Eliyahu Hakim was one of two young men from British-ruled Palestine who killed Lord Moyne (Walter Edward Guinness), Britain's Minister Resident in the Middle East, in Cairo on November 6, 1944. The minister's driver, Lance Corporal Fuller of the British Army, died with him. Hakim and his companion, Eliyahu Bet-Zuri, were members of Lehi, the underground group the British called the Stern Group, which sought a Jewish state in Palestine through the violent overthrow of the British administration there. Both were in the hands of the Egyptian police the same day. In January 1945 a five-man Egyptian military court heard their case. Both men admitted the killings, and both were found guilty and sentenced to death. They were executed in Cairo on March 22, 1945.
The case was a political event before it was a criminal one. The dead man was a member of the British government and its senior political officer in the region, and he died in the capital of Egypt, not in a British territory. The prosecution that followed belonged to Egypt, under Egyptian law, before an Egyptian military court.
Hakim came from Haifa. In November 1944 the Palestine authorities identified him as Eliahu Khakim of that city, and the same identification gave his companion as Ephraim Ben-Zuri of Tel Aviv, the name under which Bet-Zuri appeared throughout the trial. Hakim had served in the British Army and had left it in February 1944, nine months before the killing.
The minister had served as a young man in the South African War, and in the First World War he commanded a battalion and fought at Gallipoli, in France and in Flanders. He was mentioned in despatches three times and won the Distinguished Service Order and bar. He then spent more than twenty years in the House of Commons, where he served as Financial Secretary to the Treasury and later as Minister of Agriculture, before he went to the House of Lords. At the outbreak of the Second World War he returned to government as Under-Secretary in the same ministry he had once led. He was Secretary of State for the Colonies in 1941 and 1942 and Leader of the House of Lords. He went to Cairo as Deputy Minister of State in 1942, and from the beginning of 1944 he was Minister Resident in the Middle East, the British cabinet's representative in the region.
Away from office he was an explorer and traveler with a devotion to natural history and science, an interest in art and fine architecture, and a love of yachting. He had followed Lord Lloyd as President of the Seamen's Hospital Society.
The second man was a young British soldier who was driving the minister that day. The court later accepted that his death had not been planned, and Bet-Zuri told the court that he regretted it.
Egyptian police arrested both men in Cairo on the day of the killing. At first the two prisoners refused to answer questions. When they did give names, they gave false ones, Moshe Cohen Itzhak and Charles Salzman, and the Egyptian government announced that neither was an Egyptian subject.
The Egyptian authorities led the inquiry, working with the Palestine Police. On November 9 the Foreign Secretary told the Commons that the two men had confessed to belonging to the Fighters for the Freedom of Israel, which he identified as the Stern Group, and that they said they had acted on its instructions. At a preliminary examination in Cairo the next day, Bet-Zuri told investigators that the minister had been chosen for his office and not for any personal reason. By November 14 the Palestine authorities had established the true identities of both men.
On November 10, 1944, Egypt announced that the two men would be tried by a military court. Under the wartime regulations then in force in Egypt, murder counted as a military offense. The charges were murder, the attempted murder of an Egyptian police constable, and an offense under the arms law. As first drawn, the indictment charged Hakim as the principal in the murder of the minister and as an accessory to the murder of the driver. Bet-Zuri was charged as the principal in the driver's murder and as an accessory in the death of the minister. A further charge of unlawful possession concerned materials Bet-Zuri had left in Cairo.
The trial opened in Cairo in January 1945 before a five-man military court. A defense request to move the case to a civil court was refused.
Both men admitted the murder of the minister and pleaded guilty to the death of the driver and to the possession charge. Both denied attempting to kill the constable. Hakim told the court that he had not wanted to harm the constable or the driver, accepted that the killing of the minister had been deliberate and premeditated, and argued that it had been a political act. The prosecution asked for the death penalty for both men. Defense counsel did not ask for an acquittal, only for leniency.
As the trial neared its end, the prosecution changed its case on responsibility. Because the court had accepted that the death of the driver was unplanned, it asked the court to hold Bet-Zuri equally responsible for the murder of the minister, on the ground that both men had admitted coming to Egypt to kill him. The court adjourned for a day so that the defense could answer the altered indictment.
On January 18, 1945, the military court found both men guilty and announced that they would be sentenced to death. Under Egyptian procedure, the court referred the papers of the case to the Grand Mufti of Egypt for his opinion before the sentence could be pronounced. The Mufti confirmed the verdict, and a few days later the president of the court read out the grounds and formally pronounced sentence of death on both men.
There was no appeal. Egyptian law allowed none from a military court, and the only course left was a plea to the Egyptian government to commute the sentences. Appeals for clemency were made from abroad, but the sentences were not commuted. Eliyahu Hakim and Eliyahu Bet-Zuri were executed in Cairo on March 22, 1945.
Hakim's age is the main uncertainty in the case. The first identification in November 1944 gave him as 25. At the trial the prosecution and the defense disputed whether he had reached 18, the age below which Egyptian law forbade a death sentence, and the court appointed a doctor to examine him; it then passed sentence of death.
The division of roles rested on the defendants' own admissions. Hakim was held to have killed the minister and Bet-Zuri the driver, and the prosecution's late motion asked that Bet-Zuri also be held responsible for the minister's death. One contemporary news dispatch dates the execution March 23, 1945.
February 1944: Hakim leaves the British Army.
Early 1944: The minister becomes Minister Resident in the Middle East.
November 6, 1944: The minister and his driver are killed in Cairo; Hakim and Bet-Zuri are arrested by Egyptian police the same day.
November 9, 1944: The British government tells the House of Commons that both men have confessed to membership of the Stern Group.
November 10, 1944: Egypt announces a military court trial; Bet-Zuri is questioned at a preliminary examination.
November 14, 1944: The true identities of the two men are established.
January 1945: The trial opens before a five-man military court in Cairo; both men admit the killings.
January 18, 1945: The court finds both men guilty and announces death sentences.
Late January 1945: The Grand Mufti of Egypt confirms the verdict, and the sentences are formally pronounced.
March 22, 1945: Hakim and Bet-Zuri are executed in Cairo.