FIVE TIMES THE CORRECTION WAS REFUSED

About a quarter of an hour before he was hanged at Fremantle Prison on October 26, 1964, Eric Edgar Cooke reportedly put his hand on a Bible and swore that he had killed two young women in Perth. Two other men had already been convicted of their deaths. A clergyman wrote the statement down, and a copy went into one of those men’s court files. The first of those convictions was not quashed until 2002, the second not until 2005.

Most accounts of wrongful conviction dwell on the moment of error: the coerced statement, the witness who picked the wrong face. The five cases that follow turn on a later and quieter moment, when someone handed the system a way out and the system declined to take it. In Perth, in Hohhot and in Shijiazhuang the offer was a confession from a man already in custody. In DuPage County, Illinois, it was a confession with a condition attached. In Fort Lauderdale it was a request for a laboratory test. Two other cases, one from Oregon and one from upstate New York, show how fast the same machinery can move when it chooses to.

Portland: a confession by telephone

Taunja Bennett was 23 and lived in the Portland area. Her sister remembered her as the only one in the family to finish high school, a reader who played Madonna all day. Her death came to light in the Columbia River Gorge, east of Portland, on January 21, 1990, according to the National Registry of Exonerations.

The case went wrong almost at once. L.P., a 57-year-old Portland woman, had spent about ten years with J.S., a farmhand 18 years her junior, whom she said abused her. The registry records that she saw the killing as a way to end the relationship. She phoned in anonymous tips, then named him to detectives, then told a story in which he had forced her to take part. A search of his belongings turned up nothing, and he denied all of it. Both were arrested in February 1990. L.P. recanted at her own trial, but in January 1991 a Multnomah County jury convicted her of felony murder on the strength of her recorded statements. In March 1991 J.S., afraid of a death sentence, pleaded no contest to murder and kidnapping. Both were sentenced to life.

In 1994 newspapers and authorities in Oregon received anonymous letters from a man who said he had killed Bennett. No one put a name to them. On March 24, 1995, Keith Hunter Jesperson, a long-haul trucker, telephoned a Clark County sheriff’s detective in Washington and confessed to the killing of Julie Winningham, and he was arrested in Arizona, the Associated Press reported. He had come forward partly, he said, because "I wanted to get those two people out of prison."

This time the authorities listened. In October 1995 the Multnomah County district attorney, Michael Schrunk, told Circuit Judge Paul Lipscomb that considerable evidence showed the pair had been wrongly convicted, while insisting that nobody in the 1991 trials had done anything wrong. Jesperson pleaded no contest to Bennett’s murder in November. On November 27, 1995, Lipscomb ordered both prisoners released. "There’s no longer any doubt that these two individuals are innocent," he said. Even in Oregon the correction was partial. The judge set aside J.S.'s conviction but refused to set aside L.P.'s, writing that "her persistence in this manipulation resulted in her own conviction," and freed her only because keeping an innocent person in prison would be cruel and unusual punishment.

Buffalo: the slides in the hospital

Anthony Capozzi was arrested in Buffalo on September 13, 1985, and charged over a series of sexual assaults in Delaware Park. He had been diagnosed with schizophrenia but was held competent to stand trial. Three women picked him out of a photo lineup. On April 6, 1987, an Erie County jury convicted him of two counts of first-degree rape, with other charges, arising from two incidents in 1984, and acquitted him over a third. The Appellate Division upheld the verdict in July 1989. His mother spent the next two decades fighting for his release.

On January 15, 2007, police in Buffalo arrested Altemio Sanchez, whose DNA linked him to three murders and to a string of sexual assaults across Erie County over two decades, WBFO reported. Investigators went back to Capozzi’s case at once. Members of the task force visited him in prison, and he told them again that he was innocent. In March 2007 slides from the two Delaware Park cases surfaced at Erie County Medical Center, once officers followed the hospital’s procedure for requesting them; a state review later cleared the hospital of negligence over the delay. The DNA excluded Capozzi and matched Sanchez, District Attorney Frank Clark said. Prosecutors joined the motion to vacate, and on April 2, 2007, at a hearing that lasted seven minutes, Judge Shirley Troutman threw out both convictions and dismissed the charges.

Sanchez pleaded guilty on May 16, 2007, to the murders of Linda Yalem, Majane Mazur and Joan Diver, and received 75 years to life. He was never charged with the assaults: New York’s five-year limit on rape prosecutions had expired on every one of them, and the Legislature’s repeal of that limit in June 2006 did not reach back. In June 2010 the state paid Capozzi 4.25 million dollars. His mother had died the previous October. "He will never get back 20 years of his life," his lawyer said.

The two Oregon prisoners and Capozzi lost years that nothing returns. But in each case, once a credible new account reached the people with the power to act, they acted within months. The five cases that follow ran on a different clock.

Perth: the man who confessed to the gallows

Eric Edgar Cooke, a petty thief and prowler from the Perth suburb of Rivervale, was arrested in September 1963 and confessed to eight killings and 14 attempted murders, ABC News reported. He was tried for one of them, the wilful murder of an 18-year-old student, John Sturkey, at Nedlands, and that single conviction was enough to send him to the gallows. Among the crimes he admitted were two for which other men were serving time.

Jillian Brewer, 22, a young woman from a wealthy Melbourne family, was killed at Cottesloe in December 1959. D.B., a deaf young man who could not speak, was convicted of her wilful murder in 1961 and sentenced to death, a sentence later commuted to life. Rosemary Anderson, 17, died after being struck by a car at Shenton Park on February 9, 1963, on the night her boyfriend, J.B., turned 19. J.B. confessed under police questioning; decades later he said detectives had beaten him until he did. In May 1963 the jury convicted him of manslaughter rather than wilful murder, and he was sentenced to ten years with hard labor.

In 1964 Cooke’s confessions came before the courts as evidence in the two men’s appeals. The judges put little weight on them, according to the Australian Dictionary of Biography, which records that Chief Justice Sir Albert Wolff called Cooke a "villainous unscrupulous liar." The Court of Criminal Appeal declined to order a new trial for D.B., and J.B.'s appeals failed. Then came the oath on the Bible. The Law Society of Western Australia records that the Reverend Jenkins took down the statement. Police began no inquiry, the Central Western Daily reported, and both men stayed in prison. J.B. was paroled in December 1967 after five and a half years; D.B. served 15.

The case was reopened by a journalist, not by the state. In 1991 Estelle Blackburn met J.B.'s brother at a social gathering and began to look into Rosemary Anderson’s death. Her book Broken Lives, published in 1998, laid out the full sequence of Cooke’s crimes. In February 2000 an American crash reconstruction specialist, William Haight, ran pedestrian impact tests in Perth with a Simca like the one J.B. had been driving. Cooke’s own confessions were inadmissible as hearsay, so the Court of Criminal Appeal looked instead at the evidence of his other hit-and-run victims. On February 25, 2002, it quashed J.B.'s conviction as unsafe and unsatisfactory, almost 40 years after it was entered. The attorney general, Jim McGinty, said the chief justice had stated plainly that there had been a miscarriage of justice, and in April 2003 the government paid J.B. 460,000 dollars.

McGinty sent D.B.'s case back to the same court in June 2002, saying J.B.'s result weighed heavily with him. At the hearing in October 2004 the Director of Public Prosecutors still questioned whether Cooke’s confession was genuine, pointing out that it was neither signed nor dated, and a Crown lawyer argued that the Brewer killing did not fit Cooke’s pattern. On April 1, 2005, the court unanimously quashed the conviction, holding that a substantial miscarriage of justice had occurred because a retrial had been refused in 1964 in the face of Cooke’s confessions. In June 2011 the state paid D.B. 425,000 dollars, as an act of grace, while noting that there had been no conclusive finding of misconduct by police or prosecutors. As of January 2021, Western Australia Police had refused repeated requests to apologize to either man.

Hohhot: the charge the prosecutors left out

On the evening of April 9, 1996, a woman surnamed Yang was killed in Hohhot, the capital of Inner Mongolia. The person who reported the crime was Hugjiltu, an 18-year-old ethnic Mongolian who worked at a cigarette factory. He was convicted of her murder on May 17, 1996, lost his appeal on June 5, and was executed on June 10, 61 days after her death, Xinhua reported. His parents spent years petitioning to reopen the case.

In October 2005 police arrested Zhao Zhihong, who went on to confess to more than 20 robberies, killings and other crimes, and told investigators that the first killing of its kind he had committed was the one in Hohhot on April 9, 1996. When the Hohhot Intermediate People’s Court heard his case behind closed doors on November 28, 2006, prosecutors charged nine killings. The 1996 case was not among them. Zhao raised the omission himself, and the hearing was adjourned. In detention that year, The Paper reported, he wrote what he called an application to pay with his life, asking prosecutors to examine the 1996 killing in full. The case was not heard again until after Hugjiltu’s had been retried, China News Service reported.

The Inner Mongolia Higher People’s Court decided to retry Hugjiltu’s case on November 19, 2014. On December 15 it declared him not guilty. Its reasons went to the original evidence: his confession did not match the autopsy, the blood-type evidence identified only a type and not a person, and his statements were unstable and contradicted the rest of the record. On December 30 the court awarded his parents 2,059,621.40 yuan in state compensation; money, they told Xinhua, could not bring back a life. On February 1, 2016, the regional authorities announced that 27 people had been held responsible; the former deputy police chief who had led the 1996 investigation was dealt with under criminal law, and 26 police, prosecutors and judges received Party or administrative discipline. Hugjiltu’s mother told Radio Free Asia the handling had been too hasty.

Zhao was convicted in 2015 and executed at Hohhot on July 30, 2019. In approving the sentence, the Supreme People’s Court confirmed 17 of his crimes and declined to confirm four, among them the killing of Yang, holding that his confession conflicted with the other evidence on the time of the killing, the victim’s clothing and other details. The court was careful about what that meant. Hugjiltu’s retrial "ended in acquittal because the evidence that Hugjiltu committed intentional homicide was insufficient, not because Zhao Zhihong admitted to being the real killer," the head of its Fifth Criminal Division said. No court has established who killed Yang.

Shijiazhuang: one killing, two confessions

In August 1994 a woman was killed in the western suburbs of Shijiazhuang, the capital of Hebei province. Nie Shubin, a young factory worker, was detained on October 1, 1994, and confessed on the sixth day of questioning, according to the U.S.-Asia Law Institute at New York University. He was convicted of intentional homicide, with other charges, on March 15, 1995, lost his appeal on April 25 and was executed on April 27.

In January 2005 police in Xingyang, Henan province, questioned a man who gave a string of false names before admitting he was Wang Shujin, a farmer wanted in Guangping County since 1995. He confessed to six cases. One was the Shijiazhuang killing. When a Guangping police officer realized that someone had already been executed for it, he told reporters, and on March 15, 2005, a newspaper headline asked: "One case, two killers: who is the real killer?" The next day the Hebei Provincial Political-Legal Committee promised a conclusion within a month. None was published before the Supreme People’s Court ruled on Nie’s case more than 11 years later. The officer said he was later investigated repeatedly and, in 2009, removed from his post.

Prosecutors indicted Wang in March 2006 for three killings and an attempted killing in Guangping, leaving Shijiazhuang out. He was sentenced to death in March 2007 and appealed on an unusual ground: that the prosecution had wrongly omitted the killing for which Nie had died. The appeal sat for six years. In September 2013 the Hebei High People’s Court dismissed it and held that Wang had not committed the Shijiazhuang killing, saying his account contradicted the evidence on several points. Forty lawyers signed an open letter accusing the court of ignoring the many places where his confession and the evidence agreed, the South China Morning Post reported.

In December 2014 the Supreme People’s Court moved Nie’s case to the Shandong High People’s Court in another province for review. On December 2, 2016, the Supreme People’s Court’s Second Circuit Court declared Nie Shubin not guilty, holding that the facts at his trial were unclear and the evidence insufficient. His parents received 2.68 million yuan in compensation in March 2017. The judgment named no one else. Wang’s own case was retried in 2020 on new evidence in one of the Guangping killings; at every stage he repeated that he had killed the woman in Shijiazhuang, and at every stage the prosecutors and judges declined to accept it. The Hebei High People’s Court dismissed his last appeal on December 22, 2020, and he was executed at Handan on February 2, 2021. In a statement on the case the Supreme People’s Court explained that confessing to one’s own crimes is not meritorious service under Chinese law, and that a person is held liable only for the confessions the courts recognize. Two men are dead, and no one stands convicted of the Shijiazhuang killing.

DuPage County: a confession with a condition

Jeanine Nicarico, a 10-year-old fifth-grader from Naperville who loved horses, was killed on February 25, 1983. A year later, DuPage County prosecutors indicted three young men from Aurora, among them Rolando Cruz and Alejandro Hernandez, on the strength of a story that, according to the National Registry of Exonerations, Cruz had made up in hope of a reward. The lead detective resigned because he believed the men were innocent. On February 22, 1985, a jury convicted Cruz and Hernandez, and both were sentenced to death.

On June 3, 1985, Brian Dugan was arrested on Kane County warrants, and in November 1985 he pleaded guilty to the murders of Donna Schnorr, a 27-year-old nurse, and Melissa Ackerman, a 7-year-old girl, and received two life sentences. During the plea talks he let it be known that he had also killed Jeanine Nicarico and had acted alone, and he signed a statement which, his former public defender testified in 2009, said he was confessing "to ensure that innocent people are not murdered by the state for a crime they had no part of." He would confess formally only if his life was spared. Prosecutors, doubting parts of his account, refused to bargain.

DuPage prosecutors then fought for a decade to keep the original convictions. At Cruz’s second trial they argued that Dugan may have been involved, but that Cruz had committed the crime; a dog handler’s testimony was used to suggest more than one person had taken part. Cruz was convicted again in 1990 and resentenced to death; Hernandez was convicted at a third trial in 1991 and given 80 years. In 1992 DNA testing excluded Hernandez and the third man as the source of evidence in the case, and prosecutors kept opposing the appeals. An assistant attorney general assigned to Cruz’s appeal, Mary Brigid Kenney, resigned in protest. The Illinois Supreme Court upheld Cruz’s death sentence by four votes to three in December 1992, then, after a change in its membership, reheard the case and in July 1994 ordered a new trial.

At that third trial a sheriff’s lieutenant’s account of a telephone call, supposedly showing Cruz had made admissions, collapsed when it emerged that the lieutenant had been on vacation in Florida at the time. On November 3, 1995, Judge Ronald Mehling acquitted Cruz. Prosecutors dropped the case against Hernandez on December 8. A 1995 DNA test matched evidence from the crime to Dugan, according to the Center on Wrongful Convictions at Northwestern University. Seven officials, three former prosecutors and four sheriff’s officers, were indicted in 1996 on charges that included perjury and obstruction of justice; all were cleared in 1999. In 2000 DuPage County paid 3.5 million dollars to settle the civil rights suits of the three men first charged, and Governor George Ryan pardoned Cruz on grounds of innocence on December 19, 2002.

Dugan was indicted for the murder in November 2005 and pleaded guilty on July 28, 2009, with no promise about his life. "It has been his desire to admit to this crime for 25 years," his lawyer said. A jury sentenced him to death that November; when Illinois abolished capital punishment on March 9, 2011, the sentence was commuted to life in prison.

Fort Lauderdale: the test that came too late

Shandra Whitehead, eight, died in Fort Lauderdale in April 1985. Frank Lee Smith, 37, who had a long criminal record, was arrested on April 29. No physical evidence linked him to the crime, the registry records; two witnesses identified him from photographs and a third from a lineup. On January 31, 1986, a Broward County jury convicted him of first-degree murder, with other charges, and on May 6 Judge Robert Tyson sentenced him to death.

In 1989 a defense investigator showed the trial’s key eyewitness a photograph of Eddie Lee Mosley, a man long suspected by a Fort Lauderdale detective in a series of killings in the city’s northwest neighborhoods. She signed an affidavit saying Mosley was the man she had seen. The trial court rejected her recantation as not credible. The prosecutor argued that Mosley did not prey on children. "You can blame a lot things on Eddie Lee Mosley, but this homicide is not one of them," he told the court, as FRONTLINE recorded. The sheriff’s office never investigated Mosley as a suspect in the case, FRONTLINE reported. In October 1998 Judge Mark Speiser denied Smith’s motion for DNA testing.

Smith was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer on January 1, 2000, and died on death row on January 30, at 52. In July 2000 his lawyers and the state agreed to the test. On December 11 the FBI laboratory reported that Smith was not the source of the evidence; four days later it reported that the genetic material was consistent with Mosley’s. Smith’s conviction was vacated and the charges dismissed on December 15, 2000, eleven months after his death. In 2013 his family settled with the sheriff’s office for 340,000 dollars.

Mosley was never tried for anything. He had been charged with murder in 1987, held incompetent to stand trial and committed to a state psychiatric hospital, where he stayed until he died in 2020. In 2001 DNA tests linked him to two more deaths for which another man, Jerry Frank Townsend, had been convicted. Townsend, whom the Innocence Project describes as having the mental capacity of an eight-year-old, was freed on June 16, 2001, after about 22 years in prison, and Broward Sheriff Ken Jenne apologized to him.

The shape of a refusal

Set side by side, the five cases show two kinds of refusal. In Perth, Hohhot, Shijiazhuang and DuPage County a man already in custody confessed to a crime for which someone else had been convicted, and a prosecutor or a court decided the confession was not good enough. Sometimes that judgment had substance: the Supreme People’s Court gave reasons for rejecting Zhao’s account, and the Hebei courts gave reasons for rejecting Wang’s. But in neither Chinese case did doubt about the confessor become doubt about the conviction until years later. In Fort Lauderdale nothing had to be weighed at all. A test existed, the prisoner asked for it, and a judge said no.

The repairs, when they came, rarely came from inside. In Perth it was a journalist; in Hohhot and Shijiazhuang, parents who petitioned for a decade or more; in Illinois, an appellate court and an assistant attorney general who quit rather than defend the case. The Oregon and Buffalo prisoners were freed within months of the new evidence. J.B. waited nearly 40 years, and Hugjiltu, Nie Shubin and Frank Lee Smith did not live to hear themselves cleared.

Timeline

• December 1959: Jillian Brewer killed at Cottesloe, Western Australia.

• 1961: D.B. convicted of her wilful murder and sentenced to death; the sentence is later commuted to life.

• February 9, 1963: Rosemary Anderson dies at Shenton Park, Perth.

• May 1963: J.B. convicted of her manslaughter.

• September 1963: Eric Edgar Cooke arrested; he confesses to eight killings, including the Brewer and Anderson deaths.

• 1964: the Western Australian courts reject appeals by D.B. and J.B. that rely on Cooke’s confessions.

• October 26, 1964: Cooke, having reportedly sworn on a Bible that he killed both women, is hanged at Fremantle Prison.

• February 25, 1983: Jeanine Nicarico killed, Naperville, Illinois.

• February 22, 1985: Rolando Cruz and Alejandro Hernandez convicted; both sentenced to death.

• November 1985: Brian Dugan pleads guilty to two other murders and offers to confess to the Nicarico killing if his life is spared; prosecutors refuse.

• January 31, 1986: Frank Lee Smith convicted of first-degree murder, with other charges, in Broward County, Florida; sentenced to death May 6.

• April 6, 1987: Anthony Capozzi convicted in Erie County, New York.

• January 1991: L.P. convicted of felony murder in Multnomah County, Oregon; J.S. pleads no contest in March.

• 1992: DNA testing excludes Hernandez in the Nicarico case.

• 1994: anonymous letters claiming the Taunja Bennett killing reach Oregon newspapers and authorities.

• March 15 to April 27, 1995: Nie Shubin convicted, his appeal rejected and the sentence carried out, Shijiazhuang, Hebei.

• March 24, 1995: Keith Hunter Jesperson confesses by telephone to a Washington killing.

• November 3, 1995: Cruz acquitted at his third trial; charges against Hernandez dropped December 8.

• November 27, 1995: L.P. and J.S. ordered released in Oregon.

• June 10, 1996: Hugjiltu executed in Hohhot, 61 days after the killing of a woman surnamed Yang.

• 1998: Estelle Blackburn’s Broken Lives published; in October Judge Mark Speiser denies Smith’s motion for DNA testing.

• January 30, 2000: Smith dies of cancer on death row.

• December 15, 2000: Smith’s conviction vacated after DNA excludes him.

• June 16, 2001: Jerry Frank Townsend released in Florida.

• February 25, 2002: J.B.'s conviction quashed by the Western Australian Court of Criminal Appeal.

• December 19, 2002: Governor George Ryan pardons Cruz on grounds of innocence.

• January 2005: Wang Shujin questioned at Xingyang, Henan; he confesses to the Shijiazhuang killing.

• April 1, 2005: D.B.'s conviction quashed.

• October 2005: Zhao Zhihong arrested in Inner Mongolia; he confesses to the 1996 Hohhot killing.

• November 28, 2006: Zhao’s hearing adjourned after he raises the omission of the 1996 case.

• April 2, 2007: Capozzi’s convictions vacated after DNA points to Altemio Sanchez.

• July 28, 2009: Dugan pleads guilty to the Nicarico murder.

• September 2013: the Hebei High People’s Court rejects Wang’s claim to the Shijiazhuang killing.

• December 15, 2014: Hugjiltu declared not guilty by the Inner Mongolia Higher People’s Court.

• February 1, 2016: 27 officials held responsible in the Hugjiltu case.

• December 2, 2016: Nie Shubin declared not guilty by the Supreme People’s Court.

• July 30, 2019: Zhao executed; the Supreme People’s Court holds his guilt in the 1996 killing unproved.

• February 2, 2021: Wang executed at Handan.