Shani Warren was 26 years old and lived in Stoke Poges, in south Buckinghamshire, when she was killed at Taplow over the Easter weekend of 1987. Her death defeated a full murder inquiry and stayed open for more than three decades. In June 2021 Thames Valley Police arrested Donald Robertson, a Slough man who was already in prison for another offense, and in May 2022 a jury at Reading Crown Court convicted him of her murder, false imprisonment and indecent assault. The same jury convicted him of kidnapping a girl of 16 in Slough in July 1981, together with a further offense against her. He refused to attend any part of his trial. On May 19, 2022, he was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 30 years.
She grew up in a close family in south Buckinghamshire. Her parents lived in Gerrards Cross, a few miles from her own home, and she saw them every few days, joining her mother on shopping trips and going on holidays with them as an adult. She went to grammar school, and her parents kept a photograph of her first day there, at the age of eleven.
She was determined to stand on her own. She refused to work in the family's business and built her career herself, and she was frustrated by employers who did not keep their promises. When her father bought her a small house in Stoke Poges, she insisted on paying him rent, took in lodgers to cover it, and began putting money aside to repay him for the car he had also bought her. She had a dry, observational sense of humour and a busy social life, and she spent many evenings with friends talking over her plans. She had been through some disappointing relationships and hoped one day to have a family of her own.
She died over the Easter weekend of 1987 and was found dead at Taplow. The offenses of which Robertson was later convicted were dated between April 16 and April 19, 1987.
Thames Valley Police treated the death as suspicious from the start. The pathologist who carried out the original post-mortem examination concluded that she had taken her own life. Detectives did not accept that conclusion and ran a murder investigation, but it produced no charge, and the case passed into the force's files as unsolved. Her family lived for the next 34 years without an answer, and both of her parents died in 2021, months before anyone was brought to court.
Robertson lived in Slough, across the county line in Berkshire, and both of the cases eventually brought against him in 2021 arose while he lived there. By the spring of 1987 he already had a criminal record for offenses against girls.
In July 1981 a girl of 16 was kidnapped in Slough and subjected to a further offense. Robertson was arrested at the time and was a suspect, but no charge followed: the identification parade procedures then in force left police without enough evidence to take the case further. Days after police released him over that matter, he committed an offense against a teenage girl in Farnham Royal, in south Buckinghamshire. He pleaded guilty to that offense in 1981.
Less than two months after the Taplow killing, in June 1987, he committed an offense against another teenage girl. That case also went unsolved for years, until Thames Valley Police's cold case team reopened it, and in 2010 Robertson was convicted of it. In April 1990 he had been convicted of burglary with intent, together with kidnapping. When he was arrested in 2021, he was in prison serving a life sentence.
Thames Valley Police set up a dedicated cold case unit, the Major Crime Review Team, in 2007. Its first review of the Taplow death failed to identify a suspect.
The breakthrough came between 2019 and 2020, when renewed scientific examination of material preserved since 1987 pointed to Robertson. The same review returned to the 1981 kidnapping in Slough, and retesting of material from that case linked him to it as well.
On June 22, 2021, officers arrested Robertson on suspicion of the murder and of the 1981 offenses. On November 26, 2021, he was charged with murder, indecent assault and false imprisonment, and with the kidnapping of the 16-year-old and a further offense against her. He was remanded in custody to await trial.
The trial opened at Reading Crown Court on April 29, 2022. Robertson had told his barristers to enter pleas of not guilty to every count, and then he declined to come into court at all. The dock stood empty throughout. The girl kidnapped in 1981, now an adult, came to court and gave evidence against him. Robertson did not give evidence, and the defense called no witnesses.
On May 17, 2022, the jury returned unanimous verdicts of guilty on all five counts: the murder, false imprisonment and indecent assault of the woman killed at Taplow, and the kidnapping of the girl in 1981 together with the further offense against her. Robertson was 66.
On May 19, 2022, the judge sentenced him to life imprisonment for the murder, with a minimum term of 30 years. Concurrent terms of ten years each were imposed for the false imprisonment and for the two offenses against the girl in 1981, and eight years for the indecent assault. Robertson stayed away from the sentencing hearing as he had stayed away from the trial, and sentence was passed in his absence. As of May 2022 he was serving that sentence in England.
Robertson denied every charge, gave no evidence and offered no account of his movements in April 1987, so his own version of events is not on record. His motive was never established in court.
The original post-mortem conclusion that she had taken her own life was the basis for years of doubt about her death. The jury's verdicts settled the question in law: she was murdered, and Robertson was the man who murdered her.
July 1981: A girl of 16 is kidnapped in Slough. Robertson is arrested but not charged.
1981: Robertson pleads guilty to an offense against a teenage girl in Farnham Royal.
April 1987 (Easter weekend): A young woman of Stoke Poges is found dead at Taplow. Thames Valley Police open a murder investigation; no one is charged.
June 1987: Robertson commits an offense against another teenage girl.
April 1990: Robertson is convicted of burglary with intent, together with kidnapping.
2007: Thames Valley Police set up the Major Crime Review Team; its first review of the Taplow case identifies no suspect.
2010: Robertson is convicted of the June 1987 offense after a cold case review.
2019 to 2020: Renewed scientific examination of material from 1987 points to Robertson.
2021: Her parents die.
June 22, 2021: Robertson is arrested on suspicion of the murder and the 1981 offenses.
November 26, 2021: He is charged and remanded in custody.
April 29, 2022: The trial opens at Reading Crown Court.
May 17, 2022: A unanimous jury convicts him on all five counts.
May 19, 2022: Life imprisonment with a minimum term of 30 years.