William Palmer was a surgeon in the Staffordshire town of Rugeley who gave up most of his practice for horse racing and betting and fell deep into debt. In November 1855 his racing associate John Parsons Cook, 28, won a large sum, fell ill, was tended by Palmer for several days, and died. The Crown charged that Palmer had poisoned him with strychnine.
The case became one of the most closely followed of its time. Two more coroner's inquests, on the exhumed bodies of Palmer's wife and brother, returned verdicts of wilful murder against him. Feeling in Staffordshire ran so high that Parliament passed a new law, known as Palmer's Act, allowing him to be tried at the Central Criminal Court in London. At a trial that opened on May 14, 1856, and turned largely on rival medical experts, a jury convicted him on May 27 of the wilful murder of Cook. He was hanged at Stafford on June 14, 1856. He was never tried for any other death.
Palmer was born on August 6, 1824, according to the chronology in the historian Katherine D. Watson's study of the case. He trained in medicine and returned to his native Rugeley, where, in the account of James R. Voelkel for the Science History Institute, he married a local woman and meant to settle as a country doctor. His obsession with racing and betting led him to abandon most of that practice, Voelkel writes, and he fell deeply into debt. Watson describes him as a general practitioner who gave up medicine to follow gambling and horse racing, and who had run up significant debts and turned to moneylenders.
His wife was Anne Palmer. Her mother came to stay at the Palmers' house early in 1849 and died there within a fortnight of arriving, Watson writes. Voelkel notes that under the family's arrangements, a trust would go back to her relatives when Palmer's wife died. In 1850 Leonard Bladen, a racing companion to whom Palmer owed eight hundred pounds, died at Palmer's house in Rugeley, in circumstances that Watson says were to be repeated in Cook's case. Rumors of poisoning went around the town.
Four of the Palmers' infant children died of convulsions between 1851 and 1854, according to Watson's chronology. Palmer also fathered a son by the family's housemaid; Watson records that the infant died of convulsions five months after his birth, following a visit from his father.
None of these deaths was the subject of an inquest verdict against Palmer, and none was ever charged. Watson's point is that they were seen differently only afterward: after Cook's death, she writes, it became clear with hindsight that his was not the first sudden death around Palmer.
Palmer took out three policies on his wife's life, totaling thirteen thousand pounds, Voelkel writes. Anne Palmer died on September 29, 1854. In January 1855, according to Voelkel, Palmer insured his brother Walter's life for thirteen thousand pounds as well. Walter Palmer died on August 16, 1855. The insurers became suspicious, refused to pay, and put a private detective on the case, Voelkel writes. The Cambridge University Library's account of the case says Palmer was suspected of poisoning his wife, his brother and possibly four of his young children to collect on insurance.
John Parsons Cook was 28. Watson describes him as a wealthy racing enthusiast with whom Palmer co-owned some horses; Voelkel calls him Palmer's associate and betting partner. In November 1855 Cook won a large sum and soon afterward fell strangely ill. Palmer collected the winnings and tended him for several days, Voelkel writes, before Cook died. Watson dates the death November 21, 1855. In the days before, according to Voelkel, Palmer had bought strychnine, and he could not account for it.
Cook's stomach contents and other organs were sent to Dr. Alfred Swaine Taylor at Guy's Hospital in London. Taylor was the most respected toxicologist in England and an unofficial adviser to the Crown, Watson writes, and Voelkel notes that he was the author of a leading treatise on poisons. His analysis did not detect strychnine. He concluded all the same that strychnine had killed Cook, and he became the prosecution's chief witness.
Voelkel writes that Taylor told the court strychnine was hard to detect even in controlled laboratory conditions, and that he reasoned from the symptoms instead: the convulsions Cook suffered could come only from tetanus or strychnine poisoning, and since tetanus could be ruled out, the cause was poison. The conviction, Voelkel writes, rested on that reasoning rather than on chemical proof.
The inquest on Cook opened on November 29, 1855, and on December 15 the jury returned a verdict of wilful murder against William Palmer, Watson writes. The case drew the press in numbers: Palmer's solicitor later swore that more than thirty newspapers had reporters at the inquests.
Cook's sudden death raised questions about the deaths of Palmer's wife and brother, Watson writes. Their bodies were exhumed on December 22, 1855, and inquests were opened on both. Taylor found antimony in Anne Palmer's body and attributed her death to it. He suspected that Walter Palmer had died of prussic acid, but none was found. On January 12, 1856, the jury at Anne Palmer's inquest returned a verdict of wilful murder against her husband, and on January 23 the jury in Walter Palmer's case returned the same verdict against his brother. These were findings of coroner's juries, not convictions. Neither case was tried.
By late January 1856 local feeling was intense. Watson quotes one report that the population was divided into Palmerites and Anti-Palmerites, and the Illustrated Times called the case the crime of the age. On January 26 Palmer and his solicitor, John Smith, swore affidavits saying he could not get a fair trial in Staffordshire or anywhere in the Midlands. Palmer swore that the prejudice was so great that he doubted any ordinary panel of jurors could be impartial, and that it would cost about a thousand pounds to answer Taylor's evidence, money he did not have. Smith cited the press coverage and swore that one juror had helped gather evidence against Palmer, and that the solicitor for the prosecution also believed a fair trial in the region was impossible.
The Crown agreed. The Court of Queen's Bench, with Lord Chief Justice Campbell presiding and Charles Wilkins arguing for Palmer, granted a rule on January 29 and on January 31, 1856, ordered the trial moved from Stafford to the Central Criminal Court in London. The court's power to try crimes committed outside London was fixed by statute, however, so a new law was needed.
On February 5, 1856, the Lord Chancellor brought a Trial of Offences Bill into the House of Lords. He told peers that it would let the Court of Queen's Bench send certain offenses for trial at the Central Criminal Court, that a trial at bar in the Queen's Bench was costly and slow and ill suited to felonies, and that it was unclear whether the court already had that power. The bill was meant for cases where a person charged with a serious offense faced prejudice in his own neighborhood, and he said it had the support of the Lord Chief Justice and the other judges. Campbell championed it, Watson writes, and it met little resistance in the Lords.
In the Commons a few members objected, Watson writes, chiefly that people charged with treason, a concern tied to Ireland, could be forced to trial in London, and that prisoners might be tried there against their will. In the committee debate on March 10, 1856, Mr. Whiteside referred to the Stafford case, where the prisoner had wanted his trial in London, and moved an amendment on treason that he later withdrew. The Attorney General, Sir Alexander Cockburn, replied that in Palmer's case the Queen's Bench could have sent the trial to another county, and that the prisoner had asked for removal because the state of public feeling in Stafford left him no hope of an impartial trial. Mr. Henley argued against making general law for rare cases. Two Staffordshire members denied that Palmer could not be fairly tried in his county, Watson writes. The bill passed without amendment and received royal assent on April 11, 1856, as the Central Criminal Court Act 1856, chapter 16 of the statutes of that session. It allowed a crime committed outside London to be tried there when that was expedient to the ends of justice, and it became known as Palmer's Act.
On March 14, 1856, the grand jury at Stafford returned true bills against Palmer for the murders of Cook and of his wife Anne. It ignored the bill in Walter Palmer's case. Only the Cook indictment was tried in London. Watson writes that the Crown was ready to pursue Anne's death if the Cook case failed. The same day, at the Stafford assizes, Palmer's close friend Samuel Cheshire, the Rugeley deputy postmaster, was convicted of unlawfully opening a letter and sentenced to twelve months without hard labor.
The trial opened at the Central Criminal Court, the Old Bailey, on May 14, 1856, before three judges: Lord Chief Justice Campbell, Baron Alderson and Mr. Justice Cresswell. The Attorney General, Cockburn, led for the Crown. Palmer was defended by Serjeant William Shee. Wilkins, the counsel Palmer had wanted, had fallen seriously ill, and Watson notes that Shee had never before defended in a murder trial. The family had about two thousand pounds for the defense.
On the first morning a juryman named Mason told the court he felt too prejudiced to serve and was excused. Cockburn's opening speech lasted about four hours. He told the jury to put aside whatever they had read and to decide the case impartially. Watson counts seventeen medical and scientific witnesses called by the Crown and fifteen by the defense, and notes that the prosecution produced thirteen new witnesses only four days before the trial.
Shee, in his speech, declared his own belief that his client was innocent, a breach of the rules of advocacy, Watson writes. The defense case was that Cook could have died of natural causes. Contemporaries complained that Campbell and Alderson were biased against the prisoner, that Taylor and the Crown's experts were given unfair advantages, and that the press had made a fair hearing impossible, Watson writes.
On May 27, 1856, the jury found Palmer guilty of the wilful murder of John Parsons Cook. Lord Campbell put on the black cap, told Palmer that he had been convicted after a long and impartial trial, and sentenced him to death. The Cambridge University Library's exhibition account of the trial report adds that he was sentenced to be executed at Stafford, and that the judge justified this as a warning to others. The indictment for Anne Palmer's death was never tried, and the coroner's verdicts in the deaths of Anne and Walter were left on the record without a trial.
The verdict was argued over at once. Palmer's brother Thomas published an open letter to Lord Campbell criticizing the prosecution and the conduct of the judges. A pamphlet titled The Cries of the Condemned, or Proofs of the Unfair Trial, argued that Palmer had not had a fair hearing; it was attributed to Thomas Wakley, who wrote to the press on June 7 denying that he had written it. Three of the jurors later petitioned the Treasury for compensation for their serious financial loss and inconvenience during the trial; the request was refused, because the law made no provision for paying jurors, a change that came only in 1949.
Charles Dickens took the opposite side. In Household Words, in an essay titled The Demeanour of Murderers, he described the poisoner as the greatest villain that ever stood in the Old Bailey dock, and argued that the composure the newspapers had admired in court was not a sign of innocence but of a lack of feeling, the usual bearing of a very wicked man. In a letter of June 1, the editors of Dickens Journals Online note, Dickens called the piece a quiet protest against the newspaper descriptions of Palmer in court. It appeared on June 14, 1856, the day Palmer was hanged.
Palmer was hanged outside Stafford prison on June 14, 1856, aged 31. Voelkel puts the crowd at an estimated thirty thousand, and the Cambridge University Library describes about thirty thousand people at the execution, some of whom probably bought the broadside ballads printed for the occasion. One such sheet, in the library's collection, has Palmer speaking from the grave to his mother and surviving son.
He never confessed, Voelkel writes. The statement remembered from him was that he was innocent of poisoning Cook by strychnine, a denial so narrowly worded that Voelkel counts it, with the uncertain forensic evidence, among the reasons the case has remained an open question. The Dickens Journals Online editors record his last words on the scaffold as a question, "Is it safe?", and his mother's lament afterward: "They hanged my saintly Billy!"
The Palmer case put the expert evidence of a toxicologist at the center of a murder trial. Voelkel argues that it turned on Taylor's reasoning from symptoms rather than on any chemical finding. Taylor drew a rebuke from the bench during the trial for a letter he had written to the press while the case was pending, Watson writes, and in April 1856 he complained to the Treasury Solicitor about misstatements in the Morning Advertiser.
Watson, writing in 2020, concludes that Palmer was not clearly denied a fair trial. The weight of circumstantial evidence was probably convincing, she writes, and there is little support for the view that a Staffordshire jury would have acquitted him. She also notes the prosecution's resources: the prosecution cost the state 7,532 pounds, according to the judicial statistics she cites, while the defense, competent but stretched, had about two thousand. The question of fairness, in her view, cannot be separated from the medical, legal and financial sides of the case.
The bill went through Parliament as the Trial of Offences Bill, and the name Palmer's Act stayed with it. Its rule, that a crime committed outside London could be sent to the Central Criminal Court when that was expedient to the ends of justice, was written as a general power. In the Commons debate of March 10, 1856, Mr. Baines argued that it corrected a defect in the law rather than answering a single case, and that the prisoner's consent should not be required.
The only court finding of murder against William Palmer is the jury's verdict of May 27, 1856, that he wilfully murdered John Parsons Cook. The Crown charged that the poison was strychnine. No strychnine was detected in Cook's body, and the conviction rested on circumstantial evidence, including his purchase of strychnine, and on expert reasoning from Cook's symptoms. The defense case that Cook might have died of natural causes did not persuade the jury. Palmer's narrow denial has kept alive the suggestion that, if he poisoned Cook, it may not have been with strychnine.
Coroner's juries returned verdicts of wilful murder against him in the deaths of his wife, Anne, and his brother Walter. Taylor said he found antimony in Anne's body and suspected prussic acid in Walter's, though none was found. The Stafford grand jury accepted the bill on Anne and rejected the one on Walter. Neither death was tried, and he was not convicted of either.
The deaths of his mother-in-law in 1849, of Leonard Bladen in 1850, of four of his infant children between 1851 and 1854, and of his housemaid's infant son were never the subject of any inquest verdict or charge against him. They are linked to him by rumor at the time, in Bladen's case, and by later writers. Popular accounts give larger totals; no court or inquest supports them.
August 6, 1824: William Palmer born.
Early 1849: his mother-in-law dies at his house.
1850: Leonard Bladen, a racing companion, dies at his house in Rugeley.
1851 to 1854: four of his infant children die of convulsions.
1854: insures Anne's life for thirteen thousand pounds in three policies.
September 29, 1854: Anne Palmer dies.
January 1855: insures Walter Palmer's life for thirteen thousand pounds (Voelkel).
August 16, 1855: Walter Palmer dies; the insurers refuse to pay.
November 21, 1855: John Parsons Cook dies at Rugeley (Watson).
November 29, 1855: the inquest on Cook opens.
December 15, 1855: the inquest jury returns a verdict of wilful murder against Palmer.
December 22, 1855: the bodies of Anne and Walter Palmer are exhumed.
January 12 and 23, 1856: inquest verdicts of wilful murder against Palmer in the deaths of Anne and Walter.
January 31, 1856: the Court of Queen's Bench orders the trial moved to London.
March 14, 1856: Stafford grand jury finds true bills for Cook and Anne and ignores the bill for Walter; Samuel Cheshire convicted of unlawfully opening a letter.
April 11, 1856: royal assent to the Central Criminal Court Act 1856 (Palmer's Act).
May 14 to 27, 1856: trial at the Central Criminal Court; convicted of the wilful murder of Cook and sentenced to death.
June 14, 1856: hanged at Stafford before a crowd of about thirty thousand.