Delwar Hossain Sayeedi

Victims
2 murders in Pirojpur, 1971, as crimes against humanity; also convicted of torture, abduction, confinement and rape, and the forced conversion of Hindus.
Years active
May 1971 to June 1971
Location
Parerhat, Chitholia, Umedpur and Hoglabunia, Pirojpur District, Bangladesh (killings and other crimes); Dhaka, Bangladesh (trial, death in custody).
Method
Shot (tribunal findings on both deaths); victims tortured (torture convictions, charges 7 and 8).
Status
Death on 2 charges (2013); Appellate Division commuted it to imprisonment until death, September 17, 2014; reviews dismissed 2017. Died in custody in Dhaka, Bangladesh, August 14, 2023.

Before the war of 1971, Delwar Hossain Sayeedi sold oil, salt, onions and pepper from a shop at Parerhat Bazar in Pirojpur District, in the south of what was then East Pakistan. Four decades later he was among the best-known men in Bangladesh: a preacher whose sermons could draw hundreds of thousands of listeners, a two-term member of parliament and a vice president of the Jamaat-e-Islami party. In 2010 he became the first accused whose case went to trial before the International Crimes Tribunal, the domestic court Bangladesh set up to try crimes committed during its war of independence.

On February 28, 2013, International Crimes Tribunal-1 in Dhaka found him guilty of crimes against humanity on eight of the twenty charges against him and sentenced him to death for two of them: an abduction and murder at the village of Chitholia on May 8, 1971, and a murder in the Hindu quarter of Umedpur on June 2, 1971. The other six convictions covered persecution, torture, abduction, confinement and rape, and the forced conversion of Hindu villagers to Islam. On appeal, the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh acquitted him on three charges, cut the sentence for the Chitholia murder to twelve years, and commuted the death sentence for the Umedpur murder to imprisonment for the rest of his natural life. He denied every charge from first to last. He died in custody in Dhaka on August 14, 2023, at the age of 83.

Sayeedi was born on February 1, 1940, in the village of South Khali, under the Indurkani police station of Pirojpur. He studied in madrasas, passing the Dakhil examination in 1957 and the Alim in 1960. The tribunal's account of his background records that before the war his means were modest and that he ran a small grocery business at Parerhat Bazar. It also records a detail that later mattered in the case: he spoke Urdu well, the language of the West Pakistani officers who would arrive in the district in the spring of 1971.

In those years he went by the family name, and people in the area knew him as Delowar Sikder or Delu Sikder; the tribunal's judgment names him as Delowar Hossain Sayeedi, alias Delu. The name Sayeedi, and the honorifics Allama and Moulana that came to sit in front of it, belonged to the later public career.

The war in East Pakistan began in late March 1971. In Pirojpur, as across the province, local men who sided with the army formed Peace Committees and joined the Razakar Bahini, an auxiliary force that worked with the troops. The tribunal found that Sayeedi was one of them. It held that he was a member of the Razakar force and a close associate of the Pakistani army, and that he took part in forming the Peace Committee and the Razakar unit at Parerhat.

The first charge on which the tribunal convicted him dated from May 7, 1971, the day the army reached Parerhat. It found that Sayeedi led a Peace Committee party to meet the troops and then took part in identifying and looting the property of the town's Hindu and pro-independence families, and it classed this as persecution on political and religious grounds. The Appellate Division later acquitted him of that charge. The next day, May 8, the army and its local helpers went to the village of Baduria. There, the tribunal found, a local Awami League leader was taken and tortured and his family's property looted and set on fire, and it convicted Sayeedi of persecution and of abetting torture, a conviction that stood.

The same day, the tribunal found, the army and Razakars came to the village of Chitholia, near Parerhat. A man named Ibrahim, whom the village knew as Kutti, was seized together with another man, and both were tortured. The second man got away and lived to give evidence. The first did not. The court held that Sayeedi took part in the abduction and in the events that led to the killing, and that five dwellings in the village were set on fire. It convicted him of murder, abduction, torture and persecution as crimes against humanity, and this was the first of the two charges on which it imposed death.

Nearly four weeks later the violence reached the villages under Indurkani, Sayeedi's home police station. On June 2, 1971, the tribunal found, a party of Pakistani soldiers and Razakars that included Sayeedi went to the Hindu quarter of Umedpur. There a man named Bisabali was killed at Sayeedi's direction, and 25 dwellings belonging to the Hindu families of the quarter were set on fire. The court convicted Sayeedi of murder and persecution as crimes against humanity, and imposed death on this charge as well.

Later the same day, the tribunal found, the group went on to the village of Tengra Khali, where the family of a local freedom fighter lived, looted their property and detained and tortured the fighter's elder brother. The tribunal convicted Sayeedi on that charge too; the Appellate Division acquitted him of it.

Three further convictions concerned crimes against women and against Hindu families later in the war. At Hoglabunia, under Indurkani, the tribunal convicted Sayeedi of persecution and rape over the rape of a woman of the village and the burning of Hindu dwellings; the Appellate Division acquitted him on that charge. At Parerhat Bandar, it found that three sisters from a Parerhat family were abducted, handed over to the Pakistani army camp at Pirojpur and held and raped there, and it convicted Sayeedi of abetting their abduction, confinement and rape. That conviction stood.

The last proved charge ran across the whole war, from March 26 to December 16, 1971. The tribunal found that Sayeedi and his associates forced between 100 and 150 Hindus in Parerhat and the surrounding villages to convert to Islam and compelled them to attend prayers at the mosque. It convicted him of other inhuman acts as a crime against humanity.

The war ended on December 16, 1971, with the independence of Bangladesh.

Sayeedi's public life after independence was built on preaching, and he became one of the country's best-known preachers. In 1979 he joined Jamaat-e-Islami as an ordinary supporter. He rose to become one of the party's nayeb-e-ameers, or vice presidents, and he was elected to parliament from Pirojpur in 1996 and again in 2001.

In March 2010 the government set up the International Crimes Tribunal under the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act of 1973. On June 29, 2010, Sayeedi was arrested in Dhaka in a separate case over the alleged hurting of Muslims' religious sentiments, and on August 2, 2010, he was shown as arrested in the case concerning crimes against humanity in 1971. On October 3, 2011, the tribunal framed twenty charges against him, covering killings, abduction, confinement, torture, rape, looting, arson, persecution and forced conversion, all alleged to have been committed in Pirojpur District between May and December 1971. Two of the counts were framed as genocide. He pleaded not guilty to all of them.

His defense rested on three main arguments. The first was an alibi: that he had been living in Jessore, far from Pirojpur, until mid-July 1971, and that he never joined a Peace Committee or the Razakars. The second was mistaken identity: the defense argued that a different Razakar of a similar name, killed after liberation, had committed the crimes. The third attacked the proceedings themselves, arguing that the charges were vague, that forty years had passed and that a tripartite agreement made after the war barred the prosecution.

Tribunal-1 gave its judgment on February 28, 2013. On eight charges it found the case proved beyond reasonable doubt. On the remaining twelve it acquitted him, and the acquittals included both genocide counts and every charge alleging the mass killings in Pirojpur in early May 1971.

The tribunal rejected each defense argument. It held that the alibi had not been proved, and it found no substance in the claim of mistaken identity, because witnesses from the same locality identified the accused in the dock and knew of no other Razakar of that name in their area. The sentence was death for the two murders. Because of it, the court imposed no separate punishment for the other six convictions.

The verdict set off weeks of rallies and street clashes in which scores of people died.

Sayeedi appealed against all eight convictions and asked to be acquitted; the government appealed too, asking for punishment on every charge. A five-judge bench of the Appellate Division gave its decision on September 17, 2014, and it was divided: three judges formed the majority, one would have upheld the death sentence and one would have acquitted Sayeedi of everything. The majority acquitted him of three charges: the looting at Parerhat, the torture at Tengra Khali and the crimes at Hoglabunia. For the persecution and torture at Baduria it imposed ten years' rigorous imprisonment. For the Chitholia murder it altered the sentence to twelve years' rigorous imprisonment. For the Umedpur murder it commuted the death sentence to imprisonment for life, meaning the rest of his natural life. For the abduction and rape of the three sisters and for the forced conversions it sentenced him to imprisonment until death.

Both sides asked the court to review its decision, the government seeking death and Sayeedi seeking acquittal. On May 15, 2017, the Appellate Division dismissed both petitions, and the convictions on five charges and the sentence of imprisonment until death became final.

Sayeedi spent the rest of his life in prison. He died in custody at a hospital in Dhaka on August 14, 2023, at the age of 83.

Sayeedi maintained his innocence throughout and called the charges politically motivated. The core of his defense, the claim that he was in Jessore and not in Pirojpur during the spring of 1971, was rejected by the tribunal, and the convictions that survived appeal rest on that finding. The court itself was divided at the final stage, with one appellate judge for full acquittal and one for death.

The tribunal was a national court with no international judges, and rights organizations questioned its fairness. On the day of the verdict the International Commission of Jurists said the trial had fallen short of international fair-trial standards, citing among other things the denial of pretrial release, the abduction and intimidation of witnesses and allegations of collusion between the government, prosecutors and judges. Human Rights Watch called for an independent investigation after a defense witness was taken from outside the tribunal's gates in November 2012; the prosecution reported that no abduction had happened, and no independent inquiry was held. In December 2012 the chairman of Tribunal-1 resigned after recordings said to be his conversations about the tribunal's work were published, and the bench was reconstituted; the tribunal refused a retrial.

Twelve of the twenty charges ended in acquittal at trial, and three more convictions fell on appeal. Those allegations were never proved against him.

Timeline

February 1, 1940: Born in South Khali, Pirojpur.

May 7, 1971: Pakistani army reaches Parerhat; looting and persecution of Hindu and pro-independence families (convicted 2013, acquitted on appeal 2014).

May 8, 1971: Persecution and torture at Baduria; abduction and murder at Chitholia.

June 2, 1971: Murder and burning of 25 dwellings in the Hindu quarter of Umedpur; torture at Tengra Khali (convicted 2013, acquitted on appeal 2014).

March 26 to December 16, 1971: Forced conversion of 100 to 150 Hindus.

1979: Joins Jamaat-e-Islami.

1996 and 2001: Elected to parliament from Pirojpur.

March 2010: International Crimes Tribunal set up.

June 29, 2010: Arrested in a separate case; shown arrested in the 1971 case on August 2, 2010.

October 3, 2011: Twenty charges framed.

February 28, 2013: Convicted on eight charges; sentenced to death on two.

September 17, 2014: Appellate Division acquits on three charges and commutes death to imprisonment until death.

May 15, 2017: Review petitions of both sides dismissed.

August 14, 2023: Dies in custody in Dhaka, aged 83.