The advertisements were brief and nearly identical from London to Sydney to Copenhagen. A respectable woman, they said, would take a young child. A country home was offered, or a good family, or a titled lady who wanted a baby of her own. What the advertisement did not say, and what the mother who answered it usually did not ask, was what would become of the child once the money had changed hands.
For roughly three quarters of a century, in Britain, Australia, New Zealand, Scandinavia and Canada, a woman who had a baby outside marriage could pay a stranger to take it. The trade had a name everywhere it went. In English it was baby farming. In Danish and Swedish the women who practiced it at its worst were angel makers. Most of the women in the business were not killers. Some were. Nine of them were tried for what happened to the infants in their care, in courts that stretched from the Old Bailey to the Supreme Court at Invercargill, and almost every one of their cases changed the law.
The economics were simple, and they explain a great deal. A mother could pay a carer by the week, a few shillings at a time, or she could pay once. The single payment was the one that killed. The historian Joanna Bourke, lecturing at Gresham College in 2021 on the case of Amelia Dyer, pointed out that a carer paid a lump sum profited most when the child did not live long. Caitlin Davies, writing about the Finchley case in the Camden New Journal, described the same choice facing London mothers in 1902: a weekly fee, or one sum for an "adoption."
The mothers were rarely villains in the story. Many were domestic servants who would lose their places if they kept a child. Davies wrote that a great many of the London babies belonged to servants. In Copenhagen, the head of the Police Museum, Frederik Strand, told TV 2 Kosmopol that a child born outside marriage in Denmark around the First World War brought shame, money trouble and no childcare at all. In Helsingborg, according to the city archive, a mother could pay a single sum, "allt i ett," meant to keep a child to the age of 15, and if the child died, the foster home kept the money.
The first of these cases to shake Parliament ended on October 11, 1870, at the Surrey County Gaol in Horsemonger Lane, Newington. Margaret Waters, 35, was executed there for the murder of one child who had been in her care. The register of prisoners who died in that gaol, indexed by Surrey History Centre, gives her name, her age and the date.
Very little else about her was reported. Her birthplace, her family and the name of the child she was convicted of killing do not appear in the parliamentary record. The law professor Kristin Kalsem, writing for The Victorian Web in 2024, states that she was suspected in the deaths of some forty other children. None of those deaths was tried.
Her case nonetheless became the starting point for legislation. On March 6, 1872, Mr. Charley began the Commons debate on his Infant Life Protection Bill by reminding the House that members "were familiar with the case of Margaret Waters, the Brixton baby-farmer." Three months later he credited a barrister, Mr. Serjeant Relf, with having brought her to justice, and he defended her sentence against those who had questioned it: if the extreme penalty was ever needed as an example, he said, it was needed in her case. Lyon Playfair, one of the bill’s sponsors, told the House that one advertisement offering a premium of £5 to £10 for someone to adopt an infant "for life" had drawn about 300 replies.
The bill became the Infant Life Protection Act 1872. As Charley described it, anyone taking in two or more infants under a year old for payment needed a license, had to keep a register, and had to report any death to the coroner within 24 hours. Not everyone thought it went far enough. One member objected that it did nothing about the people who handed children over in the first place. The Infant Life Protection Act 1897 replaced it, widening the rules to cover children up to the age of five.
In inner Sydney two decades later, the deaths of infants who had passed through the hands of one family came to light in Macdonaldtown in October 1892, and then in Redfern and Chippendale that November. The family was the Makins. Sarah Makin, born Sarah Jane Sutcliffe in Sydney in 1845, was a midwife. Her husband John had driven a brewery dray until an injury put him out of work, and after that, according to the historian Heather Radi’s entry in the Australian Dictionary of Biography, the family lived by caring for babies born outside marriage. John usually answered the newspaper notices placed by mothers, agreed a lump sum of three to five pounds, and had the parents sign away any claim on the father. The family moved often.
One of the babies was Horace Murray, born on May 30, 1892, to an 18-year-old unmarried mother who advertised for someone to adopt him. SBS News reported in 2020 that the Makins answered under the name Hill and promised to raise him as their own. The day after the handover they told her they were moving to Hurstville. They had already left for Macdonaldtown, and when she asked to see her son she was turned away.
The Dictionary puts the number of infants whose deaths were linked to the family at 13; ABC News and the Illawarra Mercury give 15. John and Sarah Makin, with two of their teenage daughters, were arrested in November 1892, and the daughters were later released. How any of the children died was never established, SBS News reported.
John and Sarah were tried together at the Central Criminal Court in Sydney in March 1893 for the murder of Horace Murray or, if the identification failed, an unknown infant. Neither gave evidence. The jury convicted both after three days and recommended mercy for Sarah. Justice Stephen, as quoted from the press of the day by Region Illawarra, told them they had practiced "baby-farming in its worst phase and most forbidding aspect." He sentenced both to death.
Their appeal turned on the evidence of other mothers who had handed babies to the couple. The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council dismissed it, and its decision, Makin v Attorney-General for New South Wales, became a cornerstone of the law of similar fact evidence across the common-law world. Lord Herschell held, as the legal scholar Wendy Harris has quoted him, that evidence of other crimes is not barred if it is relevant to whether the acts charged "were designed or accidental." John Makin was hanged at Darlinghurst Gaol in August 1893. Sarah’s sentence was commuted to penal servitude for life. She was released from the State Reformatory for Women at Long Bay on April 29, 1911, on grounds of age and failing health, and died at Marrickville in 1918.
SBS News reported that the case led the New South Wales legislature to pass the Children’s Protection Act 1892, which began to regulate adoption and made it an offense not to report an infant’s death.
Williamina Dean, always called Minnie, was born Williamina McCulloch at West Greenock, Scotland, on September 2, 1844, according to her biographer Lynley Hood in the Dictionary of New Zealand Biography. By the late 1880s she and her husband, ruined by the collapse of Southland’s land boom, were living in a cottage on about 22 acres outside Winton, a farming town in the far south of New Zealand. She began taking in babies for money. Hood records her charges as five to eight shillings a week, or lump sums of 10 to 30 pounds for an adoption. At times, the government history site NZHistory says, there were as many as nine children under three in the house.
The police watched her for years and could do little. A coroner cleared her after a baby’s death in 1891, while urging her to take fewer children. In 1893 New Zealand passed its own Infant Life Protection Act, which required anyone paid to keep infants under two to be licensed and open to inspection. Dean did not register.
In May 1895 a grandmother who had handed her month-old granddaughter, Eva Hornsby, to Dean went to the police. The deaths of Eva and of Dorothy Edith Carter, a baby girl Dean had collected days earlier, came to light at Winton that month, along with the death of a small boy whom an inquest jury believed to be Willie Phelan. Dean was arrested. Her husband was arrested too, and discharged by the magistrate, who accepted there was no evidence he knew what his wife had done.
The trial began in the Supreme Court at Invercargill on June 18, 1895, before Justice Joshua Williams, on the charge of murdering Dorothy Carter. The Crown called 47 witnesses. Her young counsel, Alfred Hanlon, called none, and Dean did not give evidence. Hanlon pressed for manslaughter; the judge, summing up, called that verdict "a weak-kneed compromise." The jury took about half an hour to convict her of murder on June 21. The second charge, over Eva Hornsby, did not proceed. The legal scholar Sophie Davis, in a 2015 study in the Victoria University of Wellington Law Review, records that when Dean sought leave to appeal, the Court of Appeal relied on the Privy Council’s new decision in the Makin case to uphold the admission of evidence about other children. Leave was refused unanimously on July 27, 1895.
Dean was hanged at Invercargill on August 12, 1895. Asked whether she had anything to say, she told those present she was innocent, the Otago Daily Times reported. She is the only woman ever executed in New Zealand, by the count of both NZHistory and the New Zealand Police Museum. In a written account she prepared before her death, summarized by Hood, she said 26 children had passed through her care since 1889. Rumor at the time put the dead as high as 20. No court ever held her responsible for any death but Dorothy Carter’s, and Hood writes that the 1893 act was revised and strengthened in 1896 in response to the case.
Amelia Dyer is the best remembered of the English baby farmers, though only one death was ever proved against her. Born Amelia Hobley at Pyle Marsh, east of Bristol, in 1837 by the account of Wells Nub News, she trained as a nurse, ran a house in Bristol where unmarried women came to give birth, and then took in their babies in Bristol, Reading, Cardiff and London, Bourke said in her Gresham lecture. She used a string of names, Mrs. Thomas and Mrs. Harding among them, and her fee, Bourke said, settled at a single payment of ten pounds.
She had been in court before. In 1879 she was convicted under the Infant Life Protection Act 1872 and sentenced to six months' hard labor. Bourke describes the offense as neglect; Wells Nub News, citing newspaper reports of the time, says the charge was failing to obtain the license the act required. Through the 1890s she passed in and out of asylums at Gloucester and Wells.
One of the last children placed with her was Doris Marmon, born in Cheltenham in November 1895 to an unmarried barmaid. Her mother answered a "Mrs. Harding" advertisement offering a country home, signed an agreement for a fee of ten pounds, and handed the baby over at Cheltenham on March 31, 1896, according to the Friends of Reading Old Cemetery. In the spring of 1896 the deaths of infants in Dyer’s care came to light in Reading. Reading Borough Police arrested her on April 3, 1896, the crime historian Angela Buckley told the History of Reading Society, as reported by the Henley Standard.
She was tried at the Old Bailey for the murder of Doris Marmon. Her defense was insanity. The jury took about five minutes to convict her, by the accounts of Bourke, Buckley and Wells Nub News. Bourke quotes the judge, Henry Hawkins, telling her she had been treacherous to more than one mother and barbarous to more than one child, always for the same sordid motive. She was hanged at Newgate on June 10, 1896.
How many children died in her care is unknown. Bourke, noting witnesses' claims that Dyer sometimes took in several babies in a day, offered about 300 over some thirty years as an illustration and called it an underestimate. It is a historian’s estimate, not a court finding. The case arrived as Parliament was already weighing a wider law: the House of Lords sent a new Infant Life Protection Bill to a select committee on March 9, 1896, weeks before her arrest, and a government Infant Life Protection Bill passed the Commons on July 28, 1897.
The 1872 and 1897 acts did not close the trade. In 1902 Amelia Sach, 29, ran a lying-in home in East Finchley, in north London, where unmarried women could give birth in private. Her advertisements, as Davies summarized them, promised skilled nursing and home comforts and added that the baby "can remain." For a fee, Sach would arrange an adoption. Annie Walters, a woman in her fifties who worked for her, collected the babies.
On November 15, 1902, a young servant gave birth to a healthy boy at the home. Sach persuaded her to give him up for 25 pounds, promising, the Camden New Journal reported, that a titled lady would raise him. Within days the boy was in Walters’s hands at her lodgings in Islington. The landlady there was married to a police constable, and the household had grown suspicious of the babies that came and went. When a detective stopped Walters in London that November, the boy’s death came to light. He was four days old.
Both women were charged with murder, Sach as an accessory, and both were convicted of killing that one child. They were suspected of killing many more; no other death was tried. The writer Laura Thompson, in a book excerpt published by CrimeReads, noted that poverty, the usual plea in mitigation for women accused of killing infants, carried no weight for baby farmers. Sach and Walters were hanged together at Holloway Prison on February 3, 1903, the first women executed there. Davies linked the case to the pressure that produced the Children Act 1908. The historian Daniel Grey, writing in 2009, took a different view, concluding that the case had not led to any change in the law.
Hilda Nilsson was born in 1876 in Tirup, in Skåne, into a large and poor family, according to an account compiled by the Helsingborg city archive for the court history site Domstolenshistoria.se. She lost two infants of her own soon after their births. She worked at a rubber factory in Helsingborg, took a cookery course, worked in restaurants, and in 1902 married a fireman. The couple fell into debt and eventually went bankrupt. In her forties and short of money, she began taking in foster children for payment. Her husband, the archive’s account says, was against it and went along anyway.
Thirteen children passed through her care. Some were placed elsewhere or adopted. Eight died at her hands, and the money paid for them was soon spent. Nyheter24, a Swedish news site, dates the first killing to 1915, a girl of ten months.
The case came apart because one mother would not let go. She had given up her son and then regretted it, and she asked to see him. Nyheter24 reports that Nilsson claimed the boy had been taken to Gällivare, in the far north, and had died there, and that the mother wrote to the parish priest in Gällivare and learned that the parish had no record of him. She went to the police. A detective named Stjernström led an inquiry that the archive’s account calls thorough, and with each interrogation Nilsson admitted more. Several examinations detected no mental illness, and the case files give no real answer to why she did it.
On June 13, 1917, she was sentenced to death for killing the eight children. Nyheter24 describes the judgment as seven murders and one manslaughter. She appealed. Moved to the women’s prison in the citadel at Landskrona to await the outcome, she took her own life in her cell in 1917, before the appeal was decided; Nyheter24 gives the date as August 10 and reports that her sentence had been commuted to life imprisonment that same day without her knowledge. Helsingborgs stadslexikon, the city’s encyclopedia, describes her as the last person in Sweden convicted as an änglamakerska, an angel maker.
Danish records spell her name Overby. Dagmar Johanne Amalie Overby was born on April 23, 1887, at Assendrup in Jutland, the daughter of a smallholder of the poorest class, according to the historian Hanne Rimmen Nielsen in Dansk Kvindebiografisk Leksikon. She had several convictions for theft before she was thirty. By 1920 she was living in the Vesterbro district of Copenhagen, answering and placing newspaper advertisements that offered to "adopt" babies for a single cash payment.
On August 30, 1920, a 21-year-old mother brought her two-month-old daughter to Overbye’s apartment and left her there. Three days later she came back, regretting the arrangement, and asked for the child. Overbye told her the baby had been sent out of town, TV 2 Kosmopol reported in 2025, drawing on the Copenhagen police’s main report of 1920. The young mother went to the police, and Overbye was arrested. She first denied killing the child, then confessed, and then went on confessing. In the city court she admitted as many as 16 killings of children, according to Den Store Danske, the Danish national encyclopedia.
The case went to a jury at Østre Landsret, the Eastern High Court, in 1921. The hearings lasted three days. Her defense lawyer argued that she had been the tool of a deficient society and of indifferent mothers. Experts told the court that she had probably been under the influence of naphtha and ether, but that she was not insane. The jury convicted her and she was sentenced to death. Danish reference works give the verdict as guilty on nine counts, one of them concerning a child of her own; TV 2 Kosmopol, drawing on the Police Museum, and the science site Videnskab.dk put the figure at eight killings of infants between 1916 and 1920. She did not appeal.
No woman had been executed in Denmark since 1861. About a month after the verdict, Overbye was pardoned, on condition that she never be released and never receive any easing of prison rules. She died in Vestre Fængsel, Copenhagen, on May 6, 1929. Nielsen writes that the trial set off a public argument about unmarried mothers and the responsibility of both parents, and both her entry and Den Store Danske describe the Act on the Supervision of Foster Children of 1923, which placed every child born outside marriage under public supervision, as a direct result. Information, the Copenhagen daily, noted that Mødrehjælpen, an organization for single mothers and women with unwanted pregnancies, was established the following year. The case was the basis for the 2024 Danish film The Girl with the Needle, a work of fiction.
The last of these cases ran the longest and ended without any conviction for a death. From 1928, William Young, a chiropractor, and his wife Lila, who described herself as an obstetrical specialist, ran the Ideal Maternity Home in East Chester, a seaside village in Nova Scotia. The historian Karen Balcom, in a 2002 study in Acadiensis, describes it by the mid-1940s as the largest maternity home in Eastern Canada, with 80 to 125 babies in its nursery. Unmarried mothers paid about $500 or $600 for shelter, medical care, secrecy and an adoption. Women who could not pay worked off the debt. Adoptive parents, many of them in New Jersey and New York, paid "fees" or "donations" that, by the author Bette Cahill’s account as reported by CBC News, could reach $10,000. Investigators, Balcom writes, could confirm only several hundred dollars.
The courts saw the Youngs several times. In 1935 they were convicted of fraud for trying to collect payment for the care of a child after the child had died. In 1936 they were acquitted on two charges of manslaughter arising from the deaths of a mother and her baby at the home. Nova Scotia passed a Maternity Boarding Houses Act in 1940 requiring licenses and inspection. The Youngs incorporated the home to escape it, a loophole the province closed in 1945. That August the provincial director of child welfare, Fred MacKinnon, inspected the home himself; the provincial minister, Frank Davis, his deputy, Ernest Blois, and MacKinnon led the effort to shut it down, and at the province’s request the RCMP looked into the home’s adoptive placements. In the spring of 1946 the Youngs were convicted on seven of nine charges under the Maternity Boarding Houses Act and fined. The home closed in June 1946. A libel suit they brought against the Montreal Standard over Mavis Gallant’s 1946 exposé was dismissed in 1947.
Cahill’s book Butterbox Babies alleged that at least 100 babies had died at the home. Balcom, reviewing the provincial records, wrote that there does not appear to be documentary evidence in support of Cahill’s most serious allegations, and noted that the Youngs were never convicted of killing an infant. The province rewrote its adoption and maternity-home laws in 1943, 1946 and 1949, and in 1951 replaced the Illegitimate Children’s Act with the Children of Unmarried Parents Act.
Taken case by case, the convictions were narrow. Waters, Makin, Dean, Dyer, Sach and Walters were each convicted of a single death, and the larger numbers attached to their names rest on suspicion, confession or a historian’s estimate. Nilsson and Overbye were convicted of several. Young was convicted of nothing beyond fraud and licensing offenses. What the cases share is less a tally of victims than a sequence: a private market in unwanted infants, a death no one could explain away, and a legislature forced to act. England legislated in 1872 and again in 1897; New South Wales in 1892; New Zealand in 1893 and 1896; Denmark in 1923; Nova Scotia in 1940 and 1946. The trade did not end because these women were caught. It ended as adoption came under public supervision and as the stigma that had driven mothers to the advertisements began to lift.
• October 11, 1870: Margaret Waters is executed at the Surrey County Gaol, Horsemonger Lane, Newington.
• March 6, 1872: The Waters case opens the Commons debate on the Infant Life Protection Bill, which becomes law that year.
• 1879: Amelia Dyer is convicted under the Infant Life Protection Act 1872 and serves six months.
• October to November 1892: Infant deaths connected with the Makin family come to light in Macdonaldtown, Redfern and Chippendale, Sydney.
• March 1893: John and Sarah Makin are convicted of murder in Sydney; John is hanged at Darlinghurst Gaol that August.
• 1893: New Zealand passes the Infant Life Protection Act.
• June 21, 1895: Minnie Dean is convicted at Invercargill of the murder of Dorothy Carter.
• August 12, 1895: Dean is hanged at Invercargill.
• April 3, 1896: Amelia Dyer is arrested in Reading.
• June 10, 1896: Dyer is hanged at Newgate after her Old Bailey conviction for the murder of Doris Marmon.
• 1897: The Infant Life Protection Act 1897 replaces the 1872 act.
• November 1902: Annie Walters is stopped by a detective in London; she and Amelia Sach are charged with murder.
• February 3, 1903: Sach and Walters are hanged together at Holloway Prison.
• April 29, 1911: Sarah Makin is released from Long Bay.
• June 13, 1917: Hilda Nilsson is sentenced to death in Helsingborg for killing eight foster children.
• 1917: Nilsson dies in custody at Landskrona before her appeal is decided.
• August 30, 1920: A young mother leaves her daughter with Dagmar Overbye in Copenhagen; her return three days later leads to Overbye’s arrest.
• 1921: Overbye is convicted at Østre Landsret and sentenced to death; she is pardoned on condition of life imprisonment.
• 1923: Denmark passes the Act on the Supervision of Foster Children.
• 1928: William and Lila Young open the Ideal Maternity Home in East Chester, Nova Scotia.
• May 6, 1929: Overbye dies in Vestre Fængsel.
• 1935: The Youngs are convicted of fraud.
• 1936: The Youngs are acquitted on two charges of manslaughter.
• 1940: Nova Scotia passes the Maternity Boarding Houses Act.
• Spring 1946: The Youngs are convicted on seven charges under the Maternity Boarding Houses Act; the home closes in June.
• 1951: Nova Scotia passes the Children of Unmarried Parents Act.