Dinko Šakić was the commander of the Jasenovac concentration camp in 1944, during the years when the Independent State of Croatia, the wartime state of the Ustasha movement, ran the camp system. He left Croatia when that state collapsed in 1945, settled in Argentina, and lived there for about fifty years. In the spring of 1998, after he spoke about his command on Argentine television, he was arrested and sent back to Croatia. On October 4, 1999, the Zagreb County Court found him guilty of a war crime against the civilian population and sentenced him to twenty years in prison, the maximum the law allowed. The court held him responsible for the deaths of at least 2,000 prisoners during his period of command. In September 2000 the Supreme Court of Croatia rejected his appeal and upheld the judgment. He died in Zagreb on July 20, 2008, still serving the sentence.
Šakić was born on September 8, 1921, in Studenci, a village near Perušić in the Lika region of Croatia. He was nineteen when the Independent State of Croatia was proclaimed in April 1941 and twenty-two when he held command at Jasenovac.
The prosecution would later place his command between April and November of 1944. The court that tried him drew the line more narrowly. Its findings ran from May to the end of October 1944, and it was to those months, and to the prisoners held there in that time, that the judgment attached.
When the Ustasha state fell in 1945, Šakić fled. By 1947 he was living in Argentina, and he stayed there for the next half century. He settled in Santa Teresita, a seaside town in the province of Buenos Aires, about two hundred miles southeast of the capital. His Argentine identity document, issued by the Federal Police, carried the name Ljubomir Šakić Bilanović.
In early April 1998 an Argentine television crew found Šakić in Santa Teresita and interviewed him. In the broadcast, which aired nationally that month, he acknowledged that he had commanded Jasenovac.
The President of Argentina called for his arrest as soon as the program aired, and Šakić left Santa Teresita.
Croatia moved quickly. On April 20, 1998, the Zagreb County Public Prosecutor's Office asked for an investigation. The next day the Zagreb County Court opened the investigation and ordered him detained. On April 24 the Croatian Ministry of Justice sent Argentina a formal request for his extradition.
Within a week an Argentine court had validated the Croatian request, and the police were free to act on it. They arrested Šakić on April 30, 1998, in Santa Teresita, the town he had left a few weeks before.
Two states wanted him. Yugoslavia also asked Argentina to hand Šakić over, and its request competed with Croatia's. The extradition hearing on the Croatian request was held in an Argentine court in the first days of May, and Šakić's lawyer said his client had agreed to it. The Yugoslav request was not taken up at that hearing. A federal judge ordered him sent to Croatia on the ground that the alleged crimes had taken place on Croatian territory. The proceedings ran before the Federal Court in Dolores, and Argentina's executive approved the extradition: by the middle of May the President of Argentina had signed the order. Šakić himself preferred to go to Croatia rather than to Yugoslavia.
He was moved to a prison in Buenos Aires in early May to await transfer. Six weeks passed before the handover. He left Buenos Aires under the extradition order and landed in Zagreb on June 18, 1998.
The case now belonged to the investigating judge of the Zagreb County Court. Šakić was brought before the judge on June 19, the day after his arrival. He said that he understood the charges against him, and beyond that he kept silent, so the questioning ended almost as soon as it began. A pretrial hearing followed within days.
The prosecution turned to the witnesses. Its office announced in late June that interviews would begin the following week, and through the second half of 1998 the investigation gathered evidence from people who had been held at the camp. Many of those survivors lived outside Croatia, in what remained of Yugoslavia and in Bosnia, and much of their evidence was taken as sworn statements before courts in Serbia and in Bosnia rather than in Zagreb.
His wife, also extradited from Argentina, was investigated separately; on February 1, 1999, the prosecutor stopped that investigation for lack of evidence, and she was released.
On December 14, 1998, the prosecutor's office filed its indictment in case K-242/98 before the Zagreb County Court. It charged Šakić with a war crime against the civilian population under Article 120 of the Croatian criminal code, for acts committed as commander of Jasenovac in the months from April to November 1944. The counts covered ordering executions, the torture and inhuman treatment of prisoners, intimidation, collective punishment and forced labor, along with a further count. The indictment also charged that he had personally killed prisoners. If convicted, he faced twenty years in prison, the most the law permitted for the offense.
The prosecution took the position that there were no grounds for a charge of genocide, and none was brought.
The sworn statements taken abroad posed a practical problem for the trial to come. The defense said it would move to strike them because the witnesses could not be cross-examined. The court said it would admit new witnesses until the trial ended.
The trial opened in Zagreb on March 4, 1999, before a panel of seven, headed by the court's presiding judge. That first sitting did not get far. Šakić complained of health problems, the court heard medical evidence that pointed in different directions, and the panel adjourned the proceedings.
The court sat again on March 15. The indictment was read aloud, and Šakić pleaded not guilty. Some seventy journalists filled the courtroom for the reopening.
Over the spring and summer the panel heard the witnesses. More than thirty survivors of the camp testified; most of the people called to the stand had once been prisoners there. The court also heard expert witnesses, among them a historian and a demographer. At the request of the Croatian government, representatives of B'nai B'rith attended the proceedings as official international observers; the organization had also helped find witnesses.
Šakić denied the charges. His lawyers argued that he had obeyed the orders of his superiors.
On July 8, 1999, the prosecution filed an amended indictment. Closing arguments were heard in September 1999. The prosecution asked for the maximum sentence of twenty years. By then the trial had run for six months.
On Monday, October 4, 1999, the seven-judge panel of the Zagreb County Court found Šakić guilty of a war crime against the civilian population. The court found that he had ordered the execution of prisoners. It found that he had maltreated, tortured and killed prisoners and had done nothing to prevent his subordinates from doing the same. It found that he had personally killed four prisoners. And it held him responsible for the deaths of at least 2,000 Serb, Jewish, Roma and other prisoners during his command.
The judgment did not adopt the full span of the indictment. The panel fixed his command at May to the end of October 1944, a shorter period than the prosecution had charged, and its findings rested on those months alone.
The court sentenced him to twenty years in prison, the maximum the law allowed and the penalty the prosecution had sought. He was seventy-eight years old. His defense lawyer said they would appeal to the Supreme Court of Croatia.
The sentence came fifty-five years after the events the court examined.
The defense took the case to the Supreme Court of Croatia, the country's highest court. In September 2000 the Supreme Court rejected every ground of the defense's appeal and upheld the verdict and the twenty-year sentence. The conviction was final. The ruling brought to an end the proceedings that had begun with his extradition from Argentina more than two years earlier.
Šakić served his sentence in Croatia. He died in Zagreb on July 20, 2008, a little more than ten years after his arrest in Santa Teresita and with roughly half of his sentence still to run.
Šakić never accepted the verdict. He denied the charges throughout and argued that he had followed orders. The Zagreb court rejected his account, and the Supreme Court of Croatia upheld its judgment.
Šakić put the length of his command at about a hundred days. The indictment charged a period of roughly seven months, from April to November 1944; the court found that he held command from May to the end of October 1944, and the figure of at least 2,000 deaths attaches to that period.
September 8, 1921: Born in Studenci, near Perušić, Croatia.
May to October 1944: Commands the Jasenovac camp, by the court's finding; the court later holds him responsible for the deaths of at least 2,000 prisoners in this period.
1945: Leaves Croatia as the Ustasha state collapses.
1947: Living in Argentina, later in Santa Teresita.
April 1998: Interviewed on Argentine television; acknowledges his command.
April 20 and 21, 1998: Zagreb prosecutors request an investigation; the Zagreb County Court orders the investigation and his detention.
April 24, 1998: Croatia requests his extradition from Argentina.
April 30, 1998: Arrested in Santa Teresita.
May 1998: An Argentine federal judge orders him sent to Croatia; the President of Argentina signs the extradition order.
June 18, 1998: Extradited to Croatia; lands in Zagreb.
June 19, 1998: Appears before the investigating judge in Zagreb.
December 14, 1998: Indicted for a war crime against the civilian population.
March 4, 1999: Trial opens before the Zagreb County Court and is adjourned the same day.
March 15, 1999: Trial resumes; pleads not guilty.
July 8, 1999: Amended indictment filed.
September 1999: Closing arguments; the prosecution asks for twenty years.
October 4, 1999: Convicted; sentenced to twenty years.
September 2000: The Supreme Court of Croatia rejects the appeal and upholds the verdict and sentence.
July 20, 2008: Dies in Zagreb.