Elize Matsunaga killed her husband, Marcos Kitano Matsunaga, in the Vila Leopoldina district of São Paulo on the night of May 19, 2012. She was the mother of a small daughter and the holder of a law degree her husband had paid for. For more than two weeks the death was a police inquiry without a suspect in custody. On June 4 a court ordered her temporary arrest, and on June 6, after a long interview at the state homicide department, she admitted the killing and said she had acted alone.
Her admission settled who had done it. It did not settle what the law should call it, and that question took four and a half more years to answer. Prosecutors charged her with homicide carrying three aggravating qualifiers, a case worth as much as 33 years. Her defense asked a jury to see a crime committed in the grip of violent emotion after years of humiliation in a failing marriage, which would have cut the sentence sharply. After seven days of testimony at the Barra Funda criminal courthouse, the jury rejected two of the three qualifiers but convicted her of homicídio qualificado and a second offense. The presiding judge sentenced her to 19 years, 11 months and 1 day. Appeals in São Paulo failed; the Superior Tribunal de Justiça in Brasília later trimmed the homicide sentence to 16 years and 3 months because she had confessed. She left prison on conditional release on May 30, 2022, almost exactly ten years after the killing.
Elize Araújo grew up in Chopinzinho, a small town in the interior of Paraná, in southern Brazil, and later moved to Curitiba, the state capital, to train as a nursing technician. She met her future husband in late 2004, she told the jury, and the relationship moved slowly toward marriage. They lived together for about two years and married in 2009. He paid for her law studies, and in the early years he traveled with her to Paraná to meet her family. By the spring of 2012 they had a small daughter. By her own account the marriage had been in trouble since 2010, when she learned that he was seeing another woman. She consulted divorce lawyers, she testified, but never filed. Later she hired a private investigator to follow him.
What passed between husband and wife that night is known almost entirely from her own statements, first to the police and later to the jury. She had returned to São Paulo from a trip with the couple's daughter and the child's nanny. That evening, she said, she learned of a family visit he had planned and suspected it was cover for a meeting with his lover. She told him that she had hired an investigator. The argument that followed, in her account, turned to insults and then to a slap. On the stand in December 2016 she insisted that she had not planned what followed and had never wanted him dead. The prosecution argued the opposite: that she had prepared for the killing and had acted out of revenge and for money. The jury was asked to choose between those accounts, and its answers, as the sentence later showed, fell between them.
The case went to the Departamento de Homicídios e de Proteção à Pessoa, the São Paulo state police homicide department. For more than two weeks its detectives worked the inquiry while the widow remained free. The evidence they gathered pointed to her, and on June 4, 2012, a court ordered her temporary arrest.
Questioning began at the homicide department on June 6, and the same day the department confirmed that she had confessed. She told detectives that she had confronted her husband over his affair, that the confrontation had turned violent, and that she had done everything herself. A reconstruction of the events followed within days, and investigators concluded that she appeared to have acted alone. By June 7 the department regarded the inquiry as nearly closed, with only expert reports outstanding.
The São Paulo state prosecutors' office charged her with homicide carrying three qualifiers: motivo torpe, a base or vile motive; meio cruel, a cruel means; and recurso que impossibilitou a defesa da vítima, a means that left the victim unable to defend himself. It added a second offense, destroying and concealing a corpse. On June 19, 2012, a judge of the 5th Jury Court of São Paulo accepted the accusation and converted her custody into preventive detention, the Brazilian form of remand. Preliminary hearings began that November, and the judge went on to send her to trial before a popular jury on all three qualifiers and the second offense. More than three years passed before the trial began, and she spent all of them in preventive detention.
The trial opened on November 28, 2016, at the Fórum Criminal da Barra Funda and ran for seven days. The prosecution pressed all three qualifiers. Its case was that the killing had been planned, carried out for revenge and for money, and that the victim had been given no chance to defend himself; with the qualifiers and the second offense, it said, the sentence could reach 33 years. The defense did not contest that she had killed him. Its lawyers asked the jury to convict her of simple homicide and to find that she had acted under violent emotion after unjust provocation, which would have reduced the term. They told the jury that she had suffered domestic abuse and rejected any suggestion that someone had helped her.
She testified on December 4, the seventh day, for about four and a half hours, answering the judge's questions and declining the prosecution's. She described meeting her husband, the years of living together, the marriage and the discovery of his affair, and the insults she said he had directed at her. She said she had never wanted to kill him and had not acted out of cruelty, and she apologized to the people she had hurt.
The verdict came in the early hours of December 5, 2016. The jury convicted her of homicide but accepted only one of the three qualifiers: that she had used a means that left the victim unable to defend himself. It rejected motivo torpe, finding that the killing had not been committed for revenge or for money, and it rejected meio cruel. It also convicted her of the second offense and declined to reduce the homicide to a crime of emotion. The qualified homicide was a crime classed as hediondo under Brazilian law, and that classification meant she could not await her appeals at liberty. The presiding judge fixed the total sentence at 19 years, 11 months and 1 day of reclusão, to begin in the closed regime. Both sides announced appeals before they left the courthouse: the defense because it considered the term too high for a homicide with a single qualifier, the prosecution because it wanted the two rejected qualifiers restored.
The appeals went first to the 7th Criminal Chamber of the Tribunal de Justiça de São Paulo, the state's court of appeal. The defense challenged the calculation of the sentence. It argued that the base term was out of line with other homicide cases carrying one qualifier and that the trial judge had wrongly refused to treat her confession as a mitigating circumstance because she had confessed only after the investigation already pointed at her. The prosecution asked the chamber to annul the verdict and order the two rejected qualifiers tried again. On April 25, 2018, the chamber rejected both appeals unanimously and upheld the sentence of 19 years, 11 months and 1 day in full.
The defense took the confession question to the Superior Tribunal de Justiça in Brasília. In a habeas corpus decided by its Fifth Panel, the court held that a defendant who admits the crime is entitled to the mitigation even if she adds defensive claims to the admission. It applied a reduction of one-sixth and cut the homicide sentence by two years and six months, to 16 years and 3 months. The decision was reported in March 2019. In June 2019 the reporting minister rejected a separate special appeal by the defense, and the reduced homicide term from the habeas corpus stood.
She served her sentence at a women's penitentiary in São Paulo state, where she ran a sewing workshop operated by the state prison-labor foundation, and days of work counted against her term. In August 2019 a criminal-execution judge in Taubaté moved her to the semi-open regime, after the prosecution gave a favorable opinion and an assessment panel found her fit for it, allowing her to work or study by day and return to prison at night.
On May 30, 2022, she left the penitentiary on livramento condicional, conditional release, and the state prison administration confirmed that the order had been carried out. The conditions required her to report her address and occupation to the court at regular intervals, and with the reduced sentence the term was due to run until 2028. In a short statement after her release, she said she knew she could not undo what had happened and that she had been given a second chance her husband would never have. She settled in the interior of São Paulo state and took up work as a driver.
In March 2023 the local prosecutors' office asked the criminal-execution court to return her to prison while a police inquiry into a job application she had made was at an early stage; she denied wrongdoing. The court refused, finding that she had complied with the conditions of her release. As of July 2026 she was living in the interior of São Paulo state, serving the rest of her sentence outside prison.
The date of the killing is given as May 19, 2012, in later accounts of the case and in the record of her release; some reports from 2012 placed it on May 20, the early hours of the following day.
Whether she planned the killing was the central dispute of the trial. The prosecution said she did; she denied any plan, and the jury's rejection of two of the three qualifiers, including the finding that she had not killed for revenge or for money, left the question of premeditation without a separate answer.
Her claim that her husband struck her during the argument rests on her own statements. The jury did not accept the defense plea of violent emotion after unjust provocation.
The prosecution suggested at an early stage that someone had helped her; she has always said she acted alone, the homicide department concluded the same, and no one else was charged.
2004: Elize Araújo meets her future husband, by her own account.
2009: The couple marry after about two years of living together.
May 19, 2012: Her husband is killed in the Vila Leopoldina district of São Paulo.
June 4, 2012: A court orders Elize Matsunaga's temporary arrest.
June 6, 2012: She confesses to the São Paulo homicide department and says she acted alone.
June 19, 2012: The 5th Jury Court of São Paulo accepts the prosecution's accusation and orders preventive detention.
November 28, 2016: The jury trial opens at the Fórum Criminal da Barra Funda.
December 4, 2016: She testifies for about four and a half hours.
December 5, 2016: The jury convicts her of homicídio qualificado and a second offense; sentence of 19 years, 11 months and 1 day.
April 25, 2018: The 7th Criminal Chamber of the São Paulo Court of Justice unanimously upholds the sentence.
March 2019: The Superior Tribunal de Justiça reduces the homicide sentence to 16 years and 3 months for her confession.
August 2019: A Taubaté criminal-execution judge moves her to the semi-open regime.
May 30, 2022: She leaves prison on conditional release.
March 2023: A criminal-execution court refuses a prosecution request to return her to prison.
July 2026: She is living in the interior of São Paulo state, serving the remainder of her sentence on release.