On the morning of May 8, 1984, Denis Lortie, a corporal in the Canadian Armed Forces, walked into the Parliament Building in Quebec City in combat fatigues. The legislature was not sitting. Three people who were there that morning died and thirteen others were injured before the Assembly's sergeant-at-arms, a retired army major, talked Lortie into surrendering several hours later.
Lortie was charged with three counts of first-degree murder. A jury in Quebec City convicted him in February 1985, and he was sentenced to life imprisonment with 25 years to serve before he could seek parole. The Court of Appeal of Quebec set the verdict aside the following year, ruling that the trial judge had wrongly told the jury to reject the evidence of three psychiatrists who considered him insane at the time. At his second trial, in May 1987, he pleaded guilty to three counts of second-degree murder and was sentenced to life with no eligibility for parole for ten years. He left prison on day parole in 1995 and was granted full parole in 1996.
Denis Lortie was born in Quebec City on March 10, 1959. He joined the Canadian Armed Forces at 17. His early service took him to sea aboard a naval destroyer, and for a time he was stationed in Halifax.
By the spring of 1984 he was 25 and held the rank of corporal. He worked as a supply technician at Canadian Forces Station Carp, in Ontario, an underground installation built during the Cold War to serve as an emergency command center for the federal government. It was from that posting that he traveled to Quebec City in May.
Before he reached the building that morning he had left a recorded message at a Quebec City radio station, and the station called the police.
Three years later, at his second trial, he gave a different account of what had driven him. He testified that abuse he had suffered as a child had left him mentally unstable, and that the Parti Québécois government had come to remind him of his father.
The National Assembly was not in session that morning. A committee was preparing to meet in the chamber to examine the budget estimates of Quebec's chief electoral officer, and the people working in the building had no warning. Ministers who were there barricaded themselves away from him; others did not have that chance. About 50 elementary school students on a visit took cover and were not hurt.
Three people died: Georges Boyer, Camille Lepage and Roger Lefrançois. Thirteen others were injured, among them twelve employees of the Assembly, a tourist and a construction worker.
The sergeant-at-arms, the head of security at the National Assembly, was a retired army major. When word of what was happening reached him he went toward the chamber and found Lortie there.
He then proposed that Lortie give himself up to military police rather than to the provincial force, and offered to call the base at Valcartier. Lortie agreed. A colonel at Valcartier arranged for military police to come, and Lortie spoke to him on the telephone himself. The sergeant-at-arms then led him out of the chamber and down to his own office. The provincial police officers they passed raised their hands, which seemed to steady Lortie. In the office the older man insisted on being called "major" and addressed Lortie as "corporal," a small reversal that put him in charge of the conversation. Another officer called from the military, and Lortie took the telephone; the four-minute conversation seemed to calm him further.
While the two men talked, police cleared the building and evacuated the injured.
The standoff ended that afternoon, a little more than four hours after it began, when Lortie surrendered peacefully. Officers of the Sûreté du Québec, the Quebec City police and the Assembly's own security service took part, and military police from Valcartier escorted him out. The provincial force confirmed that afternoon that he was in custody. When the sergeant-at-arms returned to the building the next day, the Assembly's staff greeted him with a standing ovation.
On May 9, 1984, the day after the killings, Lortie appeared in the Quebec Sessions Court. He was charged with three counts of first-degree murder, one for each of the dead, and he pleaded not guilty.
His state of mind lay at the center of the case from the start. Three psychiatrists who examined him concluded that he had been insane at the time, and the defense put that evidence before the jury.
Lortie's first trial opened before a jury in Quebec City in January 1985. The question for the jurors was not whether he had caused the three deaths but whether he could be held criminally responsible for them. In his directions on the law, the trial judge told the jury to reject the expert evidence of the three psychiatrists who had found him insane.
On February 13, 1985, the jury rejected the insanity defense and found him guilty on all three counts of first-degree murder. He was sentenced to life imprisonment, with 25 years to serve before he could be considered for parole.
Lortie appealed, with a new lawyer, who built the appeal around the Criminal Code's definition of insanity. In the fall of 1986 the Court of Appeal of Quebec set the conviction aside. It held that the trial judge had been wrong to instruct the jury to reject the testimony of the three psychiatrists, and it ordered a new trial.
The ruling neither acquitted him nor decided whether he had been sane. It sent the case back to a jury, which would have to weigh the psychiatric evidence for itself.
The new trial took place in 1987. Lortie went into the witness box and spoke about his childhood, telling the court that the abuse he had suffered had driven him into mental instability and that the Parti Québécois government had reminded him of his father.
His lawyer then sought to settle the case on reduced charges, and it took two attempts. The first judge to hear the proposal refused to accept a plea of guilty to second-degree murder. On May 11, 1987, a second judge accepted his pleas of guilty to three counts of second-degree murder, and the pleas brought the case to an end. He was sentenced to life imprisonment with no eligibility for parole for ten years.
Lortie served his sentence in the federal system in Quebec. By the mid-1990s he was in a minimum-security institution in the province, where he was receiving psychiatric treatment.
In 1995 the National Parole Board granted him day parole to a halfway house in Hull, Quebec. He would become eligible for full parole six months later.
In 1996 the board granted him full parole.
Denis Lortie was granted full parole in 1996. In 2007 he was released from the conditions of his parole. In May 2024 he was alive and living in the community, out of prison since 1995.
The question of Lortie's sanity was never settled by a verdict. Three psychiatrists considered him insane at the time of the killings. The first jury, told to reject their evidence, convicted him of first-degree murder; the appeal court set that verdict aside because of the direction; and the second trial ended in guilty pleas to second-degree murder before a jury could decide the issue.
March 10, 1959: Denis Lortie is born in Quebec City.
1984: He is a corporal and supply technician at Canadian Forces Station Carp, Ontario.
May 8, 1984: Three people are killed and thirteen injured at the National Assembly in Quebec City; Lortie surrenders that afternoon.
May 9, 1984: He appears in the Quebec Sessions Court, charged with three counts of first-degree murder.
January 1985: His first trial opens before a jury in Quebec City.
February 13, 1985: The jury rejects his insanity defense and convicts him on three counts of first-degree murder; he is sentenced to life imprisonment with 25 years to serve before parole.
Fall 1986: The Court of Appeal of Quebec sets the conviction aside and orders a new trial.
1987: At his second trial a first judge refuses a plea of guilty to second-degree murder.
May 11, 1987: A second judge accepts his guilty pleas to three counts of second-degree murder; he is sentenced to life with no parole eligibility for ten years.
1995: The National Parole Board grants him day parole to a halfway house in Hull, Quebec.
1996: He is granted full parole.
2007: He is released from the conditions of his parole.