A number has a way of outliving the proceedings that should have tested it. It is printed once, repeated a thousand times, and in the end it stands beside a name as though a jury had returned it. In each of the eight cases that follow, the figure is famous and no court ever weighed it, because no court ever convicted the person of murder. Two of them were acquitted. One was never charged and died under guard in a castle. One was ruled dead by a coroner whose ruling few people believed. One died weeks after a judge threw out most of the case against her. One was convicted only of running an unlicensed maternity home. One was convicted of kidnapping and sexual crimes and never charged with a killing. And one confessed, was charged, and was ruled insane before any trial began.
Tracing each figure back to its source is a plain exercise in reading the record. It is also, case by case, the clearest way to see what was proved and what was only said.
Elizabeth Báthory was born on August 7, 1560, at Nyírbátor, in the east of the Kingdom of Hungary, according to Encyclopaedia Britannica, into one of the most powerful families in the kingdom. She married Ferenc Nádasdy, a soldier who rose to command Hungary’s armies against the Ottomans, and after his death in 1604 she ran the family’s estates herself.
Early in 1610 King Matthias II ordered the Palatine of Hungary, György Thurzó, to investigate rumors that girls and young women in her service had died in her household, according to the State Archive in Prešov. The Hungarian historian Gábor Várkonyi, writing in 2025, counts 327 witnesses. In his analysis 220 of them had seen or heard nothing relevant, 43 gave statements that did not support the accusation, and the remaining 64 spoke of killings they had heard about. None of the 64 was an eyewitness. The Prešov archive summarizes the testimony as claiming deaths between 1585 and 1610 in numbers ranging from 2 to 650.
On December 29, 1610, Thurzó's men seized the countess after dinner at her manor house in Čachtice, in what is now western Slovakia, and the next day took her up to the castle on the hill. Four members of her household were tried at the palatine’s court at Bytča in January 1611. They confessed under torture, and on January 7, 1611, three of them were executed, the Prešov archive records. The countess was never questioned in court, never charged and never tried. The king demanded a new trial, a death sentence and the confiscation of her property; her relatives pleaded for leniency, and he accepted confinement for life. She died at Čachtice Castle on August 21, 1614, aged 54. The Prešov archive records that she was never formally convicted.
The figure that follows her name everywhere, 650, rests on a single witness. Várkonyi identifies her as a woman named Zsuzsanna. Guinness World Records, whose record book long credited the countess with up to 650 victims, explained in 2023 that the figure came from a servant girl who said that a courtier, Jakab Szilvásy, had told her he had seen the number written in the countess’s private book. Szilvásy said nothing of the kind in his own testimony, and the book was never produced. Várkonyi lists the other figures given by the handful of witnesses behind most of the accusations, among them 300 from Boldizsár Poky, 560 from János Kadludecz and 200 from a vicar of Vágújhely, and argues that almost every substantial claim traces back to about ten people. In his reading the case was shelved because the testimony would not have survived a trial. Others read the same silence as a family’s influence at work. Either way, no court ever made a finding on any number at all.
John Bodkin Adams, a Methodist from County Antrim and a lifelong bachelor, built a prosperous general practice in Eastbourne on the south coast of England. He drove a Rolls-Royce, attended a great many wealthy widows and prescribed heroin and morphine freely, according to the magazine History Ireland. A good number of his patients remembered him in their wills.
In July 1956 a widow in his care, Gertrude Hullett, known as Bobbie, fell into a coma after he had prescribed barbiturates and died without regaining consciousness; Adams certified a cerebral hemorrhage. The Eastbourne chief constable, Richard Walker, learned that she had given the doctor a check for 1,000 pounds and left him her Rolls-Royce, and he called in Scotland Yard. Detective Superintendent Herbert Hannam traced gifts to Adams in at least 132 wills, together with forged checks and forged prescriptions, and became convinced, according to the Solicitors Journal, that Adams had killed up to 25 patients. Rumor, History Ireland reports, had the police examining no fewer than 300 suspicious deaths. The Old Police Cells Museum in Eastbourne records that the press linked him to as many as 400 and that the evidence does not support that figure.
Hannam arrested Adams at his home on December 19, 1956, for the murder of Edith Alice Morrell, a widow who had once made him the main beneficiary of her will before changing it. Time magazine gave her age as 81 and reported that she had died six years before the arrest. The trial began at the Old Bailey on March 18, 1957, before Mr. Justice Devlin and ran 17 days, the longest murder trial in British legal history at the time, the Solicitors Journal wrote. The defense, led by Geoffrey Lawrence, produced the nurses' original sickroom records and used them to show that what the nurses remembered six years later did not match what they had written at the bedside, Time reported in its 1959 review of Sybille Bedford’s book on the trial. Physicians disagreed over whether the doses were excessive and whether they caused death. Adams did not give evidence. The jury of ten men and two women acquitted him in less than an hour, Time reported in April 1957; the Eastbourne museum puts the deliberation at 44 minutes.
He then faced 15 further charges, Time reported, among them forging prescriptions, failing to keep proper records of dangerous drugs and making false statements on cremation forms. He pleaded guilty to all but one, paid a fine and was struck off the medical register. He was reinstated about four years later, returned to general practice in Eastbourne and won thirteen libel actions, History Ireland records. He died in 1983. He was never convicted of killing anyone. Hannam’s 25, the rumored 300 and the press’s 400 are suspicions of different people at different moments; a jury heard one case and rejected it.
Marie Besnard was the wife of Léon Besnard, a rope merchant in Loudun, a town of about 5,000 people in the Vienne department of western France. When Léon died on October 25, 1947, his doctors spoke of a liver complaint, and three scientists writing in L’Actualité Chimique in 2003 report the cause as uremia. Within days the town’s gossip had it otherwise. A local postmistress said Léon had confided that his wife was poisoning him, and on November 4, 1947, a neighbor wrote to the public prosecutor at Poitiers. A gendarmerie inquiry closed the matter, but the talk did not stop.
A Marseille laboratory expert, Georges Béroud, reported an abnormal amount of arsenic in Léon’s body, and on July 21, 1949, Marie Besnard was arrested at her home and charged with poisoning him. Béroud went on to report arsenic in eleven more people who had died in her family and circle between 1927 and 1949, among them her first husband, her parents and her parents-in-law, and she was charged with those deaths too. Twelve deaths in all stood against her.
The prosecution never recovered from its first trial. At Poitiers in February 1952 a defense lawyer, Albert Gautrat, handed Béroud a set of test tubes that held antimony, not arsenic, and the expert identified arsenic in some of them. The court ordered new expert reports, and she went back to prison. At the second trial, at Bordeaux in March and April 1954, the advocate general told the jury that only six of the deaths remained in question. The defense’s scientists argued that arsenic in the soil and water of the Loudun cemetery, in the zinc common in cemeteries and in the pesticides used on nearby fields could account for the readings, and the court ordered yet another review. She was released on April 12, 1954.
The third trial began at Bordeaux on November 20, 1961. The court experts' figures conflicted, Henri Griffon’s laboratory notebooks turned out to be full of crossings-out, with figures that differed from his final reports, and the toxicologists Jean-Pierre Anger and Jean-Pierre Goullé, writing in 2006, describe the official expert evidence collapsing day by day until nothing remained to the prosecution but the gossip of Loudun. The jury answered no on her guilt in each death, and in December 1961 she was acquitted. She went home to Loudun and died there in 1980.
The number twelve began as a neighbor’s list. In 2024 the historian Marc Lefrançois told the legal journal Actu-Juridique that he was personally convinced of her guilt; that is his opinion. The only finding any court made was the Bordeaux jury’s.
Belle Gunness was born Brynhild Paulsdatter Storset on November 11, 1859, in Selbu, Norway, according to Store norske leksikon, the Norwegian national encyclopedia, and emigrated to Chicago in 1881. In 1901 she bought a farm outside La Porte, Indiana. Twice widowed, she placed matrimonial notices that drew Scandinavian immigrant men to La Porte with their savings; the writer Ted Hartzell, who read her original Norwegian letters, describes them urging one South Dakota farmer to sell his property and come with cash, and to tell no one.
On April 28, 1908, her farmhouse burned. The La Porte County coroner ruled that she had died in the fire with her three children, a ruling that doctors and townspeople disputed from the start. In early May 1908 the deaths of men who had answered her notices, and of her foster daughter, Jennie Olson, came to light in La Porte, and the county’s sheriff, coroner and prosecutor came to treat the widow as the person responsible. Among the dead identified by the coroner’s inquests were Andrew Helgelien of South Dakota and Ole B. Budsberg of Iola, Wisconsin.
She was never charged and never tried. The only trial the case produced was that of her former hired man, Ray Lamphere, indicted for murdering her and her children by setting the fire. In November 1908 a La Porte jury convicted him of arson and, as Hartzell and the judge and legal columnist R. Marc Kantrowitz both describe it, acquitted him of the murders. DNA testing begun in 2007, meant to settle whether she died that night, was reported inconclusive, Indiana Public Media noted in April 2026.
The figures attached to her have grown with the telling. Hartzell, writing in American History magazine in 2008, reported that most researchers put the number of her victims at 10 to 14 and that the figure of more than 40 belongs to popular lore. The La Porte County historian Bruce Johnson told Indiana Public Media in 2026 that his own estimate is at least 21. Each is a researcher’s judgment. No court ever ruled on a single one of the deaths.
Felícitas Sánchez Aguillón was a midwife born in Veracruz, according to the Mexico City magazine Chilango. On April 9, 1941, deaths of infants came to light in the Roma district of Mexico City, and neighbors named her. She was detained days later with people the police described as her accomplices. El Universal called her the ogress; Excélsior called her the hyena woman; La Prensa gave her the nickname that lasted.
The historian Martha Santillán Esqueda of the National Autonomous University of Mexico reconstructed the case from prison archives and the press for a volume published by Mexico’s Supreme Court of Justice. On April 27, 1941, La Prensa reported that Sánchez Aguillón had been formally consigned for abortion, criminal association, technical and medical responsibility, and violation of the burial laws. The case did not survive its first test. The abortion charge could not proceed, because the body of the offense was never established. The judge of the First Criminal Court, Clemente Castellanos, held that the remaining charges lacked merit and kept only the burial-law offense. Because that offense carried no more than six months, the case passed to a justice of the peace, and she was released on bail of 600 pesos.
The press had already passed its own sentence. La Prensa, Santillán Esqueda writes, accused her of thousands of infanticides; Chilango, looking back in 2022, wrote that the coverage spoke of more than fifty. The historian states that there was not a single indication that she had killed a newborn child, and she was never charged with infanticide or with any homicide. About two months after the case broke she took her own life; Chilango dates her death June 16, 1941. Letters she left complained of her ruined name and of the lawyer who had taken part of her property for his fees.
From 1928, William Young, a chiropractor, and his wife Lila ran the Ideal Maternity Home in East Chester, a seaside village in Nova Scotia. The historian Karen Balcom, writing in the journal Acadiensis in 2002, describes it by the mid-1940s as the largest maternity home in Eastern Canada, with 80 to 125 babies in its nursery. Unmarried mothers paid 500 or 600 dollars for shelter, care, secrecy and an adoption. Adoptive parents, many of them in New York and New Jersey, paid fees or donations that, Balcom writes, ran from a few hundred dollars to perhaps 10,000, though investigators could not confirm payments beyond several hundred.
The courts saw the Youngs repeatedly. In 1935 they were convicted of fraud for trying to collect payment for the care of a child after the child had died. In 1936 they were acquitted on two charges of manslaughter arising from the deaths of a mother and her baby. Nova Scotia’s Maternity Boarding Houses Act of 1940 required a license and inspection; the Youngs were licensed for three years, then incorporated the home to place it outside the act, a loophole the legislature closed in the spring of 1945. In August 1945 the provincial director of child welfare, Fred MacKinnon, inspected the home and refused a license. In the spring of 1946 the Youngs were convicted on seven of nine charges under the act and fined 50 or 100 dollars on each conviction, plus costs. In June 1946 their lawyer announced that the home would close. A libel suit they brought against the Montreal Standard over Mavis Gallant’s exposé of that summer was dismissed in May 1947.
The death toll attached to the home comes from Bette Cahill’s book Butterbox Babies. Balcom records Cahill’s account of a long-standing local suspicion that the home’s infant deaths ran to at least 100. Balcom confirms serious sanitary and medical failings and many neglected and malnourished children, but she writes that the Youngs were never convicted of killing an infant and that documentary evidence for Cahill’s most serious allegations does not appear to exist. The CBC, reporting on adoptees still trying to trace their birth families, attributes the account of deaths to Cahill and gives no number of its own.
David Parker Ray, a former maintenance man, lived near Elephant Butte Lake outside Truth or Consequences, New Mexico. He was arrested in 1999 and was at first charged with 37 counts involving three women, the Associated Press reported. In 2001 a jury convicted him in the 1996 kidnapping of a Colorado woman. In the case of a second woman, from 1999, he pleaded guilty to kidnapping and rape, and the third case was dismissed under a plea bargain. Reuters reported that he pleaded guilty to more than 20 counts, among them kidnapping, criminal sexual penetration and conspiracy, and that State District Judge Kevin Sweazea sentenced him, at 61, to 224 years. The FBI and the AP put the sentence at more than 223 years. His daughter, who had taken part in one of the kidnappings, pleaded no contest and was released with the time she had already served, Reuters reported. Ray died in a New Mexico state prison in 2002.
He was never charged with murder. The figure attached to him comes from Ray himself. The FBI’s Albuquerque Division stated in October 2011 that he had claimed to have abducted about 40 victims from several states, and the AP reported that he boasted of being responsible for 40 victims; police, the AP added, did not know whether that figure counted only people he had killed or everyone he had harmed. That month the FBI, the New Mexico State Police and the Albuquerque police announced a fresh effort around the lake, and the FBI named Ray as a suspect in the disappearance and possible death of Jill Troia, an Albuquerque woman who disappeared in 1995. "We just don’t know if there are any there," an FBI spokesman, Frank Fisher, told the AP. "But we do believe there are victims somewhere." No murder charge followed. What a court established is the kidnapping and the crimes against the women who testified; the rest is Ray’s boast and the suspicion of the investigators who heard it.
Cécile Bombeke, spelled Bombeek in Time magazine’s 1978 report, was born in 1933 in Wichelen, in Flanders, into a Catholic farming family, according to the Flemish journalist Tom De Smet. She joined the Apostolic Congregation of St. Joseph in Wetteren, took the name Sister Godfrieda, and in 1967 became head nurse of the 38-bed geriatric ward of a public home in the town. By the mid-1970s, De Smet writes, she was dependent on morphine and forging prescriptions.
In 1977 the ward recorded 21 deaths, against an average of 13 a year, De Smet writes, and nurses kept a private diary of deaths and incidents in which, Time reported, one name kept recurring. Her superiors dismissed their concerns, and she was sent away for a drug cure that failed. When she returned in January 1978, three staff members went to a young general practitioner, Dr. Jean-Paul De Corte. She was arrested on February 10, 1978, at first on charges tied to forged prescriptions. In custody she confessed to killing three elderly residents, Leon Matthys, 81, Irma De Backer, 79, and Maria Vanderginst, 87, and was charged with three murders. She told investigators the three had been "too difficult at night," words both Time and De Smet report. She later denied killing anyone deliberately and said she had only calmed them.
The larger figures came from those around the case. De Corte told reporters in 1978 that the toll "could just as well be 30 people as three," Time reported. The investigating judge, Leo Tas, listed 17 people whose deaths she may have caused, according to De Smet, writing in The Brussels Times in 2023, and VRT NWS, the Flemish public broadcaster, reported the same number from the judge’s file. None of those deaths led to a charge. In 1980 experts ruled her insane, and instead of a trial she was interned in a psychiatric institution at Melle. She was released in 1990, returned to her convent and died in 2019, aged 86. Not even the three deaths she confessed to were ever tested before a judge.
Set beside one another, the eight figures share a single feature: each was produced outside a courtroom, by someone under no obligation to be right. Báthory’s 650 is a servant’s account of what a courtier said he had seen in a book no one ever produced. Adams’s 25 was a detective’s conviction, and the higher figures were rumor and newsprint. Besnard’s twelve began as a neighbor’s list and was reduced by the prosecution itself. The Gunness totals are researchers' estimates. Sánchez Aguillón’s thousands were a tabloid’s. The Youngs' hundred is a local suspicion that a historian could not match to a document. Ray’s 40 was his own boast. Sister Godfrieda’s 17 and 30 are a judge’s working list and a doctor’s warning.
None of this says that nothing happened. Ray’s convictions are real and serious. Three of Báthory’s servants went to their deaths on their own confessions, however they were obtained. Sister Godfrieda confessed. The Youngs ran a home that, by a historian’s account drawn from provincial records, left many children neglected and malnourished. But the endings are of a particular kind: two acquittals, a finding of insanity, a coroner’s ruling, a charge reduced to a burial offense, a licensing conviction, a sentence for other crimes, and a confinement ordered without a trial. A verdict on a number is not among them.
• Early 1610: King Matthias II orders Palatine György Thurzó to investigate Elizabeth Báthory’s household.
• December 29, 1610: Báthory is seized at Čachtice.
• January 7, 1611: three of her servants are executed at Bytča after trial.
• August 21, 1614: Báthory dies in confinement at Čachtice Castle.
• April 28, 1908: Belle Gunness’s farmhouse outside La Porte, Indiana, burns; the coroner later rules her dead.
• May 1908: the deaths of men who answered her notices come to light in La Porte.
• November 1908: Ray Lamphere is convicted of arson only.
• 1928: William and Lila Young are operating the Ideal Maternity Home in East Chester, Nova Scotia.
• 1935: the Youngs are convicted of fraud.
• 1936: the Youngs are acquitted on two counts of manslaughter.
• April 9, 1941: infant deaths come to light in the Roma district of Mexico City; Felícitas Sánchez Aguillón is named.
• April 27, 1941: La Prensa reports her consignment on four charges; she is later held only on the burial-law charge and bailed.
• June 1941: Sánchez Aguillón takes her own life.
• Spring 1946: the Youngs are convicted on seven of nine counts under the Maternity Boarding Houses Act; the home closes that June.
• October 25, 1947: Léon Besnard dies in Loudun.
• July 21, 1949: Marie Besnard is arrested and charged with poisoning him.
• February 1952: Besnard’s first trial, at Poitiers, ends without a verdict.
• March to April 1954: second Besnard trial at Bordeaux; she is released on April 12, 1954.
• December 19, 1956: John Bodkin Adams is arrested in Eastbourne.
• March 18, 1957: Adams’s trial begins at the Old Bailey.
• April 1957: Adams is acquitted of murder.
• December 1961: Besnard is acquitted at Bordeaux.
• 1977: 21 deaths are recorded on the Wetteren geriatric ward.
• February 10, 1978: Sister Godfrieda is arrested; she confesses and is charged with three murders.
• 1980: experts rule her insane; she is interned at Melle. Marie Besnard dies in Loudun.
• 1983: Adams dies.
• 1999: David Parker Ray is arrested in New Mexico.
• 2001: Ray is convicted at trial and pleads guilty in a second case.
• 2002: Ray dies in prison.
• October 2011: the FBI states that Ray claimed about 40 victims.
• 2019: Sister Godfrieda dies, aged 86.