ELEVEN CASES BROKEN BY SOMEONE WHO SURVIVED

The arrest is the part of a serial case the public remembers, and it is usually credited to someone with a badge. A detective works a hunch, a laboratory returns a match, a patrol officer pulls over the wrong car. In the eleven cases that follow, the decisive information came from somewhere else: from a person who had been attacked by the offender and lived.

What they contributed varied. Some reached the police within hours and gave a description that put a name in a detective’s notebook within days. Some sat with a sketch artist. One man, unable to find the place again, had friends copy down a license plate when he saw his attacker in a bar. Others waited years for a courtroom and identified the man across it. Several told the police what had happened and were not believed.

Robert Frederick Carr: Florida, 1976

In 1976 Robert Frederick Carr III was arrested in Florida after an attack on a woman who survived it. United Press International described her as a housewife; the journalist Sarah Weinman, writing for CrimeReads in 2019, gave the same account.

In custody he talked. He admitted killing four young people earlier in the decade: two 11-year-old boys, Todd Payton and Mark Wilson; a 16-year-old girl, Tammy Ruth Huntley; and a 21-year-old woman, Rhonda Holloway, whose death came to light in Connecticut. UPI reported that he also confessed to offenses against more than a dozen other boys and girls. The detective who arrested him, David Simmons, later said that in a career of 33 years Carr was the most dangerous predator of children he had investigated.

Carr was spared the death penalty and sentenced to concurrent life terms for the murders of Mark Wilson, Todd Payton and Tammy Ruth Huntley, with other charges. Rhonda Holloway’s death, which he admitted, was not among the three. The Miami Herald reporter Edna Buchanan covered the trial and later wrote a book from more than 120 hours of interviews with him, published by Dutton in 1979; Weinman reports that Buchanan gave most of her proceeds to victims' rights groups. Carr was held at a state prison in Union County, Florida, from 1976 until his death there in 2007, at 63. No one claimed his body, UPI reported, and he was buried in a prison cemetery.

Bobby Joe Long: Tampa, 1984

Between March and November 1984 at least eight women were killed around Tampa. In the early hours of November 3, 1984, a 17-year-old girl was abducted in Tampa and released about a day later. She went to the police. Her account gave Hillsborough County detectives what they needed, and within two weeks they had a name.

On November 16, 1984, Robert Joe Long, known as Bobby Joe, was arrested in the parking lot of a Tampa movie theater on a warrant in her case. He was a former Army enlistee and radiology technician, then on probation for an aggravated assault on a woman. After his arrest he admitted a long run of earlier attacks on women in their homes, the Associated Press reported.

On September 23, 1985, under a plea agreement, Long pleaded guilty in Hillsborough County to eight counts of first-degree murder. He received life sentences on seven and, in 1986, a death sentence for the murder of Michelle Simms, which was vacated in 1988, imposed again in 1989 and affirmed in 1992. The girl testified against him in 1988 at his trial in Pasco County for the killing of Virginia Lee Johnson, 18; that conviction was reversed three times, and in 1997 the Florida Supreme Court ordered a judgment of acquittal. Long was executed by lethal injection at Florida State Prison on May 23, 2019.

Thierry Paulin: Paris, 1984 to 1987

From October 1984, elderly women were killed in their homes in Paris, most of them in the 18th arrondissement. Eight died that autumn, according to the Argentine daily Diario UNO, and eight more between December 1985 and June 1986. The killings resumed in late November 1987.

On November 25, 1987, an 87-year-old woman was attacked and survived. She recovered and described the man. Using that description, Inspector Francis Jacob recognized Thierry Paulin on a Paris street on December 1, 1987, and he was arrested. Paulin, born in Fort-de-France, Martinique, on November 28, 1963, was 24. He confessed, and he was charged with 18 murders; he claimed 21. An earlier survivor, a 91-year-old woman attacked in October 1984, had been unable to give details.

Paulin never stood trial. He died of complications of AIDS in the hospital of Fresnes prison on the night of April 16, 1989, at 25. His former companion, Jean-Thierry Mathurin, who was 19 at the time of the first killings, was tried for the first nine attacks and killings, convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment; Diario UNO reported that he was held until January 2009.

Lonnie Franklin Jr.: South Los Angeles, 1988 and 2016

In November 1988 a woman then in her late twenties or about 30 was attacked in South Los Angeles and survived. By then several women had been killed in the same part of the city. Her account gave the Los Angeles Police Department its only description of the man: a composite sketch was drawn from it, and it went up on reward billboards. The billboards stood eight blocks from Franklin’s house, and in 2010 the police chief, Charlie Beck, said Franklin drove past them every day.

The sketch did not produce a name. That came in July 2010, when California’s familial DNA search program identified Lonnie Franklin Jr., a former city sanitation worker and police garage attendant, as a suspect. He was arrested on July 7, the state attorney general’s office announced.

The woman who survived did not face him in a courtroom until 2016. On February 25, 2016, at 57, she took the stand in Los Angeles Superior Court. Shown a 1989 photograph of Franklin and asked how certain she was that he was the man who shot her, she answered, "100 percent." He had "less hair now," she said, "but he still looks the same," City News Service reported. She acknowledged under cross-examination that the sketch "didn’t really look like" him.

On May 5, 2016, the jury found Franklin guilty of ten counts of first-degree murder, with the special circumstance of multiple murder, and of the attempted murder of the woman who had survived. The women he was convicted of killing were Debra Jackson, Henrietta Wright, Barbara Ware, Bernita Sparks, Mary Lowe, Lachrica Jefferson, Alicia "Monique" Alexander, Princess Berthomieux, who was 15, Valerie McCorvey and Janecia Peters. Judge Kathleen Kennedy sentenced him to death on August 10, 2016. He died at San Quentin on March 28, 2020, while his automatic appeal was still pending.

Herb Baumeister: Indianapolis, 1994 to 1996

Through 1993 and 1994 young men disappeared from Indianapolis. Two families hired a private investigator, the former police detective Virgil Vandagriff, and Detective Mary Wilson of the Indianapolis Police Department took on the search.

The break came from a man who said he had been attacked in August 1994 by someone he met at an Indianapolis bar; the man had called himself Brian. He survived and told investigators. He could not place the property again, and Wilson drove the northern suburbs with him repeatedly without success, WRTV reported in its account of the police records. In July 1995 he saw the same man in a bar. Friends followed him out and took down the license plate of his vehicle. The plate belonged to Herbert R. Baumeister, a married father of three who ran two thrift stores in Indianapolis and lived at Fox Hollow Farm, an 18-acre estate in Westfield.

The survivor’s word was not enough. In August 1995 Wilson saw that the estate matched his description, but a judge refused to sign a search warrant; Vandagriff told WRTV that Hamilton County judges did not find the witness credible enough. On November 1, 1995, Wilson and a lieutenant confronted Baumeister at one of his stores, and his lawyer later refused consent to a search. His wife, advised by her own lawyer, also declined. She filed for divorce in January 1996.

On June 24, 1996, with his wife’s consent, investigators went onto the property, and the deaths of several men came to light in Westfield that day and in the weeks that followed. Baumeister had gone to Ontario. On July 3, 1996, he shot himself at Pinery Provincial Park, near Grand Bend. He was 49 and had never been charged, and police named him as the only suspect. By November 2025 the Hamilton County coroner had identified ten men, among them Roger Allen Goodlet and Allen Wayne Broussard, the two whose families had hired Vandagriff in 1994. The man who survived is the reason the police had Baumeister’s name a year before anyone was allowed onto his land.

Sergei Ryakhovsky: Moscow region, 1988 to 1993

Sergei Ryakhovsky, a former electrician from Balashikha, east of Moscow, had served four years for a run of attacks on elderly women in Moscow in 1982. The killings that followed his release began in June 1988 and continued across Moscow and the Moscow region for nearly five years, with victims who ranged from teenagers to pensioners. More than one person who was attacked lived. Two women survived attacks in 1988, and a 71-year-old woman survived one in June 1992, according to MSK1.RU.

The decisive survivor was a woman attacked on December 25, 1992. She survived and gave investigators a description of a large, heavy man with a sullen look. News.ru, which gave her age as 57, reported that the portrait identification laboratory of the Moscow police drew a composite sketch from her account, and 360.ru reported that other survivors added to it. The sketch became the main tool of the search.

Officers working from it watched the Odintsovo district, where a woman had been killed in March 1993, and on April 13, 1993, they recognized him there and arrested him. Surviving victims identified him, News.ru reported. He confessed, later retracted, and was tried. In July 1995 a court convicted him of 18 of the 19 murders charged and of two attempted murders, and sentenced him to death. The sentence was replaced with life imprisonment. He died of tuberculosis in a special-regime colony in Mordovia on November 12, 2007.

Harvey Miguel Robinson: Allentown, 1993

Between August 1992 and July 1993 three people were killed in Allentown, Pennsylvania: Joan Burghardt, a 29-year-old nurse’s aide, in August 1992; Charlotte Schmoyer, a 15-year-old high school student who delivered newspapers, on June 9, 1993; and Jessica Jean Fortney, a 47-year-old grandmother, whose death came to light on July 14, 1993.

On June 28, 1993, between the second and third killings, a woman was attacked in her Allentown home and survived. After further entries into her home, Allentown police reasoned that her attacker would come back. Officers were stationed at her home. In the early hours of July 31, 1993, an intruder returned and was confronted by Officer Brian Lewis. About two hours later Harvey Miguel Robinson, 18, arrived at a hospital for treatment. Lewis identified him as the man he had faced, the woman identified him as well, and he was arrested, the federal district court recorded.

Her case was resolved first. On February 28, 1994, Robinson pleaded guilty to three counts of burglary, two counts of attempted criminal homicide and two firearms counts arising from his entries into her home, and he was sentenced to 40.5 to 81 years. In November 1994 a Lehigh County jury convicted him of the first-degree murders of Joan Burghardt, Charlotte Schmoyer and Jessica Jean Fortney, with related counts, and sentenced him to death for each. The death sentences for Burghardt and Schmoyer were later vacated, one because he was a juvenile at the time of that killing. The death sentence for Fortney’s murder survived every state and federal appeal; the Supreme Court of the United States declined review on January 21, 2025. In February 2026 the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections signed a notice of execution for March 24, and Governor Josh Shapiro issued a reprieve. As of March 24, 2026, Robinson was held at SCI Phoenix, WFMZ-TV reported.

Kendall Francois: Poughkeepsie, 1998

Over about 22 months between 1996 and 1998, women went missing from Poughkeepsie, New York. On September 1, 1998, a woman who had been attacked by Kendall Francois, a former middle school hall monitor who lived in the city with his parents and his younger sister, survived and called the police. Her report brought officers to Francois, and that month the deaths of eight women came to light in Poughkeepsie. His family was not implicated, the Associated Press reported.

A Dutchess County grand jury indicted him on October 8, 1998, on eight counts of first-degree murder, eight of second-degree murder and one count of attempted assault in the second degree, the last for the attack on the woman who survived. The case then turned on a point of capital law. On December 23, 1998, the day after the state’s highest court struck down the provisions that had let capital defendants plead guilty to avoid death, Francois appeared in court unscheduled and offered to plead guilty to the whole indictment; the district attorney filed notice of intent to seek death the next morning. In Matter of Francois v. Dolan, decided May 18, 2000, the Court of Appeals held that he had no unqualified right to plead guilty while the prosecutor’s time to decide was still running.

He pleaded guilty in the end, in a plea the AP said spared him the death penalty, and in 2000 he was sentenced to life without parole. He was also convicted of attempted assault on the woman who survived. At the sentencing, the daughter of Sandra French, 51, one of the eight, spoke to him directly. Francois died at Wende Correctional Facility in Alden, New York, in September 2014, at 43. The reporter Claudia Rowe, who corresponded with him for years, later wrote a book about the case; she told The Stranger in 2017 that the city’s denial about the women who were disappearing was one of the reasons she wrote it.

Julio Pérez Silva: Alto Hospicio, 2001

For three years girls disappeared from Alto Hospicio, a fast-growing settlement on the desert plateau overlooking the port of Iquique in northern Chile. The police told their families that the girls had run away, perhaps to Peru, to escape hard lives at home. Jorge Burgos, then undersecretary of the Interior, linked the disappearances in 2001 to family violence and extreme poverty. Families said they were treated as suspects. "They said we were loose-living, promiscuous families," the grandmother of one girl told Inter Press Service.

On October 3 and 4, 2001, a 13-year-old girl was attacked by Julio Pérez Silva, an unlicensed taxi driver then 38. She survived and reported it to the Carabineros, and her description brought police to him the same day, October 4, Inter Press Service and Cooperativa reported. He confessed within days. Another young woman who had survived an attack in April 2001 later recognized his voice, T13 reported in 2024.

On February 26, 2004, Judge Eliana Ayala in Iquique convicted Pérez Silva of fourteen aggravated homicides and of the attempted homicide of the girl who survived, with other charges. The Iquique Court of Appeals raised the sentence in September 2005 to qualified life imprisonment, which requires at least forty years before any prison benefit can be sought, and the Supreme Court ratified it, Cooperativa reported on October 16, 2006. Among the fourteen were Macarena Sánchez, who disappeared on November 23, 2000, Viviana Garay, who disappeared on June 30, 2000, and Ivón Carrillo, fifteen. Their families had heard for years that the girls had left of their own accord. President Ricardo Lagos apologized to them in Iquique, and the minister Claudio Huepe apologized for police attempts to discredit the victims. Burgos later apologized as well. As of March 2026, El Dínamo reported, Pérez Silva was serving his sentence at Colina 1.

Mohan Kumar: Karnataka, 2009 to 2020

Mohan Kumar, a former government school teacher from Kanyana in Bantwal taluk, Karnataka, was arrested on October 21, 2009, at Deralakatte near Mangaluru. His arrest followed the June 2009 death of a 22-year-old woman from Bantwal taluk at the bus stand in Hassan; her family’s missing-person complaint, public protests and a special police team’s work on telephone records brought investigators to him. The deaths of young women at bus stands in Mysuru, Bengaluru, Hassan and other towns, many of them recorded as suicides, were connected to cyanide poisoning and to one man. Police said at the time that he had been linked to the deaths of 18 women.

The survivors did their work in court. Open magazine reported in 2014 that one woman from Bantwal had survived, recovered after five days in hospital and later married. She became a witness. When the first case was tried in camera before Judge B.K. Naik in Mangaluru, the prosecution called 49 witnesses, and the surviving woman was among them. The Karnataka High Court, in its judgments of 2017, recorded that two women who had survived testified about his methods and the false names he used.

Prosecutors brought about 20 separate cases, and sessions courts in Mangaluru tried them one at a time between 2013 and 2020, often with Kumar conducting his own defense. The press has counted the result as 20 convictions, but the record is more mixed. On October 12, 2017, the High Court upheld his murder conviction in the Hassan case and commuted the death sentence to imprisonment for the rest of his life without remission. On October 24, 2017, it set aside a murder conviction in a Mysuru case of September 2005 for lack of proof, keeping only a robbery conviction. On November 15, 2017, it confirmed the death sentence for the murder of a 30-year-old woman from Sullia taluk who died in Mysuru in February 2008. A trial court acquitted him in a case from Kollur in January 2019, and on August 17, 2026, a division bench of the High Court dismissed the state’s appeal. He remained in custody as of that date.

Anthony Sowell: Cleveland, 2008 and 2009

On December 8, 2008, a woman was attacked by Anthony Sowell, a registered sex offender who had served 15 years in prison for a 1989 attack on a woman. She survived and went to the police, and Sowell was arrested. He was released without charges. The Supreme Court of Ohio later recorded that the arresting officer had mislabeled the offense on the incident report; a sex crimes detective’s report, obtained by CBS News in 2010, marked the allegations "unfounded."

On September 22, 2009, another woman survived an attack by Sowell and reported it to police. More than a month passed. On October 28, 2009, an officer working her complaint obtained arrest and search warrants, and on the evening of October 29, as officers served them, the deaths of women came to light in Cleveland. Over the next five days the toll reached eleven. Sowell was arrested on October 31, 2009, after a member of the public recognized him from news broadcasts.

Five women who had survived attacks testified at his trial. On July 22, 2011, a Cuyahoga County jury convicted him of the aggravated murders of Tonia Carmichael, Nancy Cobbs, Tishana Culver, Crystal Dozier, Telacia Fortson, Amelda Hunter, Leshanda Long, Michelle Mason, Kim Yvette Smith, Diane Turner and Janice Webb, and of kidnapping, attempted murder and other counts involving three of the surviving women. Judge Dick Ambrose imposed eleven death sentences in August 2011, and the Supreme Court of Ohio affirmed them on December 8, 2016. In 2018 the City of Cleveland agreed to pay one million dollars to the families of six of the women, Ideastream reported, in a suit built on the release of December 2008. Sowell died in state custody of a terminal illness on February 8, 2021, never executed.

What the survivors carried

Set side by side, the eleven cases show how narrow the margin was. A teenage girl in Tampa and a 13-year-old in Alto Hospicio reported what had happened within hours, and in both cases an arrest followed within days. A woman in Poughkeepsie made one telephone call, and eight deaths came to light that month. In Paris a woman of 87 gave a description that a detective carried into the street.

Other survivors were made to wait, or were not believed. In Indianapolis a judge would not sign a warrant on the word of a man who had survived, and the deaths at Fox Hollow Farm did not come to light until June 1996. In Cleveland, the woman who flagged down a patrol car in December 2008 was written up as an unfounded complaint, and the next woman’s report sat for more than a month. In Los Angeles, the only person who could describe the man had to wait until 2016 to say "100 percent" to a jury.

What none of them could do was undo what had already happened. Their accounts arrived after the deaths, and in most of these cases after many of them. But a sketch drawn from one woman’s memory put officers in the right district outside Moscow; a woman’s identification and a police watch on her home gave Allentown its arrest; and two women who survived Mohan Kumar’s cyanide told judges in Karnataka how he had worked. In each case the record that convicted the offender began with someone he had meant to silence.

Timeline

• 1976: Robert Frederick Carr is arrested in Florida after an attack on a woman who survives; he then admits four killings.

• October 1984: Killings of elderly women begin in Paris.

• November 3, 1984: A 17-year-old girl is abducted in Tampa and released; she reports it to police.

• November 16, 1984: Bobby Joe Long is arrested in Tampa.

• September 23, 1985: Long pleads guilty to eight counts of first-degree murder.

• November 25, 1987: An 87-year-old woman survives an attack in Paris.

• December 1, 1987: Thierry Paulin is arrested in Paris.

• June 1988: The killings in the Moscow region series begin.

• November 1988: A woman is shot in South Los Angeles and survives; a composite sketch is drawn from her account.

• April 16, 1989: Paulin dies at Fresnes, untried.

• December 25, 1992: A woman survives an attack near Moscow; her description becomes the basis of a composite sketch.

• April 13, 1993: Ryakhovsky is arrested in the Odintsovo district.

• June 28, 1993: A woman is attacked in her Allentown home and survives.

• July 31, 1993: Harvey Miguel Robinson is arrested in Allentown.

• August 1994: A man survives an attack by a man he met at an Indianapolis bar.

• November 1994: Robinson is convicted of three first-degree murders.

• July 1995: Friends of the Indianapolis survivor take down a license plate that belongs to Herb Baumeister.

• July 1995: Ryakhovsky is convicted of 18 murders and two attempted murders.

• June 24, 1996: Deaths come to light at Fox Hollow Farm, Westfield, Indiana.

• July 3, 1996: Baumeister shoots himself in Pinery Provincial Park, Ontario.

• September 1, 1998: A woman survives an attack by Kendall Francois in Poughkeepsie and calls police; that month the deaths of eight women come to light.

• May 18, 2000: The New York Court of Appeals decides Matter of Francois v. Dolan.

• 2000: Francois is sentenced to life without parole.

• October 4, 2001: Julio Pérez Silva is arrested in northern Chile after a 13-year-old girl survives and reports an attack.

• February 26, 2004: Pérez Silva is convicted of fourteen aggravated homicides and an attempted homicide.

• 2007: Carr dies in a Florida prison.

• November 12, 2007: Ryakhovsky dies in a colony in Mordovia.

• December 8, 2008: A woman survives an attack in Cleveland and flags down police; Anthony Sowell is arrested and released without charges.

• June 2009: A 22-year-old woman from Bantwal taluk dies in Hassan, Karnataka.

• September 22, 2009: A second woman survives an attack by Sowell and reports it.

• October 21, 2009: Mohan Kumar is arrested near Mangaluru.

• October 29, 2009: The deaths of women come to light in Cleveland; Sowell is arrested on October 31.

• July 7, 2010: Lonnie Franklin Jr. is arrested in Los Angeles.

• July 22, 2011: Sowell is convicted of eleven aggravated murders.

• December 2013: Kumar is convicted in the first three of his cases in Mangaluru.

• September 2014: Francois dies in prison.

• February 25, 2016: The woman who survived in 1988 identifies Franklin in court.

• May 5, 2016: Franklin is convicted of ten murders and one attempted murder.

• October and November 2017: The Karnataka High Court rules on three of Kumar’s cases.

• May 23, 2019: Long is executed.

• March 28, 2020: Franklin dies at San Quentin.

• February 8, 2021: Sowell dies in state custody.

• March 24, 2026: Robinson receives a governor’s reprieve from an execution date.

• August 17, 2026: The Karnataka High Court upholds Kumar’s acquittal in the Kollur case.