Dr. Harold Frederick Shipman: Doctor Death

Victims
15 murder convictions, patients in Hyde, 1995-1998. The Shipman Inquiry attributed about 250 deaths, 218 identified, 1971-1998, never tried; he never admitted any killing
Years active
Convicted killings: March 1995 to June 24, 1998. Attributed by the Inquiry: 1971 (Pontefract) and 1975 (Todmorden, first identified victim, Eva Lyons) to June 1998
Location
Nottingham (birth); Leeds (medical school); Pontefract, Todmorden and Halifax, West Yorkshire; County Durham (Newton Aycliffe); Hyde, Greater Manchester (Donneybrook practice, 1977 to 1992.
Method
Injection of diamorphine or morphine, usually on a home visit; he then certified the death himself as natural and in later years altered computer records to invent a history
Status
15 life sentences, January 31, 2000; the Home Secretary ruled in 2002 he should never be released. Struck off by the GMC. Found hanged in his cell at HMP Wakefield, January 13, 2004

Harold Shipman was a family doctor in Hyde, a town on the eastern edge of Greater Manchester. On January 31, 2000, a jury at Preston Crown Court convicted him of murdering 15 of his patients by injecting them with diamorphine, and of forging the will of the last of them, Kathleen Grundy. He was 54. The judge, Mr Justice Forbes, passed 15 life sentences and told him: "In your case, life must mean life. You must spend the remainder of your days in prison."

The 15 were a sample. A public inquiry chaired by the High Court judge Dame Janet Smith reported in July 2002 that he had killed at least 215 patients. In January 2005 her final report went further: "My overall conclusion, therefore, is that Shipman killed about 250 patients between 1971 and 1998, of whom I have been able positively to identify 218." Those figures are the findings of an inquiry, not convictions. Prosecutors had decided that no second trial could be fair, and Shipman never admitted a single killing. He hanged himself in his cell at Wakefield prison on January 13, 2004, the day before his 58th birthday.

What follows separates the two records throughout: the 15 murders a jury found proved, and the much larger number of deaths that the Inquiry and the coroner attributed to him.

Nottingham and Leeds

Shipman was born on January 14, 1946, in Nottingham, the son of a lorry driver, CBS News reported. Mikaela Sitford, the Manchester Evening News reporter who broke the story of the police investigation in 1998, later wrote that he grew up on a Nottingham council estate and went to High Pavement Grammar School. His mother, Vera, died of lung cancer while he was still a student. The Week, in a 2019 profile, put his age at the time at 17 and said he had cared for her and become fascinated by the morphine that eased her pain. News agencies in 2004 noted that some people linked his later crimes to watching her die; no court or inquiry finding rests on that idea.

He studied medicine at the University of Leeds. There he met Primrose May Oxtoby, and they married in 1966, when she was 17 and five months pregnant, The Week reported. They had four children. Primrose stayed with him through everything that followed; at his trial she sat in court every day, often with one of their adult children.

He graduated from Leeds University Medical School in 1970, according to the clinical audit of his career commissioned by the Chief Medical Officer.

Pontefract

From 1970 to 1974 Shipman held junior hospital posts at Pontefract General Infirmary in West Yorkshire. Dame Janet Smith turned to those years in her final report, published on January 27, 2005.

Questions had been raised about 137 deaths at the hospital between 1970 and 1974, the years he worked there, the Middlesbrough Evening Gazette reported. Dame Janet concluded that he had probably caused the deaths of 10 to 15 patients at Pontefract, the Yorkshire Post reported; the Press Association put it as up to 15 patients killed while he was a junior doctor. She concluded, the British Medical Journal reported, that he "probably began to kill patients within a year of leaving medical school." He had also become addicted to pethidine as a young doctor, the Press Association noted.

Todmorden

In 1974 Shipman became an assistant in a general practice in Todmorden, a town in West Yorkshire, and after a month he was invited to become a principal, the Chief Medical Officer's audit records. The Yorkshire Post names the practice as the Abraham Ormerod medical centre. Peter Devine, then a senior reporter on the Todmorden News, later worked out that Shipman was in the town for about 19 months, from roughly March 1974 to September 1975.

The Inquiry found that his first identified victim died there. Eva Lyons was 70 and had cancer. She died in March 1975, a year after he began in practice, the Associated Press reported from the First Report. The Inquiry examined more than 30 deaths from his Todmorden period. Devine reported that it found Eva Lyons had been murdered, found a suspicion of unlawful killing in six other cases, and found the evidence insufficient in five. Devine had earlier gone through the registrar's records and found that Shipman signed 22 death certificates in Todmorden, eight of them over five days in 1975, three on January 21. Relatives of those three told him Shipman had been at the bedside.

The pethidine case

Shipman's time in Todmorden ended when it came out that he had been obtaining pethidine, a strong opioid painkiller, for his own use. He was convicted of obtaining pethidine by deception and forging prescriptions, Devine wrote. The British Medical Journal recorded that in 1976 he was convicted of offenses involving the misuse of pethidine and was reported to the General Medical Council. The Canadian Medical Association Journal reported in 2000 that he had eight criminal convictions for drug offenses. He was fined; The Week put the fine at 600 pounds. The Prisons and Probation Ombudsman, reviewing his history in 2004, recorded a period of depression and drug misuse in the mid-1970s and treatment at The Retreat, a hospital in York.

He was not struck off. After the 1976 case he was reported to the General Medical Council; he sought treatment, and no further action was taken, the British Medical Journal recorded. The GMC allowed him to keep practicing, the Press Association noted in 2005. Devine, looking back, wrote that Shipman was forgiven for his earlier forgery after the 1976 trial. No evidence was presented at his murder trial of any later drug misuse, the British Medical Journal added.

In Parliament in 2007, Chris McCafferty, the MP for Calder Valley, which includes Todmorden, put the local view more bluntly: he had been found abusing drugs in Todmorden and was then "able to go down the road and carry on practising in Hyde, with no monitoring at all."

Durham and the move to Hyde

For about two years after the conviction Shipman worked as a clinical medical officer, the Canadian Medical Association Journal reported. The Middlesbrough Evening Gazette later noted that in the mid-1970s he lived in Newton Aycliffe and worked in County Durham.

In 1977 he returned to general practice, joining the Donneybrook group practice in Hyde, a working-class town of about 22,000 people outside Manchester, according to the Associated Press. When he applied, he did not hide his drug conviction. He persuaded his new partners, as he had already persuaded the GMC, that he had put the problem behind him, the government recorded in its 2007 response to the Inquiry.

Donneybrook

Shipman was a partner at Donneybrook from 1977 to 1992. The Inquiry found that he killed 71 patients during those years, The Week reported in its summary of the First Report.

Gaps in the record made this period hard to examine. Most medical records of patients who died before 1991 had been routinely destroyed, and few survived for deaths before 1984, The Irish Times reported when the Inquiry opened. The Chief Medical Officer's audit found that the excess of deaths among his patients was evident from his first years in practice and continued throughout his career. A prospective audit of all patients registered with him from 1987 found 98 more deaths among women than expected between 1987 and 1998, and 12 fewer than expected among men.

His departure from Donneybrook in 1992 was, in the words of the Inquiry's Second Report, "acrimonious."

21 Market Street

In August 1992 Shipman began practicing on his own from 21 Market Street, Hyde. By 1998 he had about 3,000 patients and, CBS News reported, a large waiting list of people who wanted to join. He was known locally as Fred. The local Community Health Council had described him as one of the best family doctors in the Manchester area, The Globe and Mail reported. "Nobody else was up to his standard," a former colleague said.

The Inquiry found that he killed 143 patients between 1992 and 1998, the Associated Press reported.

How he killed

The jury convicted Shipman of injecting 15 women with diamorphine, the pharmaceutical form of heroin, during routine visits at their homes or at his surgery; many of them were in good health, the Associated Press reported. All but one of the 15 died during a home visit, RTÉ News reported. At the Inquiry, Henry McQuay, professor of pain relief at the University of Oxford, said a patient injected with 30 milligrams or more of diamorphine would die within ten minutes or less. "If you do not breathe for three minutes then your brain will be starved of oxygen and you will die," he said.

Shipman then signed the death certificate himself, giving a cause such as old age, heart disease or a stroke. The Chief Medical Officer's audit, by Professor Richard Baker of the University of Leicester, compared his certificates and cremation forms with those of other doctors. It found that his patients were more likely to die in the afternoon, to die within 30 minutes of the onset of what was described as a collapse, and to have Shipman present, and less likely to have a relative or carer with them. Baker found Shipman present at about 20 percent of the deaths he certified, against a norm of 0.8 percent, and relatives present at 40 percent, against 80 percent for other doctors, the Canadian Medical Association Journal reported. Shipman issued 521 death certificates in his career, 499 of them in Hyde; the highest number issued by any comparable Hyde doctor was 210.

In his later years he covered his tracks in his computer records. After a death he went back into the patient's file and added entries describing symptoms the patient had never had, so that the death would look expected. The practice software kept an audit trail, and it showed that the entries had been typed after the fact.

He obtained the drug in several ways. The Canadian Medical Association Journal reported that he over-prescribed to terminally ill patients and offered to collect the leftover supply after they died. He stockpiled diamorphine at his home and his surgery, Reuters reported. The Week, summarizing the Inquiry's findings, said that he once prescribed as much as 12,000 milligrams of diamorphine for one dying patient, enough, the Inquiry said, "to kill about 360 people." The Chief Medical Officer's audit could not establish how he had obtained all the diamorphine he used.

Dame Janet found no sign of a sexual motive and no evidence that he sought money from his victims except in one case, Kathleen Grundy's. He did not rob the dead or make them suffer, CBS News reported.

The people he killed

The Inquiry's 215 identified victims in the First Report were 171 women and 44 men, aged from 41 to 93. Some were named in court records, the Inquiry's reports and major news coverage.

Kathleen Grundy was 81, a former mayoress of Hyde who lived in Gee Cross. She was known for her good health and for helping people less fortunate than herself. She was the last of the 15 women whose murders brought his conviction.

Kathleen Wagstaff was 81. Shipman had been the doctor of her son Peter and his wife, Angela, for more than 20 years, and had treated their parents and their children. She died in December 1997 with Shipman present, and he certified a heart attack. Peter Wagstaff remembered that on the day she died she had walked into Hyde to buy Christmas presents and to collect cheques from the building society. He later found that Shipman had lied about the death and had made no call to the emergency services or to his surgery. She was one of the 15.

Winifred Mellor died on May 11, 1998, and Joan Melia on June 12, 1998. The Inquiry named them, with Kathleen Grundy, as "Shipman's last three victims," killed after a police investigation into him had been closed.

Hilda Hibbert was 81 and died in January 1996, shortly after Shipman visited her at home. In January 2001 the South Manchester coroner, John Pollard, recorded that she had been unlawfully killed, saying it "beggared belief" that any other conclusion could be reached. Her granddaughter, Jane Ashton-Hibbert, campaigned for years to have her death examined. "Murder is murder and I have got to continue fighting for her," she said.

Valerie Cuthbert died at her home in May 1996 after Shipman called to treat an inflamed bunion; he returned later the same day and alerted her relatives to her death. The coroner recorded unlawful killing in January 2001.

Bertha Moss was a 68-year-old widow who died in June 1995 on a treatment bed in Shipman's surgery, of what was recorded as a heart attack. Her daughter remembered her as caring and said she "loved dancing." The family was upset that she was not on the charge sheet.

Mary Hamer was 81. Her daughter told CBS News in 2002 that her mother had been given a lethal injection on the couch in Shipman's surgery. Elizabeth Baddeley, 83, was killed in 1997, her daughter Kathleen Wood said. Lizzie Adams was 77 when she died in 1997; her friend Bill Catlow, then 90, still spoke for her when Shipman died. Dorothea Renwick was 90; her daughter, Thea Morgan, was among the relatives who spoke out in 2004.

Renate Overton was given an overdose of diamorphine, or possibly morphine, with intent to kill, the Inquiry found. She survived for 14 months in a persistent vegetative state and died in April 1995. A pathologist's autopsy wrongly attributed the death to natural causes and the coroner held no inquest. The death of Charles Barlow was also investigated by a coroner and wrongly put down to natural causes.

In March 1998, while the coroner and the police were looking into his death rate, three more of his patients died: Lily Higgins on March 17, Ada Warburton on March 20, and Martha Marley on March 24. The Inquiry found that Shipman had killed Mrs Higgins and Miss Warburton.

Signs that were missed

In Hyde, some people had noticed. Sitford later wrote that by 1998 an undertaker had been checking the bodies of his patients for signs of violence, that a taxi driver had kept a log of regular customers he had lost over seven years, and that home helps had called Shipman "Dr Death" as a joke for two years.

The undertakers were Frank Massey and Son. Deborah Bambroffe, born Deborah Massey, who worked in the family firm, saw a pattern in the deaths: elderly women who had died at home, apparently alone, found sitting in a chair, fully dressed, who had not seemed to be ill. Shipman often seemed to have been there at the time of death or shortly after. She took her concerns to the doctors of the Brooke Practice, another Hyde practice, though she did not want her name passed to the coroner. Her father, Alan Massey, did not at first share her worries. On April 2, 1998, he visited Shipman at the surgery.

Dr Reynolds goes to the coroner

Dr Linda Reynolds was a principal at the Brooke Practice, which had about 9,500 patients. Shipman, practicing alone, had about 3,000. Under the cremation rules then in force, a second doctor had to complete a confirmatory certificate, known as Form C, before a body could be cremated, and the Brooke doctors regularly signed Shipman's. They estimated that his death rate was at least three times theirs and possibly eight or nine times higher.

On March 24, 1998, Dr Reynolds telephoned John Pollard, the coroner for Greater Manchester South. She told him that in the previous three months Shipman had signed 16 cremation certificates, while her own much larger practice had recorded 14 deaths, later corrected to 15. Her main concern, the Inquiry found, was that Shipman might be killing his patients. Mr Pollard referred the matter to the police the same day.

The first police investigation

Chief Superintendent David Sykes, commander of the Tameside division of Greater Manchester Police, gave the inquiry to Detective Inspector David Smith. He did not seek advice from the force's senior detective, Detective Superintendent Bernard Postles, who was on leave, and he gave DI Smith little direction and no supervision. DI Smith worked alone and kept few notes.

He interviewed Dr Reynolds on March 24. On March 26 he went to the Tameside register office and came away with 19 or 20 copy death certificates, though the staff there said they had handed over 31. On March 26 and 27 Dr Alan Banks, medical adviser to the West Pennine Health Authority, looked at 14 sets of medical records, and on April 1 he reassured the detective. That day DI Smith visited the crematorium at Dukinfield, but he did not ask how the cremation procedures worked or check its records properly. The police did not check whether Shipman had a criminal record and did not contact the GMC, the Canadian Medical Association Journal reported.

On April 15 he met the Massey family. On April 16 he told Dr Reynolds he had found no evidence, and on April 17 he telephoned the coroner to say that the investigation had found nothing of concern. It was closed that day, without a written report.

The Inquiry's Second Report, published in July 2003, found that this was a failure at every level. Of Chief Superintendent Sykes it said: "He should have instructed a suitably experienced detective officer to undertake this unusual and potentially serious investigation." DI Smith had been allowed to close the investigation before it was complete. Dr Banks's "prior knowledge of, and respect for, Shipman made him an unsuitable person to carry out the task of examining the medical records." An autopsy with toxicology tests, ordered by the coroner on Mrs Higgins or Miss Warburton before their cremations on March 25 and March 30, would probably have found morphine. Dame Janet also found that DI Smith had "continued to the end to lie" about how he learned of Miss Warburton's death, and that the force should not have waited until 2002 to look searchingly at what went wrong.

Her conclusion was direct: "I think that, if the police and the Coroner had moved with reasonable expedition, the lives of Shipman's last three victims would probably have been saved." Greater Manchester Police apologized to the Grundy family. Angela Woodruff, Kathleen Grundy's daughter, had told the Inquiry that the events of 1998 should be judged by the circumstances of the time, not with hindsight.

Shipman appears to have paused his killing after Alan Massey's visit, the Inquiry found. After the investigation closed, he killed Winifred Mellor on May 11, Joan Melia on June 12, and Kathleen Grundy on June 24.

Kathleen Grundy

On June 24, 1998, Kathleen Grundy was found dead at her home, after a visit from Shipman. He certified her death, and he recorded the cause as old age. On the day she died, a will arrived at Hamilton Ward, a firm of solicitors in Hyde. It appeared to be hers, and it left her whole estate to her doctor and nothing to her daughter or her grandchildren, who had been close to her. Her genuine will left about 386,000 pounds, the Coventry Telegraph reported.

The two people named as witnesses to the signature were patients of Shipman's. Both denied knowing anything about the document.

Angela Woodruff

Angela Woodruff was a solicitor who practiced in Warwick and lived at Harbury, near Leamington, and she handled her mother's legal affairs. She found the new will impossible to believe. Its grammar was poor and its tone curt, nothing like her mother. "My mother thought he was wonderful," she said later. She also found Shipman "strangely vague" about her mother's condition, she told the Inquiry in 2002.

Believing that the doctor might have forged a will, and might therefore have killed her mother, was "a huge gap to cross," she said after the trial. In July 1998 she took her suspicions to a senior officer of Warwickshire Police, who faxed them to Greater Manchester Police. Without what she did, she said, the police would never have known and the deaths would have been seen as natural.

Exhumation and arrest

The second investigation was led by Detective Superintendent Bernard Postles. Kathleen Grundy's body was exhumed from Hyde Cemetery on August 1, 1998, and toxicologists found a large amount of morphine. Police searched Shipman's surgery and found the typewriter on which the forged will had been typed.

On September 7, 1998, Shipman was arrested and charged with Kathleen Grundy's murder and with offenses connected with the forged will. He was remanded the next day to HMP Manchester. At his trial, Shipman suggested that Mrs Grundy might have been a secret drug addict.

The story first became public when the Manchester Evening News reported, about three weeks after the exhumation, that police were investigating Mrs Grundy's death; police then admitted they were looking at 20 deaths. Mikaela Sitford, who had been on the patch for four months, went to the surgery. Shipman told her, "I have no comment," and gave her the telephone number of the Medical Defence Union.

The investigation widened to other patients who had died suddenly. Police exhumed 12 bodies, ITV News later reported. Morphine was found in nine of the exhumed women; six other women in the case had been cremated, RTÉ and the Associated Press reported. By the time of the trial, police had opened investigations into more than 120 other deaths, Newsweek reported. Shipman was suspended and charged with 14 further murders, the Gosport Independent Panel's report records, bringing the total to 15.

Trial at Preston

The trial opened at Preston Crown Court on October 5, 1999, before Mr Justice Forbes. Shipman, then 53, stood in the dock for 15 minutes before legal argument began, and the jury was not sworn until the following week. He had pleaded not guilty to every charge.

Richard Henriques QC led the prosecution. He told the jury that Shipman had killed because he enjoyed "exercising the ultimate power of controlling life and death," and that he had "repeated the act so often that he must have found the drama of taking life to his taste." The women, aged 49 to 81, had been certified by Shipman as dying of old age, cancer and other natural causes. The prosecution said the killings had begun in March 1995. The jury also heard about the computer entries and the forged will.

Nicola Davies QC led the defense. She argued that many of the women had illnesses that could have killed them. Shipman gave evidence himself, leaning forward in the witness box and speaking slowly, an Associated Press reporter wrote. He said he had not injected the women and could not explain their deaths. "I was not aware I had got away with anything," he said.

The trial lasted 58 days by the count of the Manchester Evening News reporter who covered it; Newsweek gave it as 59. It was then the largest murder trial in British history, the Coventry Telegraph later wrote.

Verdict and sentence

The jury of seven men and five women reached its verdicts on the sixth day of deliberations. On January 31, 2000, it found Shipman guilty of all 15 murders and of forging Kathleen Grundy's will. Mr Justice Forbes called him "evil and wicked" and described the murders as a "calculated and cold-blooded perversion" of his medical skills. He passed 15 life sentences, with four years for the forgery to run concurrently, and said he would recommend that Shipman spend the remainder of his days in prison.

Only after the verdicts was it reported that he had a drug conviction from 1976.

On the Tuesday evening after the verdicts, hundreds of people went to a prayer service at St George's Church in Hyde. "People are still reeling," said the curate, John Harries. "They are still in shock and are looking for something to hold on to." Margaret Walker, who had lost friends, said: "It is very sad. There is no other way to describe it because he was so well liked." Father Denis Maher of St Paul's Church told a reporter, "There is little healing in our town."

The General Medical Council's Professional Conduct Committee removed his name from the medical register.

The questions after the verdict

On February 1, 2000, the Health Secretary, Alan Milburn, told the House of Commons that he was setting up an independent inquiry, whose main purpose would be to recommend how patients could be better protected. Shipman, he said, had "betrayed the trust of his own patients." As a first step the government ordered a clinical audit of Shipman's practice, covering deaths, prescriptions and records.

The inquiry was at first to be held in private under Lord Laming, and it began on March 10, 2000. Families of the dead and the media went to the High Court, which ruled in their favor and asked the government to reconsider. In September 2000 the Health Secretary announced a public inquiry under the Tribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) Act 1921, and Parliament approved it in January 2001. Dame Janet Smith, a High Court judge, began work in February 2001.

Prosecutors had considered bringing 23 more murder charges in May 2000 but did not proceed, believing he could not now get a fair trial, Reuters reported. Families of patients who were not among the 15 felt shut out. Jayne Gaskill, whose mother was Bertha Moss, said her family was upset that her mother had not been on the charge sheet.

The Baker audit

Professor Richard Baker's audit, a 156-page report for the Chief Medical Officer, was released by the Department of Health on January 5, 2001. Comparing Shipman with similar practices, he found 297 more deaths certified by Shipman than would have been expected over his career, and 236 more deaths at home or on practice premises than expected, a figure he considered more likely to reflect the deaths in suspicious circumstances. Of deaths from 1985 on for which information survived, he classed 166 as highly suspicious and 43 as moderately suspicious. The excess was greatest among women aged 75 or over.

Professor Liam Donaldson, the Chief Medical Officer, said a doctor with Shipman's motivations was "a once-in-a-lifetime occurrence." Detective Superintendent Postles said the figures were broadly consistent with the deaths police had investigated. Baker stressed that the evidence was circumstantial and further prosecutions unlikely. Families learned of the numbers through the news. Peter Wagstaff said they had expected the audit to cover only Shipman's access to drugs and his records.

Inquests

Between August 2000 and April 2001, the South Manchester coroner held inquests into the deaths of 27 of Shipman's patients. He recorded unlawful killing in 25 and open verdicts in two. On May 18, 2001, he opened inquests into a further 232 deaths, which were then left to the Inquiry.

At the inquest into Hilda Hibbert's death in January 2001, Mr Pollard said it "beggared belief" that she had died of anything other than unlawful killing. John Pollard later offered his own view of the motive: that Shipman "simply enjoyed viewing the process of dying and enjoyed the feeling of control over life and death."

The Shipman Inquiry

The Inquiry had four tasks: to establish the extent of Shipman's unlawful activities; to examine the actions of the bodies and people involved in the procedures and investigations after his patients' deaths; to examine how primary care and controlled drugs were monitored; and to recommend how patients could be protected in future.

At its first public session in Manchester, in May 2001, Dame Janet said she would examine the deaths of 466 patients, a figure that could rise and was not an estimate of how many he had killed. "There will be several hundred deaths in which I can say yes or no," she said. "I hope that will bring a sense of closure." Shipman declined to take part. In May 2001, at Halifax police station, he was questioned about the Todmorden deaths; Peter Devine and Chris McCafferty watched as he refused to answer and turned his chair to face the wall.

Phase one hearings began on June 20, 2001, and phase two, which began with the police investigation of March 1998, on May 7, 2002. By early 2002 Dame Janet had reviewed more than 800 deaths. Documents found late forced her to reopen some cases and delayed her report.

The First Report

The First Report, Death Disguised, was published on July 19, 2002. It examined 887 deaths of Shipman's patients and the case of one living patient. Dame Janet found that he had killed at least 215 of them: 171 women and 44 men, aged from 41 to 93, between 1975 and 1998. In 45 more cases she found a "real suspicion" but not enough evidence for a positive finding, and in 38 there was too little information to form any view. She found one victim in Todmorden, 71 in his years at Donneybrook and 143 at Market Street.

On motive she reached no clear conclusion. "It is possible that he was addicted to killing," she said. She found no evidence of a financial motive except in the Grundy case and no suggestion of sexual depravity. "He betrayed their trust in a way and to an extent that I believe is unparalleled in history," she said.

Earlier that month the Home Secretary, David Blunkett, ruled that Shipman should never be released.

Police, coroners and certificates

Dame Janet's Second Report, on the police investigation of March 1998, and her Third Report, on death certification and coroners, were published together on July 14, 2003.

The Third Report found that the systems for certifying deaths and for reporting them to coroners "had failed to both deter Shipman from killing his patients and to detect his crimes after they had been committed." A doctor effectively decided whether a death went to the coroner, an arrangement she said was "not satisfactory and should not be allowed to continue." The second cremation certificate, Form C, was "wholly inadequate as a safeguard against concealed wrongdoing." Shipman lied to the doctors who signed his Form Cs, and they believed him; she criticized six of the ten Hyde doctors who had signed them. At the Dukinfield crematorium, one medical referee, Dr Betty Hinchliffe, had authorized the cremation of 176 of his patients, 107 of whom he had killed, in what the report described as "essentially a clerical check."

She recommended that the coroner system be "retained, but in a form entirely different from at present," with medically qualified coroners, judicial coroners and trained investigators, and a single system of certification for every death, whether followed by burial or cremation. The report also observed that Shipman had "killed more people than any other serial killer yet identified."

Controlled drugs and the GMC

The Fourth Report, published on July 14, 2004, dealt with controlled drugs. It recommended stronger controls on how they were prescribed and on tracking them from prescriber to dispenser to patient, the NHS Business Services Authority records. In December 2004 the government accepted that the systems could be strengthened, provided patients' access to the drugs was not hindered.

The Fifth Report, published on December 9, 2004, examined how complaints about family doctors were handled and the work of the General Medical Council. It found that the GMC was not directly responsible for Shipman's crimes, because it never had enough information to uncover the murders, The Irish Times reported. But she found that its culture "has focused too much on being fair to doctors and not sufficiently on the need to protect patients," and that the reluctance of doctors to report colleagues persisted. "It must go," she said. "There can be no room today for protection of colleagues when the safety and welfare of patients are at stake."

The Final Report

The sixth and last report, Shipman: The Final Report, was published at Manchester Town Hall on January 27, 2005. It dealt with Pontefract, with three further cases in Hyde, and with a claim that Shipman had confessed to a fellow inmate at Preston prison. It raised the estimated total to about 250 patients between 1971 and 1998, of whom 218 were positively identified.

The same day the Health Secretary, John Reid, announced a review, led by the Chief Medical Officer, of how doctors' fitness to practice was assessed and of the GMC's role.

Prison

Shipman was held on remand at HMP Manchester, moving to Preston on September 9, 1998, to Liverpool on October 14, 1998, and back to Manchester on November 13, 1998. After his conviction he went to HMP Frankland in County Durham on February 7, 2000, and stayed there until June 18, 2003, when he was moved to HMP Wakefield, the high-security prison in West Yorkshire, as a category A prisoner. He was held in a single cell in both prisons.

He was put on the prison service's suicide and self-harm monitoring four times: on first remand, at his trial, after bad news about his pension, and when he was told his pension would be forfeited. The last was opened on July 17, 2002, and closed on August 30, 2002. He kept a diary, and on March 27, 2001, he wrote: "I'm looking at dying, the only question is when and can I hide it from everyone?" He spoke repeatedly of suicide as a possibility once his appeals had failed and his wife was financially secure. Frankland did not pass that full history on to Wakefield, the Ombudsman later found.

At Wakefield he played cards each evening with a small group of prisoners and studied English literature; fellow inmates said he gave them informal medical advice and talked of researching a book on Napoleon, the Yorkshire Post reported.

The pension

On July 17, 2002, the Health Secretary ordered the forfeiture of Shipman's own benefits under the NHS pension scheme. His wife's survivor benefits were left payable, but she would receive nothing while he lived. The lump sum due to her on his death would fall each year after his 60th birthday and would not be payable at all after 65. He said he would not kill himself until the pension question was resolved.

In December 2003 his privilege level was cut to "basic" at an annual review. He lost the television in his cell and the right to wear his own clothes, and his visits were cut to two half-hour visits every 28 days. His appeal against that decision was turned down on December 17, though the board noted his willingness to do personal development work. On January 8, 2004, he was restored to the standard level. The Ombudsman found that the marks used to downgrade him had been harsh and that he should not have been on the basic regime at all.

January 13, 2004

On January 12, 2004, Shipman sent out five letters and telephoned his wife as usual; nothing unusual was noticed. At about 6.10 on the morning of January 13, an officer doing the roll count found him hanging from his cell window, by a ligature made from bed linen. Staff tried to resuscitate him for about half an hour. No ambulance was called. A doctor, called at 6.43, arrived at about 8.00 and pronounced him dead at 8.10. He was 57. The Prison Service gave the time he was found as 6.20.

"He was showing no signs whatsoever of pre-suicidal behaviour," a Prison Service spokeswoman said. The police had been given the wrong address for Primrose Shipman, and she learned of his death from a relative who had heard it on the radio, the Ombudsman reported.

His solicitor, Giovanni di Stefano, said Shipman had been planning an appeal against his convictions and that his death was surprising. Bernard Postles, who had retired the previous June, said there had been a "real possibility" that Shipman would one day confess. "Unfortunately, that never came to pass and he's now dead and taken the secrets to his grave," he said.

The families' reaction

"He has won again. He has taken the easy way out," said Jayne Gaskill, Bertha Moss's daughter. Jane Ashton-Hibbert told Sky News he had taken the easy way out and that he had never shown remorse. Thea Morgan, Dorothea Renwick's daughter, said: "I want to see the end of him but I think he should have stayed in his cell and rotted." Bill Catlow said of the man who had killed his friend Lizzie Adams: "I am glad that he has gone." Kathleen Wood, whose mother Elizabeth Baddeley died in 1997, said she was not sorry but that the news had brought the pain back, and that an admission would have eased many minds. Ann Alexander, a solicitor for about 200 relatives, said many would feel cheated of ever learning why.

In Parliament in 2007, Chris McCafferty said his death had "robbed all those families of the one thing that he could have given them: the truth."

Inquiries into his death

The Prisons Minister, Paul Goggins, asked the Prisons and Probation Ombudsman, Stephen Shaw, to investigate. His report, submitted in March 2004 and published in anonymized form in May 2005, concluded that on the evidence available the death "could not have been predicted or prevented." It found no evidence for prisoners' claims that officers had pressured Shipman or told him to kill himself. It criticized the failure to call paramedics, the delay in calling a doctor and the use of rigor mortis as a reason to stop resuscitation, and it made 17 recommendations. It found nothing in the pension position to explain why he died when he did.

An inquest was opened and adjourned at Wakefield before the coroner David Hinchliff in late January 2004, after two post-mortem examinations found the death consistent with hanging. The full inquest was held at Leeds Crown Court in 2005 and lasted ten days. The jury, three men and five women, returned a narrative verdict that Shipman killed himself because he could not face spending the rest of his life in prison. It heard that he had threatened suicide several times, that he had made it known he would kill himself once his wife's pension was settled, and that if he died before 60 his wife would receive a widow's pension and the maximum lump sum. One prisoner from his card group, who gave evidence at the inquest, claimed that two officers had offered Shipman rope, the Yorkshire Post reported; the Ombudsman found no evidence to support such claims.

In the days after his death, the Department of Health confirmed that Primrose Shipman would receive survivor benefits, a lump sum and a regular pension, which she would not have received had he lived past 60.

Reforms

The government set out its response to the six reports in February 2007, in a paper called Learning from tragedy, keeping patients safe. Its foreword described Shipman as a respected Hyde doctor who over 20 or more years "was responsible for the murder of around 250 of his patients," and it noted that the Inquiry had found he "did let his guard slip" several times, leaving clues that were missed.

Controlled drugs came first. Every health organisation was required to appoint an accountable officer for the safe management of controlled drugs, under section 3 of the Health Act 2006 and regulations made that year. On medical regulation, the government proposed an independent tribunal for final decisions on doctors' fitness to practice, the civil standard of proof in such cases, and a stronger system of appraisal and revalidation. A draft Coroners Bill had been published in June 2006. The government also accepted the principle of independent medical examiners who would check the cause of every death not referred to a coroner, for burials as well as cremations.

The statutory medical examiner system and the new death certification rules came into force across England and Wales on September 9, 2024, the Welsh government announced, noting that the Shipman Inquiry had first proposed medical examiners in 2003.

Hyde

A memorial garden for Shipman's victims, the Garden of Tranquillity, was opened in Hyde Park, Hyde, with Angela Woodruff among the relatives at the ceremony. In January 2001 his former surgery on Market Street was still busy as a practice, which hoped to move from the site; when he died, someone had written "Justice" twelve times on its metal shutters.

In November 2013 it emerged that Greater Manchester Police had disposed of tissue samples taken from exhumed victims, which had been kept in case Shipman or his family appealed, without telling the families. The force had decided in February 2011 to dispose of them because there had been no legal challenge. The chief constable, Sir Peter Fahy, said officers had "agonised" over whether to tell the families and had chosen not to, to spare them further distress. In June 2017 the Independent Police Complaints Commission found that the force had acted within the law and its policies, and that no officer had a case to answer.

Dr Linda Reynolds died of cancer weeks after Shipman's conviction. Angela Woodruff died in 2018. In 2020 the BBC broadcast a three-part documentary series, The Shipman Files: A Very British Crime Story, which asked whether deference to doctors and attitudes to old age had let him go undetected.

No court and no inquiry established why Shipman killed. The prosecution's case was that he enjoyed the power of life and death. The coroner thought he enjoyed watching the process of dying. Dame Janet suggested he might have been addicted to killing. He never confessed, and he refused to cooperate with the police or the Inquiry after his conviction. Profilers found no sadism or sexual perversion, CBS News reported. Speculation that his mother's death shaped him, or that he killed for gain, has no support in any finding beyond the single forged will.

Disputed and unproven points

Proven by final conviction: the murders of 15 women patients in Hyde between March 1995 and June 1998, among them Kathleen Grundy and Kathleen Wagstaff, and the forgery of Kathleen Grundy's will. His solicitor said in January 2004 that he had been planning an appeal against the convictions.

Found by the Shipman Inquiry, never tried: at least 215 killings in the First Report (2002), and about 250 between 1971 and 1998 in the Final Report (2005), of which 218 were identified, including Eva Lyons in Todmorden in 1975 and an estimated 10 to 15 patients at Pontefract. These are findings on the evidence, made by a judge sitting without a jury, not convictions. Coroners recorded unlawful killing in 25 deaths.

Figures that vary between sources: the number of deaths the Inquiry examined (466 at the outset; 494 and 887 in different news reports of the First Report); the Grundy estate (386,000 pounds in most reports, 375,000 in a 2020 report, "almost 400,000" in another); the length of the trial (58 or 59 days); the year his drug conviction came (1976 in the British Medical Journal and the Irish Times; 1975 in one medical journal report); the population of Hyde (22,000 in Associated Press reports; about 35,000 in one American newspaper summary); and the time he was found dead (about 6.10 by the Ombudsman's account, 6.20 by the Prison Service's). For Pontefract, reports give the period of the questioned deaths as 1970 to 1974 or 1971 to 1974.

Unproven claims: a fellow prisoner's claim that officers offered Shipman a rope was not supported by the Ombudsman's investigation. A claimed confession to a fellow inmate at Preston prison was examined in the Final Report. Some later reports state wrongly that he was convicted of 16 murders, or of killing 215; he was convicted of 15.

Timeline

January 14, 1946: Harold Frederick Shipman is born in Nottingham.

1966: marries Primrose May Oxtoby while a medical student at Leeds.

1970: graduates from Leeds University Medical School; junior posts at Pontefract General Infirmary until 1974.

1974: joins a general practice in Todmorden, West Yorkshire.

March 1975: Eva Lyons, 70, dies in Todmorden; the Inquiry later finds he killed her.

1975 to 1976: his pethidine use is discovered; convicted in 1976 of drug and prescription offenses and fined; treated at The Retreat, York; reported to the GMC, which takes no further action.

Mid-1970s to 1977: clinical medical officer in County Durham.

1977: joins the Donneybrook practice in Hyde.

August 1992: begins practicing alone at 21 Market Street, Hyde.

March 1995: the first of the killings for which he would be convicted, according to the prosecution.

April 1995: Renate Overton dies after 14 months in a persistent vegetative state; the Inquiry finds he gave her an overdose.

December 1997: Kathleen Wagstaff, 81, dies.

March 24, 1998: Dr Linda Reynolds reports her concerns to the coroner, John Pollard, who calls in the police.

April 17, 1998: the first police investigation is closed.

May 11, June 12 and June 24, 1998: Winifred Mellor, Joan Melia and Kathleen Grundy die.

July 1998: Angela Woodruff reports the suspected forgery.

August 1, 1998: Kathleen Grundy's body is exhumed; morphine is found.

September 7, 1998: Shipman is arrested and charged with her murder and the forgery.

October 5, 1999: the trial opens at Preston Crown Court.

January 31, 2000: convicted of 15 murders and forgery; 15 life sentences.

February 1, 2000: Alan Milburn announces an inquiry.

February 7, 2000: moved to HMP Frankland.

August 2000 to April 2001: inquests into 27 deaths; 25 verdicts of unlawful killing.

January 5, 2001: the Baker audit finds 297 excess deaths.

February 2001: Dame Janet Smith begins work; hearings open June 20, 2001.

July 2002: David Blunkett rules he should never be released; his NHS pension benefits are forfeited on July 17.

July 19, 2002: First Report finds he killed at least 215 patients.

June 18, 2003: moved to HMP Wakefield.

July 14, 2003: Second and Third Reports published.

December 2003: privileges cut to basic; restored January 8, 2004.

January 13, 2004: found hanged in his cell at Wakefield.

July 14, 2004: Fourth Report (controlled drugs).

December 9, 2004: Fifth Report (complaints and the GMC).

January 27, 2005: Final Report concludes he killed about 250 patients, 218 identified.

2005: inquest at Leeds Crown Court returns a narrative verdict.

May 2005: Ombudsman's report on his death published.

February 2007: the government's response to the Inquiry.

February 2011: police decide to dispose of retained tissue samples; disclosed November 2013.

June 2017: the IPCC finds no officer has a case to answer over the tissue.

2020: The Shipman Files broadcast on the BBC.

September 9, 2024: statutory medical examiners begin checking deaths in England and Wales.