Diego Pillco

Victims
1 manslaughter, Manhattan, November 1, 2006; pleaded guilty to first-degree manslaughter, February 2008
Years active
November 1, 2006
Location
Greenwich Village, Manhattan, New York (killing); Manhattan, New York (trial court); Ecuador (birth)
Method
Strangled (his own admission at his 2008 guilty plea)
Status
Sentenced March 2008 to 25 years in New York State prison, with deportation on his release. Imprisoned in New York as of March 2008.

On the evening of November 1, 2006, Adrienne Shelly was found dead in Greenwich Village, in Manhattan. She was an actress, a writer and a director, known for the independent films that had made her name at the end of the 1980s, and she had just finished a feature of her own that was waiting to hear from the Sundance Film Festival. For the first days the police treated her death as a possible suicide. Within a week they had arrested a 19-year-old construction worker from Ecuador named Diego Pillco, who had been working on a renovation crew in the same building, and he had made statements to detectives admitting that he caused her death.

He was charged with second-degree murder. In February 2008, rather than go to trial, he pleaded guilty to first-degree manslaughter, and in March 2008 a justice of the New York State Supreme Court in Manhattan sentenced him to 25 years in prison, the term agreed when he entered the plea, with deportation to follow his release. His account of how the encounter began changed between his first statements to detectives and the admissions he made in court, and that change is the one lasting question in a case that never reached a jury.

She was born in Queens and grew up on Long Island. She came to the New York theater and to independent film young, leaving college before she graduated, and she found her first real break in the work of the director Hal Hartley. She played Audry Hugo in his first feature, The Unbelievable Truth, in 1989, and Maria Coughlin in Trust the following year. She went on to appear in more than 20 films.

At the height of her film work she also founded a theater company, Missing Children, to write, direct and produce her own plays and to give work to friends who were struggling to find it. She began as a playwright and moved behind the camera in the 1990s. Her first feature as a director, Sudden Manhattan, came out in 1996. Over the following decade she worked across film, theater and television while turning more and more toward writing and directing. In 2005 she appeared as Jerry in Factotum, opposite Matt Dillon.

By the autumn of 2006 she had written and directed a new feature, Waitress, in which she also took a supporting role, with Keri Russell and Nathan Fillion in the leads. She had submitted it to Sundance and was waiting to hear whether it had been accepted. She lived in lower Manhattan and did her work from a second address in Greenwich Village. Waitress was accepted at Sundance and released in 2007, after her death.

Pillco, a native of Ecuador, was 19 that autumn. He was working with a construction crew on interior renovations in the same Greenwich Village building, one floor below the rooms where she worked.

The police at first treated her death as a probable suicide and waited on the medical examiner before deciding whether to investigate it as a crime. That decision did not take long. Detectives from the New York City Police Department's Sixth Precinct, which covers Greenwich Village, kept working the case. Evidence they gathered was linked in the end to the renovation work going on one floor below, and that pointed the inquiry at the construction crew. Pillco had missed several days of work after the death, and witnesses had seen him working near the building.

Detectives arrested him in Brooklyn at the start of the following week. He made written and videotaped statements in which, prosecutors said, he admitted fighting with her and causing her death. On November 7, 2006, he was arraigned in the New York State Supreme Court in Manhattan on a charge of second-degree murder and held without bail.

His first account, given to detectives in Spanish, described a quarrel. As the police and later court papers summarized it, she had come to complain about the noise of the renovation below, and the argument turned physical. He told detectives he had been afraid that if she called the police he would be deported. Court papers released in December 2006 set out that version of events; by then he had pleaded not guilty.

The case never went to trial. In February 2008 Pillco pleaded guilty to first-degree manslaughter before a justice of the State Supreme Court in Manhattan, in exchange for an agreed sentence of 25 years in prison. In entering the plea he gave a different account. He no longer described a quarrel over noise. He admitted that the encounter had begun with a theft, that she had caught him and threatened to call the police, and that he had then caused her death. He acknowledged that he had first told detectives her death was an accident during a fight, and before the hearing ended he said he wanted to ask her family for forgiveness.

He was sentenced in March 2008 to the agreed 25 years in New York State prison. Because he was in the country without legal status, the court stated that he would be subject to immediate deportation on his release. Pillco spoke at the hearing. He told the court that he had not set out that day intending to hurt anyone and that he had suffered because he knew what he had done, and he again asked her family for forgiveness.

Twenty-five years was the longest term New York law allowed for first-degree manslaughter, a class B violent felony, and the sentence was a determinate one, which means release is not a matter for the state's parole board. As of March 2008 he was serving that term in New York State prison, with deportation to follow on his release.

The main point of dispute is how the encounter began. His first account, as summarized by police and in court papers in 2006, was of an argument over renovation noise that turned physical, with his fear of deportation if she called the police. At his plea in 2008 he admitted instead that the encounter began with a theft and that she had threatened to call the police after catching him. The plea admission is the account he gave in court and the one on which he was sentenced. No trial tested either version.

Timeline

1989: The victim appears in her first Hal Hartley feature, The Unbelievable Truth.

1996: Her first feature as a director, Sudden Manhattan, is released.

2006: Pillco, 19, is working on a renovation crew in a Greenwich Village building in Manhattan.

November 1, 2006: The victim is found dead in Greenwich Village; police at first treat the death as a possible suicide.

Early November 2006: Sixth Precinct detectives arrest Pillco in Brooklyn; he makes written and videotaped statements.

November 7, 2006: Arraigned in the New York State Supreme Court in Manhattan on a charge of second-degree murder; held without bail.

December 2006: Court papers set out his first account; he has pleaded not guilty.

2007: Waitress is released.

February 2008: Pleads guilty to first-degree manslaughter in exchange for a 25-year sentence.

March 2008: Sentenced to 25 years in New York State prison, with deportation on his release.