbal’s appeal as infructuous and acquits his two juvenile co-accused.
• August 31, 2007: Jones’s conviction and death sentence are affirmed.
• 2009 to 2014: Maranhão juries convict Francisco das Chagas Rodrigues de Brito in a series of trials.
• October 2013: Louis dies in custody in Nancy.
• 2024: Nesset, at 87, tells NRK he was worn down until he confessed.
• December 2025: Nesset dies, aged 89.
• October 19, 2026: Pereira is held at Iaras; a psychiatric internment procedure is undecided.