Erich Muhsfeldt

Victims
Tens if not hundreds of thousands killed with his part, court found; convicted by the Supreme National Tribunal, Kraków, December 22, 1947
Years active
August 1940 to August 1944
Location
Oświęcim (Auschwitz-Birkenau), Lesser Poland, Poland (killings); Lublin (Majdanek), Lublin region, Poland (killings); Neubrück, Brandenburg, Germany (birth).
Method
Gassing, shooting, hanging and drowning of camp prisoners and Soviet prisoners of war, and beatings causing death (Supreme National Tribunal findings, 1947)
Status
Sentenced to death December 22, 1947, with loss of public and civic rights of honor forever and forfeiture of all property. Executed in Kraków, Poland, January 24, 1948.

Erich Muhsfeldt was a baker from Brandenburg who spent four years of the Second World War in the two largest German camps on occupied Polish soil. He served at Auschwitz from the summer of 1940, at Majdanek on the edge of Lublin from November 1941, and at Auschwitz again in the summer of 1944, where he took charge of the first two crematoria at Birkenau. At Majdanek he was the Kommandoführer of the crematorium and was widely known by name among the prisoners. He rose in that time from a junior noncommissioned officer to the rank of SS-Oberscharführer and was decorated with the War Merit Cross, second class, with swords.

On December 22, 1947, Poland's Supreme National Tribunal, sitting in Kraków, found him guilty of taking part in the killing of prisoners and Soviet prisoners of war in both camps, of abusing them, and of belonging to the SS and to the criminal group the court held the Auschwitz staff to be. It sentenced him to death. The judgment held that the number of people killed with his participation ran to tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands. By then he was already serving a life sentence imposed by an American military court at Dachau for crimes committed at Flossenbürg. He was executed in Kraków on January 24, 1948, with twenty other members of the Auschwitz staff.

Neubrück, Fürstenwalde and the SS

Muhsfeldt was born on February 18, 1913, in Neubrück on the Spree, in Brandenburg. He finished eight grades of elementary school and trained as a baker, the trade the Kraków judgment gives for him. The same judgment names his parents as Otto and Frida, born Schwabe, and records that he was married and the father of two children. Before the war he lived in Fürstenwalde.

His political record became a point of dispute at his trial. The tribunal had before it a document drawn up by the American authorities from material in their hands, which showed that he had joined the National Socialist party in 1933, had belonged to the SA, the party's storm troopers, from 1933 to 1937, and had entered the SS of his own will. The judgment records him as a member of the SS from January 15, 1940. In court he denied all of it. He said he had never belonged to the party or to the general SS, and that he had been drafted into the armed SS against his will in January 1940. The tribunal held that the American document refuted that defense completely.

His own account of his first months of service was not in dispute. After training with the 12th SS Totenkopf regiment, he was posted to the concentration camp at Auschwitz in the summer of 1940. The judgment gives July 15, 1940, in one passage as the day he was sent there, and August 15, 1940, as the start of the period for which it convicted him.

Auschwitz, 1940 and 1941

Auschwitz had opened that year, and in its first period the largest group of its prisoners were Poles. The tribunal found that during this first stay he held, among other posts, that of Blockführer, the SS man in charge of a prisoner block. The court's conviction covers the whole of this period, from August 15, 1940, to November 15, 1941, as one of the two spans in which he took part in killings of prisoners and Soviet prisoners of war at Auschwitz.

On November 15, 1941, he was transferred to the new concentration camp at Lublin, the camp the Germans called Konzentrationslager Lublin and the Poles called Majdanek.

Majdanek

Majdanek stood about five kilometers from the center of Lublin. It operated from October 1941 to July 1944 and was the largest concentration camp in the General Government. People from about thirty countries passed through it, most of them Jews, Poles, Russians, Czechs, Belarusians and Ukrainians. Of about 150,000 prisoners, some 80,000 died there, nearly 60,000 of them Jews.

Muhsfeldt reached the camp in November 1941. Former prisoners questioned in 1947 remembered him first as a Blockführer, then as the man who came, in about March 1942, to set up the camp's crematorium, and afterward as its Kommandoführer. The Kraków tribunal found that the first crematorium at Majdanek went into service in June 1942 under his management, and that in January 1944 he was also given charge of a new installation. One former prisoner, who had been in the camp from December 1941 to April 1943, recalled that Muhsfeldt was widely known by name throughout the camp. He was promoted twice while at Majdanek, to Scharführer and then, at the beginning of 1944, to Oberscharführer.

On the testimony of numerous witnesses, the tribunal found that at Majdanek, as at Auschwitz, he took a very active part in killing prisoners and Soviet prisoners of war, and that most of those killings were mass killings. Among them, it found, were numerous executions of Soviet prisoners of war, the killing of 2,000 sick prisoners and the killing of 83 Polish prisoners in 1943.

The court gave particular weight to November 1943. It found that Muhsfeldt directed the killing of about 17,000 Jews at Majdanek on November 3 of that year, among them Jews brought to Lublin after the destruction of the Warsaw ghetto, and that he was responsible afterward for the deaths of twenty Jewish boys who had survived that day.

The camp fell to the Red Army on July 23, 1944. Before the year was out, a Polish court in Lublin had tried six of its former staff and prisoner functionaries, the first trial of German war criminals held on Polish soil, and sentenced five of them to death. Parts of the record of that case were read aloud at Muhsfeldt's own trial in Kraków three years later, and the tribunal noted that witnesses in Lublin had already named him.

Birkenau, summer 1944

As the Soviet front approached, the SS emptied Majdanek. Muhsfeldt went back to Auschwitz at the end of May 1944. There, the tribunal found, he took over the direction of work in the first two crematoria at Birkenau, the vast extension of the camp. A former Auschwitz prisoner told an investigating judge in Kraków in September 1947 that Muhsfeldt had arrived from Lublin at about the turn of spring 1944, had been in charge there for a couple of months, and had been commandant of the two installations that summer.

That summer was the period of the deportation of the Jews of Hungary to Auschwitz. The tribunal found that Muhsfeldt distinguished himself in their killing. It put the number of Hungarian Jews killed at Auschwitz at no fewer than 400,000, a figure drawn from the testimony of Rudolf Höss, the camp's first commandant, and it held that Muhsfeldt's share in that operation alone put the number of victims killed with his participation in the tens of thousands, if not the hundreds of thousands.

His second stay at Auschwitz was short. In mid-August 1944 he was assigned to front-line units.

Flossenbürg and the American court

In March 1945 the SS withdrew him from the front and posted him to the concentration camp at Flossenbürg in Bavaria, where he served for four weeks. Those four weeks put him before an American court first.

At the end of the war he was in American hands. By December 1946 he was held in the bunker for war criminals at Dachau. On December 24, 1946, a member of a Polish guard company serving there recognized him. The guard had first met Muhsfeldt at Majdanek on May 10, 1943, when Muhsfeldt was head of the crematorium there and held the rank of Scharführer. On January 13, 1947, he gave a statement at Dachau describing what he had witnessed at Majdanek and naming former prisoners in Poland who had known Muhsfeldt as head of the crematorium in Lublin.

By then Muhsfeldt was a defendant in the American case against the Flossenbürg camp staff. On January 23, 1947, the American military court at Dachau sentenced him to life imprisonment for crimes committed at Flossenbürg. He did not serve that sentence in Germany. He was handed over to Poland and was on Polish soil, in custody, from May 31, 1947.

The case is built

The case against the Auschwitz staff was prepared in Kraków by the District Commission for the Investigation of German Crimes, led by an investigating judge who had been taking evidence from former prisoners of Auschwitz since April 1945. Through August and September 1947, judges of the Warsaw and Kraków commissions questioned former prisoners and showed them a photograph of Muhsfeldt.

Their answers placed him in both camps. A former Majdanek prisoner questioned in Warsaw on August 25, 1947, who had been in the camp from December 1941 to April 1943, said Muhsfeldt had led the crematorium detail. Another, questioned two days later, recognized him in the photograph and noted that he had seen the name written as Mussfeldt in the camp. A third, questioned on August 28, identified him as Kommandoführer of the crematorium. A former prisoner of both Majdanek and Auschwitz, questioned in Warsaw on September 11, said the photograph resembled the man and described him as a Blockführer who later became Kommandoführer of the crematorium.

Several of these witnesses separated what they had seen from what was common talk in the camp, and some of what they described came to them from fellow prisoners. The tribunal later named thirteen witnesses on whose evidence it rested its findings about his part in the killings at both camps.

Forty defendants

The trial opened in Kraków on November 24, 1947. Forty former members of the Auschwitz staff sat in the dock, among them Arthur Liebehenschel, who had succeeded Höss as commandant; Maria Mandl, head of the women's camp at Birkenau; and Maximilian Grabner, head of the camp's Political Department. It was the largest trial of German war criminals held in Poland.

Muhsfeldt pleaded not guilty and said that he had only sometimes beaten prisoners. Beyond his denial of party and general SS membership, which the American document disposed of, he offered no account the tribunal accepted. During the hearing a former Majdanek prisoner testified that he recognized Muhsfeldt among the defendants and that he had been chief of the crematorium in the camp's last period. The evidence closed on December 16, 1947.

Verdict and sentence

The tribunal gave judgment on December 22, 1947. It found all but three of the forty defendants guilty of taking part, after September 1, 1939, in the SS, a criminal organization that had served the National Socialist party in committing war crimes and crimes against humanity, and of taking part, as members of the authorities, administration or staff of the Auschwitz camp, in a criminal group whose aim was crimes against humanity.

It then found Muhsfeldt guilty of specific crimes. In the court's words, from August 15, 1940, to November 15, 1941, and from the end of May to the middle of August 1944 at Auschwitz, and from November 15, 1941, to the end of May 1944 at Majdanek, in various posts in the administration and staff of both camps, he took part in the killing of prisoners and Soviet prisoners of war, and he abused prisoners and Soviet prisoners of war morally and physically by degrading their personal dignity, by beating and kicking them and by bringing inhuman corporal punishments upon them. The court added that it was impossible to list every mass and individual killing in which he had taken part, or every act against prisoners that had not caused death.

He was sentenced to death under Article 1 of the decree of August 31, 1944, on the punishment of fascist-Hitlerite criminals. The court ordered the loss of his public rights and civic rights of honor forever and the forfeiture of all his property.

Twenty-three defendants were sentenced to death, sixteen to prison terms, six of them for life, and one, the SS physician Hans Münch, was acquitted. In fixing sentence, the tribunal held that eighteen of the twenty-two defendants convicted under Article 1, Muhsfeldt among them, had abused prisoners, and it refused all of them the extraordinary mitigation the decree allowed, holding that their abuse of prisoners showed they had not taken part in the killings merely on their superiors' orders.

Execution

President Bolesław Bierut granted clemency to only two of the condemned, Johann Paul Kremer, the SS physician, and Arthur Breitwieser, whose sentences were commuted to life imprisonment.

On January 24, 1948, Muhsfeldt was executed in Kraków together with twenty others condemned in the same case, among them Liebehenschel, Mandl and Grabner.

Disputed and unproven points

Muhsfeldt denied in court that he had joined the party or the general SS and said he had been forced into the armed SS in January 1940. The tribunal rejected that account on the strength of the American document showing party membership from 1933, SA membership from 1933 to 1937 and voluntary entry into the SS.

He denied any part in the killings and admitted only to having sometimes beaten prisoners. The tribunal convicted him on the testimony of thirteen named witnesses and on the Lublin record, and it stated that the individual killings in which he took part could not all be identified or counted. Its estimate of the number of victims, tens if not hundreds of thousands, is a judgment drawn largely from his share in the deportation and killing of the Hungarian Jews in 1944, not a count of individual acts.

Some of what former prisoners told the commissions in 1947 was hearsay from fellow prisoners, and they said so; one witness at the hearing could not say whether Muhsfeldt had directed the killings he was asked about.

Beyond the life sentence, what the American court at Dachau found about his four weeks at Flossenbürg in 1945 is not on record.

Timeline

February 18, 1913: Born in Neubrück, Brandenburg, Germany.

1933: Joins the National Socialist party and the SA, the Kraków tribunal later finds; SA membership lasts until 1937.

January 15, 1940: Member of the SS from this date.

Summer 1940: Posted to the concentration camp at Auschwitz after training with the 12th SS Totenkopf regiment; serves among other posts as a Blockführer.

November 15, 1941: Transferred to Majdanek, Lublin.

About March 1942: Arrives, by one witness account, to set up the Majdanek crematorium.

June 1942: The first crematorium at Majdanek goes into service under his management.

November 3, 1943: The tribunal later finds he directed the killing of about 17,000 Jews at Majdanek on this day.

Early 1944: Promoted to SS-Oberscharführer.

January 1944: Placed also in charge of a new installation at Majdanek.

End of May 1944: Returns to Auschwitz and takes over work in the first two crematoria at Birkenau.

Mid-August 1944: Assigned to front-line units.

March 1945: Posted to Flossenbürg for four weeks.

December 24, 1946: Recognized at Dachau by a member of a Polish guard company who knew him from Majdanek.

January 23, 1947: Sentenced to life imprisonment by an American military court at Dachau for crimes at Flossenbürg.

May 31, 1947: In custody on Polish soil.

August and September 1947: Former prisoners questioned in Warsaw and Kraków identify him from a photograph.

November 24, 1947: Trial of forty former Auschwitz staff opens before the Supreme National Tribunal in Kraków.

December 16, 1947: Evidence closes.

December 22, 1947: Found guilty and sentenced to death.

January 24, 1948: Executed in Kraków.