Dilawar Singh Babbar

Victims
17 people killed in Chandigarh, 1995, Beant Singh among them; attributed to him by the prosecution; he died in the attack and was never tried.
Years active
August 31, 1995
Location
Chandigarh, India (killings and death); Burail, Chandigarh, India (trial)
Method
Bombing with explosives (prosecution case), outside the Punjab and Haryana Civil Secretariat, Chandigarh.
Status
Co-accused Balwant Singh Rajoana remained under sentence of death as of October 7, 2026. Dilawar Singh was killed in the attack in Chandigarh, August 31, 1995, before any charge or trial.

On the afternoon of August 31, 1995, the chief minister of Punjab, Beant Singh, was killed outside the Punjab and Haryana Civil Secretariat in Chandigarh, the seat of his own government. Sixteen other people died with him and at least fifteen were injured. By the prosecution's account, and in the findings later made against the men tried with him, the attack was carried out by Dilawar Singh Babbar, a constable of the Punjab Police, who died in it.

Because he died there, Dilawar Singh was never charged with anything and never stood trial. Everything the courts later said about him came in the prosecutions of the men accused of planning the attack with him. A special court convicted five of them in July 2007, sentenced two to death and three to life imprisonment, and acquitted one. A sixth was convicted of a lesser offense. A further accused, Jagtar Singh Tara, was convicted in 2018. The case has never fully closed, chiefly because of the unexecuted death sentence of the constable who was to act if Dilawar Singh did not.

The chief minister was born on February 19, 1922, in Bilaspur, a village near Doraha in Ludhiana district, into a farming family. He graduated from Government College, Lahore, before Partition, and spent a short period in the army before turning to public life. He was elected sarpanch of Bilaspur in 1959 and served as a director of the Central Cooperative Bank in Ludhiana.

He entered the Punjab Vidhan Sabha in 1969 as an independent, joined the Congress party the next year, and was returned from Payal in 1972, 1977 and 1980. In 1992 he won the Jalandhar Cantonment seat, and on February 25, 1992, he was sworn in as chief minister. Punjab had then lived through more than a decade of armed militancy, and the central task of his government was to bring it to an end.

Dilawar Singh was a member of the Punjab Police; the case papers describe him as a police officer, and Balwant Singh Rajoana, the co-accused who later confessed, described him as a fellow constable. Rajoana had joined the Punjab Police in 1987 and was a serving constable in 1995, as was a third man in the conspiracy, Lakhwinder Singh.

He was connected with the Babbar Khalsa International, the organization named at every stage of the prosecution. The surname by which he is now generally known, Babbar, is the name of that group. According to the prosecution case, Jagtar Singh Hawara, a member of the organization, came to Delhi in June 1995 and persuaded Dilawar Singh to carry out the attack. Rajoana, by his own later account, was to act in his place if he failed.

The prosecution and later reporting attributed to the three police officers a motive of retaliation for Operation Bluestar, the army action at the Golden Temple in Amritsar in 1984, and for the violence in Delhi after the assassination of Indira Gandhi that year. The Babbar Khalsa International claimed the killing soon after it happened.

The secretariat was one of the most closely guarded sites in Chandigarh. Late in the afternoon, as the chief minister left the building, the attack killed him and sixteen other people. Three of the dead were commandos of the National Security Guard, the force charged with his protection. Dilawar Singh died with them. At least fifteen people were injured.

The sixteen who died beside the chief minister were the larger share of the dead, and every charge the co-accused later faced included their deaths.

The Central Bureau of Investigation, which prosecuted the case, moved quickly. Within days investigators had linked the attack to a conspiracy organized through the Babbar Khalsa International. Lakhwinder Singh was arrested in September 1995. Jagtar Singh Tara was arrested in Delhi on September 13, 1995. Jagtar Singh Hawara, whom the prosecution described as the principal conspirator, was also taken into custody. Balwant Singh Rajoana was arrested on January 27, 1996.

In April 1996 charges were framed against nine accused, among them Hawara, Rajoana, Tara, Lakhwinder Singh, Gurmeet Singh, Shamsher Singh, Nasib Singh, Navjot Singh and Paramjit Singh Bheora, for murder, attempt to murder and criminal conspiracy, and for offenses under a 1908 statute. Dilawar Singh's name ran through the case against every one of them, but he was not among the accused: he had died before the first arrest was made.

Rajoana took a course that set him apart from the others. He admitted his part, declined to be defended and made three confessional statements. He also apologized for the deaths of the innocent people who had died with the chief minister.

The trial was held in a special court sitting inside the high-security Model Jail at Burail, Chandigarh, where the accused were held, and it ran for more than eleven years. On January 21, 2004, Hawara, Tara and Bheora escaped from the jail. Hawara was arrested again in 2005 and Bheora in 2006. Tara remained at large for years and was later arrested in Thailand and returned to Chandigarh to stand trial on his own.

On July 27, 2007, the special court found Hawara, Rajoana, Gurmeet Singh, Shamsher Singh and Lakhwinder Singh guilty of murder, attempt to murder and conspiracy, and of offenses under the 1908 statute. Nasib Singh was convicted of a single offense under that statute and, having already spent more than eleven years in jail, was released. Navjot Singh, charged with sheltering the accused, was acquitted for want of sufficient evidence after eleven years and eleven months in custody.

On July 31, 2007, Hawara and Rajoana were sentenced to death. Gurmeet Singh, Shamsher Singh and Lakhwinder Singh were sentenced to life imprisonment.

The death sentences came before the Punjab and Haryana High Court for confirmation, heard together with the appeals of Hawara, Lakhwinder Singh, Gurmeet Singh and Shamsher Singh. Rajoana filed no appeal. On October 12, 2010, the court commuted Hawara's death sentence to life imprisonment without release for the rest of his life, and confirmed the life terms of the other three.

Rajoana's death sentence stood: the court relied on his refusal to defend himself and on his three confessional statements. Appeals by co-accused and by the Central Bureau of Investigation then went to the Supreme Court of India and were still pending in May 2023.

Tara's separate trial took place in the special court inside Burail jail. In January 2018 he submitted a written confession of his part in the conspiracy. The court found him guilty of murder, attempt to murder and criminal conspiracy, and of offenses under the 1908 statute, on March 16, 2018. The next day it declined to treat the case as one of the rarest of the rare and sentenced him to life imprisonment until his natural death. In court Tara said that he regretted the deaths of the sixteen people who died with the chief minister.

A death warrant fixed Rajoana's execution for March 31, 2012. A mercy petition was filed on his behalf on March 25, and days before the date set, the Union government stayed the execution. The petition was not decided. In September 2019 the Union Ministry of Home Affairs proposed that his sentence be commuted, but the commutation was never formally carried out; the ministry later told the Supreme Court it had deferred a decision until the appeals of the co-accused and the Central Bureau of Investigation were decided.

On May 3, 2023, the Supreme Court refused Rajoana's plea that the delay itself entitled him to commutation, holding that there had been no inordinate delay of the kind the law recognizes, since he had not filed the mercy petition himself, and leaving the question to the executive. A fresh petition followed, and on September 25, 2024, the court agreed to examine the question again. On October 7, 2026, it listed the plea for hearing on October 28, 2026. As of that date Rajoana remained under sentence of death, his mercy petition still pending.

Dilawar Singh's own part has never been tested by a court in a proceeding against him. It rests on the prosecution case, on Rajoana's confessions and on the findings made in the trials of the men accused with him, which treated him as the man who carried out the attack. The account of his recruitment and of the parts the two constables were to play comes from the prosecution and from the co-accused, not from any finding about him. The motive attributed to him and his associates is likewise the prosecution's and the co-accused's account.

His standing in the police at the time of the attack is not settled: some reports describe him as a serving constable and one as a dismissed policeman, and no court has decided the point. The death toll also varies: the Supreme Court and most reports give the dead as the chief minister and sixteen others, while some accounts give seventeen others.

Timeline

February 19, 1922: The future chief minister is born in Bilaspur, Ludhiana district.

February 25, 1992: He is sworn in as Chief Minister of Punjab.

June 1995: Jagtar Singh Hawara comes to Delhi; by the prosecution case he recruits Dilawar Singh.

August 31, 1995: The chief minister and sixteen others are killed outside the Civil Secretariat in Chandigarh in an attack the prosecution attributes to Dilawar Singh, who dies in it.

September 13, 1995: Jagtar Singh Tara is arrested in Delhi.

January 27, 1996: Balwant Singh Rajoana is arrested.

April 1996: Charges are framed against nine accused.

January 21, 2004: Hawara, Tara and Paramjit Singh Bheora escape from Burail jail.

July 27, 2007: The special court convicts five accused of murder and conspiracy, convicts Nasib Singh of a lesser offense and acquits Navjot Singh.

July 31, 2007: Hawara and Rajoana are sentenced to death; three others receive life imprisonment.

October 12, 2010: The Punjab and Haryana High Court commutes Hawara's sentence to imprisonment for the rest of his life and confirms Rajoana's death sentence.

March 2012: Rajoana's execution, set for March 31, is stayed.

March 16 and 17, 2018: Tara is convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment until his natural death.

September 2019: The Ministry of Home Affairs proposes commuting Rajoana's sentence; the order is not carried out.

May 3, 2023: The Supreme Court declines to commute Rajoana's death sentence.

October 7, 2026: The Supreme Court lists Rajoana's plea for October 28, 2026.