Nine brothers, four families, courtrooms in two countries. In Toledo, two truck-driving brothers confessed together to a string of killings and walked out of the same plea agreement on opposite terms: one to a lifetime of parole hearings, the other to a work-release dormitory after 20 years. In northern China, two brothers from a farming village were sentenced together and put to death together. In Richmond, three brothers were arrested in the same week of October 1979; two went to the electric chair and the youngest went to prison, where he still was in December 2024. In upstate New York, identical twins killed in separate cities, decades apart, and never stood in the same case at all.
What separates the endings is seldom what the brothers did. It is what each man could give the state, what a single witness could prove against him, and which law was on the books the day the crime took place.
Anthony and Nathaniel Cook were Toledo men who both drove long-haul trucks, the Associated Press and WTOL reported. Anthony was the older. The killings he later confessed to began years before his brother had any part in them: Vicki Small was abducted and killed in Toledo on December 20, 1973, a case that stayed open until he described it to detectives in 2000.
The series that drew in both brothers began on May 14, 1980, by the date in most WTOL reports (one gives May 13). Tom Gordon was abducted in Toledo with a young woman who was with him. Gordon was killed. The young woman survived, and the evidence preserved from that night would bring both brothers into court 18 years later. Connie Sue Thompson, 18, was killed about eight months after Gordon, WTOL reported; her death came to light in Lucas County. Dawn Rene Backes was 12, a student at Gesu in Toledo, when she was killed in February 1981. Her mother remembered her to WTOL as a kind child who said her prayers every night, and a classmate told the station years later that her death ended the innocence of the children at that school. Nathaniel told investigators it was the last killing he took part in.
Anthony went on alone. By the brothers' later accounts, as the Associated Press reported them, he killed five more people in 1981, among them Scott Moulton, Denise Siotkowski, Stacey Balonek, 21, and her boyfriend, Daryle Cole. On September 18, 1981, Peter Sawicki of Ottawa Hills, a well-known area developer, was killed when he came to the aid of two young people Anthony had confronted. Weeks later an informant turned on him, WTOL reported, and officers who included John Tharp, later the Lucas County sheriff, arrested him on the interstate; he surrendered without a struggle.
A Lucas County jury convicted Anthony Cook in March 1982 of murdering Peter Sawicki. The timing shaped everything that followed. Ohio’s current death penalty law took effect on October 19, 1981, a month after Sawicki’s death, and the state had no sentence of life without parole for crimes of that period, WTOL and the Associated Press reported. He was sentenced under the older law, to a life term that carried parole eligibility.
For the next 16 years investigators suspected the brothers in the other cases but lacked the evidence to charge them. In October 1997 the Lucas County prosecutor, Julia Bates, proposed testing biological evidence kept from the old cases, WTOL reported. The results matched both brothers to the May 1980 case, though not to the other killings. Nathaniel was arrested in early 1998, and both brothers were charged in the Gordon case.
Before trial, the brothers' lawyers asked Bates whether she would consider a deal, WTVG 13abc reported. She took the question to the victims' families, and they agreed, because they wanted to know who had killed their relatives. The terms were simple and severe. Both brothers would confess fully to their crimes in Lucas County and pass polygraph examinations confirming their accounts, WTOL reported. In return Nathaniel would be freed after 20 years. If either man lied, the deal would be void.
The brothers sat for videotaped interviews on April 3, 2000. Between them they accounted for nine killings, the earliest in 1973, and Nathaniel admitted taking part in three: those of Tom Gordon, Connie Sue Thompson and Dawn Backes. Under the agreement Nathaniel pleaded guilty to kidnapping and attempted murder in the 1980 case, the Associated Press and WNWO NBC24 reported; NBC24 later gave his sentence as 21 to 75 years. Anthony was convicted in the Gordon killing, and in 2018 the Associated Press reported him serving two life sentences. None of the other killings went to trial. Investigators, working with the FBI, spent part of the next two decades trying to tie the brothers to another case. "We always thought within 20 years we could come up with something," the retired Toledo detective Frank Stiles told the Associated Press in 2018. They did not.
Nathaniel’s 20 years ran out in February 2018, and his lawyer, Peter Rost, asked the Lucas County Court of Common Pleas for his release under the plea agreement. Bates had expected it. She had promised not to oppose the release, she said, not to support it, and a prosecutor who broke her word would damage every prosecutor who came after her. Dawn Backes’s mother told the Associated Press that her daughter had been used as a bargaining tool. "We’ve dreaded it, but we agreed to it," Scott Moulton’s sister said.
On August 9, 2018, Judge Linda Jennings granted the release. "Frankly, Mr. Cook, I was trying to find a legal basis to prevent your release," she told him. She had none, she said, and was bound by the agreement reached 18 years earlier. She placed him on five years of community control, with six months in a work-release program and a year on an electronic monitor, and classified him as a sexual predator, required to register his address every 90 days. When WTOL later released portions of the confession tapes, ahead of a parole hearing for Anthony, it reported that Nathaniel had lived in Toledo without incident since his release.
Anthony’s path ran the other way. The Ohio Parole Board denied him parole in February 2015, WNWO NBC24 reported. A hearing set for December 5, 2024, was moved to March 2025, WTVG 13abc reported, and WTOL reported that he had refused to meet the board. Bates said she had not seen anyone worse in 48 years in her job. Stiles called him the worst person he had investigated. Before one of those hearings the families gathered at Gesu Catholic Church around a photograph of the nine victims, set with nine flowers and nine candles.
So the same confessions produced two endings. One brother, never convicted of murder, went home. The other, convicted of two murders, stayed inside on sentences that a calendar had left open to parole.
Shen Changyin and Shen Changping came from Nanwu village in Huojia county, in the central province of Henan. The Taipei Times, reporting their detention in September 2004, described them as farmers and gave their ages as 29 and 21. Sing Tao Headline, in a 2025 retrospective, wrote that both had finished junior high school, that their father and neighbors had seen them as dutiful sons, and that the elder brother had already served three years in prison for theft. Two reports describe an earlier killing at home: Shanghai Daily wrote that Shen Changyin killed a man in his home county in September 1999, and the Taipei Times, citing the Hebei paper Yanzhao Metropolitan Daily, said the brothers left their village after the elder brother killed a man there. Whether that death was ever charged has not been reported.
After the Spring Festival of 2003 the brothers started an auto parts business in Lanzhou, the capital of Gansu province, and lost money, according to Shanghai Daily and Sing Tao Headline. Shanghai Daily reported that they planned their crimes after that loss. The first woman they killed was in Lanzhou; Shanghai Daily named her as Yao Fang, and Sing Tao Headline described her as a single woman in her thirties. In late November 2003, in Baotou, Inner Mongolia, they met Li Chunling, who became their accomplice. Sing Tao Headline named four women killed in Baotou. Other cities named in the reporting include Taiyuan, Hefei and Shijiazhuang.
The case broke from the inside. Zhao Meiying, another woman later convicted with the brothers, surrendered to the police, who then arrested Li Chunling, Shanghai Daily reported. The brothers were taken in Shijiazhuang, in Hebei province, in August 2004. The first English-language report, on September 3, 2004, said they were accused of killing 12 people, 11 women and a man, in six provinces. Shanghai Daily and Sing Tao Headline later gave the total as 11 women.
In 2005 the Lanzhou Intermediate People’s Court sentenced both brothers to death for robbing and killing the women, Shanghai Daily reported. Li Chunling, then 23, was also sentenced to death. Three other women, aged 16 to 26, received terms of three to 20 years; Sing Tao Headline wrote that Zhao Meiying, the woman who surrendered, received three years, and that Shen Changping’s girlfriend and a girl who had been a minor each received 20. The brothers' father, Sing Tao Headline reported, suggested that his sons had done it to get rich quickly.
They were executed in April 2006. Sing Tao Headline gave the date as April 28. Of the four cases, theirs is the only one in which the brothers received the same sentence and met the same end, and the only one in which the courts drew no line between them.
The Briley brothers grew up in a house in North Richmond, where their parents were respected members of the community, the Richmond reporter Mark Holmberg wrote for WTVR in 2014. Linwood and James were the two oldest; UPI gave their ages in 1984 as 30 and 28. Anthony was the youngest. In 1971, when Linwood was 16, he killed an elderly neighbor, according to WTVR; the legal outcome of that case was not reported. James had a 1973 conviction for armed robbery and attempted murder, the Supreme Court of Virginia recorded, and he was on parole in 1979.
That year the three brothers and Duncan Eric Meekins, a 16-year-old neighbor, robbed people across Richmond. Police and prosecutors linked the group to at least 11 killings in 1979, and Robert Rice, one of the prosecutors, told Virginia Lawyers Weekly in 2009 that the true number was at least 11 and probably more. UPI’s 1984 list of victims police linked to the brothers included John Gallaher, a Richmond disc jockey and bass player known on the air as Johnny G; Mary Wilfong, a private nurse; Blanche Page, 75, and Charles Garner, 59, who boarded in her home; Mary Gowen, 76; and Christopher Phillips, 17.
On October 19, 1979, by the Supreme Court of Virginia’s account, the four planned a robbery of the Richmond home of Harvey Wilkerson, 26. He lived there with Judy Diane Barton, 23, whom the courts called his common-law wife, and her five-year-old son, Harvey Wayne Barton. All three were killed that night. Their deaths came to light in Richmond on October 21, and Linwood Briley and Meekins were arrested the next evening. Officers who had been watching the group, without knowing a crime was under way, had kept a record of their movements that later corroborated Meekins’s account.
Meekins became the Commonwealth’s principal witness against all three brothers. Under his plea agreement, as the Fourth Circuit described it, he would testify truthfully in every case involving the group, and the Commonwealth would not seek his death. He received a life sentence. "He described small things that corroborated big things," Rice said of him in 2009.
Linwood was tried for Gallaher’s death before Judge William E. Spain. He testified that he had bought the dead man’s ring and watch and denied any part in the robbery or the killing; Meekins was the only witness who identified him as the man who fired, the federal appeals court noted. The jury convicted him of capital murder and fixed his punishment at death. A separate jury convicted him of three counts of first-degree murder, with rape, robbery and five firearm counts, and the court imposed five life terms and five one-year terms, a judgment entered on January 12, 1980. UPI described him in 1984 as convicted in six killings.
James was tried in January 1980 before Judge James B. Wilkinson. He did not testify. The jury convicted him of the capital murder of Harvey Wayne Barton during an armed robbery, the capital murder of Judy Diane Barton during or after a rape, the first-degree murder of Harvey Wilkerson, robbery, rape and firearm counts, and recommended death on both capital counts after about 45 minutes, the Fourth Circuit recorded. He was one of the few people in the United States to receive two death sentences from a single trial, UPI reported, and the wire service later said he had been convicted in seven killings in all.
Anthony was never sentenced to death. His record, as the Virginia Parole Board set it out in 2024, shows four convictions for first-degree murder in the Circuit Court of the City of Richmond, with judgments on April 30 and June 24, 1980, together with robbery, abduction and weapons counts, and a separate robbery conviction in Henrico County in 1981. The board’s list shows one life term and three terms of 30 years for the murders. The parole records do not name the victims of each count. The Supreme Court of Virginia’s account of October 19 places him inside the house that night.
The Supreme Court of Virginia affirmed both older brothers' death sentences on November 26, 1980, and the federal courts turned back their petitions through 1984. On May 31, 1984, Linwood and James led six condemned men out of the death row unit at the Mecklenburg Correctional Center, a breakout UPI called the largest from any American death row. Anthony, held at another prison, had no part in it. The brothers were the last of the six to be recaptured, in Philadelphia, on June 19, 1984.
Linwood Briley was executed in the electric chair at the Virginia State Penitentiary in Richmond on October 12, 1984, and pronounced dead at 11:05 p.m. Eight citizens witnessed it; no reporters were present. His lawyer said his last words maintained his innocence. Warren Von Schuch, a prosecutor who had tried the brothers, called them "killing machines" that day. James followed on April 18, 1985, pronounced dead at 11:07 p.m., after telling reporters that week that he was innocent and had been framed.
Anthony, then 66, came before the Virginia Parole Board twice in 2024. On March 18 it refused him parole, citing the serious nature of his offenses and an extensive criminal record. On December 27 it refused him geriatric parole. As of that decision he was in the custody of the Virginia Department of Corrections. Meekins, given a new name and moved to another state’s prison system, was refused parole in 2008; in 2009 Rice said the Commonwealth had not kept its side of the bargain.
Robert and Stephen Spahalski were identical twins from the Elmira area of New York, and theirs is the one case of the four in which the brothers never acted together. The writer Michael Benson, who corresponded with Robert in prison and wrote a book about the pair, set out the outline in a 2016 article for the Rochester magazine 585: Stephen killed a man in Elmira in 1971, and Robert’s killings came years later in and around Rochester. In a 2018 interview with WXXI News, Benson said the brothers had gone their separate ways, one in Elmira and one in Rochester. Neither was charged in the other’s case. The outcome of Stephen’s Elmira case has not been reported.
Robert’s case is set out in far greater detail, in two court decisions. Moraine Armstrong died in Rochester in December 1990. Adrian Berger, his girlfriend, died in Rochester in July 1991. Charles Grande was killed in October 1991 in the Town of Webster, east of the city. Rochester and Webster investigators spoke with Spahalski in connection with all three deaths at the time; in 1991 a witness picked his photograph from an array, and he was questioned and released. No one was charged.
The fourth death, of Vivian Irizarry, a friend, came in Rochester in November 2005. On November 8, 2005, Spahalski walked into the Monroe County Public Safety Building in downtown Rochester without an appointment and told the officers at the counter that he had killed someone. Over one long day of interviews he signed written statements on Irizarry, Grande and Berger, and late that night, after first denying it, on Armstrong. Arraigned in Webster Town Court shortly after midnight, he said, without being asked, "I’m guilty. I just want to get this over with."
Judge Patricia D. Marks of Monroe County Court denied his motion to suppress the statements on August 22, 2006, ruling that his 2005 statements had been voluntary and that the earlier contacts with police had not been custodial. A jury convicted him of five counts of murder in the second degree covering the four deaths, and Judge Stephen R. Sirkin entered judgment on December 12, 2006. On June 9, 2017, the Appellate Division, Fourth Department, unanimously affirmed, rejecting his right-to-counsel claim, upholding the refusal to sever the counts and holding that the sentence was not unduly harsh or severe. Benson described him in 2016 as serving a life term.
Three deaths had sat open for almost 15 years even though police had spoken to the man who later confessed to them. They were closed not by a match or a tip but by the suspect himself, walking in off the street.
Set side by side, the four cases turn less on the brothers than on the instruments the state had to hand. In Toledo it was a plea agreement, struck because 18-year-old evidence tied the Cooks to only one case and because Ohio law of 1980 offered neither death nor life without parole; the price was Nathaniel’s freedom after 20 years, and a judge who looked for a way around it had none. In Richmond it was a single accomplice’s testimony, which sent two brothers to the electric chair and left the third serving terms that bring him before a parole board. In Lanzhou the court drew no distinction at all between the two men in the dock. In Rochester there was no case against Robert Spahalski until he made one himself.
Nathaniel Cook went home in 2018. Anthony Briley was still in prison at the end of 2024, decades after his older brothers were executed. The confession that freed one brother was the same confession that kept the other inside.
• 1971: Stephen Spahalski kills a man in Elmira, New York, by Michael Benson’s account; in the same year, by WTVR’s account, Linwood Briley, 16, kills an elderly neighbor in Richmond.
• December 20, 1973: Vicki Small is abducted and killed in Toledo; Anthony Cook confessed in 2000.
• 1979: the Briley brothers and Duncan Meekins are linked by police and prosecutors to at least 11 killings in and around Richmond.
• September 14, 1979: John Gallaher is killed in Richmond.
• October 19, 1979: Harvey Wilkerson, Judy Diane Barton and Harvey Wayne Barton are killed in Richmond; their deaths come to light on October 21.
• October 22, 1979: Linwood Briley and Meekins are arrested.
• January 1980: James Briley is convicted and sentenced to death on two capital counts; Linwood’s judgment on three first-degree murder counts is entered on January 12.
• April 30 and June 24, 1980: judgments on Anthony Briley’s four first-degree murder convictions.
• May 14, 1980: Tom Gordon is abducted and killed in Toledo; a young woman with him survives.
• February 1981: Dawn Rene Backes, 12, is killed in Toledo.
• September 18, 1981: Peter Sawicki is killed; Anthony Cook is arrested weeks later.
• October 19, 1981: Ohio’s current death penalty law takes effect.
• March 1982: Anthony Cook is convicted of murdering Peter Sawicki.
• May 31, 1984: Linwood and James Briley lead six men out of death row at Mecklenburg; they are recaptured in Philadelphia on June 19.
• October 12, 1984: Linwood Briley is executed.
• April 18, 1985: James Briley is executed.
• December 1990 to October 1991: the deaths of Moraine Armstrong and Adrian Berger in Rochester and Charles Grande in Webster.
• October 1997: Julia Bates proposes testing the evidence kept from the Toledo cases.
• Early 1998: Nathaniel Cook is arrested.
• April 3, 2000: the Cook brothers give videotaped confessions under their plea agreement.
• 2003: the Shen brothers lose money in an auto parts business in Lanzhou; the first killing follows there.
• Late November 2003: the Shens meet Li Chunling in Baotou.
• August 2004: the Shen brothers are arrested in Shijiazhuang.
• 2005: the Lanzhou Intermediate People’s Court sentences both Shen brothers and Li Chunling to death.
• November 8, 2005: Robert Spahalski walks into the Monroe County Public Safety Building and confesses to four killings.
• April 2006: the Shen brothers are executed (April 28, by Sing Tao Headline’s account).
• December 12, 2006: judgment on Robert Spahalski’s five murder convictions.
• February 2015: Anthony Cook is denied parole.
• June 9, 2017: the Appellate Division affirms Robert Spahalski’s convictions.
• August 9, 2018: Judge Linda Jennings orders Nathaniel Cook released.
• March 18 and December 27, 2024: the Virginia Parole Board refuses Anthony Briley parole and geriatric parole.
• December 5, 2024: Anthony Cook’s parole hearing is moved to March 2025.