Dražen Erdemović

Victims
Took part in killing hundreds of men near Pilica, Bosnia, 1995; pleaded guilty January 14, 1998, to murder as a violation of the laws or customs of war; put his own share at about 70
Years active
On or about July 16, 1995
Location
Pilica and Zvornik municipality; Srebrenica; Tuzla; Novi Sad; The Hague; Norway
Method
Murder as a violation of the laws or customs of war, committed with others of his unit under superior orders and, as the court accepted, under threat of death
Status
10 years, November 29, 1996; remitted on appeal for a new plea, October 7, 1997; 5 years, March 5, 1998; served in Norway from August 1998; early release 1999

Dražen Erdemović was 23 years old and a private in a Bosnian Serb army sabotage unit when, on or about July 16, 1995, he took part in the killing of hundreds of unarmed Bosnian Muslim men brought by bus from Srebrenica to a site near Pilica, in the Zvornik municipality of eastern Bosnia. The men had surrendered or been captured after the fall of the United Nations "safe area" at Srebrenica five days earlier. The Appeals Chamber of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia put the number killed that day at approximately 1,200. Erdemović told the court he believed he had killed about 70 of them himself.

He was a Bosnian Croat serving in a Serb army, and he did something almost no one in the Srebrenica operation did: he told. Months later he gave his account to a journalist, was arrested in Serbia, and was handed to the tribunal in The Hague, where on May 31, 1996, he became the first person to plead guilty before it. His case went on to settle one of the hardest questions in international criminal law. In October 1997 a divided Appeals Chamber held that duress does not afford a complete defense to a soldier charged with a crime against humanity or a war crime involving the killing of innocent human beings. Erdemović pleaded again, this time guilty to murder as a violation of the laws or customs of war, and on March 5, 1998, he was sentenced to five years' imprisonment. He served the balance of that term in Norway, was released early in 1999, and spent the following years as a prosecution witness in the tribunal's Srebrenica trials.

A soldier of three armies

Erdemović was born on November 25, 1971, in the municipality of Tuzla in northeastern Bosnia and Herzegovina, then part of the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia. He described himself to the court as a Croat from Bosnia and Herzegovina, and no one disputed it. He grew up in Dragunj, a village near Tuzla. He finished eight years of primary school and three years of technical secondary school, where he trained as a locksmith. By his own account he grew up among Serbs, Croats and Muslims, kept friends in every group, and voted before the war for a reformist party that opposed it.

His military life began in December 1990, when he started his service in the Yugoslav People's Army, the JNA. He served in its military police in Belgrade and was then sent to Slavonia, in Croatia, where he served alongside Slovenian, Hungarian, Serbian and Albanian conscripts until the end of March 1992. When war reached Tuzla that spring he stayed on the Bosnian government side. He did guard duty with the Territorial Defense in his village and in 1992 was called up into the Army of Bosnia and Herzegovina, which he said he joined unwillingly, having already ignored one summons from the Tuzla barracks. He left it later that year.

He next served in the military police of the Croatian Defense Council, the HVO, from late 1992 until November 3, 1993. That service ended badly. He told the court he had helped a family of Serb civilians, mostly women and children, cross from the Tuzla area into territory held by the Bosnian Serbs, and that HVO soldiers arrested and beat him for it. A defense witness who had served with him in the same HVO police unit confirmed the incident, and medical experts later noted that he had been held for about 25 days. In his own later testimony he described it as a few days in a military remand facility. His position in the HVO, he said, had become untenable.

On November 3, 1993, he crossed into Republika Srpska.

He chose his unit with care. The group he joined in Bijeljina began as a small special unit and in October 1994 became the 10th Sabotage Detachment, a formation of about 60 men in two platoons, one based in Bijeljina and one in Vlasenica, answering to the intelligence center of the army's Main Staff. Its work was reconnaissance and sabotage behind the lines of the Army of Bosnia and Herzegovina. He said he picked it because, besides Serbs, it had "a few Croats, a Slovene and a Muslim," and because its work, as he described it to the court, involved artillery and "old iron" rather than the loss of human life. In August 1994, serving with Bosnian Serb soldiers on Mount Majevica, he came upon a former HVO colleague who had been captured and insisted that the man be released unharmed. That man later testified for him in The Hague.

July 1995

On or about July 6, 1995, the Bosnian Serb army began an attack on the Srebrenica enclave, which the United Nations Security Council had declared a safe area in 1993. On July 11 its first units entered the town. Thousands of Bosnian Muslim civilians fled to the United Nations compound at Potočari. A column of about 15,000 men, with some women and children, set out through the woods toward Tuzla, which was held by the Bosnian government. Between July 12 and 13, the men at Potočari were separated from the women and children and taken to holding sites around Srebrenica, and many of the men in the column were captured or surrendered. The indictment against Erdemović set out what followed in its own terms: between July 13 and about July 22, thousands of Bosnian Muslim men were summarily killed by members of the Bosnian Serb army and police at sites across the region.

The 10th Sabotage Detachment took part in the assault on the town. On July 16, Erdemović and seven other members of the unit were ordered from their base at Vlasenica to a site near Pilica, northwest of Zvornik. He said they were told nothing of the purpose. When they arrived, a lieutenant colonel and the group's commander informed them that buses carrying Bosnian Muslim men from Srebrenica, unarmed civilians who had surrendered to the army or police, would be arriving throughout the day, and that the men were to be killed.

He told the court that he had refused and had been threatened with death if he did not take part.

The killings near Pilica went on for most of that day.

The tribunal's judgments identify the victims as Bosnian Muslim men from Srebrenica, unarmed, who had surrendered or been captured after the enclave fell. The prosecution, citing Erdemović's own various accounts, said he was responsible for between 10 and 100 of the deaths. He settled on about 70.

Confession

By then he had decided to talk. In Belgrade, still deeply shaken by what he had done, he contacted a journalist and told her what had happened near Pilica, and that he wanted to go to the tribunal in The Hague. On March 2, 1996, he was detained by the authorities of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, who were investigating the crimes committed around Srebrenica. He repeated his account to the Serbian authorities and to the court in Novi Sad.

The tribunal's prosecutor wanted him. He was not yet indicted, but the prosecutor told the court he could provide evidence in the cases against Radovan Karadžić and Ratko Mladić. On March 28, 1996, a judge of the tribunal ordered his transfer to its custody, and he arrived in The Hague on March 30. He confessed to the prosecutor's investigators at once. On May 29 a Trial Chamber asked the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia to defer its own proceedings against him to the tribunal, and the same day the indictment against him was confirmed.

It charged him, on the basis of his individual criminal responsibility, with murder as a crime against humanity or, in the alternative, murder as a violation of the laws or customs of war. The indictment alleged that on or about July 16, 1995, he and other members of his unit, with soldiers from another brigade, had killed unarmed Bosnian Muslim men brought to the site near Pilica, and that the killings resulted in the deaths of hundreds of Bosnian Muslim male civilians.

The first guilty plea

On May 31, 1996, at his initial appearance before Trial Chamber I, Erdemović pleaded guilty to the count of murder as a crime against humanity. He then added an explanation: he had to do it, he had refused and been threatened with death, and he feared for his partner and his nine-month-old son. The chamber accepted the plea and, with the agreement of both sides, dismissed the alternative count. It also ordered a psychological and psychiatric examination by a panel of three experts.

The panel reported in late June that he was suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder severe enough that he could not then appear before the court. The chamber postponed the sentencing hearing. Erdemović said he still wanted to cooperate, and on July 5, 1996, he testified at the tribunal's public review of the indictments against Karadžić and Mladić. The court later found that his evidence contributed to the decision to issue international arrest warrants for both men. In October the panel found that he was now fit to stand trial, and the pre-sentencing hearing took place on November 19 and 20, 1996.

The prosecution called one witness, the investigator in charge of its Srebrenica inquiry. He told the court that Erdemović had given investigators four incidents they had known nothing about, among them the killings near Pilica and in the public building there, and two other killings he had witnessed. On-site investigation, aerial photographs and exhumation work had confirmed much of what he said. The prosecution told the court that without his account it could not have discovered where the prisoners held in the Pilica building had been killed, and that his information widened the known geography of the killings and showed them to be planned and organized. Two protected defense witnesses spoke to his character: the former HVO colleague whose life he had saved, and a friend who had known him since 1993 as part of a mixed group of friends and described a calm, outgoing man who hated the war and was no nationalist.

On November 20, Erdemović addressed the court and expressed remorse.

Ten years

Trial Chamber I delivered its judgment on November 29, 1996, the first sentence handed down by the tribunal and the first sentence for a crime against humanity by an international court since Nuremberg and Tokyo. It began by testing the plea itself. The chamber was satisfied that he had understood what he was doing when he pleaded on May 31 and that the plea was voluntary. It then considered whether his claim of duress, if proved, would cancel the crime and so make the plea invalid.

The chamber held that obedience to superior orders, under the tribunal's Statute, could never relieve him of criminal responsibility and could at most reduce the penalty. Duress, which the Statute did not mention, it examined against the case law of the postwar military tribunals. It did not rule out duress as a full defense in principle, but held that its conditions were especially strict. Then it applied a demand of its own: it would require his statements to be corroborated by independent evidence. The defense had produced no testimony, evaluation or other material to support his account of the threat, and the chamber therefore declined to accept the plea of extreme necessity. It also found no evidence for the defense argument that he had been in a state of mental incompetence when he acted.

On gravity, the chamber held that crimes against humanity were of extreme gravity and that the crime he had committed was of that order. In mitigation it took account of his age, his subordinate rank, his remorse, which the prosecution itself considered sincere, his wish to surrender to the tribunal, his guilty plea, his cooperation, which it said must weigh significantly, and its finding that he no longer posed a danger and was capable of reform. The prosecution had asked for no more than ten years. The chamber imposed ten years' imprisonment.

The appeal and the duress ruling

His counsel appealed in December 1996, supplementing the appeal in April 1997. He asked the Appeals Chamber to find him guilty but excuse him from serving any sentence, on the grounds that he had acted under duress and in extreme necessity, or else to reduce the sentence substantially. The five judges of the Appeals Chamber raised questions of their own: whether duress could be a complete defense to crimes against humanity or war crimes, whether a guilty plea accompanied by a claim of duress was equivocal, and whether his mental condition had undermined the plea.

The Appeals Chamber gave judgment on October 7, 1997. It unanimously rejected his request for acquittal and unanimously found that his plea had been voluntary. By four votes to one it rejected his application to have the sentence revised. By three votes to two it found that duress does not afford a complete defense to a soldier charged with a crime against humanity and/or a war crime involving the killing of innocent human beings, and that his plea was therefore not equivocal. Two judges dissented on that point, holding that duress could in principle be a defense even to killing, under strict conditions.

The decisive finding was another one. By four votes to one, the Appeals Chamber held that the plea had not been informed. Erdemović had not understood the difference between the two alternative charges or the consequences of choosing one over the other. In the majority's view a crime against humanity was the more serious offense and carried the heavier penalty, and he had pleaded to it without knowing that a plea to the war crime was open to him. The chamber sent the case to a different Trial Chamber so that he could plead again in full knowledge of the nature of the charges and the consequences of his plea.

The second plea

On January 8, 1998, the prosecution and the defense filed a joint motion asking the court to consider a plea agreement between them, the first such document ever presented to the tribunal. Under it, Erdemović would plead guilty to the war crime count in full understanding of how it differed from the alternative charge; the two sides agreed the facts, including that he had acted under duress; the prosecution would drop the crime against humanity count; and both sides recommended a sentence of seven years, while acknowledging that the sentence was for the court alone.

At the hearing on January 14, 1998, before Trial Chamber II ter, the presiding judge explained the two charges and his options. Erdemović confirmed that he understood the indictment, that his counsel had explained it, that no one had pressured him, and that he knew the tribunal could impose life imprisonment. To the count of a crime against humanity he answered, "I plead not guilty." To the count of murder as a violation of the laws or customs of war he answered, "I plead guilty." The prosecution withdrew the crime against humanity count, and the chamber convicted him on the war crime.

He declined to give evidence again and asked the court to rely on what he had already said. "I would prefer not to talk about it any more," he told the chamber. The defense argued that he had been a victim of the war who killed because he would otherwise have been killed, with no prior record, a family facing hardship, a failed attempt to save one man and a refusal to join the killings in the Pilica building to his credit. The prosecution, which said it would focus on mitigation because the gravity of the crime spoke for itself, pointed to his voluntary confession, his remorse and the value of his cooperation.

Five years

The new Trial Chamber gave judgment on March 5, 1998. It accepted as fact the version of events the two sides had agreed: that the allegations in the indictment were true and that he had acted under superior orders and under threat of death. Applying the Appeals Chamber's ruling, it treated duress as a matter for mitigation only, and it found that there was a real risk he would have been killed had he disobeyed the order. He had voiced his feelings, the chamber said, but he had to kill or be killed.

It weighed the magnitude of the crime and the scale of his part in it as aggravating. The prosecution estimated he might have killed up to 100 people, close to his own estimate of about 70, and the chamber noted that however reluctant his first decision had been, he went on killing for most of that day. On the other side it set his age, his family circumstances, his lack of any criminal record, his honesty, his admission of guilt, his remorse and his cooperation, which the prosecution praised without reservation and the chamber weighed heavily. It noted that he had confessed at a time when no authority was seeking to prosecute him, knowing he would almost certainly be prosecuted as a result, and that his evidence had given investigators the names of commanders and fellow perpetrators and the structure of the units involved. The plea agreement did not bind the chamber, but it took the agreement into careful account.

The chamber unanimously sentenced him to five years' imprisonment, with credit for the time he had spent in custody since the transfer order of March 28, 1996. One judge appended a separate opinion on points of law. Neither side appealed, and on July 2, 1998, the tribunal certified that the proceedings were concluded.

Norway and release

On July 10, 1998, the President of the tribunal decided that he would serve his sentence in Norway, and he was transferred there on August 26, 1998. Under Norwegian law he became eligible for early release in July 1999. The tribunal's Registrar gathered reports from Norway, the prosecution set out his cooperation, and the President spoke with him by telephone on May 28, 1999.

In June 1999 the President decided to authorize his release on July 28, 1999. The decision found him remorseful, citing his recognition of his crimes and their consequences, his repeated expressions of contrition and his continuing cooperation with the prosecution. It found that his prospects on release were relatively positive, noting his determination not to offend again, his improved health, his youth, his young family and the practical and language skills he had gained in custody, and it concluded that further detention would serve no useful purpose.

Witness

His usefulness to the prosecution did not end with his release. On May 22, 2000, having completed his sentence, he testified freely and voluntarily for the prosecution at the trial of Radislav Krstić, a Bosnian Serb army corps commander, laying out his own service history and the chain of command above his detachment. In August 2003 he testified at the trial of the former Yugoslav president. In the years that followed he gave evidence in the Popović case and others, and in February 2012 at the trial of Karadžić.

In July 2013 he testified at the trial of Mladić, his eighth appearance as a witness before the tribunal, under protective measures that concealed his face and voice. He had by then been admitted to the tribunal's witness protection program as a cooperating witness. Under cross-examination the defense put documents to him about his rank and other men's accounts of his conduct, and he held to his testimony. Asked about rumors that the commander of his unit had been promised gold and money for the killings, he said he had heard them in Bijeljina, did not know whether they were true, and had received nothing himself.

The genocide question at Srebrenica was settled in other cases. On April 19, 2004, the tribunal's Appeals Chamber, in the Krstić case, convicted Krstić of aiding and abetting genocide committed against Bosnian Muslims in Srebrenica. Erdemović himself was never charged with genocide. His conviction is for murder as a violation of the laws or customs of war.

As of 2017 he was living in Europe.

Context: the law his case applied

The tribunal's Statute gave the chambers two ways to charge what happened near Pilica. One provision covered crimes against humanity, including murder committed as part of an attack on a civilian population. Another covered violations of the laws or customs of war, and the count to which Erdemović finally pleaded was framed as murder recognized by the Geneva Conventions. The indictment charged them as alternatives, so he could be convicted of one, not both. When he replead, the presiding judge read him the Appeals Chamber's view that a crime against humanity is more serious than a war crime and carries a heavier penalty, which is why the choice between them mattered to his sentence.

Two other provisions shaped the case. One provided that acting on the orders of a government or a superior does not relieve an accused of responsibility but may be considered in mitigation if justice so requires. Another limited the tribunal's penalties to imprisonment, directed it to have recourse to the general practice of the courts of the former Yugoslavia, and told it to weigh the gravity of the offense and the individual circumstances of the convicted person. The tribunal's Rules allowed imprisonment up to the remainder of a person's life and named substantial cooperation with the prosecutor as a mitigating circumstance. At the replea hearing the prosecution told the court that domestic sentences for crimes of this type in the former Yugoslavia ranged from five to 20 years.

The appeal also fixed the conditions for any guilty plea before the tribunal. The joint opinion of two judges of the majority set three minimum requirements: the plea must be voluntary, made by an accused mentally fit to understand it and free of threats, inducements or promises; it must be informed, so that the accused understands the charges and the consequences of pleading guilty to them; and it must not be equivocal, which means it cannot be accompanied by words amounting to a defense that contradicts the admission of guilt. The Trial Chamber that resentenced Erdemović applied those conditions to his second plea, together with the tribunal's rule on guilty pleas, which required that a guilty plea be voluntary and not equivocal and that there be a sufficient factual basis for the crime and the accused's part in it.

Disputed and unproven points

The number of men killed near Pilica on July 16, 1995, has never been fixed in the judgments against Erdemović. The indictment said hundreds, the resentencing judgment said the exact number had not been ascertained, and the Appeals Chamber described his crime as participation in the killing of approximately 1,200 unarmed civilian men. Erdemović himself estimated 1,000 to 1,200 in later testimony, and in 2013, when defense counsel put to him another participant's lower figure, he said he could not say.

His own share is an estimate. The prosecution put it at between 10 and 100 in 1996 and up to 100 in 1998; he believed it was about 70.

The duress he described was not accepted in 1996, when the first Trial Chamber found it uncorroborated. In 1998 the prosecution agreed that it was true, and the second Trial Chamber accepted it as fact on that agreement. The Appeals Chamber was split three to two on whether duress could ever be a complete defense to killing innocent people, and the majority's answer, no, governed his sentence.

His rank was also disputed. He said he had briefly been a sergeant and was demoted before July 1995; the tribunal found no document establishing his rank, and the 1998 judgment described him as a private. In 2013 the defense at the Mladić trial put documents to him suggesting he was still a sergeant on July 10, 1995, which he disputed.

Timeline

November 25, 1971: Born in the municipality of Tuzla, Bosnia and Herzegovina.

December 1990 to March 1992: Serves in the Yugoslav People's Army, including in Slavonia.

1992: Serves in the Territorial Defense and the Army of Bosnia and Herzegovina.

Late 1992 to November 3, 1993: Serves in the HVO military police; crosses into Republika Srpska on November 3, 1993.

April 1994: Joins the Bosnian Serb army; later part of the 10th Sabotage Detachment.

July 11, 1995: Bosnian Serb forces enter Srebrenica.

On or about July 16, 1995: Takes part in the killing of hundreds of Bosnian Muslim men near Pilica; refuses a second order the same day.

March 2, 1996: Detained by authorities of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia.

March 30, 1996: Transferred to the tribunal in The Hague.

May 29, 1996: Indictment confirmed.

May 31, 1996: Pleads guilty to murder as a crime against humanity.

July 5, 1996: Testifies at the review of the indictments against Karadžić and Mladić.

November 29, 1996: Sentenced to ten years' imprisonment.

October 7, 1997: Appeals Chamber rules duress is no complete defense to killing innocents and remits the case for a new plea.

January 14, 1998: Pleads guilty to murder as a violation of the laws or customs of war.

March 5, 1998: Sentenced to five years' imprisonment.

August 26, 1998: Transferred to Norway to serve the sentence.

June 1999: Tribunal President authorizes early release from July 28, 1999.

May 22, 2000: Testifies at the Krstić trial.

July 2013: Testifies at the Mladić trial, his eighth appearance as a tribunal witness.