On the morning of Friday, May 18, 2018, ten people died at the high school in Santa Fe, Texas, a small city in Galveston County about 35 miles southeast of Houston. Eight of them were teenagers. Two were adult women. Thirteen others were wounded, among them a school district police officer. Before the morning was out, a 17-year-old who attended the school, Dimitrios Pagourtzis, was in custody. By that night he was charged with capital murder and held without bond.
He has never been tried. In November 2019 a state district judge in Galveston found him mentally incompetent to stand trial, and the following month he was committed to a maximum-security state hospital in Texas. Every year since, the hospital's doctors have reported that his competency has not been restored, and the court has repeatedly sent him back for up to twelve more months. The capital murder indictment returned against him in August 2018 still stands, unanswered by any jury, and the case cannot move until he is able to understand it.
Pagourtzis surrendered to officers that morning. No one else was charged, and within a day investigators said they had concluded that he acted alone. The first count of the wounded was ten; the FBI raised it to thirteen the following day. The school district police officer was among the most seriously hurt, and so was an adult who had been teaching in the building that morning. Both survived.
The eight teenagers who died were classmates of the accused. The two adults who died were Cynthia Tisdale and Glenda Ann Perkins. Tisdale was the center of a large family's gatherings, a woman who loved cooking Thanksgiving dinner and decorating, and her grandchildren called her Grammy. Perkins, known as Ann, had been at the school for years. She loved the beach, had turned her backyard into a tropical garden of palm trees and seashells, and marched in an all-women Galveston Mardi Gras krewe. The young people there remembered that she learned their names and was always smiling.
Pagourtzis was booked into the Galveston County Jail the day of the killings and denied bond on charges of capital murder and aggravated assault. The probable cause affidavit filed that night stated that after his arrest he gave an investigator a statement describing his own part in the killings and saying he had acted alone. That statement has never been tested in court, and no judge or jury has ruled on whether it was lawfully taken. He stayed in the county jail for the next year and a half.
On August 9, 2018, a Galveston County grand jury indicted him on a charge of capital murder of multiple persons, alleging that the deaths occurred during the same criminal transaction. A second count charged aggravated assault on a public servant over the wounding of the school district police officer. In April 2019 federal prosecutors filed charges of their own over the same events; because he was 17 at the time, the federal court treats him as a juvenile, and that case is sealed. It has moved no further than the state case. His age also shaped what any trial could bring: because he was 17 on May 18, 2018, Texas law bars both a death sentence and a sentence of life without the possibility of parole.
In February 2019 the presiding judge agreed with the defense that local publicity made a fair trial in Galveston County unlikely. He moved the trial to Fort Bend County and set it to begin on February 18, 2020. Court papers filed that year showed that the defense intended to raise an insanity defense, a question about his state of mind on May 18, 2018. Before any jury could hear it, a different question, about his state of mind in the present, stopped the case.
In August 2019 his lawyers told the court that his mental health had deteriorated badly since his arrest and that he no longer understood the proceedings against him, and they asked for a competency hearing. Three experts examined him, one for the defense, one appointed by the court and one chosen by the district attorney's office, and all three reached the same conclusion. On November 15, 2019, the judge ruled that Pagourtzis was mentally incompetent to stand trial and committed him to a facility of the Texas Department of State Health Services for treatment aimed at restoring his competency, for no more than 120 days. The February 2020 trial date was postponed indefinitely. In early December 2019 he was moved from the county jail to a state hospital.
The 120 days passed without the result the order was written to produce. In March 2020, and at each yearly review since, hospital doctors reported that he remained incompetent, and the court recommitted him for up to twelve months at a time; the report of January 2026 said the same. In 2023 a newly elected judge ordered an independent evaluation of his competency; the order was challenged, that judge was removed from the case on a defense motion in May 2023, and another Galveston County district judge took it over. By May 2026 Pagourtzis had been held at the hospital for 2,359 days, and the criminal case remained on hold.
In August 2024 a Galveston County jury in a civil suit brought by families and survivors found his parents not liable and found Pagourtzis himself liable for the deaths and injuries.
No court has found that Pagourtzis caused any death. The facts of May 18, 2018, as they bear on his guilt, rest on the indictment, on what investigators said in the first days, and on a probable cause affidavit describing a statement he gave after his arrest. None of that has been tested in a criminal trial. The 2024 civil verdict against him was reached under a civil standard of proof, while he remained hospitalized and incompetent; it is not a criminal finding.
Whether he can ever be restored to competency is itself an open question. Every hospital report since 2019 has said that he cannot be tried, while the court has twice sought, in 2019 and 2023, examinations from outside the defense. No criminal court has ruled on his mental state at the time of the killings.
May 18, 2018: Ten people die and thirteen are wounded at the high school in Santa Fe, Texas. Pagourtzis, 17, surrenders and is taken into custody; that night he is charged with capital murder and aggravated assault and denied bond.
August 9, 2018: A Galveston County grand jury indicts him for capital murder of multiple persons and aggravated assault on a public servant.
February 2019: The trial is moved from Galveston County to Fort Bend County and set for February 18, 2020.
April 2019: Federal charges are filed; the case is sealed because he is treated as a juvenile in federal court.
August 2019: The defense asks for a competency hearing.
November 15, 2019: He is found incompetent to stand trial and committed for up to 120 days; the trial is postponed indefinitely.
December 2019: He is moved to a state hospital.
March 2020 to January 2026: Yearly reports find him still incompetent; the court recommits him for up to twelve months at a time.
2023: A newly elected judge orders an independent competency evaluation and is removed from the case on a defense motion in May; another judge takes it over.
August 2024: A civil jury finds his parents not liable and finds him liable.
May 2026: He has been held at the hospital for 2,359 days; the criminal case remains on hold.