Eden Natan-Zada

Victims
4 people killed in Shefa-Amr, attributed to him by the government and police; more than ten hurt; he was never charged or tried.
Years active
August 4, 2005
Location
Shefa-Amr, Israel (killings and his death); Rishon LeZion, Israel (where he grew up); Tapuah, West Bank (where he had been staying); Nitzanim, Israel (army base).
Method
Shot (the government's and police's account; he was never tried).
Status
Never tried. In 2013 a court convicted six Shefa-Amr residents over his death. He was killed by a crowd in Shefa-Amr, Israel, on August 4, 2005, while in police custody.

On the evening of August 4, 2005, four Arab citizens of Israel died in Shefa-Amr, a town in the Galilee, in an attack that the Israeli government and police attributed to Eden Natan-Zada, a 19-year-old army recruit who had deserted his unit about two months earlier. More than ten other people were hurt, two of them police officers. Natan-Zada did not survive the evening. He was overpowered and taken into police custody, and members of a crowd that had gathered in the town killed him before officers could take him away. He was never charged, and no court ever tested the case against him. The government ordered that the attack be treated as a terror attack when aid was given to those who had been hurt.

The deaths came less than two weeks before Israel was due to begin removing its settlers from the Gaza Strip, a withdrawal Natan-Zada had refused to take part in. His own death left a question that took eight years and a trial in the Haifa District Court to settle.

Natan-Zada grew up in Rishon LeZion. He also went by the name Eden Tzuberi, and he had enlisted in the army as Natan-Zada. In the summer of 2005 he was a recruit at the army's basic training base at Nitzanim. He was already known to the police before he left the army: they knew him as a member of Revava, a far-right group, and of Kach, a movement that Israel had outlawed.

About two months before the attack, he left the Nitzanim base without permission. The army later said he had left his unit because he did not want to take part in the Gaza withdrawal. He spent much of the following period in and around Tapuah, a settlement in the northern West Bank, and by the beginning of August he had been staying there for about two weeks.

Shefa-Amr, which many of its residents call Shfaram, lies in the Galilee in northern Israel. In 2005 it had about 35,000 people. Roughly half were Muslim, about a third Christian and the rest Druze.

On the evening of Thursday, August 4, Natan-Zada came to Shefa-Amr. Four residents of the town died in the attack that followed: Hazar and Dina Turki, who were sisters, Michel Bahouth and Nader Hayek. All four were Arab citizens of Israel. More than ten other people were hurt, among them two police officers.

Natan-Zada was overpowered and held, and police took him into custody. A large and angry crowd had gathered by then. Police tried to remove him from the town but could not hold the crowd back, and members of it killed him that evening while he was still in police hands. In 2013 the Haifa District Court convicted four Shefa-Amr residents of attempted manslaughter and two of aggravated assault over his death, acquitted a seventh, and imposed terms ranging from a six-month suspended sentence to two years in prison.

The families of the four applied to the National Insurance Institute for compensation as victims of a hostile act. The institute told them they did not legally qualify under the Compensation Law for Victims of Hostile Acts of 1970, but that as an exceptional case they would receive financial compensation outside that law. In October 2005 the Jewish Agency for Israel gave the four families about NIS 100,000 from its fund for victims of terror.

Natan-Zada was never charged, tried or convicted. His responsibility for the four deaths rests on the account of the police, the army and the government, given in the hours and days after the attack, and it was never tested in any court because he died that same evening.

His motive was never examined by a court either. Whether anyone else knew of his plans or helped him was a question from the first night; a police inquiry opened in Tapuah was held under a publication ban.

Timeline

Summer 2005, about two months before the attack: Natan-Zada leaves the army's Nitzanim base without permission.

Early August 2005: he has been staying for about two weeks in the West Bank settlement of Tapuah.

August 4, 2005: four residents of Shefa-Amr die in an attack attributed to him; more than ten others are hurt; members of a crowd kill him that evening while he is in police custody.

August 4, 2005: the government orders that the attack be treated as a terror attack for benefits to the injured.

October 2005: the Jewish Agency gives the four families about NIS 100,000.

2013: the Haifa District Court convicts six Shefa-Amr residents over his death, acquits a seventh and sentences the six to terms from a suspended sentence to two years in prison.