On the morning of Friday, May 31, 2019, DeWayne Craddock sent his supervisor a short email. He was resigning his post as an Engineer III with the City of Virginia Beach, he wrote, for personal reasons; it had been a pleasure to serve the city. His supervisor asked him to confirm a last day of June 14. Craddock spent part of the afternoon visiting project sites with two colleagues so the work could be handed on, then came back to the office.
By the end of that afternoon, twelve people were dead. Eleven of them had worked alongside him in the city's public works and public utilities departments, and one was a man who had come to the building on business. Four more people were critically injured, and a police officer was hurt. Before evening Craddock himself had been killed by Virginia Beach police officers. He was 40 years old.
Because he died that afternoon, no charge was ever filed and no court ever ruled on what happened. The deaths are attributed to him by the Virginia Beach Police Department, whose 20-month investigation closed in March 2021, and by the FBI. Neither found a clear answer to the question the investigators kept asking. He left no note. The police concluded that the reason might never be known; the FBI's behavioral analysts, a few months later, pointed to workplace grievances on which he had fixated for years.
Craddock was born on October 15, 1978, and grew up in Hampton Roads, the cluster of cities around the mouth of the Chesapeake Bay. He graduated from Denbigh High School in Newport News in 1996. That April, still a teenager, he enlisted in the Army National Guard in Hampton. He went through basic training at Fort Sill, Oklahoma, and was then assigned to an infantry brigade combat team in Norfolk. He was never deployed, and in April 2002 he received an honorable discharge.
The discharge came the same spring he finished his degree. In May 2002 he graduated from Old Dominion University in Norfolk with a Bachelor of Science in civil engineering and began his professional career. In June 2008 he passed the engineering examination and became a licensed professional engineer.
His working life before the city was unremarkable. Police later found that he had lost one position for economic reasons, and that at an earlier employer there had been a disagreement with a supervisor; he was not written up, and nothing about it involved violence.
The City of Virginia Beach hired him as an Engineer II in February 2010. He worked in the public utilities department, out of a five-story brick building on the city's government campus that was the daily workplace for about 400 people in public works, public utilities, planning and information technology, as well as the place where residents came for building permits and plan reviews. By 2019 he held the rank of Engineer III.
For seven years his record was clean. Those who knew him described a reserved, organized man who kept his living and working spaces immaculate and was modest about what he had achieved. Neighbors saw a clean-cut man who sat on the board of the neighborhood association, a car enthusiast and bodybuilder. A colleague called him quiet, polite and a nice guy. He drank occasionally and did not use drugs. He briefly played in a workplace volleyball group and then dropped out of it some years before 2019. He did not attend church and kept no social media accounts.
Investigators traced the change to 2017. People around him noticed that he began to withdraw, and he had no close friends, police found. He had no diagnosed mental illness and no prescriptions for controlled medications in the two years before May 2019, and his financial records showed no trouble: his bills were paid, and he had a sizable amount of money in the bank.
His work began to slip at the same time. A paperwork issue in December 2016 was written up as a record of incident, though not as discipline. In June 2017 he was placed on a performance improvement plan over shortcomings in managing his projects. His annual evaluation that August found that he met expectations.
The following year was harder. On July 12, 2018, he received a written reprimand for poor performance. He met with his immediate supervisor about it at the end of July and with the next supervisor up the chain in early August, and neither meeting resolved anything. On August 9 he filed a grievance. In it, and at other times, he said he was being given work above his pay grade. His evaluation that month rated his overall performance as poor, and he received no merit increase. On September 7 he was told that the reprimand stood and that his assignments were within his grade and would stay that way. His supervisor also told him that he had been improving and encouraged him to keep going. Department leaders later said that he would have met the standards in his 2019 evaluation.
There was no substantiated report that he had ever threatened anyone, by word or in writing.
Early in 2019 a payment for one of the projects he managed ran into trouble. A vendor asked to be paid, and when Craddock submitted the request a discrepancy came to light that stopped the payment. The purchasing office took the matter to the city attorney's office. On May 29 a purchasing employee left him a voicemail about it. On May 30 he met with his immediate supervisors, who told him the problem was being handled. That same day he told a co-worker that he would cover the amount, less than $5,000, out of his own pocket if it came to that.
He was at his desk early the next morning, and the resignation email followed a few hours later.
Of the seventeen people killed or hurt, sixteen worked for the city, and all of those except a police officer worked in that building. Between them, the eleven city employees who died had given the city more than 150 years of service.
Laquita C. Brown lived in Chesapeake. Friends called her "Ms. Worldwide" for the trips she took and documented, to New York City, to Europe and to West Africa. A former colleague said she lit up the office every day and brought cupcakes in on the bad ones. She was a devout Jehovah's Witness.
Ryan Keith Cox, of Virginia Beach, had worked for the city for more than twelve years. He had a voice that friends called golden and sang in his church choir, and he had recently accepted a call to the ministry and was working on his first sermon. Witnesses said that on May 31 he guided colleagues to safety and stayed behind to look out for others.
Tara Welch Gallagher, of Virginia Beach, had been with the city for six years, and part of what she did was help the public understand clean water.
Mary Louise Gayle, known as Mary Lou, lived in Virginia Beach and had worked for the city for 24 years. Neighbors knew her as a sweet woman with a wide smile who was nearly always out in her yard working on something and ready to talk with whoever passed.
Alexander Mikhail Gusev, of Virginia Beach, had nine years with the city. Those who knew him described a generous, thoughtful man who would cut a neighbor's lawn without being asked.
Joshua O. Hardy, of Virginia Beach, had been with the city for a little over four years. He was a devoted uncle, a careful eater and a runner who smiled through the working day, and he had written a book for children about the danger of strangers.
Michelle Langer, whom everyone called Missy, lived in Virginia Beach and had twelve years with the city. She loved the Pittsburgh Steelers, Paul McCartney and the ocean, and those close to her remembered someone who was always laughing.
Richard H. Nettleton, of Norfolk, had given the city 28 years. He was an Army veteran who had served as a lieutenant in the 130th Engineer Brigade in Germany. A friend remembered that he always wore a jacket and tie to work, and he took pleasure in mentoring younger colleagues.
Katherine A. Nixon, known as Kate, lived in Virginia Beach and had about ten years with the city. She had learned to quilt as a teenager.
Christopher Kelly Rapp lived in Powhatan County and had been with Virginia Beach for only eleven months. He had graduated from Old Dominion University in 1994. He loved Scottish music, played the bagpipes and had joined the Tidewater Pipes and Drums the previous fall; the band remembered him as reserved but friendly, quietly drawing members out one by one after the weekly practice. In Powhatan he had spent much of his free time over several years keeping a neighbor company through a long recovery.
Herbert Snelling, known as Bert, of Virginia Beach, was not a city employee. He had come to the building that afternoon to obtain a permit, and he was active in his church, where he led its security team.
Robert Williams, known as Bobby, lived in Chesapeake and had worked for the city for 41 years, longer than any of the others. He was planning to retire that year and spend more time with his family.
After a prolonged confrontation with four Virginia Beach police officers, he was taken into custody gravely hurt, and he died that evening. One of the officers was hurt but escaped serious injury.
The next day police named Craddock and said that he had not been fired. In early June, Virginia's Office of the Chief Medical Examiner classified Craddock's own death as a homicide, which ruled out suicide.
Three inquiries followed, and they did not reach quite the same place.
An independent review commissioned by the city, the Associated Press reported in November 2019, found no clear motive and no warning signs that would have given the city a chance to step in.
The police department released its final report on March 24, 2021, after a twenty-month investigation in which detectives examined his finances, his medical records and his correspondence. They found no one who had helped him and no one who had known in advance. They found no statement, act or document that would have let a reasonable person foresee what happened, no sign of violent tendencies before that day, and no tie to any radical religious or anti-government belief. Apart from two minor traffic offenses he had no criminal record. The report examined each victim's background and his correspondence with them and found nothing to explain why some were harmed and others spared; some of the victims, it said, had no connection to him at all. Its conclusion described him as a very private man who shared little with the people he worked with, and said that it appeared the reason for what he did might never be known.
In May 2021, the Virginia Beach Commonwealth's Attorney completed his own review of the police response and of Craddock's death. In a letter to the police chief he found that the four officers involved had been justified in using deadly force, acting in defense of the employees still in the building, of themselves and of the other officers present, and that no charges would be filed.
The FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit delivered its assessment on June 9, 2021. It concluded that Craddock had been motivated by perceived workplace grievances on which he had fixated for years, and that the significant mental health stressors in his life could not explain the attack on their own. Because he had isolated himself, the bureau found, no one had been placed to see the combination of behaviors that might have warned of it.
Motive remains the central open question. The police investigation found none and said so; the FBI pointed to perceived workplace grievances. None of these findings was ever tested in a court.
His length of service was given at first as fifteen years. The police department's own record shows that the city hired him in February 2010, a little over nine years before his death.
Claims that he believed he was singled out because of his race rest on a single witness, and investigators found nothing to show that he had raised that belief with a supervisor; an earlier complaint he made about a co-worker's slur was investigated, denied and never substantiated.
In the first minutes, two callers to 911 named other employees as the attacker, one of them a man dismissed the day before; neither had any part in the events, and later callers gave the correct name.
October 15, 1978: DeWayne Antonio Craddock is born; he grows up in Hampton Roads, Virginia.
1996: Graduates from Denbigh High School in Newport News; enlists in the Army National Guard in April.
April 2002: Honorably discharged from the Army National Guard.
May 2002: Graduates from Old Dominion University with a degree in civil engineering.
June 2008: Becomes a licensed professional engineer.
February 2010: Hired by the City of Virginia Beach as an Engineer II.
June 2017: Placed on a performance improvement plan.
July 12, 2018: Receives a written reprimand for poor performance.
August 9, 2018: Files a grievance against the reprimand.
September 7, 2018: Told that the reprimand stands.
May 30, 2019: Meets supervisors over a project payment.
May 31, 2019: Emails his resignation; that afternoon twelve people die and five are injured in Virginia Beach. Craddock is killed by police the same day.
June 2019: The medical examiner classifies his death as a homicide.
March 24, 2021: Police release their final report; no motive is found.
May 2021: The Commonwealth's Attorney finds the officers justified and files no charges.
June 9, 2021: The FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit cites perceived workplace grievances.