Dimitri Tsafendas

Victims
1 man killed in Parliament, Cape Town, 1966; never tried. The victim was Prime Minister Hendrik Verwoerd. Found unfit to stand trial on the ground of schizophrenia, October 20, 1966
Years active
September 6, 1966
Location
Cape Town; Pretoria; Krugersdorp (South Africa); Lourenco Marques and Beira (Mozambique)
Method
Charged with murder; the case ended at a fitness inquiry without a plea or a verdict
Status
Detained at the State President's pleasure: Robben Island, Pretoria Central and Zonderwater prisons, then Sterkfontein hospital from 1994; died there October 7, 1999

On September 6, 1966, a temporary messenger in the South African Parliament killed the Prime Minister, Hendrik Verwoerd, in the House of Assembly in Cape Town. The messenger was Dimitri Tsafendas, a 48-year-old man born in Portuguese Mozambique who had held the post for a little over a month.

He was never tried. After a three-day inquiry in October 1966, the Supreme Court in Cape Town found him unfit to stand trial on the ground that he suffered from schizophrenia, accepted that he had no political motive, and ordered that he be detained as a State President's patient. Under that order he spent the rest of his life in custody, most of them on the death row section of Pretoria Central Prison, although no court ever convicted him of anything. He died in a psychiatric hospital near Krugersdorp in October 1999, aged 81. Since then, archival research, a petition from five senior South African jurists and a review in a South African medical ethics journal have all questioned the psychiatric evidence that kept him from trial, and the question of what he was, a sick man or a political assassin, has never been settled by any court.

Lourenco Marques

Tsafendas was born on January 14, 1918, in Lourenco Marques, the capital of Portuguese Mozambique, now Maputo. His father was a Greek marine engineer from a Cretan family; his mother was a Mozambican woman of mixed African and European descent. The father held anarchist views, and as a young man Tsafendas discussed anarchist writers with him. He read widely, from Dickens to Zola, and he grew up speaking several languages; by the 1960s he was said to speak eight. Wherever his travels later took him, he taught local children history and English.

Part of his schooling took place across the border. At about ten he went to the Transvaal and attended Middelburg Primary School from 1928 to 1930, then returned to Mozambique and spent two more years at a church school.

His parentage mattered to the rest of his life. In South Africa he was classified as white, the category that later allowed him to live and work in Cape Town under apartheid law. Shortly before September 1966, he applied to be reclassified as Coloured.

Politics came early. As a teenager he lost a job in Mozambique for voicing communist ideas. Portugal's political police, the PIDE, opened a file on him in 1938, when he was about 20, after he was suspected of distributing communist material in Mozambique. That year South Africa refused him a visa. He entered the country without permission anyway, found work as a welder in Johannesburg, and joined the Communist Party of South Africa, remaining a member until about 1942. On June 13, 1942, he left South Africa as a seaman bound for Canada. South Africa barred him from that year, a refusal later tied to his party membership.

The years abroad

For the next two decades Tsafendas moved almost constantly. In Canada he was detained as a deserter and got away from custody. In the United States he was arrested for breaking immigration law, chose prison over a return to sea, and was moved from prison to a mental institution. During the Second World War he also served on American merchant ships carrying war cargo, and he was treated in American hospitals in 1944 and 1945. In 1946 he was admitted to Grafton State Hospital in Massachusetts, one of a series of psychiatric admissions in several countries. In 1947 the United States deported him to Greece, where he joined the communist side in the Greek Civil War.

When he tried to return to Mozambique, the Portuguese authorities held him. In November 1949 he was detained at Barca d'Alva on the Portuguese border, and he spent further months in Lisbon's Aljube prison. In 1951 he entered Mozambique without permission, was arrested, and was sent back to Lisbon and held again. He then lived in exile for about twelve years in Europe and the Middle East.

Those years took him to Denmark, Sweden and West Germany, to England twice, to Istanbul, where he taught at a language college in 1961, and to Crete in 1962. He was in West Germany at the time of the Sharpeville massacre in South Africa in 1960. In 1955 he was a patient at a psychiatric hospital in Hamburg. He was treated in a British hospital in 1959. He received psychiatric treatment in Germany, England and the United States in all, and twice left mental institutions without being discharged. In London in the early 1960s he took part in the anti-apartheid movement and came to know Tennyson Makiwane, the African National Congress representative in England.

Mozambique again, then Cape Town

In 1963 the Portuguese granted him an amnesty, and he returned to Mozambique in October of that year. On November 4, 1963, he entered South Africa on a temporary visa.

He was back in Mozambique a year later, working near Beira. On November 16, 1964, the Portuguese authorities arrested him for subversive propaganda after he spoke publicly in favor of independence. After weeks in custody he was moved to the government hospital in Beira, declared insane, and released on January 19, 1965, as unfit to stand trial. On March 8, 1965, he arrived in Durban from Beira.

By the middle of 1966 he was in Cape Town. In July or August of that year he was taken on as a temporary messenger in Parliament. The post required security clearance, and he obtained it despite his record. The South African Police already held four files on him, and a year before the killing informants had described him as a dangerous communist.

September 6, 1966

The parliamentary session that week was expected to be dominated by the Prime Minister. He had led the country since 1958 and was the chief architect of apartheid, the system of racial separation that he had begun to build as Minister of Native Affairs. Born in the Netherlands and brought to South Africa as a child, he had trained as a psychologist in Germany before entering politics.

On the afternoon of September 6, as the session opened, he killed the Prime Minister in the chamber. Members of Parliament restrained him, and the Prime Minister was pronounced dead on arrival at a hospital.

Tsafendas was taken into police custody in Cape Town the same afternoon.

The investigation

The inquiry into the killing was led by a senior police general, and Tsafendas was questioned over two days. In statements given on September 11 and September 19, 1966, he described a political motive: he said he had been so disgusted by the government's racial policy that he went through with his plan, and that he believed a change of policy would follow the Prime Minister's death. He also admitted part of his past political activity.

The medical side of the case began at once. State doctors at Groote Schuur Hospital in Cape Town examined him on September 6 and 7. His defense lawyer interviewed him on September 26 and 27. The defense appointed its own panel of psychiatrists and a clinical psychologist; the psychologist's reports run from September 23 to October 17, and the psychiatric examinations from September 29 to October 11. Alongside them the defense gathered statements from witnesses and the hospital records of his past: reports from the United States, from Germany in 1955 and from Britain in 1959, and from the Somerset and Groote Schuur hospitals in Cape Town.

The police looked far beyond Cape Town, into a past that ran through Mozambique, Portugal, Greece and England, and the answers that came back from Lisbon were incomplete. The day after the killing, the head of the PIDE in Lisbon instructed his counterpart in Mozambique not to tell the South African authorities that Tsafendas had supported independence for the territory.

Alongside the criminal inquiry the government set up its own review. A secret inquiry examined how a man with his record had passed the screening for a post inside Parliament. A formal Commission of Inquiry into the Circumstances of the Death of the late Dr Hendrik Frensch Verwoerd, chaired by J.T. van Wyk, was appointed to report on all aspects of the death. Evidence put before it included testimony about his anti-apartheid activity in London.

The inquiry in the Supreme Court

Tsafendas was charged with murder, and the case was set down in the Supreme Court of South Africa, Cape of Good Hope Provincial Division, with the Judge President of the Cape presiding. It never reached a plea. Because his mental capacity had been in doubt from his first dealings with officials, the court first held a summary inquiry into whether he was fit to be tried at all. That inquiry lasted three days in October 1966. The Attorney-General conducted the case for the state.

The evidence came almost entirely from psychiatrists and psychologists, called by both the defense and the prosecution. They examined him in prison and police settings rather than in a hospital, and in one interview three psychiatrists and police officers were present together. One defense psychiatrist told the court he had been obliged to take shortcuts. Another asked that Tsafendas be admitted to a psychiatric hospital for further assessment; that admission never took place. His earlier treatment in Germany, England and the United States did not feature prominently, and no collateral information was gathered to test what he told the examiners.

The case for illness rested above all on one belief. Tsafendas told the doctors that a tapeworm lived inside him, a conviction he said had begun when he was about 18 and had survived every negative medical test. He said it shaped his thoughts and his conduct. He also said that it had not told him to kill the Prime Minister. The experts treated the belief as a delusion and the central sign of schizophrenia. They considered whether he might be feigning and concluded he was not, noting that he rejected leading questions, denied hearing voices, and showed symptoms they regarded as hard to simulate. The experts also treated one word he used, graphonola, as an invented word and a further sign of illness, although the word exists in both Portuguese and English. A personality test he took was declared invalid because his answers were careless and inconsistent. An intelligence test placed him above average, with a verbal score of 117.

The prosecution did not dispute the diagnosis. Its experts and the defense experts agreed that he was not competent to stand trial because of schizophrenia. The statements in which he had given the police a political reason for the killing were not put before the court.

On October 20, 1966, the court found him unfit to stand trial on the ground that he suffered from schizophrenia. It accepted that he had no political motive for the killing. The proceedings were stopped, and he was ordered detained at the pleasure of the State President, which made him a State President's patient. There was no plea, no trial on the facts and no verdict. The finding spared him a trial that could have ended in a death sentence.

In December 1966 the Commission of Inquiry delivered its report. It confirmed the court's conclusions: that Tsafendas suffered from schizophrenia and had acted without a political motive.

The order made in October 1966 had two consequences that shaped the rest of his life. First, a finding that he was unfit to stand trial left the charge against him unresolved. The question of whether he was criminally responsible for the killing was never decided, yet the same finding exposed him to compulsory detention without limit of time. Second, the form of the order allowed the state to choose where he was held. Although he had been found mentally ill, a gap in the law of the time allowed the government to keep him in prison rather than in a psychiatric hospital, and it did so for more than 25 years.

The years in custody

After the October hearing Tsafendas was sent to Robben Island, where he spent about four months. He was then moved to Pretoria Central Prison and placed in a cell built for him in the death row section. He remained there for about 23 years, among prisoners awaiting execution, without having been sentenced to anything. Much of his time in prison was spent in solitary confinement. Between 1966 and 1986 he wrote letters, most of them to the prison authorities, asking for medical treatment, for permission to study, for visits and for reference books.

In 1989, at the start of the presidency of F.W. de Klerk, he was transferred to Zonderwater Prison, a lower-security institution. On June 30, 1994, under the new democratic government, the Minister of Correctional Services announced that he would be moved from prison to a mental institution. He was taken to Sterkfontein Psychiatric Hospital outside Krugersdorp, west of Johannesburg, where he spent the rest of his life. By then he was the longest-serving prisoner in the country.

Release was considered after 1994. The new government was prepared to let him go, but no one could be found to take him in, and he stayed at Sterkfontein. In 1996 a lawyer asked the Truth and Reconciliation Commission to review his case. The Commission took no action on the request, and it did not examine his detention in any detail.

Tsafendas died at Sterkfontein on October 7, 1999. He was 81. He had been in poor health for some time. He had been held since September 1966, from October of that year as a State President's patient, and had never been tried for the killing.

Disputed and unproven points

The central dispute is the one the court in 1966 declined to hear: whether Tsafendas was a man driven by illness or a political assassin. The court and the Commission of Inquiry found that he had no political motive. His own statements to the police, made within two weeks of the killing, gave a political motive in plain terms. He had been a member of the Communist Party, had been watched by the Portuguese political police since 1938, had been jailed in Portugal, and had been active in the anti-apartheid movement in London. His political views were not raised at the hearing.

In April 2018 a researcher at Durham University in England submitted a report of about 2,192 pages to the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services. It drew on some 12,000 pages of records in the national archives of South Africa, Portugal and the United Kingdom and on interviews with 137 people, 69 of whom had known Tsafendas. It argued that he was not schizophrenic, that he killed the Prime Minister because of his opposition to apartheid, and that the state had preferred to present him as insane. Five senior South African jurists, among them a retired judge and a law professor, endorsed the report in a letter of April 23, 2018. They asked the government to acknowledge its findings publicly, while accepting that the Minister might first want the study independently assessed.

The psychiatric evidence itself has also been questioned by psychiatrists. A 2024 review in a South African bioethics and law journal, written by two forensic psychiatrists at Weskoppies Psychiatric Hospital and the University of Pretoria, examined the record of the inquiry. It noted that he was never observed in a hospital setting, that his foreign treatment records were barely considered, that no corroborating information was obtained, and that the state did not present evidence that he had feigned mental illness before. It also observed that the tapeworm belief might have been an extreme overvalued belief rooted in his cultural background rather than a delusion, and that the careful planning of the killing fitted a person of above-average intelligence rather than a person in a psychotic state. The authors drew no firm diagnosis, noting that they had not examined him.

There is evidence on both sides of the feigning question. In January 1965 the Portuguese authorities released him from custody in Mozambique as insane and unfit to stand trial, and throughout his travels he was admitted to hospitals, sometimes by his own choice, for food and lodging or to escape harsh treatment in detention. The experts who testified in 1966 nonetheless concluded that he was not simulating.

Timeline

January 14, 1918: Born in Lourenco Marques, Portuguese Mozambique.

1928 to 1930: Attends Middelburg Primary School in the Transvaal.

1938: The Portuguese political police open a file on him; South Africa refuses him a visa.

Late 1930s to about 1942: Member of the Communist Party of South Africa; barred from South Africa from 1942.

June 13, 1942: Leaves South Africa as a seaman bound for Canada.

1944 and 1945: Treated in American hospitals.

1946: Admitted to Grafton State Hospital, Massachusetts.

1947: Deported from the United States to Greece; joins the communist side in the Greek Civil War.

November 1949: Detained at Barca d'Alva, Portugal; later held at Aljube prison, Lisbon.

1951: Arrested in Mozambique and returned to Lisbon; about twelve years in exile follow.

1955: Patient at a psychiatric hospital in Hamburg.

October 1963: Returns to Mozambique after an amnesty.

November 4, 1963: Enters South Africa on a temporary visa.

November 16, 1964: Arrested in Mozambique for subversive propaganda.

January 19, 1965: Released by the Portuguese authorities as unfit to stand trial.

March 8, 1965: Arrives in Durban from Beira.

July or August 1966: Taken on as a temporary messenger in Parliament, Cape Town.

September 6, 1966: The Prime Minister is killed in the House of Assembly; Tsafendas is taken into custody.

September 6 and 7, 1966: Examined by state doctors at Groote Schuur Hospital, Cape Town.

September 11 and 19, 1966: Gives statements to the police describing a political motive.

September 23 to October 17, 1966: Examined by a psychiatric panel and a clinical psychologist appointed by the defense.

October 20, 1966: Found unfit to stand trial on the ground of schizophrenia; detained at the State President's pleasure.

December 1966: The Commission of Inquiry reports, confirming the court's conclusions.

1966 to 1986: Writes letters to the prison authorities asking for treatment, study, visits and books.

1989: Transferred to Zonderwater Prison.

June 30, 1994: Transfer to a mental institution announced; moved to Sterkfontein Psychiatric Hospital, Krugersdorp.

1996: A lawyer asks the Truth and Reconciliation Commission to review his case.

October 7, 1999: Dies at Sterkfontein, aged 81.

April 2018: A report arguing that he was not schizophrenic is submitted to the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services; five jurists endorse it in a letter of April 23.

April 2024: A forensic psychiatric review of the 1966 inquiry is published.