El Sayyid Nosair

Victims
1 murder: convicted (1995, federal) of murder in furtherance of a racketeering enterprise and seditious conspiracy; acquitted of murder in state court (1991).
Years active
November 5, 1990
Location
New York City, New York (killing; state and federal trials); Cliffside Park, New Jersey (residence in 1990).
Method
Shot (federal jury finding, 1995; a state jury acquitted him of the murder in 1991).
Status
State: 7 1/3 to 22 years (January 1992). Federal: life imprisonment, judgment January 17, 1996; affirmed 1999. In federal custody in Colorado, serving life, as of June 2008.

On the evening of November 5, 1990, Rabbi Meir Kahane was killed in a Manhattan hotel moments after he finished a speech. The man arrested that night was El Sayyid Nosair, a 34-year-old Egyptian-born resident of Cliffside Park, New Jersey, who worked for the City of New York and had no criminal record.

The case then took two very different turns. In December 1991 a New York state jury acquitted Nosair of murder and convicted him only of lesser counts, and the trial judge imposed the longest term the law allowed on those counts. Four years later a federal jury in the same city heard the case again as part of a far larger prosecution, one that charged Nosair, the cleric Omar Abdel Rahman and eight other men with a seditious conspiracy to wage war on the United States. On October 1, 1995, that jury convicted Nosair of the rabbi's murder in furtherance of a racketeering enterprise. He was sentenced to life imprisonment in January 1996, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed every count in 1999.

Little of Nosair's early life entered the court record. He was born in Egypt and had become an American citizen by the time of his state trial. In November 1990 he lived in Cliffside Park, across the Hudson River from Manhattan, and he was a New York City employee. On the day of the killing, the city had transferred him to another post against his wishes. He had never been arrested.

In the first days the investigation treated him as a man who had acted alone. A joint task force of the New York police and the FBI was formed to look for links to any wider plot, and it announced none.

The federal courts later drew a very different picture. The evidence at the 1995 trial showed that Nosair had belonged to a circle of followers who had been organizing in New York since 1989. In July 1989, on three successive weekends, FBI agents watched and photographed members of the group, Nosair among them, at paramilitary training on Long Island. While the cleric who would become the group's leader was still in Egypt, Nosair and another member telephoned him there to report on their progress and recorded the calls so they could be passed around among his followers. None of this was known to the public in 1990, and none of it was before the state jury in 1991.

The rabbi was born in Brooklyn in 1932. As a young man he belonged to Betar, the Revisionist Zionist youth movement, attended Brooklyn College and studied at the Mirrer Yeshiva, where he was ordained in 1957. He led a congregation in Queens until 1960 and also earned a law degree.

In 1968 he founded the Jewish Defense League in New York. He was himself convicted in a federal conspiracy case in 1971 and given a suspended sentence. That same year he moved to Israel, where he founded the Kach movement. He was elected to the Knesset in 1984 as Kach's only member, after Israel's High Court of Justice overturned an attempt to keep him off the ballot. Under a Basic Law passed in 1985, Kach was disqualified from the 1988 election.

By November 1990 he was no longer in the Knesset, but he still spoke to audiences in New York. The speech he gave on the night of his death urged American Jews to emigrate to Israel and settle there.

The rabbi addressed an audience at a hotel on Manhattan's East Side, and afterward, as he stood talking with members of the crowd, he was killed. A man in the audience was injured, and outside the hotel a uniformed officer of the United States Postal Service police was injured before he detained Nosair, who was also hurt.

On November 7 the state charged Nosair with second-degree murder, attempted murder, assault, unlawful imprisonment and an offense under the state arms law. At his arraignment he answered in writing with a statement asserting his innocence.

Among the papers investigators took from places tied to him was a handwritten notebook. Its contents, read at the 1995 trial, argued for war on the group's enemies. The notebook played no part in the state case, but it became one of the central exhibits in the federal one.

Nosair was tried in New York state court in November and December 1991. The jury heard no eyewitness to the killing of the rabbi itself.

On December 21, 1991, the jury acquitted Nosair of the rabbi's second-degree murder and of the attempted murder of the postal officer. It convicted him on four lesser counts, assault and possession of arms among them, arising from the injuries to the two men and from the taking of a taxi as he left the hotel.

At sentencing in January 1992, the trial judge imposed the maximum on those counts: an indeterminate term of 7 1/3 to 22 years. Nosair had not testified at trial. In a statement before sentence he maintained his innocence. He was held in New York state custody to serve the term.

The state sentence did not end Nosair's part in the story. The federal appeals court later found that, once he was in state custody, he received a steady stream of visitors from the same circle, used those visits to urge further violence and rebuked his visitors for doing nothing, and recorded messages for distribution that praised the killing. During the state trial an FBI informant had begun attending the proceedings and befriending the defendant's supporters, and through them he met Nosair. The informant became one of the government's key witnesses.

The court found that in June 1992 Nosair pressed two visitors to move ahead with a campaign of attacks and told one of them to seek a religious ruling from Abdel Rahman approving it. In the weeks before the attack on the World Trade Center on February 26, 1993, men later convicted of that attack visited him in state custody.

In August 1993 a federal grand jury in Manhattan indicted Abdel Rahman, Nosair and others on racketeering and conspiracy charges. The government's theory was that the killing of the rabbi, the World Trade Center attack, a plan to kill the president of Egypt and a spring 1993 plan to attack the United Nations and two Hudson River tunnels were all acts of a single enterprise, which the indictment called the Jihad Organization.

Every defendant was charged with seditious conspiracy, an agreement to levy a war of urban terrorism against the United States, to oppose its authority by force and to prevent, hinder or delay by force the execution of its laws. The counts that concerned Nosair alone went back to the night of November 5, 1990: the rabbi's murder in furtherance of a racketeering enterprise, the assault on the man in the audience and the attempted murder of the postal officer under the same statute, the attempted murder of a federal officer, and counts under the federal arms laws arising from the same events.

The racketeering murder statute made the killing a federal case without its being a federal crime in itself. To convict, the jury had to find that the Jihad Organization was an enterprise engaged in racketeering activity, that Nosair held a position in it, that he committed the killing, and that his general purpose was to maintain or increase that position.

The trial began in January 1995 in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York and lasted nine months. Before the first witness, the trial judge told the jurors about Nosair's state trial and its outcome, and instructed them that the state verdicts bound them in no way: an acquittal by a state jury was not evidence for an acquittal in federal court, and a state conviction was not evidence for a conviction.

The government's case against Nosair on the count concerning the rabbi rested on several strands: the notebook; the recorded messages; evidence that the group's leader had said he would have been honored to issue a religious ruling approving the killing; Nosair's conversations with the leader about Jewish emigration to Israel; and evidence suggesting that other members of the group had been involved on the night itself. A treating physician testified that, in custody after November 5, Nosair had answered a question about the killing by saying he had no choice and that it was his duty.

On October 1, 1995, after about a week of deliberation, the jury found the defendants guilty on every count submitted to it, with one exception: Nosair and one co-defendant were found not guilty of a bombing conspiracy count.

Nosair was convicted of seditious conspiracy; of murder and of attempted murder in furtherance of a racketeering enterprise; of the attempted murder of a federal officer; and of four counts under the federal arms laws. The jury also found that one goal of the seditious conspiracy had been "to wage a war of urban terrorism against the United States."

The sedition count itself carried a maximum of 20 years, but the count concerning the rabbi carried life, and Nosair, like Abdel Rahman, was sentenced to life imprisonment; the judgment was entered on January 17, 1996. Speaking in court, Nosair said the government had made up the case because of the World Trade Center attack.

The ten defendants appealed together, and on August 16, 1999, the Second Circuit affirmed every conviction. Nosair raised four of the opinion's main questions himself.

The first was constitutional. The Constitution allows a treason conviction only on the testimony of two witnesses to the same overt act, or on a confession in open court, and Nosair argued that seditious conspiracy by levying war was treason under another name. The court disagreed: treason necessarily includes a betrayal of allegiance, the sedition statute requires no proof of allegiance, and the Treason Clause did not govern it.

The second was his purpose. Nosair conceded every other element of the racketeering murder count and argued that killing a private Israeli citizen could not have advanced an enterprise aimed at making war on the United States. The court read the indictment more broadly, as describing an enterprise opposed to governments, institutions and individuals who did not share its interpretation of Islamic law. Pointing to the notebook, the conversations with the leader, the evidence of others' involvement, the remark about a religious ruling, the recorded messages and the statement to the physician, it held that Nosair had used the killing to inspire others and that the jury could reasonably infer he acted in furtherance of his membership.

The third was the instruction that let the jury carry his purpose in the killing over to the injuries to the two men as he left. The court held that its own precedent already applied that doctrine to motive and upheld the charge.

The fourth was double jeopardy. During the trial the judge had said in open court, outside the jury's presence, that he would dismiss the counts concerning the postal officer, then reconsidered at the government's request and sent them to the jury. The appeals court held that he had acted within his power: no judgment had been entered, the jury had never been told of the ruling, and Nosair had lost no chance to shape his defense.

The Supreme Court denied Nosair's petition for a writ of certiorari on November 1, 1999. A later habeas corpus petition, filed in federal court in Colorado while he was held in federal custody there, was denied and dismissed on June 5, 2008. As of 2008 he was serving his life sentence in federal custody.

The two juries reached opposite verdicts on the central question of who killed the rabbi. The state jury heard no eyewitness to the act itself. The federal jury heard a far wider body of evidence, gathered largely after the World Trade Center attack, about the group Nosair belonged to and what he said and recorded in custody.

The early view that he acted alone did not survive. The federal appeals court referred to evidence suggesting that other members of the group were involved in the killing, but no one else was ever convicted of taking part in it, and the extent of any other person's role on November 5, 1990, was not settled by any verdict. Nosair maintained his innocence at his state sentencing in 1992 and, at his federal sentencing in 1996, called the federal case a fabrication.

Timeline

1932: The rabbi is born in Brooklyn, New York.

1968: He founds the Jewish Defense League in New York.

1984: He is elected to Israel's Knesset as the only member for Kach.

1988: Kach is disqualified from the Knesset election under the 1985 Basic Law.

July 1989: FBI agents observe and photograph Nosair and others at paramilitary training on Long Island on three successive weekends.

November 5, 1990: The rabbi is killed in a Manhattan hotel; Nosair is arrested the same night.

November 7, 1990: The state charges Nosair with second-degree murder, attempted murder and other counts.

December 21, 1991: The state jury acquits Nosair of murder and attempted murder and convicts him on four lesser counts.

January 1992: Nosair is sentenced to 7 1/3 to 22 years.

February 26, 1993: The World Trade Center is attacked.

August 1993: A federal grand jury indicts Nosair, Abdel Rahman and others.

January 1995: The federal trial opens in the Southern District of New York.

October 1, 1995: The federal jury convicts Nosair of seditious conspiracy and murder in furtherance of a racketeering enterprise, among other counts.

January 17, 1996: Judgment entered; Nosair is sentenced to life imprisonment.

August 16, 1999: The Second Circuit affirms the convictions.

November 1, 1999: The Supreme Court denies Nosair's petition for certiorari.

June 5, 2008: A federal court in Colorado denies and dismisses his habeas corpus petition.