In December 2010, five younger brothers and sisters of Magalie Bamu came from Paris to spend Christmas with her in Newham, in east London, where she lived with her partner, Eric Bikubi. The youngest of the visitors was a teenage boy, the brother whose death on Christmas Day brought the couple to the Central Criminal Court, the Old Bailey, a little over a year later.
The prosecution case was that Bikubi had come to believe the visiting children were witches, that he accused them of bringing what he called kindoki into his household, and that over a period of days the accusation turned into violence, with the boy as its final target. Bamu, the prosecution said, did nothing to stop it and took part herself. On March 1, 2012, a jury convicted both of them of murder. Four days later the trial judge sentenced each to life imprisonment, with a minimum term of 30 years for Bikubi and 25 years for Bamu.
The trial turned on two questions, one for each defendant. Bikubi admitted that he had killed the boy, and the jury had to decide whether an abnormality of his mind reduced the crime from murder to manslaughter. Bamu denied that she shared his belief and said she had acted out of fear of him, and the jury had to decide whether she had taken part of her own accord. The jury rejected both defenses.
Eric Bikubi and Magalie Bamu were both originally from the Democratic Republic of Congo. When the trial opened in January 2012 both were 28; by sentencing in March, Bamu was 29. Bikubi worked as a football coach. Their household in Newham included a young child.
Within days the visit had become something else. The court heard that Bikubi accused the visiting children of practicing witchcraft and of exerting a harmful influence on the young child of the household. Two of the sisters were harmed until they "confessed" to being witches, and once they had done so the violence against them stopped. The boy would not confess, and the pressure on him grew. He died in Newham on December 25, 2010.
Bikubi and Bamu were each charged with the boy's murder and with two counts of actual bodily harm, one for each of the two sisters. Before the jury heard any evidence the two took different positions. Bikubi pleaded guilty to both counts of actual bodily harm and offered a plea of guilty to manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility. The Crown would not accept it, so the murder count went to trial against him. Bamu pleaded not guilty to everything.
The trial opened at the Old Bailey in January 2012, with the prosecution setting out its case to the jury on January 5, and ran into the first days of March. The Crown built its case largely on the accounts of the surviving children. It placed kindoki, the Lingala word for witchcraft, at the center of Bikubi's accusations, and argued that the belief explained what happened without excusing it, and that each defendant had acted knowing what he or she was doing. Against Bamu in particular, it alleged that she held the same belief as her partner.
Bikubi's defense rested on his mental state. His lawyers told the jury that he had a brain injury with effects resembling schizophrenia, capable of producing delusions and hallucinations, and that a brain scan had shown lesions which, the defense argued, probably contributed to an abnormal state of mind. That was the medical foundation of the plea he had offered before trial.
Bamu's defense was that she had acted under her partner's control. She told the jury that she had done what she was told because she was afraid of Bikubi, and that he had forced her to take part. She denied that she believed in witchcraft at all.
On March 1, 2012, the jury found Eric Bikubi guilty of murder, rejecting the diminished responsibility defense on which his case had depended. It found Magalie Bamu guilty of murder and of both counts of actual bodily harm against her sisters. The two were remanded in custody to await sentence.
The Crown Prosecution Service set out its position the same day. On Bikubi, it said the verdict confirmed what it had maintained when it refused his plea to manslaughter: that diminished responsibility could not be accepted on the facts, and that he had known what he was doing. On Bamu, it said she had acted of her own accord, had never tried to stop what was happening, and had held the same belief in witchcraft as her partner.
Sentence was passed at the Old Bailey on March 5, 2012. Each received the mandatory life sentence for murder, and the judge ordered that Bikubi serve at least 30 years and Bamu at least 25. He imposed no separate penalty on the counts of actual bodily harm.
On Bikubi, the judge accepted that he had brain damage, that the damage may have made him more inclined to believe the boy was a witch, and that the belief was genuinely held. He held that no belief in witchcraft, however genuine, could excuse violence against another person.
On Bamu he made the opposite finding. He did not accept her evidence that she did not believe in witchcraft, and he did not accept that Bikubi had forced her to take part. Her conduct, he found, could be explained only if she had shared her partner's belief, and that belief did not excuse it.
Both are serving the life sentences imposed in March 2012, in England.
In August 2012 the Department for Education published a national action plan on child abuse linked to faith or belief, and announced it as following the death in Newham in December 2010.
Bamu's own account was that she had never believed in witchcraft and had acted only because Bikubi frightened and compelled her. The jury convicted her, and the judge, in sentencing her, expressly rejected that account.
Bikubi's mental state is the one issue on which the jury's verdict and the judge's findings sit side by side. The jury rejected diminished responsibility as a defense to murder; the judge nonetheless accepted that he had brain damage which may have made him more inclined to believe the boy was a witch, and that the belief was genuine.
The court's findings on the belief itself went no further than the case the prosecution proved: that Bikubi accused the visiting children of kindoki, that he believed they were harming the young child of the household, and that the violence was carried out in an attempt to drive it out.
December 2010: Five of Magalie Bamu's younger brothers and sisters arrive in Newham from Paris for the Christmas holidays; Eric Bikubi accuses them of witchcraft, and two sisters are harmed before the violence turns on their brother.
December 25, 2010: The boy dies in Newham, east London.
Before trial: Bikubi pleads guilty to both counts of actual bodily harm and offers a plea of guilty to manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility, which the Crown does not accept. Bamu pleads not guilty to all charges.
January 2012: The trial opens at the Central Criminal Court (Old Bailey).
March 1, 2012: The jury convicts both defendants of murder and convicts Bamu of both counts of actual bodily harm.
March 5, 2012: Both are sentenced to life imprisonment, with minimum terms of 30 years for Bikubi and 25 years for Bamu.
August 14, 2012: The Department for Education publishes a national action plan on child abuse linked to faith or belief, announced as following the case.