Devin Kelley

Victims
26 people killed at a Texas church, 2017; never tried. Attributed to him; he died by suicide on November 5, 2017. A 2012 court-martial convicted him of assaulting his wife and stepson.
Years active
November 5, 2017 (Sutherland Springs); earlier assaults on his wife and stepson, 2011 to 2012 (Holloman Air Force Base, New Mexico)
Location
Sutherland Springs, Wilson County, Texas; New Braunfels, Texas; Holloman Air Force Base, New Mexico; El Paso County, Colorado
Method
26 deaths and 22 people wounded during a Sunday service, attributed to him; never charged, as he died the same day
Status
12 months' confinement, bad-conduct discharge, reduction to airman basic (2012); conviction upheld on appeal; released March 31, 2013; separated May 8, 2014. Died November 5, 2017

On the morning of Sunday, November 5, 2017, during the weekly service at the First Baptist Church in Sutherland Springs, a small rural community near San Antonio in Wilson County, Texas, 26 people were killed and 22 more were wounded. The Texas Department of Public Safety attributed the deaths to Devin Patrick Kelley, a 26-year-old former airman who lived in New Braunfels. He left the town after the killings and died by suicide later that day in neighboring Guadalupe County. He was never charged with any crime arising from that morning, and no court ever tried the case against him.

He did have a criminal record. Five years earlier, at Holloman Air Force Base in New Mexico, a general court-martial had convicted him, on his own guilty plea, of assaulting his wife and his infant stepson. Under federal law that conviction should have stopped him at the background checks he later passed, but the Air Force never sent his fingerprints or the result of his trial to the FBI, so the national background check system had nothing to find. In 2021, in a civil suit brought by the survivors and the families of the dead, a federal judge in San Antonio held the United States 60 percent responsible for the deaths and injuries at the church.

New Braunfels and the Air Force

Kelley grew up in New Braunfels, in Comal County, Texas, and graduated from New Braunfels High School in 2009. He enlisted in the Air Force on January 5, 2010.

His first assignment did not last. He was sent to the 316th Training Squadron at Goodfellow Air Force Base in San Angelo, Texas, to train as a network intelligence analyst, and failed out after poor test results. In November 2010 the Air Force reassigned him to the traffic management career field and moved him to Fort Lee, Virginia, to train for it. On or about January 11, 2011, he joined the 49th Logistics Readiness Squadron at Holloman Air Force Base, near Alamogordo, New Mexico. His work there was in military transportation, moving passengers, cargo and personal property. His service record from early in his career shows him flagged for failing to follow directions and orders, and he received several letters of reprimand and was ordered into counseling.

Two investigations at Holloman

The case that ended his career began in June 2011, when a doctor raised a suspicion that his infant stepson had been abused. The next day, June 9, the Air Force Office of Special Investigations, through its Detachment 225 at Holloman, opened an investigation of Kelley for assault on a child. Agents interviewed him and took two sets of his fingerprints, which went into his investigative file. They were never sent to the FBI, because no one recorded the probable-cause determination that would have triggered the submission. Then the file went quiet. Between July 2011 and March 2012 almost no investigative work was done on it, while the agent assigned to the case was deployed overseas and the detachment was changing leaders.

The second investigation opened on February 17, 2012, while the first was still running. His wife told the base's 49th Security Forces Squadron that he had been abusing her, physically and emotionally, since July 2011. Security Forces investigators tried to interview him, but he asked for a lawyer and declined to make a statement, and they did not take his fingerprints. The same day his squadron commander ordered him to have no contact with her, an order Kelley signed. A search of the Security Forces records system turned up an entry for a domestic incident in June 2011, logged at the time as non-violent. The investigator's report, issued on February 21, 2012, went to Detachment 225, to Kelley's squadron and to Security Forces.

In the spring of 2012 Kelley admitted to his wife that he had caused the injuries for which her son had been treated the year before. He recorded the admission on April 27, 2012. Two days later she handed the recording to his first sergeant, who turned it over to the Office of Special Investigations later that day, and on May 3 agents interviewed her a second time, now about her own allegations as well as the recording.

The case against him gathered pace in June. On June 8, 2012, his squadron commander recommended that he be placed in pretrial confinement, and agents of Detachment 225 interviewed him again; he told them he had asked for a lawyer and could not discuss the case. One agent certified in the interview record that he had fingerprinted Kelley that day, but no fingerprints from that date were ever found in the file. Kelley went into pretrial confinement at Holloman on June 9, 2012. Here too his fingerprints were either not taken or were lost. On July 26 a new squadron commander recommended that the charges go to a general court-martial, and on August 27, 2012, they were referred for trial.

The court-martial

Kelley went before a general court-martial at Holloman, the most serious level of military trial, in November 2012. He faced five specifications under Article 128 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice, the military's assault article, covering assaults on his wife and her son on several occasions in 2011 and 2012. Under a pretrial agreement he pleaded guilty to two of them, one involving his wife and one involving the child, and the other three were dropped.

He entered the plea on November 2, 2012. The first specification he admitted charged that, on divers occasions between on or about June 24, 2011, and on or about April 27, 2012, he unlawfully assaulted his wife. The second charged that, on divers occasions between on or about April 27, 2011, and on or about June 16, 2011, he assaulted her son, a child, with "a force likely to produce death or grievous bodily harm." In return for the plea, every other specification was withdrawn, among them a charge that he had threatened his wife, and the agreement capped any approved sentence of confinement at three years.

On November 7, 2012, the court convicted him and sentenced him to 12 months' confinement, a bad-conduct discharge and a reduction in rank to airman basic, the lowest enlisted grade. He received credit for five months and two days already spent in pretrial confinement. The Report of Result of Trial recorded the conviction as a "crime of domestic violence." He served the sentence first at Holloman and then, from December 18, 2012, at a naval brig in California.

On January 14, 2013, the convening authority approved the findings and the sentence. The memorandum of approval carried at the top of its first page, in bold capitals, the words "Crime of Domestic Violence" and a citation to the section of federal law under which a conviction of that kind disqualifies a buyer at a federal background check. It went to Detachment 225 and to the 49th Security Forces Squadron.

He was released from confinement on March 31, 2013. The next day he was notified that he was barred from Holloman indefinitely. The military appeals court upheld the conviction; on April 10, 2014, Detachment 225 and Security Forces were told that his appeal was final, and the bad-conduct discharge was executed that month. He was formally separated from the Air Force on May 8, 2014, after nearly five years of service, six months of his enlistment having been spent in confinement.

The record that was never sent

The rules required Air Force investigators to send a final disposition report to the FBI's Criminal Justice Information Services Division within 15 days of sentencing, together with the defendant's fingerprints. Those records feed the National Instant Criminal Background Check System, which the FBI administers and which federally licensed sellers are required to run.

On December 14, 2012, Detachment 225 received the Report of Result of Trial documenting the court-martial. The same day, the special agent in charge of the detachment certified on the case's closing checklist that Kelley's fingerprints and final disposition information had been sent to the FBI. They had not been, and the false entry allowed the investigation to be closed. The Report of Result of Trial had gone out on a mandatory distribution list of at least ten Defense Department units, Detachment 225 and the Security Forces investigators among them.

The confinement staff missed their own chance. When Kelley was processed into confinement at Holloman on November 7, 2012, the rules required the facility to take his fingerprints, record the conviction on the card and submit both to the FBI. That was not done either.

The day after the killings, the Secretary of Defense asked the Department of Defense Inspector General to find out whether Kelley's information should have gone to the FBI, whether it had, and if not, why not. The Inspector General opened the investigation on November 9, 2017. Its report, dated December 6, 2018, and released the next day, counted six missed chances. Four times, Air Force investigators failed to fingerprint Kelley or to send prints already taken to the FBI. Twice, the final report of his conviction was not submitted. It found "no valid reason" for any of the failures.

The federal court in the civil case heard the evidence in a bench trial in April 2021. In findings signed on July 6, 2021, it held that the government had failed to exercise reasonable care in submitting his record, found that had the record been reported it was more likely than not that Kelley would have been deterred, and assigned him 40 percent of the responsibility for the deaths and injuries.

Texas and Colorado

After his release Kelley went back to the New Braunfels area. For a time he lived in El Paso County, Colorado, near Colorado Springs, and registered to vote there in 2014.

On August 1, 2014, El Paso County authorities cited him for misdemeanor animal cruelty in connection with his treatment of a dog. He received a deferred sentence with probation, and the charge was dismissed in March 2016 after he completed it.

Back in Texas he held a state license as a non-commissioned, unarmed private security officer. He worked for about five and a half weeks as a security guard at a water park in New Braunfels and later as an overnight security guard at an RV resort in the same city. He also ran a small billing-software company, Dilloware Inc., based in Comal County.

Between December 2014 and October 2017 he passed four federal background checks run through the FBI's national system. Each time the answer came back that the sale could proceed. Had the Air Force sent his record, the court-martial conviction would have stopped each one.

The killings took place during the Sunday morning service at the First Baptist Church of Sutherland Springs. The Texas Department of Public Safety, which investigated with the Wilson County Sheriff's Office, put the toll at 26 dead. The federal court later found that 22 others were wounded. Kelley died by suicide later that day in Guadalupe County.

The Department of Public Safety released the names of the dead on November 7, 2017. Eight of them were children and teenagers, among them the pastor's daughter. The adults were Keith Allen Braden, Tara E. McNulty, Peggy Lynn Warden, Lula Woicinski White, Joann Lookingbill Ward, Therese Sagan Rodriguez, Ricardo Cardona Rodriguez, Marc Daniel Holcombe, Karla Plain Holcombe, John Bryan Holcombe and Crystal Marie Holcombe; Dennis Neil Johnson Sr. and Sara Johns Johnson, who had been members of the church for more than a decade; Robert Michael Corrigan and Shani Louise Corrigan, who had come to Sutherland Springs from northern Michigan about two years before; and Robert Scott Marshall and Karen Sue Marshall, who had moved to Texas from Pittsburgh not long before and were at the church for the first time that morning, looking for a congregation to join.

The investigation

Federal agencies joined the state inquiry: the FBI and the ATF worked alongside the Department of Public Safety and the Wilson County Sheriff's Office. State and federal law enforcement confirmed his identity. The Texas Rangers kept primary jurisdiction over the investigation; Homeland Security and the Defense Department opened inquiries of their own.

On November 6, 2017, the Air Force acknowledged in a written statement that his court-martial conviction had never reached the FBI's database. Its two senior leaders ordered the service's own Inspector General to review the case, and the Air Force asked the Defense Department's Inspector General to examine records and procedures across the department. Because Kelley was dead, there was no prosecution, and the facts of that morning were never tested in a criminal court.

Disputed and unproven points

Because Kelley died before any arrest, the account of November 5, 2017, rests on the state investigation and on the background facts set out by the federal court in the civil case, not on a criminal verdict. He was never charged, and no part of that morning was tested before a criminal court or a jury.

No court ever made a finding on his motive. The civil case turned on the record the Air Force failed to send, and the judge's finding was limited to responsibility for the deaths and injuries, divided between the government and Kelley.

Timeline

January 5, 2010: enlists in the Air Force.

January 2011: joins the 49th Logistics Readiness Squadron at Holloman Air Force Base.

June 9, 2011: Air Force Office of Special Investigations at Holloman Air Force Base opens a child-assault investigation of Kelley and takes his fingerprints, which are never sent to the FBI.

February 17, 2012: the 49th Security Forces Squadron opens an assault investigation after his wife's complaint.

April 29, 2012: his recorded admission is given to the Air Force.

June 9, 2012: placed in pretrial confinement.

August 27, 2012: charges referred to a general court-martial.

November 2, 2012: pleads guilty to two specifications under Article 128.

November 7, 2012: convicted by general court-martial, on his guilty plea, of assault on his wife and stepson; sentenced to 12 months' confinement, a bad-conduct discharge and reduction to airman basic.

December 14, 2012: the Holloman detachment certifies that his fingerprints and final disposition were sent to the FBI; they were not.

January 14, 2013: the convening authority approves the findings and sentence.

March 31, 2013: released from confinement; barred from Holloman the next day.

May 8, 2014: separated from the Air Force with a bad-conduct discharge.

August 1, 2014: cited for misdemeanor animal cruelty in El Paso County, Colorado; the charge is dismissed in March 2016 after a deferred sentence.

December 2014 to October 2017: passes four federal background checks.

November 5, 2017: 26 people are killed and 22 wounded at the First Baptist Church in Sutherland Springs; Kelley dies by suicide the same day in Guadalupe County.

November 7, 2017: the Texas Department of Public Safety releases the names of the dead.

November 9, 2017: the Department of Defense Inspector General opens its investigation.

December 6, 2018: the Inspector General's report, released the next day, finds six missed chances to send his records to the FBI.

July 6, 2021: a federal court in San Antonio holds the United States 60 percent responsible in the civil case.