Eliézer Niyitegeka

Victims
Thousands of Tutsi refugees killed at Bisesero, Rwanda, 1994. Convicted by the Rwanda tribunal, 2003, of genocide, extermination and the murder of three people; life term
Years active
April to June 1994 (Mubuga, Rugarama, Muyira Hill, Kivumu, Kucyapa, Kiziba, Kazirandimwe Hill and Kibuye)
Location
Bisesero and Kibuye, Kibuye Prefecture, Rwanda; Nairobi, Kenya; Arusha, Tanzania; Mali
Method
Genocide and crimes against humanity: leading and taking part in attacks on Tutsi refugees, planning them at meetings, and publicly inciting attackers.
Status
Life imprisonment (May 2003); appeal dismissed July 9, 2004; transferred to Mali, December 2008; died there March 28, 2018.

Eliézer Niyitegeka was Rwanda's minister of information during the genocide of 1994, a former radio news presenter and regional party chairman who had built his public life in the prefecture of Kibuye, in the west of the country. In May 2003 the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda found that, between April and June of that year, he had used that standing to help organize and lead attacks on the Tutsi civilians who had taken refuge in the hills of Bisesero. Trial Chamber I convicted him of genocide, conspiracy to commit genocide, direct and public incitement to commit genocide, and murder, extermination and other inhumane acts as crimes against humanity, and sentenced him to imprisonment for the remainder of his life.

His appeal was dismissed in its entirety in July 2004. For the next fourteen years he fought the judgment from custody, first in Arusha and then in Mali, and none of his requests reopened the case. He died in Mali on March 28, 2018, with a further request still pending, and the appeals judges dismissed it two weeks later because the tribunal's jurisdiction ends with the life of the person convicted.

Gisovu, Radio Rwanda and the MDR

Niyitegeka was born on March 12, 1952, in Gitabura secteur, in the commune of Gisovu, Kibuye Prefecture. The hills of Bisesero straddle the border between Gisovu and the neighboring commune of Gishyita, and several of the witnesses who identified him at trial had known him before 1994, which the judges treated as an answer to the defense claim that he had been mistaken for someone else.

He made his name in broadcasting. Before he entered government he worked as a journalist and news presenter on Radio Rwanda, the national station, and he later sat in parliament and worked in business, including a spell as a manager at a textile factory. In politics he belonged to the Mouvement Démocratique Républicain, the MDR. From 1991 to 1994 he chaired the MDR in Kibuye Prefecture, and he sat on the party's national political bureau.

A minister in the interim government

President Juvénal Habyarimana was assassinated on April 6, 1994, and within days an interim government had been assembled. Niyitegeka was sworn in as its minister of information on April 9, 1994. The court found that he had joined that government voluntarily and that he had supported its prime minister, Jean Kambanda, who later pleaded guilty before the same tribunal and was convicted in 1998. The judges also found that he took an active part in that government: he attended its meetings and carried the government's messages to the country on Radio Rwanda and at public meetings.

The prosecution argued that he belonged to an extremist wing of the MDR. Two veteran party politicians testified for the defense that no such faction had existed under that name, and the Chamber found the evidence too thin to decide the party's internal politics, so it made no finding either way. Its findings went to conduct instead: he was a member of the MDR, and he served the interim government willingly from its first days.

The indictment had alleged that, as minister, he bore superior responsibility for the state media office, ORINFOR, and for what was broadcast on the radio. The Trial Chamber rejected every charge brought on the basis of superior responsibility, holding that his ministerial office alone did not prove effective control over anyone who committed the crimes. The judges accepted that he was one of several leaders of the attacks and that attackers followed his orders. But no evidence showed that a minister of information commanded the bourgmestres, the Interahamwe or the soldiers and police who took part, and nothing showed that he could prevent their crimes or punish them afterward. Without that relationship, the court did not go further. The convictions that followed rested instead on what the judges found he had personally done, said and planned in Kibuye.

Bisesero

Bisesero is a hilly area of Kibuye Prefecture on the border between the communes of Gishyita and Gisovu. In April 1994 Tutsi from across the region gathered on its hills, among them Muyira, Kizenga, Kivumu and Gitwe. The Chamber found that attacks on the refugees there came on a near-daily basis from late April onward, and that the attacks across Kibuye Prefecture, and in Bisesero above all, were widespread and systematic and were directed at the civilian Tutsi population on ethnic grounds from April to July 1994.

The court accepted that some 5,000 refugees were on Muyira Hill at the time of the first attack it attributed to him there, and it found that thousands of Tutsi refugees were killed in the attack of May 13.

April 1994

The earliest conduct the Chamber attributed to Niyitegeka came within days of the president's death. On April 13, 1994, at Rugarama in Bisesero, it found that he publicly urged attackers to resume attacks on Tutsi, one of the grounds of his conviction for direct and public incitement to commit genocide. About ten days after April 6, the Chamber found, he procured gendarmes for an attack on Tutsi who had taken shelter at Mubuga, a finding the judges used as evidence of his intent to destroy the Tutsi group rather than as a separate basis of conviction.

Between April 17 and 30, 1994, the judgment found, he was among the leaders of a large-scale attack on the refugees of Muyira Hill and took part in it personally, and he led a second attack on the hill the same day. At the end of April or early in May, the Chamber found, he was again a leader in a large-scale attack, this time at Kivumu in Bisesero.

On May 3, 1994, a large meeting was held at the Kibuye prefectural office at the initiative of the interim government, presented as an exercise in pacification. The Chamber found that the killings and the worsening insecurity were not condemned there. Niyitegeka attended and spoke, and the judges found that he expressed his support for the interim government and that, judged by his own words and conduct, he supported the actions, and the failures to act, that left the Tutsi population unprotected and led to many deaths. The Chamber did not convict him of a separate offense for the meeting, but it treated his part in it as evidence of his genocidal intent.

Muyira Hill and Kucyapa, May 13 and 14

The attack of May 13, 1994, was the largest the court described. The Chamber found that Niyitegeka was one of its leaders. Thousands of people took part, among them Interahamwe militia, soldiers, police and civilians, and thousands of Tutsi refugees were killed.

That evening, at Kucyapa, about 5,000 people gathered. The Chamber found that Niyitegeka addressed them, commended the attackers for the killing of Tutsi civilians and urged them to come back the next day and continue, and that the purpose of the gathering was to organize further attacks on the Tutsi who remained in Bisesero. That address was a second ground of his conviction for incitement.

The Trial Chamber also found him responsible for an attack on Muyira on May 14, rejecting alibi evidence that placed him elsewhere on an uncertain date. On appeal that finding was held to have been made in error, because the indictment never gave him notice of it.

The meetings of June

The Chamber found that, about June 10, 1994, Niyitegeka attended a meeting at the Kibuye prefectural office as one of its leaders, held to find ways of killing the Tutsi of Bisesero, and that he promised material support for the attacks. At follow-up meetings at the same office around June 17 and 18, and at another gathering there in June, it found that he presented a plan of attack, called for men to be recruited and pledged forces for the attacks.

From these meetings, and from the organized, planned character of the attacks, the Chamber inferred an agreement between Niyitegeka, Kayishema, Ruzindana and others to commit genocide. That agreement was the basis of his conviction for conspiracy to commit genocide. The decisive evidence was the meeting of about June 10, where, the judges found, he sketched a plan of attack and those present agreed to it; the later planning meetings confirmed the inference.

The finding of genocidal intent drew the whole record together. The Chamber found that he meant to destroy the Tutsi group, in whole or in part, and it found that intent in his leadership of and personal part in the attacks, in the killings, in his support for the attack at Mubuga, in the planning meetings, in his incitement and in his stance at the meeting of May 3.

The three murders and the inhumane acts

The murder convictions rested on three deaths. The Chamber found that on May 20, 1994, between Gisovu and Kibuye, Niyitegeka killed a Tutsi girl, and that around June 18, 1994, at Kiziba in Bisesero, he killed a man and a boy. Each death was held to form part of the widespread and systematic attack on the Tutsi civilian population, and the same killings, together with his part in the attacks on the hills, supported his conviction for extermination.

The conviction for other inhumane acts rested on two events late in June: on June 22, 1994, at Kazirandimwe Hill, the Chamber found that he aided and abetted attackers in acts committed against one man, and on June 28, 1994, in Kibuye, that he ordered a further inhumane act. The judges held that both were of a gravity comparable to the crimes listed in the tribunal's statute and formed part of the same widespread and systematic attack.

Arrest and trial

The tribunal confirmed its first indictment against Niyitegeka on July 15, 1996, while he was still at large. On February 9, 1999, he was arrested in Nairobi, Kenya, under the tribunal's warrant, and two days later he was transferred to the United Nations Detention Facility in Arusha, Tanzania. He pleaded not guilty to every count. The indictment was amended four times in all, and the version on which he was tried charged ten counts covering conduct in Bisesero from about April 9 to June 30, 1994.

The trial opened before Trial Chamber I on June 17, 2002, and closing arguments were heard in February 2003. Niyitegeka did not testify, and the Chamber drew no adverse inference from his silence. His defense rested on alibi evidence and on attacks on the credibility of the prosecution witnesses and their identification of him. The judges applied the rule that an accused does not have to prove an alibi and must be acquitted if it raises a reasonable doubt, and they found that his alibi witnesses did not raise one.

The defense also argued that Rwanda in 1994 had been a country at war rather than the scene of a genocide. The Chamber rejected the argument outright. It found that genocide had taken place, that Niyitegeka knew of the killings and actively supported them, and that there was no evidence of rebel forces in Kibuye at the time. It found no evidence, either, that the prosecution witnesses had been influenced or pressured by outside groups.

Verdict and sentence

On May 15, 2003, the Chamber delivered its verdict, and its written judgment bears the date May 16, 2003. It found Niyitegeka guilty, unanimously, on six of the ten counts: genocide; conspiracy to commit genocide; direct and public incitement to commit genocide; and crimes against humanity (murder), (extermination) and (other inhumane acts).

He was found not guilty on four counts. Complicity in genocide had been charged in the alternative to genocide, and once he was convicted of genocide the Chamber entered a verdict of not guilty without deciding it separately. On rape as a crime against humanity the judges found the evidence insufficient. The two counts of serious violations of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions and of Additional Protocol II had been withdrawn by the prosecution.

In aggravation the judges set his influence in Kibuye and his abuse of the population's trust, his turn to violence as a national minister, his part in the massacres at Bisesero and his incitement of others, the murders, the inhumane acts and the prolonged character of his participation. In mitigation they set his good character before 1994 and his rescue of a group of refugees from the Interahamwe during the genocide, which they gave limited weight in light of his other crimes. The aggravating circumstances, the Chamber held, outweighed those in mitigation, and it sentenced him to "imprisonment for the remainder of his life."

The appeal

He appealed both the convictions and the sentence, and the Appeals Chamber delivered its judgment on July 9, 2004. It rejected his reading of the genocide definition, holding that the words "as such" require that victims be targeted because of their membership in the group, not solely because of it, and that personal motives do not rule out genocidal intent. It upheld the trial judges' treatment of the alibi evidence and of the prosecution witnesses.

On the alibi, the Appeals Chamber held that the burden of proving guilt beyond reasonable doubt stays with the prosecution throughout, that an accused who offers an alibi need only raise a reasonable doubt, and that the trial judges had applied exactly that rule. He had not shown that they held his witnesses to a stricter standard than the prosecution's.

The attack on the witnesses fared no better. The judges held that a Trial Chamber may rest a finding on the evidence of a single witness, that inconsistencies between a witness's earlier statements and testimony in court do not by themselves make the evidence unreliable, and that the word of an alleged accomplice is not unreliable in itself but must be weighed with care. They found the trial judges' approach to identification properly cautious, and they went through the prosecution witnesses one by one, upholding each credibility finding he had challenged. A series of broader complaints, that the evidence against him had been fabricated or tainted and that his trial had been unfair, failed because he pointed to no decision and no part of the record to support them, and his belief that statements favorable to him had been withheld was found to have no support.

Two of his points succeeded. The Appeals Chamber held that the prosecution had not given him adequate notice of the attack at Kivumu at the end of April or early May 1994, or of the attack on Muyira Hill on May 14, 1994, and that the Trial Chamber had erred in law by making findings on them. Neither error disturbed the verdict, because no conviction rested solely on either attack, and neither affected the sentence. The court held that a missing material fact in an indictment can be cured if the prosecution later gives timely, clear and consistent notice of it, and it found that this had happened for the attack of May 13 and for the Kiziba killings, both set out in the prosecution's pre-trial brief; the identity of the girl killed on May 20 did not have to be pleaded at all. For Kivumu and for May 14 there had been no such notice.

The sentence held as well. The Appeals Chamber found that the trial judges had considered everything he offered in mitigation: his good character before 1994, his support for democracy and his opposition to ethnic discrimination, and his rescue of a group of refugees. How much weight to give those factors was for the Trial Chamber, and it had been entitled to give them little, because he had chosen to take part in massacres of civilians and the rescue was a single occasion set against many grave crimes. A life sentence, the court held, may be imposed even where mitigation exists if the gravity of the crimes demands the maximum, and the two notice errors did nothing to lessen the seriousness of the crimes that had been fairly tried. There was no ground to sentence him again.

The Appeals Chamber dismissed the appeal "in its entirety" and affirmed "the sentence of imprisonment for the remainder of his life." It ordered the judgment enforced immediately and directed that he stay in the tribunal's custody until his transfer to the state where he would serve it.

Mali and the last years

People convicted by the tribunal could not serve their sentences in Tanzania, and Mali was one of the states that had agreed to take them, under an agreement with the United Nations signed on February 12, 1999. Niyitegeka reached his new prison there on December 7, 2008, and served the rest of his sentence in Mali. The sentence was carried out under Malian law and international standards of detention, subject to the supervision of the tribunal and, from July 1, 2012, of the International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals, which took over that duty. In May 2016 Mali and the United Nations signed a new agreement covering sentences of both the tribunal and the Mechanism; sixteen people convicted by the Rwanda tribunal were then serving their terms in the country.

From 2004 onward he filed a long series of requests for review, arguing that new material placed him elsewhere on dates when the court had found him in Bisesero, and later that a protected prosecution witness had given false testimony against him; the appeals judges dismissed every one, though in 2015 they found his challenge to that witness's evidence complex enough to assign him a lawyer for three months. He died in Mali on March 28, 2018, while serving his sentence, with a final request still pending. On April 13, 2018, the Appeals Chamber of the International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals dismissed it, holding that its jurisdiction covers only the living. The convictions and the life sentence affirmed in 2004 stand as the final judgment in his case.

Disputed and unproven points

Niyitegeka denied the charges throughout and maintained to the end of his life that the prosecution witnesses had lied. Several allegations against him failed. He was acquitted of complicity in genocide, of rape as a crime against humanity and of the two war-crimes counts, and the Trial Chamber rejected every charge based on superior responsibility, including the allegation that he answered as minister for what the state media broadcast. An alleged meeting in Kibuye in mid-March 1994 and an alleged attack at Kizenga Hill were not proved beyond reasonable doubt. Nor was the allegation that he killed a man and a woman near Kibuye on June 28, 1994, and the Chamber set aside two alleged June attacks in other cellules of the area because the indictment gave him no notice of them. The prosecution's claim that he belonged to an extremist wing of the MDR was never decided.

The Appeals Chamber held that the findings on the Kivumu attack and on the attack on Muyira Hill of May 14 should not have been made, although the convictions stood on other findings. His claims about the protected witness, on whose uncorroborated account the findings about the June meetings and the Kiziba killings partly rested, were never decided on their merits, and his death ended the case with that question unresolved.

Timeline

March 12, 1952: Born in Gitabura secteur, Gisovu commune, Kibuye Prefecture, Rwanda.

1991 to 1994: Chairman of the MDR in Kibuye Prefecture and member of its national political bureau.

April 6, 1994: President Habyarimana is assassinated.

April 9, 1994: Sworn in as minister of information in the interim government.

April 13, 1994: At Rugarama, Bisesero, urges attackers to resume attacks (incitement finding).

About April 16, 1994: Procures gendarmes for an attack on refugees at Mubuga.

April 17 to 30, 1994: Leads attacks on refugees on Muyira Hill.

May 3, 1994: Attends and speaks at the interim government's meeting at the Kibuye prefectural office.

May 13, 1994: Among the leaders of the large-scale attack on Muyira Hill; addresses the gathering at Kucyapa that evening.

May 20, 1994: Murder of a girl between Gisovu and Kibuye (court finding).

About June 10 to 18, 1994: Leads planning meetings at the Kibuye prefectural office.

About June 18, 1994: Murders of a man and a boy at Kiziba (court finding).

June 22 and 28, 1994: Events at Kazirandimwe Hill and in Kibuye (other inhumane acts).

July 15, 1996: First indictment confirmed.

February 9, 1999: Arrested in Nairobi, Kenya.

February 11, 1999: Transferred to the tribunal's detention facility in Arusha.

June 17, 2002: Trial opens before Trial Chamber I.

May 15, 2003: Convicted on six counts and sentenced to imprisonment for the remainder of his life (written judgment dated May 16).

July 9, 2004: Appeals Chamber dismisses the appeal and affirms the sentence.

December 7, 2008: Arrives at his new prison in Mali.

March 28, 2018: Dies in Mali while serving his sentence.

April 13, 2018: Appeals Chamber dismisses the pending request for review for lack of jurisdiction.