Duško Tadić

Victims
7 men killed in Prijedor, Bosnia, 1992; tribunal convictions. Two in Kozarac (1997 verdict) and five in Jaskići (on appeal, 1999); also cruel treatment and inhumane acts against detainees.
Years active
May to August 1992, opština Prijedor, Bosnia and Herzegovina
Location
Kozarac, Omarska, Keraterm, Trnopolje and Jaskići, opština Prijedor, Bosnia and Herzegovina
Method
Persecutions, murder and inhumane acts as crimes against humanity; murder and cruel treatment as war crimes; willful killing and other grave breaches
Status
20 years on May 7, 1997 verdict; nine more counts on appeal July 15, 1999 (25 years); cut to 20 years January 26, 2000; served in Germany; released July 17, 2008

Duško Tadić was a café owner from Kozarac, a largely Muslim town in the Prijedor district of northwestern Bosnia, who became the first person brought to trial by the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia. In the spring and summer of 1992, after Bosnian Serb forces seized power in Prijedor, he took part in driving the non-Serb population out of Kozarac and in the cruel treatment of men held at the Omarska camp. A Trial Chamber in The Hague found him guilty in May 1997 of persecutions and of crimes against humanity and war crimes involving inhumane acts and cruel treatment, among them the killing of two Muslim men in Kozarac. Two years later the Appeals Chamber went further, reversing his acquittal on nine more counts, including the murder of five men in the village of Jaskići.

His case reached far beyond its own facts. It was the tribunal's first trial and the first conviction by an international war crimes court since the Second World War, and it forced the judges to decide whether the tribunal had the power to try anyone at all, when the Bosnian war counted as an international conflict, and how far a man who joins a group that kills answers for its killings. Tadić himself held no major leadership role. The Appeals Chamber, cutting his final sentence to 20 years, held that his place in the command structure had been low. He served his sentence in Germany and was granted early release in July 2008.

Kozarac before the war

Tadić was born on October 1, 1955, and grew up in Kozarac. Before the war about nine in ten of the town's inhabitants were Muslims. Toward the end of 1990 or early in 1991 he opened a café in the center of Kozarac, which at first drew Muslims and Serbs alike.

The Trial Chamber found that despite those friendships he supported the cause of a Greater Serbia, although he denied being a nationalist. He joined the Serb Democratic Party, the SDS, in 1990. Witnesses told the court that his café gradually became a gathering place for Serb nationalists from outside the area, and that some Muslim customers stopped going. In November 1991 the SDS leadership asked him to help organize the party's plebiscite in the Kozarac area, a task the court found would have gone only to a loyal and committed member in a district where Serbs were a minority.

The takeover of Prijedor

On April 30, 1992, the SDS took control of the town of Prijedor without bloodshed, with the help of military and police forces. Serb soldiers occupied the main institutions, declared that they had taken power and renamed the district the Serb Municipality of Prijedor. Before Kozarac itself was taken, a group of its citizens tried to negotiate with the Prijedor authorities to avert the same fate, and Tadić was asked to join them because they needed a Serb voice.

The negotiations failed. On May 24, 1992, Bosnian Serb forces began a military operation against Kozarac and the surrounding area. Once the town was captured, they rounded up its non-Serb population and drove them out on foot. The Trial Chamber found that Tadić participated in that operation and in the collection and forced transfer of civilians to detention camps. Thousands of Muslim and Croat civilians from across the district were confined in camps at Omarska, Keraterm and Trnopolje, which the court found to have been part of a plan to expel non-Serbs from the Prijedor municipality.

The court found that during the capture of the town Tadić killed two Muslim men, Osman and Edin Bešić, in Kozarac. The tribunal dated the killings to May 26, 1992. That finding rested on the evidence of a single witness, a man who had known Tadić since childhood, and it became the most contested element of the case. The defense argued on appeal that the Trial Chamber should not have convicted on uncorroborated testimony. The Appeals Chamber rejected that ground, holding that the trial judges had not erred in being satisfied beyond reasonable doubt. The two deaths were not charged as separate murder counts. They formed part of Count 1, persecutions on political, racial or religious grounds, the count that carried his longest sentence.

Omarska

Through the summer of 1992 the Omarska camp held large numbers of non-Serb men from the district. The court found that prisoners there were denied drinking water for long periods, crowded into rooms in the summer heat and forced into acts of humiliation. Tadić held no post at the camp. The prosecution's case was that he visited the camps freely and took part in the mistreatment of prisoners.

The Trial Chamber accepted much of that case and rejected some of it. It found him guilty of cruel treatment and inhumane acts against six Muslim prisoners in the camp's hangar building, holding that in some instances he was himself the perpetrator and in others he aided and abetted a group of Serbs who acted together. It found him guilty of the same offenses against a prisoner mistreated by a group of Serbs, on the basis that he had intentionally assisted the group's common purpose. It convicted him of cruel treatment and inhumane acts against two further Muslim prisoners at Omarska, and against one more man held in the camp in July 1992.

On other Omarska charges the evidence failed. The court acquitted him of murder on Counts 6 and 7 because the elements of those offenses had not been proved, and of a further pair of counts for lack of evidence linking him to the acts alleged. On Counts 25 and 26 it held that the murders alleged had not been proved, and that taking part in calling people out was not by itself an inhumane act.

Jaskići

On June 14, 1992, Serb forces entered the neighboring villages of Sivci and Jaskići. Men from Sivci were taken to the Keraterm camp, and Tadić took part in their removal. In Jaskići the Trial Chamber found that he was a member of the armed group that separated the men of the village from the women and children and took them away, that he took an active part in rounding them up, and that he mistreated four of them. He was the only member of the group the villagers knew, which suggested to the court that he alone came from the locality.

After the group left, five men of the village had been killed. The Trial Chamber was satisfied that the killings had taken place, but it was not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that Tadić had any part in them. Nobody had been killed in Sivci that day, and the judges reasoned that the bare possibility that another group of soldiers had done it was enough to raise a doubt. It found him guilty of cruel treatment and inhumane acts toward the four men he had mistreated, and not guilty of the five deaths.

Office in Kozarac

After the non-Serb population had been expelled, Tadić rose in local politics. On August 15, 1992, he was elected President of the Local Board of the SDS in Kozarac and appointed acting secretary of the Local Commune, and he was later elected secretary outright. He represented the commune in the Prijedor Municipal Assembly, which gave him charge of resettling the town. From June 16, 1992, he also served as a reserve traffic police officer at a checkpoint at Orlovci, and later in Prijedor and Kozarac, until November 19, 1992.

He fell out with the Prijedor authorities over the state of the town center, and the rift cost him the lodging in Prijedor that the authorities had given him. Between March and June 1993 the military tried several times to conscript him. In June 1993 he was posted to the front near Gradačac and left the next day, and he spent the following weeks avoiding further mobilization. In August 1993 he resigned his offices and left for Germany, settling in Munich.

Arrest in Munich

Refugees from Kozarac recognized him in Munich in late 1993 and passed what they knew to German activists who were gathering evidence of war crimes in Bosnia. On February 12, 1994, German police arrested him on suspicion of offenses at the Omarska camp in June 1992, including torture and aiding and abetting genocide, which were crimes under German law.

The new tribunal moved to take the case. On October 12, 1994, its prosecutor applied for a formal request to Germany to defer its proceedings to the tribunal's competence. Trial Chamber I heard the application on November 8, 1994, with lawyers for Germany and for Tadić appearing as friends of the court. It found that the German and tribunal investigations concerned the same crimes, and that justice would not be served if some alleged co-offenders were judged in national courts and others in The Hague. The formal request for deferral was issued the same day.

Indictment and transfer

The indictment against Tadić and a co-accused was confirmed on February 13, 1995, charging the two men with 132 counts in all, including grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions, violations of the laws or customs of war and crimes against humanity. It was amended on September 1, 1995, when new charges were added and the counts were reorganized, and again on December 14, 1995. The co-accused was never tried. The indictment against him was withdrawn in April 2005 after documents showed he had been declared officially dead.

Germany passed the legislation needed to surrender him, and on April 24, 1995, Tadić was transferred to the tribunal. At his initial appearance two days later he pleaded not guilty to every count. The proceedings were broadcast live, a practice the tribunal kept for all its public sessions. His lead counsel was a Dutch lawyer assigned by the Registrar because Tadić could not pay.

The challenge to the tribunal itself

Before any evidence was heard, the defense challenged the tribunal's right to exist. It argued that the Security Council had no power to create a criminal court, that the tribunal's primacy over national courts was unlawful, and that the crimes charged lay outside its jurisdiction. On August 10, 1995, Trial Chamber II dismissed the challenges to primacy and subject-matter jurisdiction and held that the legality of the tribunal's creation was not a question it could review.

The defense appealed. On October 2, 1995, the Appeals Chamber unanimously upheld the tribunal's primacy and, with one judge dissenting, held that it had jurisdiction over the crimes charged. On the creation of the tribunal it took a different course from the trial judges: by a majority, it held that the tribunal could rule on the lawfulness of its own establishment, and then dismissed the challenge on the merits. The same summer the Trial Chamber also ruled on protective measures, granting confidentiality to six prosecution witnesses and, by a majority, anonymity from the accused to four of them.

The trial

The trial opened on May 7, 1996, before Trial Chamber II, a bench of three judges. It ran for 79 trial days. The prosecution called 86 witnesses and the defense 40; the prosecution tendered 362 exhibits and the defense 103. Counts 2 to 4 were withdrawn at the prosecution's request, leaving 31 counts for decision.

The prosecution's evidence came almost entirely from people who had lived in and around Kozarac or had been held in the camps. Many described seeing Tadić at the camps in uniform; fewer said they had seen him commit specific acts. The defense case was that he had been mistaken for someone else and was being made a scapegoat for crimes committed by others. Tadić testified that he had been elsewhere, and raised an alibi resting partly on his checkpoint duties and partly on time in Banja Luka. Defense witnesses from Kozarac said they had not seen him there. The Trial Chamber held that the checkpoint duty did not establish his presence elsewhere, and that witnesses who had not seen him could not outweigh those who had.

Closing arguments were heard from November 25 to 28, 1996.

Verdict

On May 7, 1997, Trial Chamber II delivered a 301-page Opinion and Judgment. It found Tadić guilty on 11 counts and not guilty on 20. He was convicted, on the basis of individual criminal responsibility, of persecutions on political, racial or religious grounds and of inhumane acts, both crimes against humanity, and of cruel treatment as a violation of the laws or customs of war. On two of those counts he was found guilty in respect of four of the men named and not guilty in respect of four others.

Eleven of the acquittals turned on a single legal question. The tribunal's Statute covered grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions, which apply only in an international armed conflict and only to protected persons. The majority found that the conflict in parts of Bosnia was international until May 19, 1992, when the Yugoslav army formally withdrew, but held that after that date the Bosnian Serb army could not be treated as an organ or agent of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia. Applying a test of effective control, the majority held that the victims had not been shown to be protected persons, and acquitted Tadić on every grave-breach count. The presiding judge dissented. In her view the Bosnian Serb army had acted throughout as an agent of Belgrade, the victims were protected persons, and the grave-breach provisions applied.

Sentence

A pre-sentencing hearing ran from June 30 to July 4, 1997. The prosecution asked for life imprisonment, and the defense for no more than 15 years. On July 14, 1997, the Trial Chamber imposed a separate sentence on each count, all to run concurrently. The longest was 20 years for persecutions, the count that included the killing of the two men in Kozarac. The others ranged from six to ten years. Tadić said he had nothing to say before sentence was passed.

The Chamber treated as aggravating his awareness of conditions in the camps, his support for the campaign against the non-Serb population and his lack of cooperation with the prosecution. In mitigation it weighed his personal circumstances and his lack of previous convictions, and found that he had held no major leadership role. It recommended that, unless exceptional circumstances applied, the sentence not be reduced below ten years. He was credited with the two years, eight months and six days already served.

The appeal

Both sides appealed. Tadić's new defense team asked for leave to call more than 80 further witnesses and submit fresh documents. After almost a year of filings, the Appeals Chamber dismissed that motion on October 15, 1998, holding that additional evidence should not be admitted lightly at the appellate stage and required a reasonable explanation for why it had not been available at trial. The appeals were argued from April 19 to 21, 1999.

On July 15, 1999, the five-judge Appeals Chamber unanimously rejected every ground of Tadić's appeal. It held that he had not shown any failure by the Trial Chamber to extend him the protection of equality of arms, the principle that each side must have a fair chance to present its case, and it upheld the conviction for the two killings in Kozarac.

The prosecution fared differently. On its first ground, the Appeals Chamber rejected the effective control test as the measure for organized armed forces. What international law required, it held, was overall control: more than financing and equipping a force, extending to participation in planning and supervising its operations, but not necessarily specific orders for each action. On the evidence, the armed forces of Republika Srpska had acted in 1992 under the overall control of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, so the conflict remained international after May 19, 1992, and the victims were protected persons. It found Tadić guilty of grave breaches on Counts 8, 9, 12, 15, 21 and 32.

On the second ground, the judges held that the Trial Chamber had misapplied the standard of proof in Jaskići. No witness had suggested that any other group was responsible; on the facts found, the only reasonable conclusion was that the group Tadić belonged to had killed the five men. Under the doctrine of common purpose, a participant in a shared criminal plan could be liable for crimes outside the plan that were a foreseeable consequence of it. The common aim in Prijedor had been to rid the region of its non-Serb population by inhumane acts; killings frequently accompanied that effort; and Tadić, the court held, was aware of the risk and willingly took it. It found him guilty of willful killing as a grave breach (Count 29), murder as a violation of the laws or customs of war (Count 30) and murder as a crime against humanity (Count 31).

The judgment also settled three further points. An act committed for purely personal motives could still be a crime against humanity. Discriminatory intent was a necessary element only of persecution, not of every crime against humanity. And a Trial Chamber could order disclosure of a defense witness's prior statement after the witness's evidence-in-chief.

Resentencing and the final term

Sentencing on the nine new counts went to a Trial Chamber assigned by the President, which held a hearing on October 15, 1999. On November 11, 1999, it imposed nine concurrent sentences, ranging from six years for the lesser grave breaches to 24 years for willful killing and for murder as a war crime and 25 years for murder as a crime against humanity. The effective term rose to 25 years. The Chamber credited him with five years and three days in custody since November 8, 1994, and counted his conduct in detention in his favor.

Tadić appealed again, and the Appeals Chamber joined both sentencing appeals and heard argument on January 14, 2000. On January 26, 2000, it reduced the final sentence to a maximum of 20 years. A majority held that there was in law no distinction in seriousness between a crime against humanity and a war crime, and that a sentence of more than 20 years on any count was excessive given Tadić's low rank compared with his superiors and with the architects of the policy he served. One judge dissented on the question of relative gravity. The chamber fixed the minimum term at ten years from July 14, 1997, so that it could not end before July 14, 2007, and granted credit for the whole of his detention in Germany. That judgment ended the tribunal's first and longest case.

The former lead counsel and the request for review

A separate thread ran alongside the appeal. The Appeals Chamber opened contempt proceedings against the Yugoslav lawyer who had led Tadić's defense at trial. On January 31, 2000, it found him in contempt for manipulating witnesses and evidence between September 1997 and April 1998, and fined him 15,000 Dutch guilders, the maximum then available. His appeal was dismissed on February 27, 2001, and the Registrar later struck him from the list of assigned counsel.

On June 18, 2001, Tadić relied on those findings to ask for a review of his entire case. He argued that the counsel's misconduct amounted to new facts that could have changed the verdicts, above all on the two killings in Kozarac. On July 30, 2002, the Appeals Chamber dismissed the motion. It held that some of the findings were new facts but that none could have been decisive, that others had been known to Tadić at the time, and that he had been on notice of the risks when he took the same lawyer back in 1997. It also held that a later development in the case law was not a new fact within the meaning of the review rule.

Germany and release

Tadić was transferred to Germany on October 31, 2000, to serve the rest of his sentence, with credit for time in custody from February 1994.

He reached two-thirds of his sentence in June 2007. On July 17, 2008, the tribunal's President granted him early release. The decision noted that he had no disciplinary record in custody, and that Serbia, whose citizenship he had obtained in March 2006, was willing to receive him.

Context: the law under which he was tried

The indictment drew on three articles of the tribunal's Statute, and the fate of each count depended on which one it invoked. The first covered grave breaches of the four Geneva Conventions of 1949, such as willful killing and willfully causing great suffering or serious injury to body or health. Those offenses exist only in an international armed conflict and only against persons the Conventions protect, which is why eleven counts fell at trial and seven of them became convictions on appeal once the Appeals Chamber found the conflict international. The second covered violations of the laws or customs of war. The cruel treatment counts came from it, by way of the article common to all four Conventions, which forbids violence to the life and person of anyone taking no active part in hostilities; the Trial Chamber noted that no international instrument defines cruel treatment and treated it as a general concept. The third covered crimes against humanity, including murder, persecution and other inhumane acts, which must be committed in an armed conflict as part of a widespread or systematic attack on a civilian population.

Every count charged him with individual criminal responsibility, which reaches a person who commits a crime and one who aids and abets it. That provision carried the Trial Chamber's convictions for the camp counts on which no witness had seen Tadić act with his own hands, and it was the provision the Appeals Chamber read as including liability for the foreseeable crimes of a common purpose.

The route by which he reached The Hague came from the tribunal's Rules of Procedure and Evidence. Two of its rules let the prosecutor ask a state to defer to the tribunal where national proceedings concern the same matters or raise questions significant for the tribunal's own work, and they were the basis on which Germany handed over a man it had already arrested and begun to investigate. The appeal rules shaped the later stages. One rule governed the request to call new witnesses on appeal, and another allows review only where a new fact is discovered that was unknown at the time and could not have been found with due diligence.

Disputed and unproven points

Tadić denied every charge from his arrest onward. He maintained that he had been mistaken for another man and singled out as a scapegoat, and that his checkpoint duties and time in Banja Luka placed him elsewhere. Every tribunal that heard that defense rejected it on the counts on which he was convicted.

The conviction for the deaths of the two men in Kozarac rested on one witness. It survived the appeal of 1999 and the review motion of 2002, which found that none of the material about the former counsel's conduct could have changed it.

The five deaths in Jaskići were never attributed to Tadić personally. The trial judges found no proof of who had done the killing and acquitted him; the Appeals Chamber convicted him because the group he belonged to had done it and the deaths were a foreseeable result of the common purpose he shared. The murder counts on which he was acquitted at trial, Counts 6, 7, 25 and 26, were not reopened on appeal.

Timeline

October 1, 1955: Duško Tadić is born; he grows up in Kozarac.

1990: He joins the Serb Democratic Party; late 1990 or early 1991, he opens a café in Kozarac.

April 30, 1992: The SDS takes control of Prijedor.

May 24, 1992: Bosnian Serb forces begin the operation against Kozarac.

May 26, 1992: Two Muslim men are killed in Kozarac; the Trial Chamber later finds Tadić responsible.

June 14, 1992: Armed Serbs enter Sivci and Jaskići; five men are killed in Jaskići.

June 16 to November 19, 1992: Tadić works as a reserve police officer.

August 15, 1992: He becomes President of the Local Board of the SDS in Kozarac.

August 1993: He resigns his offices and leaves for Germany.

February 12, 1994: German police arrest him in Munich.

November 8, 1994: Trial Chamber I issues a formal request to Germany to defer to the tribunal.

February 13, 1995: The indictment is confirmed.

April 24, 1995: He is transferred to The Hague; on April 26 he pleads not guilty.

October 2, 1995: The Appeals Chamber rules on the challenge to the tribunal's jurisdiction.

May 7, 1996: The trial opens before Trial Chamber II.

May 7, 1997: He is found guilty on 11 counts and not guilty on 20.

July 14, 1997: He is sentenced to concurrent terms, the longest 20 years.

July 15, 1999: The Appeals Chamber dismisses his appeal and finds him guilty on nine more counts.

November 11, 1999: He is sentenced on the new counts; the effective term rises to 25 years.

January 26, 2000: The Appeals Chamber reduces the final sentence to 20 years.

January 31, 2000: His former lead counsel is found in contempt of the tribunal.

October 31, 2000: He is transferred to Germany to serve his sentence.

July 30, 2002: The Appeals Chamber dismisses his request for review.

July 17, 2008: He is granted early release.