A sentence is the last thing a court says about a case, and for most of these men it was meant to be the last thing the state would say about their lives. Some were condemned to death in Florida and Mississippi. Others drew life terms in Arizona, Massachusetts, Wisconsin, Ohio and California, and one was serving 16 years, the most the law of Ecuador then allowed. Each judgment was written down, appealed or accepted, and set on a course the state meant to control.
Nine times, between 1973 and 2021, another prisoner ended it first. The men they killed had been convicted of crimes ranging from a single child’s murder to dozens of hospital deaths, and in one case of no killing at all. What happened to their killers afterward ranged just as widely, from a life sentence to nothing. A tenth case, from Barcelona in 1913, is a reminder of how easily a prison death turns into legend.
Albert DeSalvo went to prison for crimes that were never the ones that made his name. In January 1967 he was tried in Middlesex Superior Court in Massachusetts on eight indictments covering offenses against four women in 1964, among them armed robbery, assault and battery, and breaking and entering. All four women survived. He was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment, and the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts affirmed the judgments on January 4, 1968.
He had also confessed to the 11 killings of women in the Boston area between June 1962 and January 1964 that the press called the work of the Boston Strangler. He was never charged with any of them, and he later took the confession back. In July 2013 the Suffolk County District Attorney announced that DNA testing tied him to one of those deaths, that of Mary Sullivan, 19, killed in January 1964. By then the question could never be tried, because he had long been dead.
DeSalvo was killed by another prisoner at Walpole State Prison in late November 1973, while serving his life term. Three inmates were brought to trial for his death. One jury could not agree on a verdict, and another trial ended in a mistrial, the Associated Press reported in 2001. No one was convicted.
Charles Schmid was 23 when Tucson police arrested him in November 1965, and the national magazines that came to cover his case called him the Pied Piper of Tucson, for the teenagers who followed him. In 1966 a Pima County jury convicted him of the first-degree murders of two sisters, Gretchen Fritz, 17, and Wendy Fritz, 13, and fixed the penalty at death. The prosecution’s theory, which the Arizona Supreme Court later accepted, was that he killed them because the older girl knew of an earlier killing and was using what she knew against him.
That earlier killing was the death of Alleen Rowe, 15, in May 1964. In 1967, during his second trial, with F. Lee Bailey defending him, Schmid pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in her death and was sentenced to 50 years to life. The Arizona Supreme Court affirmed the Rowe judgment on April 28, 1971. Its ruling on the Fritz case came on April 25, 1973. By then the United States Supreme Court had decided Furman v. Georgia, and the Arizona court affirmed the convictions, declared the death-penalty provision of the state’s murder statute unconstitutional, and reduced the sentence to life imprisonment.
He served that sentence at the Arizona State Prison in Florence. In March 1975, two other prisoners killed him. He was 32. The motive was never settled in public: his former wife, speaking to AZFamily in 2025, described theories ranging from a quarrel among prisoners to a belief that he was an informer, and a claim of a paid killing that the Fritz family denied. Phoenix Magazine noted in 2025 that rumors of a hit financed by the victims' relatives were never proven.
Gerard John Schaefer had worn a badge. He had been a police officer in Broward County and a sheriff’s deputy in Martin County, Florida, before he went on trial in Fort Pierce in 1973 for the murders of two teenage girls, Susan Place, 17, and Georgia Jessup, 16, who were killed in 1972. Bob Stone, the state attorney of the 19th Circuit, prosecuted the case with Phil Shailer, the state attorney of the neighboring 17th Circuit, whom Governor Reubin Askew appointed to the case, The Florida Bar News recalled in 2009. Judge C. Pfeiffer Trowbridge presided.
The jury convicted Schaefer of both murders, and he was sentenced to life imprisonment. A ruling of the United States Supreme Court had left Florida without a usable death penalty at the time, WKMG reported in 2026. He served two life sentences and never stopped insisting he was innocent. From his cell he sued writers who called him a serial killer and lost; one of those suits ended in the federal appeals court in Chicago in June 1995.
In 1995 he was killed by another inmate in his cell. Whether the other prisoner was ever prosecuted has not been reported. Schaefer died convicted of two killings, and the suspicions did not die with him. In June 2022 the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office named him its likeliest suspect in the death of Susan Gale Poole, 15, a case dating to 1972, while saying it could not prove the connection, WPTV reported.
Daniel Camargo Barbosa was born in Cundinamarca, Colombia, in 1930. He served one prison term in Colombia, for other charges, and was later serving a second Colombian sentence, of 25 years by the account of the Ecuadorian magazine Vistazo, at the island penal colony of Gorgona. By the end of 1984 he was in Ecuador.
Over the following year the deaths of young women and girls came to light around Guayaquil and in other Ecuadorian towns. In 1985 the forensic physician Carlos Barcos Velásquez, who directed the forensic institute of the University of Guayaquil, concluded that a single person was responsible, El Universo later reported. Camargo was arrested in Quito in 1986. He confessed to killing 71 women and girls in Ecuador, Vistazo reported, and said he felt no remorse.
Ecuadorian law then capped a prison sentence at 16 years, and that is what the court imposed in 1986. Vistazo reported that police guarded him day and night while he served it. He did not complete the term. On November 13, 1994, according to a 2026 academic study published in the journal Polo del Conocimiento, he was killed by another prisoner at the Centro de Rehabilitación de Varones No. 2 in Quito. Vistazo described the prisoner responsible as a relative of one of his victims. Whether that man was ever charged was not reported.
Edwin Kaprat III was 30 and new to Florida’s death row. Earlier in 1995 a jury had convicted him of killing two elderly women, and he had been sentenced to death. He was also charged with the killings of three more elderly women, cases that had not come to trial, the Associated Press reported.
On April 19, 1995, Kaprat was killed by other prisoners at Florida State Prison near Starke. A second condemned man, Charlie Street, 41, was killed in the same incident. Street had been sentenced to death in 1990 for killing two police officers after he was released early from an overcrowded prison in 1988, a release that provoked public outrage and helped set off a prison-building boom in Florida. Laura Levings, a spokeswoman for the Florida Department of Corrections, announced the deaths. Florida State Prison then held about 1,100 inmates, about 20 of them on death row; most of the state’s condemned, some 320 men, were held at Union Correctional Institution near Raiford.
Two fellow death-row prisoners were held in connection with the killings. The department did not release their names when it announced the deaths the following day, and it gave no motive. Kaprat had been convicted only that year.
Jeffrey Dahmer was arrested in Milwaukee on July 22, 1991, and admitted killing 17 young men and boys. In Milwaukee County he pleaded guilty but insane to 15 counts of first-degree intentional homicide, which left the jury a single question: whether he had been legally sane. On February 15, 1992, after nearly five hours of deliberation, the jurors, seven men and five women, rejected the insanity defense on every count by a vote of 10 to 2, the minimum Wisconsin law required, United Press International reported. Two days later Judge Laurence C. Gram Jr. sentenced him to 15 consecutive life terms. Wisconsin had no death penalty.
He served his sentence at the Columbia Correctional Institution in Portage. On the morning of November 28, 1994, he was killed by another prisoner there; he died at 9:11 a.m. on the way to Divine Savior Hospital, UPI reported. He was 34. A second inmate, Jesse Anderson of Cedarburg, Wisconsin, who had been convicted of killing his wife, was also killed.
The man responsible was Christopher Scarver, who was already serving a life sentence for the 1990 killing of his former boss during a robbery. He first pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. He later changed his plea to no contest in exchange for a transfer to a federal penitentiary and was sentenced to two more life terms, WKBT reported in 2015.
Donald Leroy Evans, a drifter from Galveston, Texas, and a Texas parole violator, was 34 when a sheriff’s deputy in Tangipahoa Parish, Louisiana, arrested him on August 5, 1991, on a federal kidnapping charge. The case concerned Beatrice Louise Routh, 10, a homeless child who had come to the Gulf Coast with her family looking for work and housing, and who was killed in Mississippi. On August 19, 1991, Evans pleaded guilty in federal court to kidnapping her, and on October 24 he was sentenced to life in prison.
Mississippi tried him next. A Harrison County grand jury indicted him on October 15, 1991, for capital murder, with kidnapping as the underlying felony, and two other counts. The trial ran from September 13 to September 18, 1993. The jury convicted him on all counts and returned a sentence of death. On September 11, 1997, the Supreme Court of Mississippi rejected all 31 of his assignments of error and affirmed. "This Court affirms Evans' convictions and sentences," the court wrote. Its mandate issued on August 17, 1998.
Within days of his arrest, Evans had begun telling investigators that he had killed more than 60 other people in 20 or more states. The claims drew national attention and an FBI team to test them. None was ever tried against him, and when he died the Associated Press described them as false. On the record, Evans was convicted of a single killing.
In January 1999 he was killed by another prisoner on death row at the Mississippi State Penitentiary at Parchman. A Corrections Department spokesman, Ken Jones, named the man as Jimmie Mack, another death-row inmate, the Associated Press reported on January 5, 1999. The state’s Office of State Public Defender records that Evans died before any decision on a motion for state post-conviction relief. What became of any charge against Mack was not reported.
Donald Harvey spent most of his working life in hospitals, as an orderly in London, Kentucky, and later as a nurse’s aide and morgue attendant in Cincinnati. His case came to light in 1987, after an autopsy on a patient at Drake Memorial Hospital in Cincinnati, John Powell, 44, led the Hamilton County coroner’s office to suspect homicide. Harvey was charged with that one death. Facing a possible death sentence as nurses and a television reporter raised questions about other deaths on his ward, he confessed in exchange for life terms.
On August 18, 1987, in Hamilton County Common Pleas Court, Harvey pleaded guilty before Judge William S. Mathews to 24 counts of aggravated murder, four counts of attempted aggravated murder and one count of felonious assault. Twenty-one of the 24 victims were Drake patients; the other three were people in his private life. He was sentenced to three consecutive life terms, which United Press International reported would keep him from parole for at least 60 years. In November 1987, in Laurel Circuit Court in London, Kentucky, he pleaded guilty to eight counts of murder and one count of voluntary manslaughter, covering nine patients of Marymount Hospital who died in 1970 and 1971, and received eight life sentences plus 20 years. News reports since then have put his total at 37 killings.
Harvey served three decades. In March 2017 he was killed by another prisoner at the Toledo Correctional Institution, and he died on March 30, 2017, at 64. "Harvey caused a lot of pain in our community," said Joe Deters, the Hamilton County prosecutor. "I do not have any compassion for Donald Harvey."
The case against his killer took two years. James D. Elliott, a fellow prisoner from the Knox and Whitley County area of Kentucky who was serving time for a series of burglaries, wrote to newspapers in 2018 claiming responsibility. A Lucas County grand jury indicted him in May 2019 on charges that included aggravated murder. In September 2019 he pleaded guilty to aggravated murder in Lucas County Common Pleas Court, the other charges were dismissed, and Judge Myron Duhart sentenced him to life in prison with parole eligibility after 25 years. "No matter how bad a person is, that does not give you the right to be the judge, jury, and executioner," the judge told him.
Roger Kibbe, a furniture maker from Citrus Heights in suburban Sacramento, was convicted by an El Dorado County jury in 1991 of the first-degree murder of Darcie Frackenpohl, 17, and sentenced to 25 years to life. The case was reopened years later. In 2009, in San Joaquin County Superior Court, he pleaded guilty to six more counts of first-degree murder: Lou Ellen Burleigh, killed in 1977, and Lora Heedick, Barbara Ann Scott, Stephanie Brown, Charmaine Sabrah and Katherine Kelly Quinones, all killed in 1986. On November 5, 2009, Judge George Abdallah Jr. sentenced him to six consecutive terms of life without parole.
He was held at Mule Creek State Prison in Ione from 2013. A retired detective who had worked the case told CBS Sacramento that Kibbe had been afraid of the general population. In the early hours of February 28, 2021, Kibbe was killed by his cellmate, Jason Budrow, 40, and was pronounced dead at 1:23 a.m., the Associated Press reported. He was 81. "This is evil killing evil," the detective told the station.
Budrow was already serving life without parole for murder in Riverside County. In January 2024 the Associated Press reported that he was serving two terms of life without parole, one for the 2010 killing of a girlfriend in Riverside County and one for killing his cellmate at Mule Creek in 2021.
One case belongs beside these nine only as a caution. Enriqueta Martí was arrested in Barcelona on February 27, 1912, in connection with the abduction of a five-year-old girl, who survived. Within days the city’s newspapers had made her the "vampira del Raval," a woman accused of killing children. Those accusations never came to trial. She was held in the Reina Amalia women’s prison to await trial, and she died there on May 12, 1913.
For a century the popular story held that other prisoners killed her. Barcelona Metropolitan reports that her death certificate gives uterine cancer as the cause, and the Catalan broadcasters 3Cat and betevé give the same cause. The historian Elsa Plaza, whose 2014 book reconstructed the case from court records and the press, concluded that the killing by fellow inmates never happened and that she died of illness, according to Patricia Melgar’s review in HSE: Social and Education History. Jordi Corominas, whose own book on the case appeared the same year, also argued that the legend had distorted her story. Reporting on his work in 2015, elDiario.es still repeated the tale of a killing by fellow inmates, while noting that the press of 1913 never settled whether she died that way or of cancer.
Three of the killers were sentenced for what they did inside. Scarver received two more life terms for the deaths of Dahmer and Anderson. Elliott pleaded guilty to aggravated murder in Harvey’s death, with parole eligibility only after 25 years. Budrow added a second term of life without parole to the one he was already serving. The three men tried for DeSalvo’s death were not convicted. In the deaths of Schmid, Schaefer, Camargo Barbosa, Evans and Kaprat, the public record stops at a name, an initial or an arrest.
The sentences they cut short were of every kind. Kaprat had been condemned within the year, and Evans was still pursuing his appeals. Schmid’s death sentence had been reduced to life after Furman. Harvey pleaded guilty and accepted life terms with a death sentence in prospect. Camargo Barbosa was serving the longest term Ecuadorian law permitted, and Dahmer the longest Wisconsin could impose. DeSalvo was serving life for crimes in which every victim lived. Each judgment had been entered and, in most cases, upheld. Another prisoner decided how each one ended.
• February 27, 1912: Enriqueta Martí is arrested in Barcelona in connection with the abduction of a five-year-old girl, who survives.
• May 12, 1913: Martí dies in the Reina Amalia women’s prison, untried; her death certificate gives uterine cancer.
• 1966: A Pima County jury convicts Charles Schmid of the first-degree murders of Gretchen and Wendy Fritz and fixes the penalty at death.
• January 1967: Albert DeSalvo is convicted in Middlesex Superior Court of offenses against four women and sentenced to life imprisonment.
• 1967: Schmid pleads guilty to second-degree murder in the death of Alleen Rowe and is sentenced to 50 years to life.
• January 4, 1968: The Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts affirms DeSalvo’s convictions.
• April 28, 1971: The Arizona Supreme Court affirms Schmid’s Rowe judgment.
• April 25, 1973: The Arizona Supreme Court affirms the Fritz convictions and reduces Schmid’s sentence to life imprisonment.
• 1973: Gerard John Schaefer is convicted in Fort Pierce, Florida, of the first-degree murders of Susan Place and Georgia Jessup and sentenced to life.
• Late November 1973: DeSalvo is killed by another prisoner at Walpole State Prison; three inmates are later tried and none is convicted.
• March 1975: Schmid is killed by two other prisoners in Arizona; he dies at 32.
• 1986: Daniel Camargo Barbosa is arrested in Quito, confesses to 71 killings in Ecuador and is sentenced to 16 years.
• August 18, 1987: Donald Harvey pleads guilty in Cincinnati to 24 counts of aggravated murder and other counts and receives three consecutive life terms.
• November 1987: Harvey pleads guilty in London, Kentucky, to eight counts of murder and one of voluntary manslaughter.
• 1991: An El Dorado County jury convicts Roger Kibbe of the first-degree murder of Darcie Frackenpohl; he is sentenced to 25 years to life.
• August 5, 1991: Donald Leroy Evans is arrested in Tangipahoa Parish, Louisiana, on a federal kidnapping charge.
• October 24, 1991: Evans is sentenced to life on the federal kidnapping count.
• February 15, 1992: A Milwaukee jury rejects Jeffrey Dahmer’s insanity defense on 15 counts; two days later he receives 15 consecutive life terms.
• September 1993: A Harrison County jury convicts Evans of capital murder and other counts and returns a death sentence.
• November 13, 1994: Camargo Barbosa is killed by another prisoner in Quito.
• November 28, 1994: Dahmer and Jesse Anderson are killed by another prisoner, Christopher Scarver, at the Columbia Correctional Institution in Portage, Wisconsin.
• 1995: Edwin Kaprat III is convicted of killing two elderly women and sentenced to death in Florida.
• April 19, 1995: Kaprat and Charlie Street are killed by other prisoners at Florida State Prison near Starke.
• 1995: Schaefer is killed by another inmate in his cell.
• September 11, 1997: The Supreme Court of Mississippi affirms Evans’s convictions and death sentence.
• January 1999: Evans is killed by another death-row prisoner, Jimmie Mack, at Parchman.
• November 5, 2009: Kibbe is sentenced in San Joaquin County to six consecutive terms of life without parole after pleading guilty to six murders.
• March 30, 2017: Harvey dies after being killed by another prisoner at the Toledo Correctional Institution.
• September 2019: James D. Elliott pleads guilty to aggravated murder in Harvey’s death and is sentenced to life with parole eligibility after 25 years.
• February 28, 2021: Kibbe is killed by his cellmate, Jason Budrow, at Mule Creek State Prison in Ione, California.
• June 2022: The Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office names Schaefer its likeliest suspect in the death of Susan Gale Poole.
• January 2024: The Associated Press reports that Budrow is serving a second term of life without parole for killing Kibbe.