Edgar Ray Killen

Victims
3 civil rights workers killed in Mississippi, 1964. Convicted June 21, 2005 of 3 counts of manslaughter (jury rejected murder); 1967 federal jury deadlocked
Years active
June 21, 1964
Location
Philadelphia, Union and Meridian, Mississippi
Method
Manslaughter (three counts), Mississippi; indicted on three counts of murder
Status
Three consecutive 20-year terms, June 23, 2005; affirmed April 12, 2007; certiorari denied November 4, 2013; died in custody January 11, 2018

Edgar Ray Killen was a sawmill operator, farmer and part-time Baptist preacher in Neshoba County, Mississippi, and in 1964 he was an organizer for the Ku Klux Klan there. On June 21 of that year three young civil rights workers, James Chaney of Meridian and Andrew Goodman and Michael Schwerner of New York, were killed by Klansmen near the county seat of Philadelphia. Evidence at two trials, nearly four decades apart, placed Killen at the center of the conspiracy. A federal jury in 1967 convicted seven men of conspiracy in the case but could not agree on him, and he returned to Neshoba County. On June 21, 2005, exactly 41 years after the killings, a state jury in Philadelphia convicted him of three counts of manslaughter. He was 80 years old. The judge gave him three consecutive 20-year terms, and he died in state custody in January 2018, at 92, still denying any part in the deaths.

He was the only person the State of Mississippi ever charged with murder in the case and the only one it ever sent to a state prison for it.

Killen preached on Sundays to a small congregation at Smyrna Baptist Church in Union, a town south of Philadelphia, and people in the county knew him as "Preacher." His other role came out in federal court in 1967 and again in Philadelphia in 2005. Testimony at both trials described him as a kleagle, the Klan's title for a recruiter and organizer, for Neshoba County, and as the county's link to the leadership of the White Knights of the Ku Klux Klan of Mississippi. Klansmen who later became informants for the FBI testified that he had sworn men into the organization and that, in the months before the killings, he told local members the Klan's leadership had approved action against the civil rights organizers working out of Meridian.

The summer of 1964 brought hundreds of volunteers into Mississippi for a campaign to register Black voters and open community centers and Freedom Schools, coordinated by a coalition of civil rights groups known as COFO. The three men who would die in Neshoba County were part of that effort, working from a community center in Meridian and with a Black congregation in the Longdale community of Neshoba County, where a Freedom School was planned.

On June 21, 1964, a Neshoba County deputy sheriff, himself a Klan member, arrested the three men and held them in the county jail in Philadelphia. He released them that night, and they were killed by Klansmen near the town. In the evidence later given by informants and by the deputy himself, Killen was the man who brought Klansmen from Meridian to Philadelphia that day and who gave the word for the three men to be let out of the jail. Their deaths were confirmed on August 4, 1964, after a long FBI search.

Mississippi brought no charges in the 1960s, and the case went forward only in federal court, on civil rights charges. In January 1965 a federal grand jury indicted 18 men, Killen among them. A federal district judge dismissed most of the charges, but on March 28, 1966, the U.S. Supreme Court reinstated them in United States v. Price, holding that private persons who join with state officers in such a conspiracy can be prosecuted with them.

The trial opened in Meridian in October 1967 on a single count of conspiracy. On October 20 the jury convicted seven defendants, among them the deputy and the statewide Klan leader, and acquitted eight. It could not reach a verdict on three, and the judge declared a mistrial as to each of them. Killen was one of the three. The government did not retry him.

Killen went back to his sawmill and his church. For nearly four decades he was a free man, and murder, the one charge that could still be brought, was a state matter that Mississippi had never pursued. In 2000 the former deputy, cooperating with the state, gave statements to the Mississippi Attorney General's office that described Killen's part in the events of June 21. That spring and summer state investigators also went to every other surviving defendant from the 1967 trial and to many witnesses, and most of them offered nothing beyond general denials. Over the next few years, working with the FBI, the state added enough new evidence to the old record to take a murder case to a grand jury.

On January 6, 2005, a Neshoba County grand jury indicted Killen on three counts of murder. It was the first state indictment ever returned in the case, and he was the only person charged; the grand jury indicted none of the other men from the 1967 case who were still alive. At his arraignment in Philadelphia the next day, he pleaded not guilty.

The trial opened in Philadelphia in June 2005. Several of the men who had testified in 1967 had since died, and their testimony from the federal trial was read to the jury from the transcript. Those readings carried the heart of the state's case: former Klansmen described Killen as the kleagle who led the meetings before the killings, passed on the leadership's approval and brought men from Meridian on June 21. Other witnesses testified that he had spoken afterward of the three men's deaths.

The defense conceded that Killen had been a member of the Klan and argued that membership did not make him guilty, and that no witness and no evidence placed him where the men died. Killen did not take the stand.

The judge allowed the jurors to consider manslaughter as well as murder. On June 21, 2005, they found Killen guilty of three counts of manslaughter and not guilty of murder, and he was taken into custody at once. On June 23 the judge imposed the maximum of 20 years on each count and ordered the terms served consecutively, a total of 60 years.

Released on an appeal bond on health grounds in August 2005, Killen was ordered back to prison on September 9, 2005, after the court heard that he had been seen walking and driving. He remained in custody for the rest of his life.

On April 12, 2007, the Mississippi Supreme Court affirmed the convictions and the 60-year sentence. It rejected his central argument, that the 41-year delay in charging him had violated due process, finding that he had not shown any actual prejudice and noting that Mississippi has no statute of limitations on manslaughter. It held that the evidence supported the manslaughter instruction and that the testimony at trial showed Killen had directed the Klan's actions against the three men.

He then turned to the federal courts. A federal district court in Mississippi denied him relief in 2012, and on April 25, 2013, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit did the same. On November 4, 2013, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to review the case, and on January 13, 2014, it denied his request for a rehearing. A federal review of the killings opened in 2010 found no basis for a new federal prosecution, and on June 20, 2016, the Mississippi Attorney General announced that the state's investigation was closed.

Killen died in the Mississippi State Penitentiary on January 11, 2018. He was 92. He had never admitted any part in the deaths of the three men.

Killen denied any involvement in the killings from 1964 until his death. His alibi was that he spent the evening of June 21, 1964 at a wake in Philadelphia; the prosecution argued, and the deputy's 2000 statement described, that the wake was chosen to provide that alibi.

No witness at either trial placed Killen where the three men were killed. The case against him rested on testimony about his leadership in the Klan, the meetings before June 21, his trip to Meridian that day, and his own later remarks to others. The 2005 jury rejected the murder charge and convicted him of manslaughter, a verdict that did not require proof of an intent to kill. The 1967 federal jury deadlocked on him, and that case was never retried. No one else has been charged by the State of Mississippi.

Timeline

June 21, 1964: Three civil rights workers are arrested in Philadelphia, released that night and killed by Klansmen near the town; Killen brings Klansmen from Meridian that day, as later testimony described.

August 4, 1964: The three deaths are confirmed in Neshoba County.

January 1965: A federal grand jury indicts 18 men, Killen among them.

March 28, 1966: The U.S. Supreme Court reinstates the indictments in United States v. Price.

October 20, 1967: Seven defendants convicted, eight acquitted; mistrial as to Killen and two others.

2000: The former deputy gives statements to the Mississippi Attorney General's office.

January 6, 2005: Neshoba County grand jury indicts Killen on three counts of murder.

June 21, 2005: The jury convicts Killen of three counts of manslaughter.

June 23, 2005: Sentenced to three consecutive 20-year terms.

September 9, 2005: Appeal bond revoked; Killen returned to prison.

April 12, 2007: The Mississippi Supreme Court affirms the convictions and sentence.

April 25, 2013: The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit denies relief.

November 4, 2013: The U.S. Supreme Court declines review.

January 13, 2014: The U.S. Supreme Court denies rehearing.

June 20, 2016: The state attorney general closes the investigation.

January 11, 2018: Killen dies in the Mississippi State Penitentiary at 92.