ELEVEN CASES SOLVED BY AN UNRELATED ARREST

Lieutenant Paul Echols had been a rookie patrol officer in Carbondale, Illinois, when a Southern Illinois University student named Deborah Sheppard was killed in April 1982. Twenty-five years later, in the summer of 2007, he sent the evidence from her case back to the state crime laboratory. The profile matched a man in the Illinois DNA registry, and the man was not hard to locate. Timothy Krajcir had been in state custody since 1988. He was serving his time at the Big Muddy River Correctional Center in Ina, Illinois.

Cases like that one rarely end with a chase. They end with a swab taken years earlier for a reason that had nothing to do with murder: a sample required after a robbery or rape conviction, a blood draw kept in a freezer, a stale drug warrant that put a wanted man in handcuffs on the right day. Eleven American cases were closed that way or close to it. A twelfth, in Milwaukee, shows the price when the same system broke down.

Timothy Krajcir

Krajcir had entered the Illinois prison system in 1963, the Associated Press reported, and was free for only a few years in the late 1970s and early 1980s, when he studied at Southern Illinois University and worked on an ambulance crew. He was paroled in May 1981. In 1983 he was arrested in Allentown, Pennsylvania, on sexual-assault charges and served a term there, and when it ended in 1988 he was returned to Illinois on the parole violation and stayed in custody from then on.

The Sheppard match came in August 2007. Echols drove to the prison to interview him. Krajcir denied everything, then called the lieutenant the next day and confessed, according to The Daily Egyptian, the university’s student newspaper. Carbondale police announced the arrest on August 31, 2007.

In Cape Girardeau, Missouri, Detective Jimmy Smith had spent years on five unsolved killings of women in that river town. After the Carbondale announcement he went back through the files, and DNA from one of the Missouri cases matched Krajcir’s profile in CODIS, the national database. The Cape Girardeau County prosecutor, Morley Swingle, had intended to seek the death penalty. The families agreed that answers mattered more to them than an execution, and Swingle agreed to take death off the table in exchange for full confessions. In a series of recorded interviews at the prison, Krajcir described nine killings in four states.

The pleas came quickly. On December 10, 2007, in Murphysboro, Illinois, he pleaded guilty to the murder of Deborah Sheppard and received 40 years, the maximum for murder in Illinois in 1982. On January 18, 2008, in Marion, he pleaded guilty to the first-degree murder of Virginia Lee Witte and received another 40 years, to run after the first. On April 4, 2008, in Cape Girardeau, he pleaded guilty to five counts of first-degree murder, with other charges, and Judge Benjamin F. Lewis imposed 13 consecutive life sentences. "The overwhelming question was why; now we know," the son of Margie Call, one of the Missouri victims, said that day, according to the Southeast Missourian. A Pennsylvania case followed, for the death of Myrtle Rupp, and on March 25, 2010, in Paducah, Kentucky, he pleaded guilty to kidnapping resulting in death and burglary in the case of Joyce Tharp and received life plus 20 years.

The confessions reached one more case. Krajcir admitted a 1981 attack on an elderly woman in Mount Vernon, Illinois, for which a Black man, Grover Thompson, had been convicted. Thompson had died in prison in 1996. Krajcir was never charged with that attack, but in January 2019 Governor Bruce Rauner granted Thompson posthumous clemency based on innocence, the first posthumous exoneration in Illinois, according to the National Registry of Exonerations and WSIU. In March 2019 The Daily Egyptian reported that Krajcir was serving his sentences at the Pontiac Correctional Center.

William Jennings Choyce

Three women died at the hands of the same man in Northern California, nine years apart. Victoria Bell’s death came to light in Oakland on April 3, 1988. Gwendolyn Lee’s came to light in San Joaquin County on July 2, 1997, and Lawanda Beck’s in the same county on August 11, 1997. The cases sat unsolved until DNA connected all three to William Jennings Choyce, a Stockton man who, the Associated Press reported, was serving a state prison sentence for rape in Oakland when the match was made. The parties at his later trial agreed that he had been convicted in Alameda County Superior Court on April 4, 2002, of raping a woman in Oakland.

At trial in San Joaquin County, Choyce conceded that his DNA matched the samples from all three women. The defense called no witnesses at the guilt phase and argued that no rape had taken place. In closing, a prosecutor called the deaths "joy killing," the AP reported. The jury convicted Choyce of three counts of first-degree murder, with special circumstances, and of a 1994 rape in Stockton, and returned a verdict of death on each murder count. He was under sentence of death from December 15, 2008.

On July 21, 2025, the California Supreme Court affirmed the judgment in a unanimous opinion by Justice Evans, correcting only the terms on three firearm enhancements. Governor Gavin Newsom’s 2019 reprieve for every condemned inmate in California has halted executions in the state.

Ronald Macon

On Chicago’s South Side, the deaths of three women came to light in 1999: Angelnetta Peeples, 43, on February 20; Linda Soloman, 36, on April 14; and Rosezina Williams, 50, on June 21. Police said all three had been strangled. Detectives had biological evidence and no suspect.

In August 1999 Ronald Macon, then 35, was taken into custody on a separate sex-crime charge and held in Cook County Jail on a bond of $1.25 million. While he sat there, detectives compared his DNA with the evidence from the three killings, and it matched. Police said he then gave a videotaped confession. Commander Frank Trigg told reporters that once officers were able to speak with him, "his status escalated to that of a suspect." In October 1999 he was charged with three counts of murder, CBS News reported. He was later convicted of the three murders and of one criminal sexual assault, and in September 2003 he was sentenced to life in prison plus 30 years.

The City of Chicago made him an exhibit. Its 2005 "Study on Preventable Crimes," presented to the Illinois legislature, noted that Macon had been arrested on felony charges three times in 1998, the first on January 13, and that none of those arrests had put a DNA sample on file. Had one been taken that day, the city argued, a match could have followed the first killing in February 1999 and prevented the two that came after it, along with a sexual assault. That was the city’s argument for a change in the law, not the finding of any court. In 2013, in Maryland v. King, the Supreme Court of the United States cited the Chicago study among the evidence for its five-to-four ruling that taking a cheek swab from a person arrested for a serious offense is a legitimate booking procedure, like fingerprinting.

Alexander W. Watson Jr.

In 1994 Alexander W. Watson Jr. was convicted in Prince George’s County, Maryland, of killing Debra Cobb, an office manager, and sentenced to life without parole. In a letter to the judge that November he blamed an addiction to crack cocaine. "I still believe in my heart that I am a peaceful person," he wrote, The Washington Times reported.

His DNA, taken after he entered prison, went into Maryland’s statewide database. An Anne Arundel County police cold case squad led by Sergeant David Waltemeyer had spent six years on a group of old killings. The state crime laboratory had told detectives in October that Watson was linked to two of the victims, and in July 2004 he was charged with first-degree murder in three deaths in the county: Boontem Anderson, a mother who worked at Fort Meade, killed in Gambrills in 1986; Mary Elaine Shereika, a mother, killed in Gambrills in 1988; and Lisa K. Haenel, a high school freshman, killed in south Glen Burnie in 1993. Watson was a teenager at the time of the first two deaths, and address records showed he lived a few doors from each of those women, the paper reported.

"I think what this case showed is, we never close a case," Police Chief P. Thomas Shanahan said. The county’s state’s attorney, Frank R. Weathersbee, said he hoped more prisoners would be required to give DNA samples.

John Dwight Canaday

Canaday was caught by an unrelated arrest, and his first killing was solved decades later by the DNA his convictions put on file. In the winter of 1968 and 1969, three young women were killed in Seattle within little more than five weeks: Sandra Bowman, 16, pregnant and newly married, on December 17, 1968; then Mary Annabelle Bjornson, 21, and Lynne Carol Tuski, 20, in January 1969. The deaths of the two January victims came to light near Index, in Snohomish County, in March 1969. Canaday, a 24-year-old Navy veteran who worked for the Seattle Water Department, was arrested on February 22, 1969, for kidnapping another young woman, who survived. He was not then a suspect in any killing. In custody he admitted an attack on a woman on January 23, and on March 20 he gave oral and written confessions to the deaths of Mary Bjornson and Lynne Tuski, according to the Washington Supreme Court.

A King County jury convicted him of both murders in 1969 and returned the death penalty on each, and the Washington Supreme Court affirmed on September 23, 1971, calling the evidence "overwhelming proof of guilt." In 1972 a ruling of the United States Supreme Court effectively struck down the death penalty in Washington and more than 30 other states, and Canaday’s death sentences went with it, the Associated Press reported.

The Bowman case stayed open. Her husband was suspected at first and later cleared, the Seattle Police Department has said, and no one was charged for 36 years. A cold-case squad formed in 2002, and Detectives Mike Ciesynski and Gregg Mixsell sent the DNA evidence preserved from 1968 for testing. Early in 2004 a forensic scientist at the state crime laboratory matched it to Canaday, whose profile was in the state database because of his 1969 convictions. In June 2004 the detectives visited him at the penitentiary in Walla Walla. According to the charging papers, as the AP described them, he sighed, held up his hands and said, "Yes, I killed her."

King County prosecutors charged him that September with first-degree murder. A spokesman, Dan Donohoe, called it the "oldest 'cold case' ever solved in Washington state." Canaday pleaded guilty and received a third life sentence. Sandra Bowman’s husband, who had remarried, told the court that the only thing that had kept him from taking his own life was the fear that people would think he had something to do with her death. He died of a heart attack less than a month later. "You would not believe the difference in him once you solved that case," his widow told Ciesynski, the detective recalled in 2015. Canaday died at the Clallam Bay Corrections Center in December 2012, aged 68, the Peninsula Daily News reported.

Anthony Allen Shore

Maria del Carmen Estrada was 21 when she was killed in Houston in April 1992. Her case went unsolved for more than a decade. In 1998 Anthony Allen Shore, a tow truck driver and telephone repairman, pleaded no contest in an unrelated case and received eight years' probation; under the terms of the plea, his DNA went into the Texas database, the Texas Tribune and the AP reported. In 2003 the profile from his probation case was matched to DNA evidence from the Estrada killing. ABC13 in Houston reported that new technology at a Dallas crime laboratory made the comparison possible. Shore, 41 and still on probation, was arrested in Houston.

He confessed first to the Estrada killing and then, according to the Harris County District Attorney’s Office, to the killings of three girls between 1986 and 1995 and to an attack on a 14-year-old who survived. Prosecutors charged him with one count of capital murder, in the case with the strongest physical evidence; the other killings were put before the jury at the punishment phase. Before that phase began he told his lawyers he wanted to die, and they told the jury so. He was sentenced to death in 2004.

An execution date in October 2017 was withdrawn hours before it was due. He was executed at Huntsville on January 18, 2018, the first execution in the United States that year. "No amount of words or apology could ever undo what I’ve done," he said in his final statement.

Lorenzo Gilyard

In Kansas City, Missouri, the decisive sample sat in storage for years. Police took a blood sample from Lorenzo Gilyard, a trash company supervisor, in 1987, while investigating one of a run of deaths of women and girls in the city; he was one of several men who gave samples, and no charge followed. Missourinet reported that the sample was kept on ice for more than 15 years. A federal grant in 2003 paid for DNA analysis of evidence from the old cases, the AP reported, and in April 2004 the crime laboratory tied Gilyard’s blood to the evidence. He was arrested on a Friday that month and charged the next day with ten counts of first-degree murder and two of capital murder, covering deaths from 1977 to 1993. A 13th count followed in 2006.

"This is another example as to what DNA evidence can do for us in law enforcement and really for the entire community," the prosecutor, Mike Sanders, said at the time. In January 2007 prosecutors agreed not to seek death if Gilyard gave up a jury and nearly all of his appeal rights. They dismissed six counts on the first day of trial and went forward on seven. On March 16, 2007, Jackson County Circuit Judge John O’Malley convicted Gilyard of the first-degree murders of Catherine Barry, Naomi Kelly, Ann Barnes, Kellie Ford, Sheila Ingold and Carmeline Hibbs, killed in 1986 and 1987, and acquitted him in the death of Angela Mayhew, the one tried case without DNA. "These crimes have gone unsolved and unpunished for two decades," the judge wrote. In April 2007 he imposed six consecutive life terms without parole. Gilyard has denied killing anyone.

Gilyard’s case is the loosest fit among the twelve. His sample was taken in a murder inquiry, not after an unrelated arrest. What it shares with the others is the gap between collection and comparison: his blood was in police hands for more than 15 years before anyone compared it with the evidence.

Ivan Hill

Ivan Hill was serving a prison sentence for robbery, attempted robbery and assault with a deadly weapon, and was about three months from release, when DNA testing linked him to the death of a woman in Southern California. He was charged in November 2003 and, when his trial began in October 2006, faced charges of killing six women in 1993 and 1994, the AP reported. He was then 45.

At trial the prosecution played the jury recordings of telephone calls to the police in which the caller taunted officers. "Y’all better catch me before I kill again," he said in one. Hill acknowledged making the calls. His lawyer, Jennifer Friedman, told jurors that he had killed the women but argued that the killings were compulsive rather than deliberate, a distinction that would decide whether he could face the death penalty. Deputy District Attorney John Monaghan told the jury the evidence showed planning.

Samuel Little

Samuel Little was arrested again and again over three decades, in some two dozen states, for theft, assault, drugs and other offenses. The case that held him began with a database. In April 2012 Detective Mitzi Roberts of the Los Angeles Police Department’s cold case unit received a DNA match that linked the 1987 and 1989 killings of Audrey Nelson and Guadalupe Apodaca to each other and then, through California’s offender DNA databank, to Little. The testing had been paid for by a federal grant.

Finding him was the hard part. In 2007 he had been arrested in Los Angeles for cocaine possession and sent to a drug diversion program. He failed to attend, and a judge issued a bench warrant that could not be used to extradite him from another state. Over the next five years he had about a dozen encounters with police, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported, and some officers let him go because the warrant was not extraditable. "He wouldn’t stay in one place more than a week or two and then he would move on to the next one," Roberts said.

Detectives in Calcasieu Parish, Louisiana, picked up his trail after a deputy there briefly held him in April 2012, and traced him to Louisville, Kentucky, KPLC reported. On September 5, 2012, he was arrested at a Christian shelter there on the 2009 Los Angeles narcotics warrant, with help from the United States Marshals. Returned to Los Angeles, he was linked by DNA on November 27 to a third killing, that of Carol Alford, and in January 2013 he was charged with three counts of murder, the LAPD said. A jury convicted him on September 2, 2014, and on September 25 Judge George G. Lomeli imposed three consecutive terms of life without parole.

In 2018 he began talking to a Texas Ranger, James Holland, about a 1994 killing in Odessa. Over the following months he described 93 killings between 1970 and 2005. The FBI announced in October 2019 that it believed his confessions were credible and called him the most prolific serial killer in American history; by December 2021 the Texas Department of Public Safety put the number of verified cases at about 60. He pleaded guilty to one murder in Texas and four in Ohio, bringing his convictions to eight, and died on December 30, 2020, at 80.

Faryion Wardrip

Faryion Wardrip’s case runs the other way: a man already convicted of one killing, released, and tied to more by a sample he gave away without knowing it. In May 1986 he telephoned the police from a motel in Galveston, Texas, and confessed to killing Tina Kimbrew, 21, in Wichita Falls. He pleaded guilty to murder and was sentenced to 35 years. Nothing in that confession tied him to the deaths of four other young women in Wichita Falls and Fort Worth in 1984 and 1985, and three separate agencies were working those cases without connecting them, the Dallas Observer reported. The Texas Department of Criminal Justice records his release on December 11, 1997.

In late 1998 the Wichita County district attorney, Barry Macha, handed three of the old files to an investigator, John Little, and told him to look for anything that had been overlooked. Little noticed Wardrip’s name near several of them and learned that he had been convicted of the Kimbrew murder and recently paroled. Wardrip was by then living in Olney, working at a door and screen factory and singing in a church choir. Rather than seek a sample by subpoena and alert him, Little followed him for days, and on the sixth day collected a coffee cup Wardrip had thrown away outside the factory. A Dallas laboratory reported that Wardrip could not be excluded as the source of DNA in the killings of Terry Sims and Toni Gibbs.

He was arrested on capital murder charges on February 13, 1999. The next day, after learning of the DNA results, he confessed to the Sims, Gibbs and Ellen Blau killings and then to one more that no one had linked to him, the death of Debra Taylor in Fort Worth. "Without DNA," Little told the Observer, "there would never have been a case." Wardrip pleaded guilty to the capital murder of Terry Sims, and a jury in Denton sentenced him to death in November 1999. Life sentences for the Gibbs, Taylor and Blau cases followed. His death sentence has spent most of the years since in the federal courts: set aside in 2010, reinstated by the Fifth Circuit in 2020, and upheld again by the district court on May 19, 2026, which allowed an appeal on two issues. He was on the Texas death row list updated March 12, 2026.

Chester Dewayne Turner

Chester Turner, a former pizza delivery driver, pleaded no contest in a 2002 Los Angeles case to rape by force or fear and unlawful penetration and was sentenced to eight years. The DNA sample he gave after the conviction was entered in the law enforcement databases, and on September 8, 2003, the Los Angeles Police Department’s cold case unit learned that Turner’s profile matched the killing of Paula Vance and a 1996 killing. Detectives Cliff Shepard and Jose Ramirez then ran his profile against evidence kept from other unsolved deaths of women in South Los Angeles. On October 23, 2004, the department announced that DNA linked him to 13 killings between 1987 and 1998. Chief William J. Bratton used the case to promote Proposition 69, a measure on the November 2004 ballot to extend DNA collection to people arrested for felonies, the AP reported.

The same review freed another man. In April 1995 a Los Angeles jury had convicted D.A.J., a janitor with an intellectual disability, of murder and manslaughter in the deaths of three women in 1992, and he was sentenced to 36 years to life. Post-conviction DNA testing of the surviving evidence in two of those cases excluded him and matched Turner. On March 4, 2004, D.A.J.'s convictions were vacated and he was released after almost 11 years in prison, according to the National Registry of Exonerations. Los Angeles later paid him $720,000.

Turner was convicted of ten first-degree murders on April 30, 2007, and sentenced to death that July. In 2014 a second jury convicted him of four more, including the two deaths for which D.A.J. had been imprisoned, and Judge Robert J. Perry imposed four more death sentences on August 1, 2014, calling the DNA "irrefutable." The California Supreme Court affirmed the first judgment on November 30, 2020, while reversing a separate count for the death of a fetus. In June 2024 the Salt Lake County district attorney charged him with aggravated murder in the 1998 death of Itisha Camp in Salt Lake City, after a DNA profile developed years earlier was entered in the national database for the first time. He is accused in that case, not convicted, and was reported to be on California’s death row in June 2024.

Walter E. Ellis

Walter Ellis is the case that proves the rule by breaking it. Wisconsin law required a DNA sample from every convicted felon, and Ellis was in state prison on a reckless injury sentence when his came due around 2000. Authorities later said he had another inmate give the sample in his name. The state databank therefore held no profile for Walter Ellis while the deaths of women on Milwaukee’s north side went unsolved, the AP reported. "That information was not given back to us by the Department of Justice," the Corrections secretary, Rick Raemisch, said in September 2009, blaming the other agency; it had "basically sat there, frankly, for years."

In May 2009 Milwaukee police announced that DNA tied killings of women between 1986 and 2007 to one unknown man who did not appear in any database. Investigators then worked through years of records and tested the DNA of more than 100 people. In late August 2009 detectives obtained, under a warrant, a toothbrush belonging to Ellis, and DNA from it linked him to the killings, the state crime laboratory reported. He was arrested in Franklin, a Milwaukee suburb, after a struggle with officers, and charged with five counts of first-degree intentional homicide and two of first-degree murder. On February 18, 2011, he pleaded no contest to all seven, and on February 24 Judge Dennis Cimpl sentenced him to seven consecutive life terms without parole. Ellis never explained the killings. He died in custody in South Dakota in December 2013.

The swap had a cost beyond the delay. The DNA that identified Ellis also matched evidence in two killings for which other men had been convicted. C.O., convicted in 1996 in the death of 16-year-old Jessica Payne, had already won a new trial and seen the charges dismissed in 2009 after earlier testing excluded him; Milwaukee later agreed to pay him $6.5 million. W.A., convicted in 2005 in the death of Maryetta Griffin, was cleared in 2010 when testing excluded him and matched Ellis. And an audit prompted by the case showed that about 12,000 required offender samples were missing from Wisconsin’s databank by December 2009; by February 2011 the AP put the figure at nearly 17,700.

The swab and the law

The cases did not stay in the courtroom. Chicago used Ronald Macon to argue for DNA at arrest. Bratton used Chester Turner to sell Proposition 69 to California voters in 2004. Anne Arundel County’s prosecutor used Alexander Watson to call for more prisoners to be sampled. In 2013 the Supreme Court of the United States, in Maryland v. King, upheld the taking of DNA from people arrested for serious crimes and cited Chicago’s study in explaining why fast identification mattered.

In most of the eleven, the decisive moment was not a pursuit but a comparison: a lieutenant in Carbondale sending old evidence back to the laboratory, an investigator with a coffee cup in Olney, a cold case unit in Los Angeles running a new profile against files from the 1980s. Even Samuel Little’s pursuit across three states began with a database match. In Milwaukee the sample existed too. It simply carried another man’s name.

Timeline

• December 17, 1968: Sandra Bowman is killed in Seattle.

• February 22, 1969: John Dwight Canaday is arrested in Seattle for kidnapping; he confesses to two January killings in March.

• September 23, 1971: the Washington Supreme Court affirms Canaday’s convictions and death sentences, lifted after a 1972 United States Supreme Court ruling.

• April 1982: Deborah Sheppard is killed in Carbondale, Illinois.

• May 1986: Faryion Wardrip confesses in Galveston to the killing of Tina Kimbrew.

• 1987: Kansas City police take a blood sample from Lorenzo Gilyard.

• April 1992: Maria del Carmen Estrada is killed in Houston.

• April 1995: D.A.J. is convicted in Los Angeles.

• December 11, 1997: Wardrip is released from Texas prison.

• 1998: Anthony Shore’s no-contest plea puts his DNA in the Texas database.

• February 13, 1999: Wardrip is arrested after DNA from a discarded coffee cup matches two killings.

• October 1999: Ronald Macon is charged with three Chicago murders after a DNA match while he is jailed on another charge.

• April 4, 2002: William Choyce is convicted of rape in Alameda County, California.

• September 8, 2003: Turner’s profile matches two unsolved Los Angeles killings.

• 2003: Shore is arrested in Houston; Ivan Hill is charged in November while serving a robbery sentence.

• March 4, 2004: D.A.J. is released.

• April 2004: Gilyard is charged with 12 killings in Kansas City.

• July 2004: Alexander W. Watson Jr. is charged with three Anne Arundel County murders.

• 2004: Canaday pleads guilty to the Bowman murder.

• October 23, 2004: the LAPD announces that DNA links Turner to 13 killings.

• March 16, 2007: Gilyard is convicted of six murders.

• April 30, 2007: Turner is convicted of ten murders.

• August 2007: Timothy Krajcir is matched to the Sheppard killing and confesses.

• April 4, 2008: Krajcir pleads guilty to five Cape Girardeau killings.

• December 2008: Choyce is under sentence of death in San Joaquin County.

• September 2009: Walter Ellis is arrested in Franklin, Wisconsin.

• February 24, 2011: Ellis is sentenced to seven consecutive life terms.

• September 5, 2012: Samuel Little is arrested in Louisville on a Los Angeles drug warrant.

• June 3, 2013: the Supreme Court decides Maryland v. King.

• September 25, 2014: Little is sentenced to three terms of life without parole.

• January 18, 2018: Shore is executed in Huntsville, Texas.

• January 2019: Grover Thompson is granted posthumous clemency in Illinois.

• October 2019: the FBI calls Little’s 93 confessions credible.

• November 30, 2020: the California Supreme Court affirms Turner’s first death judgment.

• June 14, 2024: Turner is charged in Utah.

• July 21, 2025: the California Supreme Court affirms Choyce’s death judgment.

• May 19, 2026: a federal district court denies Wardrip’s outstanding claims.