Eric Smith

Victims
1 boy, 4, killed in Savona, New York, 1993. Convicted of second-degree murder by a jury, August 16, 1994; he was 13 at the time of the killing
Years active
August 2, 1993
Location
Savona, Steuben County, New York (killing); Steuben County, New York (trial); New York City (parole residence)
Method
Strangled and beaten (prosecution case and court documents)
Status
Nine years to life, the maximum for a juvenile; parole denied ten times from 2002, granted October 2021. Paroled February 1, 2022, to lifetime supervision in New York City.

On August 2, 1993, a small boy was killed in Savona, a village in Steuben County in western New York. Six days later Eric M. Smith, a boy of 13 from the same village, confessed to killing him. He was tried as an adult the following summer, and on August 16, 1994, a unanimous jury rejected his defense that a mental illness had driven him and found him guilty of murder in the second degree. He received nine years to life, the heaviest sentence the law then allowed for a juvenile convicted of murder.

The case did not end with the sentence. Smith became eligible for parole in 2002 and went before the New York State Board of Parole every two years for nearly two decades. Ten times the board turned him down. In October 2021, on his eleventh appearance, it granted parole, and on February 1, 2022, after almost 28 years, he left state custody to remain under parole supervision for life.

In the days after the killing, police ran the investigation from a command post in the village, and Smith came into it on his own. Four days after the killing he went to the command post offering to help, and investigators interviewed him repeatedly.

His story did not hold. At first he denied having seen the younger boy at all. Then he changed his account and said he had seen him while riding his bicycle. On August 6, 1993, police videotaped Smith walking through what he said he had seen, and investigators concluded that he could not have seen what he described from the place where he said he had been. On August 8, 1993, he confessed. His arrest drew national attention, in large part because both the victim and the accused were so young.

In September 1993 a Steuben County grand jury indicted Smith for murder in the second degree, to be tried as an adult, and he pleaded not guilty. The question that would decide the case was responsibility: whether he had understood what he was doing and knew that it was wrong.

The trial opened in Steuben County in August 1994. The prosecution argued that he had chosen to act and knew it was wrong. The defense argued that he was mentally ill and not criminally responsible; a psychiatrist it called diagnosed intermittent explosive disorder, and it asked that he be committed to a psychiatric facility rather than sent to prison. The prosecution's expert told the jury that the disorder was rare in a child of his age, and extensive medical testing had found nothing that explained his behavior.

On August 16, 1994, the jury returned a unanimous verdict of guilty. Later that year the court imposed nine years to life, the maximum then available for a juvenile convicted of murder, with Smith to be held in a juvenile facility until he turned twenty-one.

Smith spent about six years in a state juvenile facility and was then moved to a maximum-security adult prison, and over the next two decades he passed through the state system, ending at a medium-security prison. His disciplinary record was clean; he earned certificates in electrical installation and carpentry fabrication and worked toward an associate's degree.

From his first hearing on June 11, 2002, the board denied him parole ten times in a row, finding in its decisions that the seriousness of the crime outweighed his prison record. Over those years he apologized repeatedly for the loss he had caused.

He went before the board for the eleventh time on October 5, 2021. On October 7 it granted parole, citing his clean disciplinary record, his release plan and his low scores on the risk assessment, and the Department of Corrections and Community Supervision said he could be released as early as November 17, 2021.

That date passed with Smith still in custody, because he did not yet have an approved residence, and no parolee can be released without one. On February 1, 2022, the district attorney's office in Steuben County confirmed that he had been released to the supervision of the state's parole division in New York City; the terms of his release kept him out of Steuben County for as long as he remained on parole. As of May 2023 he was living in New York City, still on parole.

The central dispute at trial was Smith's mental state. The defense's psychiatrist found intermittent explosive disorder; the prosecution's expert said the condition was rare at his age, and testing found no medical explanation for his conduct. The jury rejected the defense, and the verdict of murder in the second degree stands. The explanations Smith later gave the parole board for the killing were never tested by a court.

Timeline

August 2, 1993: The killing in Savona, Steuben County, New York.

August 6, 1993: Police videotape Smith's account; investigators conclude it does not fit what he could have seen.

August 8, 1993: Smith confesses.

September 2, 1993: A grand jury indicts him for murder in the second degree, to be tried as an adult.

August 1994: Trial in Steuben County; the defense argues intermittent explosive disorder.

August 16, 1994: A unanimous jury finds him guilty of murder in the second degree.

1994: Sentenced to nine years to life, the maximum for a juvenile.

June 11, 2002: First parole hearing; release denied.

From 2002: Parole denied at ten consecutive hearings.

October 5, 2021: Eleventh hearing.

October 7, 2021: Parole granted.

November 17, 2021: Earliest release date passes without an approved residence.

February 1, 2022: Released to lifetime parole supervision in New York City.

May 2023: Living in New York City on parole.