Erich Koch

Victims
At least 72,000 Poles killed under his rule; near-total destruction of a Jewish population of over 200,000, the Warsaw court found; convicted March 9, 1959
Years active
September 1939 to April 1945
Location
Ciechanów district, Masovia, Poland (killings); Suwałki district, Poland (killings); Białystok district, Poland (killings); Elberfeld, Germany (birth); Hasenmoor, Germany (residence).
Method
Gassing in death camps; deaths in concentration camps, ghettos and camps (the accusations as described in 1958 and 1959); the verdict summaries do not state the means
Status
Voivodeship Court Warsaw death sentence March 9, 1959; Supreme Court upheld November 10, 1959; postponed June 14, 1960, never carried out. Died in custody at Barczewo November 12, 1986.

Erich Koch ruled more territory in occupied Europe than almost any other civilian official of the Third Reich. He was Gauleiter of East Prussia from 1928 to 1945 and the province's Oberpräsident from 1933. In 1939 he took charge of the civil administration of the slice of northern Masovia annexed to his province as the Ciechanów district, in 1941 of the Białystok district, and in the same year Hitler made him Reich Commissioner for Ukraine, a domain that at its height held some 17 million people. At one point his authority ran unbroken from the Baltic to the Black Sea. His name is given as Erikh Kokh in Ukrainian and Russian transliteration.

On March 9, 1959, the Voivodeship Court in Warsaw found him guilty of taking part in the murder of civilians in the Polish lands he had governed and sentenced him to death. The court held that at least 72,000 Poles had died under his rule there and that a Jewish population of more than 200,000 had been almost entirely destroyed. The Supreme Court upheld the sentence, and the Council of State refused clemency. Yet on June 14, 1960, the execution was postponed on the ground of his illness, and it was never carried out. Koch spent the rest of his life in Polish prisons and died at Barczewo on November 12, 1986. He was never tried for what was done in Ukraine.

Elberfeld, the railway and the party

Koch was born on June 19, 1896, in Elberfeld, now part of Wuppertal. He went through the elementary and middle schools of the town and a commercial school, worked briefly in a printing shop, and in 1914 joined the state railway in Elberfeld as a trainee official. He would stay on the railway, with interruptions, until 1926.

The war interrupted him first. After ten months of military training he was sent to the Eastern Front, where he served as an ordinary infantryman from 1916 until the autumn of 1918, and he was demobilized in December 1918. Back in the Rhineland, under French occupation, he joined in the agitation against the occupiers and in the unrest of the Ruhr.

He joined the National Socialist German Workers' Party in Elberfeld in 1921, early enough that his membership card carried a number below 100. Between 1921 and 1923 he fought with the Freikorps in Silesia and the Ruhr. In the party he attached himself to the brothers Gregor and Otto Strasser and belonged to its left wing, the wing that spoke of socialism as well as nation, and party comrades took to calling him "Red Erich." He rose quickly: by 1927 he led the party district of Essen and then the Gau of the Ruhr.

In September 1928 Hitler, on Gregor Strasser's advice, made him Gauleiter of East Prussia. It was an unpromising post. The province was agricultural, with little industry, and the party there had little room to grow. Koch built it up through the press, founding a weekly in 1929 and from 1931 publishing the Preussische Zeitung, which remained the party's paper in the province until the end. In 1930 he was elected to the Reichstag, where he sat until 1945. He helped found an East Prussian league of farmers and settlers as a base for the party and created a foundation in his own name.

Oberpräsident of East Prussia

When the National Socialists came to power in 1933, Koch became chairman of the provincial diet and, in June 1933, Oberpräsident of the Province of East Prussia, the head of its state administration as well as its party. He held both offices to the end of the war, and in 1938 he received the honorary rank of SA-Obergruppenführer. His survival through the fall of the Strassers and the purge of the SA leadership in 1934 has never been fully explained. Koch later claimed that Gregor Strasser had told him to keep his head down so that the party's left could live on.

Office made him rich. In Königsberg alone he came into possession of two villas, and by 1943 his fortune was put at 400 million marks. In March 1939 he signed, together with Hitler and Wilhelm Frick, the decree incorporating the Klaipėda region, taken from Lithuania, into the Reich. In the Lithuanian lands that had been part of East Prussia, his administration banned the cultural work of Lithuanian and Polish organizations and replaced Lithuanian place names with German ones.

The Ciechanów district, 1939 to 1941

The invasion of Poland in September 1939 opened the way east. On September 28, 1939, the army commander-in-chief, Walther von Brauchitsch, appointed Koch head of the civil administration in Masovia. When the General Government was created, Koch had to settle for the north of the region, which was annexed to the Reich and attached to East Prussia as the Regierungsbezirk Zichenau, the Ciechanów district. Koch administered it at first as Oberpräsident and then through its district president, and the men who ran it for the rest of the occupation were his close associates. Every commissarial county head from the period of military rule was replaced with his own appointees.

Koch was, above all, responsible for the policy pursued there: extermination, expropriation and the removal of Polish farmers from their land to make room for German settlers. In the expropriations of early 1940 many landowners were expelled to the General Government or deported to concentration camps. In April 1940 the occupiers turned on the Polish intelligentsia of the district, whom they saw as the seed of a revived independent Poland. The largest wave of arrests fell on Płock. Those arrested went first to a camp at Działdowo, and from there to concentration camps or to their deaths. In his biographer's judgment, Koch knew of the extermination, had a part in the creation of the Działdowo camp and bore indirect responsibility for the destruction of the clergy of the Płock diocese. A second wave of expulsions, this time of landless and smallholding families, followed at the end of 1942. The Jews of the district were confined in ghettos on his instructions and killed without exception in 1942 and 1943, under Aktion Reinhardt.

His appetite went beyond the district. In 1940 and 1941 he campaigned to have the heavily forested county of Ostrów Mazowiecka transferred from the General Government to East Prussia, sending officials and police into it as though they had already been appointed. The General Government did not give way, and the question was put off until after the war.

Białystok and Ukraine, 1941

The German attack on the Soviet Union in June 1941 opened far larger prospects. By mid-August 1941 Koch had secured the Białystok district for East Prussia as head of its civil administration, a post he held until 1945. As the front moved east, the district became the corridor joining his province to the new Reich Commissariat in Ukraine. The Białystok administration deported tens of thousands of Poles to forced labor in Germany by the spring of 1943, and Koch's foundation was used as an instrument for plundering the district.

Several men had wanted the Ukrainian post. Hermann Göring pushed Koch for the Baltic or Ukraine; Alfred Rosenberg, the minister for the occupied eastern territories, would have preferred him in Moscow. Hitler decided, persuaded by Göring and by Martin Bormann, and on July 16, 1941, formally named Koch Reich Commissioner for Ukraine. The Reich Commissariat was established on September 1, 1941, and Koch took up the office that month. On paper he answered to Rosenberg. In practice his position was strong enough from the start to defy him. Hitler had appointed him without consulting the minister, and Koch used his connection to Bormann to neutralize many of Rosenberg's instructions.

He chose Rivne, a Volhynian town, rather than Kyiv as his capital, but lived mainly in Königsberg. By one estimate he spent less than six months in Ukraine in all. He insisted that his subordinates address him as Gauleiter rather than as commissioner, and he brought trusted men from his Polish posts into the new administration.

The Reich Commissioner

None of what follows ever came before a court. By the account of historians of the occupation, Koch set a hard course from the first weeks. He demanded that his subordinates treat the population with severity and forbade his staff and his general commissioners to mix with Ukrainians. In the autumn of 1941 his administration moved against both factions of the Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists, dissolved the Ukrainian council that had formed in Kyiv and closed Ukrainian-language newspapers. Local courts were not permitted until the spring of 1942. The collective farms were kept rather than broken up. Food supplies to the population were cut and medical services reduced. Schooling for Ukrainian children was limited to four grades of elementary school, higher education to narrow vocational courses, and cultural institutions, libraries, museums and publishing houses were closed. They hold him jointly responsible for the deportation of hundreds of thousands of forced laborers from Ukraine to the Reich, and describe an administration that treated the country as a colony to be exploited without limit.

The cost was immense. Some four million people are estimated to have died in Ukraine during the German occupation. In Volhynia, where his capital stood, almost every Jew was murdered within about a year and a half, and the Jewish community of Rivne itself was all but wiped out. The brutality of his rule in Volhynia is counted among the reasons the Ukrainian Insurgent Army formed in 1942, and by 1943 Soviet partisans and the insurgents together made much of his territory ungovernable.

His methods drew objections inside the German apparatus as well, from the army, military intelligence, the Security Police and SD, and even one of his own general commissioners. His dispute with Rosenberg over how to govern the commissariat sharpened from 1942, and in March 1943 the minister asked Hitler to dismiss him. The attempt came to nothing. Koch was told to obey, and stayed. He blamed the partisan war on Heinrich Himmler.

Retreat, Ostland and East Prussia, 1944 to 1945

The Red Army's advance ended the commissariat. After its administration was evacuated to the General Government in February 1944, Koch became commissioner for the evacuation of the eastern territories with Army Group Center and was made responsible for building a defensive line along the San and the Vistula. His presence was unwelcome to Hans Frank's administration in Kraków, and in July 1944 the governor of the Warsaw district refused outright to take orders from him. In 1944 he also became acting Reich Commissioner for the Ostland, the Baltic and Belarusian commissariat. The Reich Commissariat Ukraine was formally dissolved on November 10, 1944.

By the autumn of 1944 he was back in East Prussia. As the front reached the province he ordered its inhabitants to build fortifications and was among the initiators of the Volkssturm militia. He failed to organize a comprehensive evacuation, and thousands of civilians died in the flight west. Into early 1945 he was still calling on East Prussians to stand fast. At the end of April 1945 he left by sea from Pillau, near Königsberg, for Denmark, and from there made his way to Schleswig-Holstein.

Four years in hiding

At first Koch passed himself off as a Wehrmacht officer. He then took the name Rolf Berger and settled at Hasenmoor, north of Hamburg, in the British zone of occupation, shaving his mustache and presenting himself as a farm laborer. After a while he began to go out again. He was recognized, probably in April 1949, and detained on the orders of the British authorities on May 27, 1949.

He was held at first in Hamburg and brought before a denazification tribunal at Bielefeld, then handed over to the British as a suspected war criminal in October 1949. By then two governments wanted him: the Soviet Union lodged an extradition request on August 6, 1949, and Poland followed on August 24. In November 1949 the extradition tribunal in Hamburg ordered him sent to Poland; the Soviet application was most likely rejected on formal grounds. Koch blamed British intelligence for his fate for the rest of his life.

Moved to the prison at Werl, he began to feign illness in an effort to delay the handover, and he went on hunger strike after the order. On January 10, 1950, the British occupation authorities handed him to the Polish Military Mission at Helmstedt, on the border between the two German states, and he was taken to the Central Prison in Warsaw.

Nine years without a trial

Koch was formally arrested in Poland on January 28, 1950. He was at first to be tried before the Supreme National Tribunal, as other senior occupation officials had been, and officers of the Ministry of Public Security ran the investigation. In the autumn of 1950 Koch sent written proposals and memoranda to the Polish president, Bolesław Bierut. After that the trial seemed to recede, and at the same time, at least in the official medical files, his health declined sharply. Officers of Soviet state security also questioned him between 1950 and 1955.

On February 5, 1955, the Prosecutor General of the Polish People's Republic indicted him before the Voivodeship Court in Warsaw under Articles 1, 2 and 4 of the August Decree, Poland's law on the punishment of Nazi crimes. The court soon suspended the proceedings on account of his illness. The amnesty of April 1956 removed one element of the case, his membership in the party, and kept the rest. A trial set for early 1957 did not take place. Koch made skilled use of his ailments, or of simulating them, and refused to read the files or sign documents put before him.

In the spring of 1958 the prison hospital reported him fit to stand trial, and that September the court resumed the case.

The trial

The trial opened in Warsaw on October 20, 1958. In its first days the court rejected his argument that the indictment breached the 1956 amnesty, and two physicians found him fit to be tried despite his ill health. He was then 62, frail and emaciated. The prosecution asked for the death penalty.

At the first sessions Koch pleaded not guilty and said that he had learned of the German atrocities for the first time in the courtroom. He presented himself as a socialist, the "red" man of the party leadership, with nothing to do with what had happened in Poland and Ukraine, and claimed that the British had handed him to Poland as an act of revenge by a British business concern whose contracts he had once cancelled. When witnesses described the destruction of the Jews of Białystok, he told the court that he knew nothing of the fate of the Jews because he had been "indifferent" to their existence. He challenged the court's right to try him and argued that others had committed worse crimes. He insisted to the end that he had been a civil administrator, not a soldier, and had only followed orders from above.

The court heard dozens of witnesses. Survivors from the districts he had governed came to Warsaw to testify, some of them from abroad, among them survivors then living in Israel, and witnesses told the court that he had been personally responsible for many of the orders behind the killings.

The verdict

On March 9, 1959, the Voivodeship Court in Warsaw delivered its judgment. It found Koch guilty of participating in the murder of civilians, by planning, organizing, inciting and aiding the killing of people the National Socialist regime saw as obstacles to its rule, from September 1, 1939, to April 1945, in the Polish territories annexed to East Prussia, the Ciechanów and Suwałki districts, and in the Białystok district. He had acted, the court held, from political, national and racial motives, and on his own initiative as well as on the orders of the regime.

The court found that at least 72,000 ethnic Poles had died under his rule in those territories, and that nearly the entire Jewish population of the region, which before the war had numbered more than 200,000, had been destroyed. His position on the extermination of the Jews, it held, was the party's own, and he had personally taken part in preparing the liquidation of the Jewish population. His civil administration had worked hand in glove with the SS and the police, whose commanders he had chosen himself. The indictment also accused him of ordering the plunder of the museums of Płock, the treasury of Płock Cathedral foremost among them.

The court found no grounds for extraordinary mitigation. It sentenced him to death, to the loss of public rights and of civic rights of honor forever, and to the forfeiture of his property.

Koch appealed. On November 10, 1959, the Supreme Court in Warsaw upheld the verdict and the death sentence. On February 12, 1960, the Council of State refused clemency. Every legal route was closed, and the execution appeared inevitable.

A sentence postponed

What followed has never been fully explained. In March 1960 the state radio announced that the sentence could not be carried out because of the condemned man's grave illness, before anyone had ordered a medical examination, and prosecutors asked the court to defer it on that ground before any medical opinion existed. On April 21, 1960, the medical commission of the Central Prison in Warsaw found that his ailments did not amount to a grave illness. On June 14, 1960, the Voivodeship Court postponed the execution all the same and gave grave illness as the reason.

Internal reviews by the Interior Ministry in the 1960s and 1970s and by the party's Central Committee in 1970 found the deferral inconsistent with the medical findings and without basis on the merits. The 1970 review held that the court had been swayed by the radio announcement and by word that the Council of State had decided the sentence should not be carried out, a decision of which no written trace exists.

The sentence was postponed, not commuted. Koch remained a condemned man for the rest of his life.

Mokotów and Barczewo

He began at once to press for release and transfer to West Germany. In 1962 the Soviet ambassador visited him. In the summer of 1964 Koch proposed to the Soviet side a secret journey to Königsberg to search for the Amber Room, the treasure the Germans had carried off during the war. The Soviet side appears to have agreed in principle, but there is no trace that the journey ever took place. A Soviet embassy official visited him on the matter as late as November 19, 1964.

Soon afterward the Ministry of Justice decided to move him out of Warsaw. He was held in the Central Prison in Warsaw until March 1965 and then transferred to the prison at Barczewo. He served most of his time there in a single cell, rare at the time. Polish intelligence regarded him as a valuable source, and through the 1970s the Security Service kept him under an operation code-named Komnata, Polish for "chamber," photographing his notes and private papers.

In the early 1970s he was allowed family visits. The West German embassy was eventually permitted to extend consular protection to him, and in 1982, during martial law, he was issued a West German passport. His efforts to be released never succeeded.

Erich Koch died in custody at Barczewo on November 12, 1986. He never expressed remorse. The execution proceedings against him were formally discontinued on March 3, 1987.

Disputed and unproven points

His death sentence is widely described as commuted to life imprisonment on account of his health, but the Voivodeship Court only deferred the execution on June 14, 1960; the sentence was never converted, and Koch lived for decades as a condemned man.

Why the sentence was never carried out remains unresolved. The official reason was his health, yet the prison medical commission of April 21, 1960, found that his ailments were not grave, and the officials who later reviewed the deferral found it unjustified on the merits. One explanation, drawn from Security Service documents and published in 2009, is that he was kept alive because Polish and Soviet authorities believed he knew where the Amber Room was hidden. Koch suggested for years that he knew, apparently as a bargaining chip, but nothing he said ever led to it, and whether the Amber Room decided his fate cannot be shown from the surviving files. Another account, from 1983, held that he may have bargained for his life by helping to trace Nazi plunder; it was never confirmed.

Why he was not sent to the Soviet Union, where the crimes of his Ukrainian commissariat lay, is equally unclear. The Soviet request of August 1949 was most likely rejected by the British on formal grounds, and the Soviet side was kept informed of his proposals throughout his imprisonment.

How much of his illness was real was contested from the beginning. Much of it was treated by Polish officials as simulation, meant first to delay his extradition and then his trial, and the physicians who found him fit in 1958 and the commission of 1960 rejected his claims.

Figures for the dead in the territories he ruled vary widely. The court's findings, at least 72,000 Poles and the near-total destruction of a Jewish population of over 200,000 in the Polish districts, are the only figures on which he was convicted. A figure of 400,000 was also given at the end of the trial. Estimates of up to four million dead in occupied Ukraine are research estimates for the occupation as a whole and were never tested against him in court.

Timeline

June 19, 1896: Erich Koch is born in Elberfeld, Germany.

1914: He joins the state railway in Elberfeld as a trainee official.

1916 to autumn 1918: He serves as an infantryman on the Eastern Front.

1921: He joins the National Socialist German Workers' Party in Elberfeld.

September 1928: Hitler names him Gauleiter of East Prussia.

1930: He is elected to the Reichstag.

June 1933: He becomes Oberpräsident of the Province of East Prussia.

March 1939: He co-signs the decree incorporating the Klaipėda region into the Reich.

September 28, 1939: He is appointed head of the civil administration in Masovia; the Ciechanów district is annexed to East Prussia.

April 1940: Mass arrests of the Polish intelligentsia in the Ciechanów district.

July 16, 1941: Hitler formally names him Reich Commissioner for Ukraine.

August 1941: He becomes head of the civil administration of the Białystok district.

September 1, 1941: The Reich Commissariat Ukraine is established, with its seat at Rivne.

March 1943: Rosenberg asks Hitler to dismiss him; the attempt fails.

February 1944: The commissariat's administration is evacuated to the General Government.

1944: He becomes acting Reich Commissioner for the Ostland.

November 10, 1944: The Reich Commissariat Ukraine is formally dissolved.

Late April 1945: He leaves Pillau by sea for Denmark and then Schleswig-Holstein.

May 27, 1949: He is detained in the British zone of Germany, where he had lived as Rolf Berger.

August 6 and 24, 1949: The Soviet Union and Poland request his extradition.

November 1949: The extradition tribunal in Hamburg orders his extradition to Poland.

January 10, 1950: British authorities hand him to the Polish Military Mission at Helmstedt.

January 28, 1950: He is formally arrested in Poland.

February 5, 1955: The Prosecutor General indicts him before the Voivodeship Court in Warsaw.

October 20, 1958: The trial opens in Warsaw.

March 9, 1959: He is found guilty and sentenced to death.

November 10, 1959: The Supreme Court upholds the sentence.

February 12, 1960: The Council of State refuses clemency.

April 21, 1960: A prison medical commission finds his illnesses not grave.

June 14, 1960: The Voivodeship Court postpones the execution, citing grave illness; it is never carried out.

March 1965: He is moved from the Central Prison in Warsaw to the prison at Barczewo.

1982: He is issued a West German passport.

November 12, 1986: He dies in custody at Barczewo.

March 3, 1987: The execution proceedings are formally discontinued.