Doc Holliday

Victims
1 death attributed to him (Tom McLaury, Tombstone, 1881), held justified at a preliminary hearing; never convicted of any killing.
Years active
October 26, 1881 to March 20, 1882
Location
Tombstone, Arizona Territory (killing); Tucson, Arizona Territory (killing); Griffin, Georgia (birth); Leadville, Colorado (trial); Glenwood Springs, Colorado (death)
Method
Shot (Tom McLaury: Wyatt Earp's sworn statement; Spicer held the homicides justified); Stilwell: shot by the Earp party (coroner's jury; never tried).
Status
Discharged November 30, 1881 ("no sufficient cause"); Colorado refused extradition on the Stilwell charge, 1882. Died untried of tuberculosis at Glenwood Springs, Colorado, November 8, 1887.

John Henry Holliday was a Georgia dentist who spent the last fifteen years of his short life dealing cards across the frontier West, and he is remembered for about thirty seconds of it. On the afternoon of October 26, 1881, in Tombstone, Arizona Territory, he stood beside Virgil, Wyatt and Morgan Earp when the city marshal set out to disarm four men of the cattle-country faction known in town as the Cowboys. When it was over, Billy Clanton and the brothers Frank and Tom McLaury were dead, and Virgil and Morgan Earp were badly hurt. Wyatt Earp later swore that it was Holliday who killed Tom McLaury.

Holliday was charged with murder three days later, along with the three Earps, on a complaint sworn by Ike Clanton, the one member of the group who walked away. After a month of testimony before Justice of the Peace Wells Spicer, the defendants were discharged on November 30, 1881, with the finding that there was "no sufficient cause to believe" them guilty and that they had been "fully justified in committing these homicides." Four months later a coroner's jury in Tucson named Holliday among the men responsible for the death of Frank Stilwell, and Arizona sought his return on a murder charge. Colorado's governor refused to give him up. Holliday was never tried for any killing. He died of tuberculosis at Glenwood Springs, Colorado, on November 8, 1887, at 36.

Around those facts grew a reputation far larger than the record. In life he was credited with as many as thirty-five killings. Of all the deaths laid to him, only one, Tom McLaury's, rests on sworn testimony given at the time, and the rest of the list has fallen away claim by claim.

Griffin and Valdosta

Holliday was born on August 14, 1851, in Griffin, Georgia, the only son of Henry Burroughs Holliday and Alice Jane McKey Holliday. His father was a planter, lawyer and politician, and the family were of Scots-Irish descent and comfortably middle class. He was baptized at First Presbyterian Church in Griffin on March 21, 1852.

In 1864, when he was about twelve, the family left Griffin ahead of the Union advance and settled at Valdosta, in south Georgia, then a raw town of perhaps four years' standing, with wooden buildings and unpaved lanes. His father went on to serve twice as Valdosta's mayor. The boy probably attended the private Valdosta Institute, where the course of study ran to mathematics, science, Greek, Latin and French.

His mother died of tuberculosis on September 16, 1866. She had been the steadying presence in his life, and the loss marked him. His father remarried three months later, taking as his second wife a woman of twenty-three, and relations between father and son cooled. In the family's memory he became the black sheep, a relative seldom spoken of.

Family accounts hold that around 1870 he drove a group of Union soldiers off a water hole on family land and that no one was killed; later versions that turn the episode into a killing, or tie him to a plot against the Lowndes County courthouse, have no evidence behind them.

Philadelphia, Atlanta and a diagnosis

Holliday enrolled in dental college in 1870, with a Valdosta dentist, Lucian Frink, as his preceptor. He wrote his required thesis on diseases of the teeth and received his degree from the Pennsylvania College of Dental Surgery in Philadelphia on March 1, 1872, one of twenty-six graduates that spring.

He began practice in Atlanta in 1872 in partnership with Dr. Arthur C. Ford. Within months he learned that he had tuberculosis, the disease that had killed his mother. His doctors expected him to live only a short time and urged a dry climate. Late in 1872 or early in 1873 he left Georgia for Texas.

Dallas and the gaming tables

The 1873 Dallas city directory lists him in a dental partnership with John Seegar, which was dissolved in March 1874. As his cough worsened, patients fell away, and the faro table, where he dealt as well as played, became his living. In January 1875 a quarrel with a Dallas saloonkeeper ended in a confrontation in which no one was hurt. Holliday left Dallas that year.

For the next four years he moved between frontier towns, practicing dentistry when he could and gambling when he could not. His circuit took in Denver, Cheyenne, Dodge City and Las Vegas, New Mexico Territory. At Fort Griffin, Texas, he was indicted in 1875 for gaming in a saloon. It was at Fort Griffin, in 1877, that he gave Wyatt Earp information that helped Earp trail an outlaw named Dave Rudabaugh, the start of a friendship that lasted the rest of their lives.

In Dodge City in 1878 he opened a practice again and advertised it in the local paper, while Earp served on the city police. By this time he was traveling with Kate Elder, the woman who would come closest of anyone to being his wife, though there is no evidence they ever married. Earp later swore under oath that he was Holliday's friend because Holliday had "saved my life" in Dodge City when he was surrounded by desperadoes.

Tombstone

Silver had been struck in the San Pedro valley in 1877, and by the end of 1879 Tombstone had a mayor and the first of the Earp brothers. Wyatt and Virgil arrived on December 1, 1879, and Virgil became a deputy marshal. Holliday came in the second half of 1880, some months after Morgan Earp, one of many sporting men drawn by the boom.

He made a poor start. In October 1880 a quarrel over cards with another gambler, Johnny Tyler, ended with Holliday returning drunk to the Oriental Saloon, where the proprietor and his partner were both hurt and Holliday was beaten. He pleaded guilty to assault and battery and paid a fine of $20 and $11.25 in costs. The proprietor remained his enemy.

On March 15, 1881, men attempting to rob the Benson stage outside Tombstone killed the driver, Eli "Bud" Philpot, and a passenger, Peter Roerig. Holliday rode with the posse that Virgil Earp led after the robbers. Suspicion nonetheless settled on him. In early July 1881, after a quarrel, Kate Elder swore an affidavit accusing him, and he was arrested on charges of murder and attempted robbery. Virgil Earp arrested her for being drunk and disorderly, and she was fined. Witnesses supported Holliday's account of his movements, and the charges against him were dropped for want of evidence. What the affidavit said is unknown, and she may later have repudiated it.

The stage robbery shaped everything that followed. In June 1881 Wyatt Earp secretly offered Ike Clanton the Wells Fargo reward if Clanton would lead him to the suspects, and Clanton asked whether the money would be paid if the men were brought in dead. Wells Fargo said it would. The suspects all died before Clanton could collect, and the secret deal became a source of fear and grievance on his side. Earp later testified that part of his purpose had been to clear Holliday: catching the real robbers, he told Clanton, would show that Holliday "knew nothing of it."

Ike Clanton and Tom McLaury rode into Tombstone on October 25, 1881, with a wagonload of beef. Clanton spent the evening drinking and gambling. Late that night, in the small hours of October 26, Holliday confronted him at the Alhambra Saloon, convinced that Clanton was spreading talk that Earp had revealed the reward arrangement. Clanton denied it. The two men exchanged threats until Morgan Earp led Holliday out of the room, and Virgil Earp warned them both that they would be arrested if it went on. Clanton later testified that Holliday called him "a son-of-a-bitch of a cowboy" and dared him to fight. Wyatt Earp swore that Holliday "did not want to fight" and wanted only to satisfy himself that the talk had not been made.

October 26, 1881

By the next afternoon Clanton had been arrested and disarmed by Virgil Earp, now chief of police, fined, and released. Wyatt Earp had struck Tom McLaury in a separate confrontation outside the courtroom. Billy Clanton and Frank McLaury had ridden into town, and the four men had been seen arming themselves before moving through the O.K. Corral toward a vacant lot beyond it. Townspeople pressed the marshal to act. Virgil called on his brothers and deputized Holliday to help him disarm the group.

What happened next lasted about thirty seconds. Billy Clanton and both McLaurys were dead or dying within minutes. Virgil and Morgan Earp were badly hurt; Holliday escaped with a minor injury. Ike Clanton, who was unarmed, ran from the scene and survived.

From the moment it ended, the two sides told different stories. In Wyatt Earp's account, the marshal ordered the men to surrender and Billy Clanton and Frank McLaury made to draw; Tom McLaury, he said, reached toward his hip and joined in before Holliday answered, and Holliday killed him. In Ike Clanton's account, Holliday opened the exchange, with Tom McLaury as his target, after Tom had thrown open his coat to show that he was disarmed and while Billy Clanton held his hands up. A witness named Martha King testified that she heard someone in the marshal's party say, "Let them have it," and Holliday reply, "All right."

Whether Tom McLaury was armed was never settled. The Earps believed he was; nothing established afterward showed it.

The coroner, Henry Matthews, held his inquest on October 28. The jury found that the men had died at the hands of the Earps and Holliday, but it assigned no blame. On October 29 Ike Clanton swore out a complaint charging the three Earps and Holliday with the murder of William Clanton, Frank McLaury and Thomas McLaury. Virgil Earp was suspended as chief of police the same day. Wyatt Earp and Holliday were arrested on the warrant. The county sheriff had tried to take them into custody on the afternoon of the deaths and had made no arrest.

Before Justice Spicer

Wells Spicer opened the preliminary hearing on October 31, 1881. The question before him was not guilt or innocence but whether the evidence justified sending the defendants to trial for murder.

Ike Clanton described the prior night's quarrel and went further: the Earps and Holliday, he claimed, belonged to a criminal combine that had been skimming Wells Fargo shipments, and Holliday's anger came from Clanton's knowledge of it. On cross-examination the defense took that story apart.

On November 7 Spicer revoked bail for Wyatt Earp and Holliday and committed them to the county jail, where they stayed for sixteen days. The defense opened on November 16 with a long written statement by Wyatt Earp, read into the record, in which he described the reward deal, the quarrel and the fight, and swore that Holliday had killed Tom McLaury.

The decision

Spicer delivered his decision on November 30, 1881. He found that Ike Clanton had gone about Tombstone armed the day before, publicly threatening the Earps and Holliday. He found that Virgil Earp, as chief of police, had honestly and reasonably believed that the group meant to resist arrest by force, and that the marshal had a duty to disarm them. On the question of felonious intent he called the evidence "anything but clear" and said he could not tell which side had begun.

He wrote that it was "beyond doubt that William Clanton and Frank McLaury were armed." On Tom McLaury he declined to decide: "There is a dispute as to whether Thomas McLaury was armed at all," he wrote, a question he set aside as "not of controlling importance."

In calling on Wyatt Earp and Holliday, he found, Virgil Earp "committed an injudicious and censurable act," but "I can attach no criminality to his unwise act," given the threats made against the Earps. His conclusion followed: "I cannot resist the conclusion that the defendants were fully justified in committing these homicides." The evidence, he said, "would not, in my judgment, warrant a conviction of the defendants by trial jury of any offense whatever." He ordered Wyatt S. Earp and John H. Holliday released, "there being no sufficient cause to believe" them guilty, and noted that the grand jury remained free to review the depositions and indict if it saw fit.

Tucson, March 1882

Spicer's ruling did not end the feud; it moved it outside the courtroom. On the night of December 28, 1881, Virgil Earp was gravely injured in Tombstone and left with an arm he could barely use for the rest of his life. Ike Clanton was widely suspected, but a preliminary hearing on charges against him was dismissed on February 2, 1882, for lack of evidence. On March 18, 1882, Morgan Earp was killed in Tombstone.

Two days later the surviving brothers left town to put the disabled Virgil and his wife on a train for California. Wyatt Earp traveled with them as escort, together with his younger brother Warren, Holliday and two other men. On the night of March 20, 1882, in Tucson, Frank Stilwell, a suspect in Morgan Earp's death, was killed.

Warrants were issued in Pima County the next morning. A Tucson coroner's jury named Wyatt Earp, Warren Earp, Holliday and the two other men of the party as the men responsible for the death. Holliday was never tried for it.

Colorado and the refusal to extradite

By April 1882 Wyatt Earp and Holliday had crossed into New Mexico and then into Colorado. In May 1882 Holliday was held in Colorado, and Arizona asked for his return to face murder charges arising from the events of March. Colorado's governor, Frederick Pitkin, refused the requisition. Holliday stayed in Colorado for the rest of his life, and the Arizona charge was never brought to trial.

He went back to the life he had led before Tombstone, dealing faro in Denver, Pueblo, Gunnison and finally Leadville, where the altitude told on his lungs. On August 19, 1884, in Leadville, a dispute over a five-dollar debt ended with Holliday injuring the man he owed in the arm. Bystanders disarmed him. He was charged and tried, and on March 28, 1885, a Leadville jury found him not guilty, accepting that he had acted in self-defense against a man he believed meant him harm.

In May 1887, with his tuberculosis far advanced, Holliday went to Glenwood Springs, where the sulphur vapors were said to ease diseases of the lungs. He took rooms at the Hotel Glenwood. He was too ill to make much use of the springs and spent his last fifty-seven days in bed, delirious for fourteen of them. He died on the morning of November 8, 1887, at the age of 36.

Disputed and unproven points

The killings credited to him in legend, as many as thirty-five, have no support in any court record, inquest or contemporary newspaper. The claim that he killed a man at Las Vegas, New Mexico Territory, rests on an 1881 newspaper item and an 1886 interview given by Bat Masterson; the man died on July 20, 1879, and the inquest into his death did not mention Holliday.

The claim that he saved Wyatt Earp's life in Dodge City comes from Earp's own sworn statement and finds no echo in the Dodge City newspapers of 1878. The tale of Kate Elder freeing him from jail at Fort Griffin by setting a building ablaze is overstated: he was held in a hotel room, and the fire she set was a shed, as a diversion.

Which side began it on October 26, 1881, was not resolved at the hearing and has not been resolved since; Spicer himself said he could not tell. The theory that Holliday and Morgan Earp opened the exchange by prearrangement was argued by the prosecution and taken apart in court. Ike Clanton's charge that the Earps and Holliday were secretly robbing Wells Fargo was never proved. Later accounts date Spicer's ruling to November 29, November 30 or December 1, 1881; the decision itself is dated November 30.

Timeline

August 14, 1851: John Henry Holliday is born in Griffin, Georgia.

1864: The family moves to Valdosta, Georgia.

September 16, 1866: His mother dies of tuberculosis.

March 1, 1872: He graduates from the Pennsylvania College of Dental Surgery, Philadelphia.

1872: He begins practice in Atlanta and learns he has tuberculosis.

1873: He is listed in a Dallas dental partnership, dissolved in March 1874.

January 1875: A Dallas quarrel with a saloonkeeper ends with no one hurt.

1875: He is indicted at Fort Griffin, Texas, for gaming.

1877: At Fort Griffin he helps Wyatt Earp trail Dave Rudabaugh.

1878: He practices dentistry in Dodge City, Kansas.

1880: He arrives in Tombstone, Arizona Territory.

October 1880: He pleads guilty to assault and battery in Tombstone and is fined.

March 15, 1881: The driver and a passenger die in an attempted robbery of the Benson stage.

July 1881: He is arrested on Kate Elder's affidavit; the charges are dropped.

October 26, 1881: Billy Clanton, Frank McLaury and Tom McLaury die in Tombstone.

October 28, 1881: The coroner's jury assigns no blame.

October 29, 1881: Ike Clanton swears a murder complaint against the Earps and Holliday.

October 31, 1881: The preliminary hearing opens before Justice of the Peace Wells Spicer.

November 7, 1881: His bail is revoked; he is jailed for sixteen days.

November 30, 1881: Spicer discharges the defendants as "fully justified."

December 28, 1881: Virgil Earp is gravely injured in Tombstone.

March 18, 1882: Morgan Earp is killed in Tombstone.

March 20, 1882: Frank Stilwell dies in Tucson; a coroner's jury names Holliday among the men responsible.

May 1882: Colorado's governor refuses Arizona's request for his extradition.

August 19, 1884: A Leadville dispute over a five-dollar debt.

March 28, 1885: A Leadville jury finds him not guilty.

May 1887: He moves to Glenwood Springs, Colorado.

November 8, 1887: He dies of tuberculosis at Glenwood Springs, aged 36.