Emilio Eduardo Massera was the admiral who brought the Argentine Navy into the military junta that seized power on March 24, 1976, and who commanded that Navy through the first two and a half years of the dictatorship. Nine years later, on December 9, 1985, a civilian federal court in Buenos Aires convicted him of three aggravated homicides and sentenced him to life in prison. He was one of only two commanders of the nine on trial to receive the maximum sentence; the other was General Jorge Rafael Videla, the army chief and the junta's first president.
The sentence did not hold him long. A presidential pardon freed him in December 1990, after less than five years. The cases opened against him later were suspended when the courts found him unfit for trial, and while they stood still, the courts took the pardon itself apart in three steps between 2007 and 2010. Massera died on November 8, 2010, with his 1985 life sentence restored.
Massera was born on October 19, 1925, in Paraná, the capital of Entre Ríos province. He entered the Escuela Naval, the Navy's officer academy, in 1942, graduated as a midshipman in 1946 and spent the next quarter century rising through the officer ranks. In 1973 a decree signed by President Juan Domingo Perón, Decree 552, named him commander in chief of the Navy, and he was promoted to full admiral in 1974.
On March 24, 1976, the commanders of the three armed forces removed President María Estela Martínez de Perón from office, and Massera took the Navy's seat in the junta beside Videla and Brigadier General Orlando Ramón Agosti of the air force. The court that later tried him recorded that he held the Navy's command "entre el 24 de marzo de 1976 y el 15 de septiembre de 1978," between March 24, 1976, and September 15, 1978. In those years the Navy ran a clandestine detention center at the Escuela de Mecánica de la Armada, the Navy Mechanics School known as ESMA, in Buenos Aires, under his command. When his command ended in September 1978, he passed into retirement.
Civilian rule returned in December 1983, and that month President Raúl Alfonsín's Decree 158 ordered the members of the first three juntas brought to trial. The case reached the federal appeals court of Buenos Aires in 1984 as Causa 13/84, with nine commanders accused. Before that court Massera maintained that the directives against what the regime called subversion had been lawful, and denied knowing of any excesses. The oral and public trial opened on April 22, 1985. It was the first time a civilian court in Argentina had put the commanders of a dictatorship on trial, and 839 witnesses, most of them survivors and relatives of the disappeared, came before it. The court rested its judgment on 709 cases presented at trial. For Massera the prosecution asked for life imprisonment on 83 counts of aggravated homicide, among other offenses.
The court delivered its sentence on December 9, 1985. In the twelfth point of the operative part it convicted "el Almirante (R) Emilio Eduardo Massera" of "homicidio agravado por alevosía, reiterado en tres oportunidades": homicide aggravated by treachery, committed on three occasions. The same point convicted him of illegal deprivation of liberty aggravated by violence and threats on 69 occasions, tormentos on 12 and robbery on 7. The penalty was "prisión perpetua, inhabilitación absoluta perpetua," life imprisonment with permanent absolute disqualification from public office, and the court added his dismissal from the Navy and the costs of the case.
The thirteenth point set out what the court did not find proved. It acquitted him of 83 counts of "homicidio calificado," aggravated homicide, and five counts of tormentos followed by death, along with 447 counts of aggravated deprivation of liberty, 260 of tormentos, 99 robberies, six counts of taking a minor and a series of lesser charges. The court held that the juntas had carried out a criminal plan in the name of fighting terrorism. Five of the nine accused were convicted: Videla received the same life sentence as Massera, three others received terms of years, and four were acquitted.
Massera served his sentence in military custody. Decree 2741/90, signed by President Carlos Saúl Menem and dated December 29, 1990, pardoned him together with Videla, Agosti and two commanders of the second junta, and he was freed from military prison.
In November 1998 he was detained again, in a federal case over children born in captivity, a matter the pardon did not reach; further Argentine cases and a trial in absentia in Rome followed, and none of them ever reached a verdict. He spent most of those years under domiciliary arrest, which Argentine law allows for defendants over 70. In early 2005 judges suspended every Argentine case against him after the official court medical body reported a condition equivalent to "incapacidad total y absoluta," total and absolute incapacity, that prevented him from facing trial.
While those cases stood still, the courts dismantled the pardon. On April 25, 2007, the Cámara Federal of Buenos Aires ruled unanimously that the pardons of Videla and Massera were unconstitutional, because they conflicted with international treaties that oblige Argentina to investigate and punish human rights violations, and the ruling revived the life sentences of Causa 13/84. On June 18, 2009, Chamber II of the Cámara Nacional de Casación Penal, the national criminal court of cassation, upheld it. On August 31, 2010, the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation rejected the last challenges, ratified the nullity of the pardons and left the question of his incapacity to the lower courts.
From April 19, 2010, Massera was held at the Naval Hospital in Buenos Aires, still under arrest. He died there on November 8, 2010, at 85, with no verdict in any of the cases opened against him after 1998.
No court ever fixed the number of people killed under Massera's command. The 1985 court convicted him of three aggravated homicides and acquitted him of 83 more that the prosecution had charged. Estimates of the dictatorship's dead, about 9,000 in official records, about 11,000 in a later official panel's count and closer to 30,000 according to human rights groups, are not findings against him.
The child-appropriation cases opened from 1998, the trial in Rome and the extradition requests from Germany, Spain, France and Switzerland never reached a verdict; the Argentine cases were suspended in 2005 for incapacity, and he died untried in all of them. A 1983 detention in an inquiry into a 1977 disappearance also ended without any conviction.
His fitness to stand trial was itself contested. Argentine court doctors found him incapable from 2005 onward; Italian experts in 2009 found him fit. The Argentine courts accepted the domestic findings, and the Supreme Court in 2010 left that judgment to them.
October 19, 1925: Born in Paraná, Entre Ríos.
1973: Named commander in chief of the Navy by Decree 552.
1974: Promoted to full admiral.
March 24, 1976: Joins Videla and Agosti in the junta.
September 15, 1978: His command of the Navy ends.
April 22, 1985: The Trial of the Juntas opens in Buenos Aires.
December 9, 1985: Convicted of three aggravated homicides and other crimes; sentenced to life imprisonment and dismissal from the Navy.
December 29, 1990: Pardoned under Decree 2741/90.
November 24, 1998: Detained in a child-appropriation case that never reached a verdict.
January to March 2005: All Argentine cases suspended for incapacity.
April 25, 2007: The Cámara Federal declares the pardon unconstitutional.
June 18, 2009: The Cámara Nacional de Casación Penal upholds that ruling.
August 31, 2010: The Supreme Court ratifies the nullity of the pardon.
November 8, 2010: Dies at the Naval Hospital, Buenos Aires.