Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold

Victims
13 killed at Columbine High School, April 20, 1999; never tried. The Sheriff's Office attributed all 13 deaths and 21 people wounded to both; both died by suicide that day.
Years active
April 20, 1999
Location
Littleton area, unincorporated Jefferson County, Colorado
Method
Thirteen deaths attributed by the Sheriff's Office; no charge was ever filed, as both died the same day
Status
Both died by suicide, April 20, 1999. Sheriff's final report May 15, 2000; Governor's Columbine Review Commission report May 2001; state grand jury report September 2004, no indictments

On April 20, 1999, a Tuesday in the last weeks of the school year, thirteen people died and 21 more were wounded at Columbine High School, in the unincorporated suburbs of Jefferson County, Colorado, on the west side of the Denver metropolitan area. The Jefferson County Sheriff's Office concluded after a ten-month investigation that the deaths were the work of two young men enrolled at the school, Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, and that they had acted alone. Harris was 18. Klebold was 17. Both died by suicide that day, before any officer reached them, and neither was ever charged, tried or convicted of anything connected with the deaths. Every finding about their responsibility rests on the investigation that followed and on the official reports it produced.

That investigation, and the arguments that grew out of it, lasted far longer than the event itself. The questions that followed, about what county officials had known of Harris before that morning, about what had been kept from the public afterward, and about records that went missing, occupied a governor's commission, the state attorney general and a state grand jury until 2004.

Eric Harris was born on April 9, 1981, in Wichita, Kansas, and settled in Littleton, Colorado, in 1993. Dylan Klebold was born on September 11, 1981, in Denver. The two met at middle school and went on together to Columbine High School, and both were due to graduate within weeks of April 1999.

By then they were already known to the county's justice system. On January 30, 1998, a sheriff's deputy arrested both of them in Jefferson County on a juvenile case arising from a theft from a parked vehicle, and both admitted the theft to him. It was the only criminal charge either of them ever faced. On March 25, 1998, they formally entered the juvenile diversion program run by the Jefferson County District Attorney's Office, under which the charges would be dropped if they met its conditions, among them fines, anger-management classes, counseling and community service. The program released them about a month ahead of schedule, on February 3, 1999, and the charges were dismissed. In October 2002 a Jefferson County district judge ordered the diversion records made public, finding a legitimate public interest in examining whether the program had failed.

The arrest of January 1998 was not the only time the Sheriff's Office had dealt with Harris. The first complaints came early in 1997, from one family in the neighborhood, over a damaged car windshield and then a prank telephone call. In August 1997 a citizen approached a deputy at a sheriff's substation and handed over printed pages from a website Harris kept. The same day another deputy collected further pages from the complaining family. The first deputy sent everything on in a directed report, the office's term for an internal memorandum passed from patrol to an investigator, addressed to the investigator who handled computer crime. That investigator filed it in a binder of intelligence material, never retrieved it and never connected it with Harris.

In March 1998 a family brought the office a complaint about threats Harris had made. Investigators could not verify what was alleged, and because the family asked not to be identified, neither Harris nor Klebold was contacted about it. The sheriff at the time was not told of the report. In July 1998 the same family named Harris as a suspect in a further complaint of property damage at their home.

An investigator nonetheless drafted an affidavit in 1998 seeking a warrant concerning property connected with Harris. It was never presented to a judge, and no warrant was ever issued or served. According to the attorney general's later findings, a supervisor did not approve it because no witness could place the items it described with Harris; the investigator could develop no further evidence, and the inquiry went no further. That draft became the most contested document in the case. A grand jury later found that, days after April 20, 1999, senior county and law enforcement officials held a private meeting to discuss the draft and what it might mean for the county's liability, and that the Sheriff's Office then said nothing about it at a news conference on April 30, 1999. The draft came to light only in 2001, when a state district judge in Golden ordered it released. The Jefferson County District Attorney's Office later concluded that the complaint behind it would not have given sufficient legal grounds for a warrant of any kind.

When the state attorney general examined the record years later, his office counted fifteen contacts with the Sheriff's Office related to Harris, Klebold or both before April 1999, arising from six separate incidents. Only two brought deputies into direct contact with either of them: the arrest of January 1998 and a traffic citation issued to Klebold on March 14, 1998. The other thirteen were complaints from third parties, nearly all of them about Harris. None came in 1999.

The 1997 directed report, the earliest known reference to Harris in the Sheriff's Office, stayed where it had been filed. On October 23, 2003, an investigator clearing out old intelligence files found the report and took it to the sheriff, who made it public on October 29, 2003.

The deaths occurred late in the morning. The Sheriff's Office found that Harris and Klebold had caused every one of the deaths and injuries attributed to them, and that both then died by suicide.

The thirteen who died were twelve young people at the school, Cassie, Steven, Corey, Kelly, Matthew, Daniel M., Daniel R., Rachel, Isaiah, John, Lauren and Kyle, and Dave Sanders.

The Jefferson County Sheriff's Office led the inquiry from the first day. An FBI Evidence Response Team processed the scene from April 20 to April 23, 1999, and the federal ATF examined the physical evidence. Reports came in from the Denver Police Department and other agencies, the Colorado Bureau of Investigation laboratory analyzed material, and the Jefferson County Coroner's Office, the District Attorney's Office and the El Paso County Sheriff's Office each produced records of their own.

In the first weeks the central question was whether anyone else had taken part. Their conclusions, which began to reach the public in March 2000, were that Harris and Klebold had acted alone, that no evidence showed anyone else knew of their plans in advance, and that the deaths were random rather than aimed at any particular group within the school. The work had by then taken close to eight months and covered thousands of interviews and more than 10,000 pieces of evidence.

The Sheriff's Office issued its final report on CD-ROM on May 15, 2000, after six months of delays. It ruled out a third participant, tracing each reported sighting of one to an innocent explanation or to Harris himself. It found that both young men had shared in the preparations. It also stated plainly that it could not answer the most basic question of all, which was why.

The report also resolved one of the earliest public fears. The physical evidence, it found, ruled out the theory that police had caused one of the deaths. That conclusion was later tested again. The El Paso County Sheriff's Office conducted a separate reinvestigation of the death of one of the thirteen after an allegation that a Denver police officer had been responsible. It found the allegation unfounded, concluded beyond reasonable doubt that Harris had caused that death, and stated that, had Harris lived, there would have been overwhelming probable cause to arrest him for murder.

One strand of the inquiry outlasted the rest. Into 2000 the Sheriff's Office was still investigating people who might have helped the pair obtain what they used, and it cited that work when it first declined requests to inspect the evidence. The strand produced the only criminal convictions to come out of the case, both in the state district court at Golden.

Mark Manes pleaded guilty to supplying the two teenagers in breach of state law. On November 12, 1999, he was sentenced to six years in prison, with a concurrent three-year term on a second count, and became the first person imprisoned in connection with the deaths. Philip Duran pleaded guilty on May 8, 2000, to two counts arising from his own part; a third count was dismissed. On June 23, 2000, he was sentenced to four and a half years. His was the last active criminal prosecution arising from April 20, 1999.

The rediscovered 1997 report led the Jefferson County sheriff, on October 29, 2003, to ask the Colorado attorney general to investigate where it had come from and how it had sat unnoticed.

The attorney general's report of February 26, 2004, found no negligence by the Sheriff's Office in missing warning signs about the two young men, but found that the investigator's file containing the draft affidavit had gone missing, along with other 1998 records. The report concluded that the 1997 directed report had followed a normal course to the investigator who filed it and had not been mixed in with the 1998 material.

In May 2004 the attorney general asked for a state grand jury to look into the missing files. A state grand jury reported in September 2004 that officials had decided soon after April 20, 1999, to withhold the document showing that deputies had known of accusations against Harris before April 1999. It found that some of the department's computer files had been purged, some of them in the summer after the deaths, and that other documents had been shredded under normal department procedures. Every witness it heard denied knowing what had become of the investigator's file. Most of that file's contents were reconstructed. The originals of the missing records were never recovered, and the grand jury returned no indictments.

The recordings and papers the pair left behind, seized from their homes under search warrants, became the subject of a records case that reached the Colorado Supreme Court. A Jefferson County district judge ruled first that the recordings were private property and beyond public inspection. The Colorado Court of Appeals disagreed and, after a rehearing, held that they were public records under the Colorado Open Records Act.

On November 15, 2005, in Harris v. Denver Post Corp., the Colorado Supreme Court unanimously reversed that judgment on different grounds. Because the Sheriff's Office had obtained the recordings under a search warrant that had never been invalidated, and had used them to investigate the crimes at the school, the court held that they were criminal justice records under the Colorado Criminal Justice Records Act. Whether anyone could inspect them was for the sheriff to decide. The case went back to the district court with directions for the sheriff to make the determination.

The Sheriff's Office released its records in stages, beginning on April 26, 2000, with video footage and continuing with the final report that May, and ending on July 6, 2006, with documents seized from the pair's homes and vehicles. All of the evidence that remained, the recordings included, was destroyed in early 2011.

No court ever heard evidence against Harris or Klebold, and their responsibility for the thirteen deaths rests on the findings of the Jefferson County Sheriff's Office, confirmed for one death by the El Paso County reinvestigation. In the early weeks of the inquiry, suggestions that others had taken part circulated widely; the final report rejected every one of them, and no one was ever charged as a participant.

The early theory that police had caused one of the deaths was rejected first by the Sheriff's Office on the physical evidence and then, after a specific allegation against a Denver officer, by the El Paso County reinvestigation. The question of what the county knew in advance, and whether it could have acted, was never settled to the satisfaction of many of the families. The District Attorney's Office held that the 1998 complaint could not have supported a warrant; the attorney general found no negligence; the grand jury found that a key document had been withheld and that records were missing, but charged no one.

Timeline

April 9, 1981: Eric Harris is born in Wichita, Kansas.

September 11, 1981: Dylan Klebold is born in Denver, Colorado.

Early 1997: The first complaints concerning Harris reach the Sheriff's Office.

August 7, 1997: A citizen gives a deputy pages from Harris's website; the deputy's directed report is filed in an investigator's intelligence binder.

January 30, 1998: Harris and Klebold are arrested in Jefferson County in a juvenile theft case.

March 14, 1998: Klebold receives a traffic citation.

March 1998: A family complains to the Sheriff's Office about threats by Harris.

March 25, 1998: Both formally enter the Jefferson County District Attorney's juvenile diversion program.

Spring 1998: An investigator drafts a warrant affidavit that is never presented to a judge.

February 3, 1999: Both are released early from diversion and the charges are dropped.

April 20, 1999: Thirteen people die and 21 are wounded at Columbine High School; Harris and Klebold die by suicide.

April 30, 1999: The Sheriff's Office holds a news conference without disclosing the draft affidavit.

November 12, 1999: The first of two suppliers is sentenced to six years in prison.

May 15, 2000: The Sheriff's Office releases its final report, finding that the two acted alone.

June 23, 2000: The second supplier is sentenced to four and a half years.

October 30, 2002: A district judge orders the juvenile diversion records made public.

October 23, 2003: The 1997 directed report is found in the investigator's old files.

October 29, 2003: The sheriff makes the report public and asks the attorney general to investigate.

February 26, 2004: The attorney general reports no negligence but finds the investigator's file missing.

September 2004: A state grand jury reports on the missing records and returns no indictments.

November 15, 2005: The Colorado Supreme Court holds that the pair's seized recordings are criminal justice records, left to the sheriff's discretion.

July 6, 2006: The Sheriff's Office releases documents seized from the two homes.

Early 2011: All remaining evidence is destroyed.