On March 14, 1980, in Manhattan, Dennis Sweeney caused the death of the man who had brought him into the civil rights movement. The victim was Allard K. Lowenstein, a former Democratic member of Congress from Long Island, a onetime American ambassador at the United Nations and, for two decades, one of the best-known organizers of student activism in the country. Sweeney was 37, a carpenter from New London, Connecticut, who had once been among his most devoted followers. New York City detectives took him into custody that day and booked him on charges in the death. He never stood trial. On February 23, 1981, an acting justice of the State Supreme Court in Manhattan accepted his plea, judged him "not responsible for his actions," and ordered him into the care and custody of the state Department of Mental Hygiene.
The two men met at Stanford University in 1961, when one was an assistant dean and the other a student. The dean became the student's mentor and steered him toward Mississippi, where Sweeney became a leader of the voting rights movement in McComb. The politics of the protest years later drove them apart, though they never lost touch.
The victim was born in Newark, New Jersey, in January 1929. He studied history at the University of North Carolina, where he took part in drives to desegregate the Chapel Hill campus and graduated in 1949. He then served as president of the United States National Student Association from 1950 to 1951. He took his law degree at Yale in 1954 and spent the next two years in the U.S. Army, most of that time in Germany.
The years that followed set the pattern of his public life. In 1957 he worked with Eleanor Roosevelt at the American Association for the United Nations, and in 1959 he became foreign policy assistant to Senator Hubert H. Humphrey. He traveled through South Africa and South West Africa and wrote a book against apartheid, Brutal Mandate, published in 1962. He taught at Stanford, at North Carolina State and at the City College of New York. He was a delegate to the Democratic National Conventions of 1960, 1964 and 1968.
In 1963 and 1964 he recruited white college students to go to Mississippi for the voter registration campaigns that became Freedom Summer, and he did legal work in the state in those years. He helped organize the movement inside the Democratic Party that led President Lyndon B. Johnson not to seek reelection in 1968. That year he was elected to Congress from New York's Fifth District on Long Island and served one term, from 1969 to 1971, before losing to the Republican Norman Lent. He ran for Congress again in 1972, 1974 and 1976, taking 48 percent of the vote in 1974, and lost a Democratic primary in Manhattan in 1978. In 1971 he became chairman of Americans for Democratic Action. Under President Jimmy Carter he led the American delegation to the United Nations Commission on Human Rights in 1977 and served from August 1977 to June 1978 as alternate United States representative for special political affairs at the United Nations, with the rank of ambassador. In the first months of 1980 he was working on Senator Edward Kennedy's campaign for the Democratic presidential nomination.
Sweeney arrived in the former congressman's life at Stanford. In 1961 and 1962 the older man was an assistant dean there and dean of Stern Hall, then a men's dormitory, and Sweeney was a student. The dean persuaded a circle of Stanford students to take up civil rights work, and Sweeney became one of his protégés. In 1962, at his mentor's urging, he went to work in the civil rights movement in Mississippi.
He stayed with it. Sweeney became one of the leaders of the movement in McComb, the economic hub of Southwest Mississippi, where Black residents made up nearly 30 percent of a city of 12,000 people and very few of them were registered to vote. The local NAACP leader, C. C. Bryant, had invited Bob Moses of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee to begin a registration campaign there in 1961, and the city's mayor chaired the local Citizens' Council.
In time Sweeney found himself on the other side of his mentor's politics. The former dean was a liberal who wanted to work through the established political system. He opposed anyone who wanted to overthrow it, and he urged students not to use violence as a means of protest. Sweeney went with the more radical wing of the student movement, the wing that took in Students for a Democratic Society and that came to denounce the older man as a reactionary. During the years of protest against the war in Vietnam the two fell out over tactics. They did not lose touch.
By 1980 Sweeney had left political life. He was living in New London and working as a carpenter.
On Friday, March 14, 1980, Sweeney came to Manhattan to see the former congressman, who was then practicing law in the city, and caused his death there. The former congressman died later that day.
New York City detectives took Sweeney into custody and escorted him to a police station in Manhattan, where he was booked on charges in the death.
The question in the case was never who had caused the death. It was whether Sweeney could be held criminally responsible for it. Six psychiatrists examined him, including doctors retained by the defense and by the district attorney's office. All six found that he was not responsible for his actions and not able to stand trial.
On February 23, 1981, nearly a year after the death, an acting justice of the State Supreme Court in Manhattan accepted Sweeney's plea. United Press International reported the disposition as "equivalent to a jury verdict of innocent by reason of insanity." The justice said she would sign an order on March 23, 1981, committing Sweeney to the care and custody of the New York State Department of Mental Hygiene. There was no trial, no conviction and no sentence.
Because the case ended on a plea before any trial, no jury heard evidence and no court made findings of fact about the events of March 14, 1980, beyond accepting that Sweeney had caused the death and was not responsible for it. What is known of his reasons comes from what he told the psychiatrists who examined him, and no court weighed those statements as anything other than part of the psychiatric findings. Contemporary accounts also differ on the date of death: most give March 14, 1980, while the 1981 wire report gives March 15.
1961: Sweeney, an undergraduate at Stanford University, meets the assistant dean who becomes his mentor.
1962: At his mentor's urging, he goes to work in the civil rights movement in Mississippi.
1963 to 1964: The mentor recruits college students for the Mississippi voter registration campaigns that become Freedom Summer; Sweeney becomes a leader of the movement in McComb.
1968: The former dean, a leader of the movement to deny President Johnson renomination, wins New York's Fifth Congressional District.
Late 1960s to 1970s: The two men fall out over tactics but stay in touch.
March 14, 1980: Sweeney causes the death of his former mentor in Manhattan and is taken into custody the same day.
1980 to 1981: Six psychiatrists find him not responsible for his actions and unable to stand trial.
February 23, 1981: An acting justice of the State Supreme Court in Manhattan accepts his plea and judges him not responsible for his actions.
March 23, 1981: The date set for the order committing him to the custody of the New York State Department of Mental Hygiene.