Duško Sikirica

Victims
1 detainee murdered, admitted in his plea agreement. Convicted of persecutions on political, racial or religious grounds (crime against humanity), Keraterm camp, Prijedor, 1992.
Years active
1992 (the admitted killing fell between June 14 and July 27, 1992).
Location
Prijedor, Bosnia and Herzegovina (killing, at the Keraterm camp); Čirkin Polje, Prijedor municipality, Bosnia and Herzegovina (birth); The Hague, Netherlands (trial); Austria (prison)
Method
Shot one detainee (his own admission in the plea agreement, accepted by the Trial Chamber).
Status
Sentenced to 15 years, November 13, 2001; no appeal. Served in Austria from May 10, 2002. Early release granted June 21, 2010; released July 20, 2010; not on record after July 2010.

In the summer of 1992 a disused ceramics factory on the eastern edge of Prijedor, in northwestern Bosnia and Herzegovina, held between one thousand and fourteen hundred men at a time. They were Bosnian Muslims, Bosnian Croats and other non-Serbs from the surrounding municipality, and the place was called the Keraterm camp. From about June 14 until about July 27, 1992, the man the guards and prisoners answered to there each day was Duško Sikirica, a reserve policeman from a village on Prijedor's outskirts, who held the title Commander of Security.

Nine years later, at the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia in The Hague, Sikirica stood trial on nine counts that began with genocide. The genocide counts did not survive the close of the Prosecution case. On September 19, 2001, after he had spent his defense case arguing that he had not been at the camp at all, he pleaded guilty to a single count: persecutions on political, racial or religious grounds, a crime against humanity. As part of that plea he admitted that he had personally killed one of the detainees, inside the camp, in front of prisoners and guards. On November 13, 2001, Trial Chamber III sentenced him to 15 years' imprisonment. He served most of that term in Austria and was granted early release in June 2010.

The indictment against Sikirica alleged that in the early hours of April 30, 1992, Serb forces took physical control of the town of Prijedor. Restrictions followed on movement and on the right to work for Bosnian Muslims, Bosnian Croats and other non-Serbs, and from late May the villages and neighborhoods where they lived were attacked by military, paramilitary and police forces. Those who were seized were taken to camps set up under the direction of the municipal Crisis Staff. The indictment named three, Omarska, Trnopolje and Keraterm, and alleged that more than 7,000 people were held in them between May 24 and August 30, 1992. At Keraterm most of the prisoners were men of military age.

The camp at the ceramics factory

Keraterm was not built to hold anyone. It was a large factory building enclosed by ordinary industrial fencing, and the first prisoners arrived on May 31, 1992, to find it empty. Within weeks it was overcrowded. Most witnesses who had been held there put the number of detainees at between 1,000 and 1,400, with an average of about 1,200, and in the smaller rooms men took turns standing because there was not space for everyone to sit.

Prisoners slept on bare concrete for their first month. Most of the lavatories did not work, there was no washing water, clothes went unchanged for weeks, and lice spread through the camp. Food came once a day, hot water with a cabbage leaf or a scrap of potato and two thin slices of bread, and witnesses told the Chamber that the detainees lost an average of 20 kilograms each. Drinking water arrived when it arrived at all, and medical care was, for most of the camp's life, not available.

Investigators from the civilian police, the state security service and the military came in from outside to interrogate the prisoners. The camp guards escorted men to and from those sessions and took no part in them. The evidence suggested, in the Chamber's words, that the interrogations sorted the prisoners into categories, and that a prisoner's category could decide whether he was singled out for mistreatment or sent on to Omarska.

Mistreatment began within a week of the camp's opening and went on daily. Guards took part, and so did armed men from outside who came mostly at night and, in the Chamber's description, did as they pleased. The Chamber recorded detainees who were extorted for money, detainees punished to settle prewar scores, and an atmosphere of terror in which prisoners lived in constant fear of being called out. A small number of women were raped at Keraterm.

The camp held men whose names the court record preserves. Among the detainees who died there that summer, the Prosecution's sentencing brief listed Emsud Bahonjić, Besim Hergić, Dževad Karabegović, Džemal Mešić, Safet Mešić, Jovo Radočaj, Dragan Tokmadžić and Fikret Avdić. Sikirica was not charged with personally causing any of those deaths, and the agreed facts tie none of them to him.

On the night of July 24, 1992, more than one hundred men held in Room 3 were killed by armed men who were not the regular Keraterm guards. The record on Sikirica's part in those events is specific. The Prosecution acknowledged in his plea agreement that there was no evidence that he was present at Keraterm during the build-up to the killings, that he knew they were about to take place, that he was present while they happened, or that he took part in them in any way. What he did admit was narrower: as Commander of Security he had a technical duty to prevent outsiders from entering the camp, and the men who carried out those killings came from outside.

The Commander of Security

Sikirica was born on March 23, 1964, in Čirkin Polje, in the Prijedor municipality. In 1992 he was a member of the reserve police, and his title at Keraterm, by his own admission, was Commander of Security. The indictment had called him the commander of the camp and alleged that he held superior authority over everyone in it. The Trial Chamber, sentencing him on the facts both sides had agreed, drew a smaller picture.

He arrived at Keraterm on or about, but not before, June 14, 1992, and his duties there ended on or about July 27. He held no rank. Among the reserve policemen who guarded the camp he was, in the Chamber's phrase, "first among equals," set above them by the duties his superior at the Prijedor II police station had given him. The effective administration of the camp was conducted from that police station under the general authority of the municipal Crisis Staff. Sikirica could report incidents and people up that chain, but he had no power of his own to punish anyone below him. He was not responsible for food, clothing, water, medical care or accommodation, though he had some discretion, for instance to let a friend or relative pass extra food to a detainee.

Detainees described a man who was at the camp every day, wore a military uniform and wrote down the names of new prisoners as they arrived. He received civilian visitors and walked them around the camp, and when prisoners needed something that mattered, they went to him rather than to the shift leaders. There was documentary evidence too: an "Official Note" dated July 4, 1992, compiled by Sikirica as "Commander of Keraterm Security." One former detainee testified that Sikirica let him keep a bag of food his family had brought, and another that Sikirica escorted a group of prisoners to the hospital in Prijedor on August 4.

Witnesses also placed him nearby while new arrivals were mistreated, though they said he did not himself lay hands on anyone. On the rapes, the Prosecution conceded that there was no evidence that he knew of them or was in a position to learn of them afterward.

The killing he admitted

Only one killing was proven against Sikirica personally. The victim was a young detainee, and he died at Sikirica's hand inside the camp. Three prisoners testified to the incident, one of them having seen Sikirica talking with the young man shortly before. The plea agreement recorded the death as murder, and Sikirica accepted it.

There was no evidence that the detainee had provoked him in any way, and the killing took place in full view of both prisoners and guards. The Trial Chamber found that it must have left the impression that such conduct was encouraged, or at least would go unpunished, and that it fed the atmosphere of terror in the camp. Sikirica's position of authority, the Chamber held, aggravated the murder.

From indictment to arrest

On July 21, 1995, three years after Keraterm closed, the Tribunal confirmed an indictment against Sikirica and twelve others, and warrants for their arrest were issued the same day. Sikirica was named as commander of the camp, and Damir Došen and Dragan Kolundžija as shift commanders. An amended indictment of August 24, 1999, charged Sikirica with genocide and complicity to commit genocide, with persecutions, inhumane acts and outrages upon personal dignity, and with murder, alleging both his own conduct and his responsibility as a superior for the acts of his subordinates. Kolundžija and Došen had been detained by SFOR in 1999. Sikirica remained at large for another eight months.

On June 25, 2000, SFOR, the NATO-led peacekeeping force in Bosnia and Herzegovina, detained Sikirica and transferred him to the Tribunal the same day. On July 7, 2000, he pleaded not guilty to all charges. A second amended indictment of January 3, 2001, kept the genocide and complicity counts against him and charged persecutions on political, racial or religious grounds as Count 3, alongside inhumane acts, outrages upon personal dignity, murder and cruel treatment.

The trial

The joint trial of the three men opened before Trial Chamber III on March 19, 2001. The Prosecution called 34 witnesses, most of them men who had been held at Keraterm. Sikirica's defense was alibi: he said he had not been there. Identification was therefore central, and the defense tested the former prisoners closely on the camp and on what they could have seen.

At the close of the Prosecution case all three accused asked the Chamber to acquit them under Rule 98 bis. On June 27, 2001, the Chamber granted Sikirica's motion on genocide and complicity to commit genocide and dismissed those two counts. Its written reasons followed on September 3. On the numbers before it, the 1,000 to 1,400 men held at Keraterm were about 2 to 2.8 percent of Prijedor's Muslim population, which the Chamber said "would hardly qualify as a 'reasonably substantial' part" of the group. It found little evidence that the detainees were leaders of their communities. The atrocities at the camp were widespread, it accepted, but they were "not sufficient to satisfy the specific intent required for the crime of genocide." With the genocide counts gone, Sikirica's defense presented its case from June 27 to July 5, 2001.

The plea

Kolundžija moved first, pleading guilty to Count 3 on September 4, 2001. On September 7 the Prosecution filed plea agreements for Sikirica and Došen. Each would plead guilty to Count 3, persecution, and if the Chamber accepted the pleas the Prosecution would withdraw every other count.

The agreement filed for Sikirica recorded, as the factual basis for the plea, that the persecution count encompassed the evidence led about Keraterm on five means set out in the indictment: the murder of Bosnian Muslims, Bosnian Croats and other non-Serbs, including those held at Keraterm; their torture and beating; their sexual assault and rape; their harassment, humiliation and psychological abuse; and their confinement in inhumane conditions in the camp. It recorded his title, the limits of his authority, the murder he committed, the absence of any evidence tying him to Room 3 or to the rapes, and his technical duty to keep outsiders out. The Prosecution would recommend a sentence of not less than 10 and not more than 17 years, and neither side would appeal a sentence inside that range.

On September 19, 2001, Sikirica and Došen each entered a plea of guilty to Count 3. Satisfied that the pleas were voluntary, informed, unequivocal and supported by a sufficient factual basis, the Chamber accepted them and entered findings of guilt that day. The remaining counts against Sikirica were withdrawn.

The sentencing hearing

At the sentencing hearing on October 8 and 9, 2001, the Prosecution asked for 17 years and the defense for 10. Sikirica had no previous convictions, and he was married with two children.

Then Sikirica spoke. He described a prewar Prijedor in which people "lived together in good neighbourly relations," and said that when war came, "we had to go where we were told to go." He told the judges: "I deeply regret everything that happened in Keraterm while I was there. I feel only regret for all the lives that have been lost and the lives that were damaged in Prijedor, in Keraterm, and unfortunately, I contributed to the destruction of these lives." He said he was sorry that he had not had "enough moral courage and power to prevent some or all of the terrible things that happened," and that he understood he had to be punished.

The sentence

The Chamber delivered its judgement on November 13, 2001. Sikirica's crime, it found, stood apart from his co-accused's in its breadth and, above all, in his personal involvement: "He alone has been convicted for committing a murder in the camp." His failure to keep outsiders from entering the camp to mistreat detainees aggravated the crime, and his position aggravated the murder.

In mitigation the Chamber gave him some credit for the plea, though less than he would have earned before trial. It found his remorse sincere and took that into account as well, and it found his cooperation with the Prosecution not substantial enough to affect the result. Had he not pleaded guilty, even late, the Chamber said, "he would have received a much longer sentence."

The sentence was 15 years' imprisonment, with credit for 1 year, 4 months and 19 days already spent in custody. Došen received 5 years and Kolundžija 3, the Chamber finding that neither had been directly involved in the crimes underlying his conviction. Sikirica did not appeal. On February 1, 2002, the Tribunal designated Austria as the state where he would serve his sentence, and on May 10, 2002, he was transferred there from The Hague.

Austria and early release

In Austria he worked in a prison handicraft department until March 2003 and afterward in the prison laundry, where his work was rated "very good." Between March 2005 and February 2009 the prison recorded three administrative infractions and the Austrian Embassy four, all for possession of unauthorized objects, and they brought small fines and reprimands. The prison management otherwise described his behavior as very good and "firmly supports" his release.

Under Austrian law he became eligible for conditional release on June 25, 2010, after serving two-thirds of his sentence, and the prison's director applied for it in February 2010. The decision belonged to the Tribunal's President, Judge Patrick Robinson, who had presided at his trial. The gravity of the crimes was high and counted against release. On rehabilitation, he agreed with the Trial Chamber that the remorse had been sincere, and he counted the plea, the remorse and the work record together as some evidence of rehabilitation. The Prosecution reported no cooperation from Sikirica that could be taken into account. A psychological report found him apparently free of psychological stress, though a language barrier made a recidivism assessment impossible.

On June 21, 2010, the President granted early release, with his colleagues unanimously agreeing, and set the decision to take effect four weeks later at the Austrian authorities' request. The release took effect on July 20, 2010, and the decision was made public that day. His whereabouts and circumstances are not on record after July 2010.

Disputed and unproven points

His title is the first point of difference. The indictments called him the commander of the Keraterm camp with superior authority over everyone in it, and the Tribunal's press releases at the time of his arrest used the same description. The facts the Chamber sentenced him on describe a Commander of Security without rank and without power to punish, working under a camp administration run from a police station in Prijedor. The Chamber accepted that narrower version. One United Nations news report of the sentencing described him only as a guard.

The Prosecution's opening statement in March 2001 and the earlier indictments alleged a great deal more than the agreed facts, including a wider role in deciding the fate of detainees and further killings. None of those allegations was proven. The counts that carried them were withdrawn when he pleaded guilty, and the plea agreement records that there was no evidence he was present for, knew of in advance or took part in the Room 3 killings.

Sikirica's own position at trial was that he had not been at the camp at the relevant times, an alibi he abandoned when he pleaded guilty. The dates of his service also differ between documents: the indictments allege acts from May 24 to the end of August 1992, while the agreed facts confine his duties to about June 14 to about July 27, 1992. The date of his arrest differs by a day as well: the judgement, the Tribunal's press release and NATO give June 25, 2000, while the Tribunal's case page gives June 26.

Timeline

March 23, 1964: Born in Čirkin Polje, Prijedor municipality.

April 30, 1992: Serb forces take control of the town of Prijedor (indictment allegation).

May 31, 1992: The first prisoners are brought to the Keraterm camp.

June 14, 1992 (on or about, not before): Sikirica begins his duties as Commander of Security at Keraterm.

June 14 to July 27, 1992: He kills one detainee in the camp, the murder he later admits.

July 4, 1992: He compiles an "Official Note" as "Commander of Keraterm Security."

July 24, 1992: More than one hundred men are killed in Room 3; no evidence links Sikirica to the killings.

July 27, 1992 (on or about): His duties at Keraterm end.

July 21, 1995: Indictment confirmed against Sikirica and twelve others; arrest warrants issued.

August 24, 1999: Amended indictment charges him with genocide.

June 25, 2000: Detained by SFOR in Bosnia and Herzegovina and transferred to The Hague.

July 7, 2000: Pleads not guilty to all charges.

March 19, 2001: Joint trial opens before Trial Chamber III.

June 27, 2001: Genocide and complicity counts dismissed under Rule 98 bis.

September 19, 2001: Pleads guilty to persecutions; remaining counts withdrawn.

October 8, 2001: Addresses the court at the sentencing hearing.

November 13, 2001: Sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment; no appeal follows.

May 10, 2002: Transferred to Austria to serve his sentence.

June 21, 2010: Early release granted by the Tribunal's President.

June 25, 2010: The date he becomes eligible for conditional release under Austrian law.

July 20, 2010: Release takes effect; decision made public.