David Milgaard was 16 years old, a teenager from Winnipeg on a road trip with two friends, when he passed through Saskatoon in the last days of January 1969. On January 31 of that year a young woman named Gail Miller died in the city. Exactly one year later, on January 31, 1970, a Saskatoon jury found Milgaard guilty of her murder, and he was sentenced to life imprisonment. He had not done it. He spent 23 years in prison before the government of Saskatchewan stayed the charge in April 1992, and five more years passed before forensic testing, in July 1997, excluded him and pointed instead to Larry Fisher, a man with a record of sexual offenses who had been living in the same part of Saskatoon. Fisher was convicted of first-degree murder in 1999. A provincial commission of inquiry found in 2008 that a tip received by police in 1980 could have led them to Fisher a dozen years before Milgaard walked free.
The case became the defining Canadian wrongful conviction of its generation. It produced a $10 million settlement, then the largest in the country's history, a public inquiry that ran for four years, and, two years after Milgaard's death in 2022, a federal statute that bears his name and his mother's: David and Joyce Milgaard's Law, which replaced the old ministerial review of convictions with an independent commission.
Milgaard was born in 1952 and grew up in Winnipeg. His mother would become the most persistent figure in the long effort to free him; his sister lived to see the federal law passed in 2024. The trip that changed his life began early in 1969, when he set out with two friends from Regina, bound for Vancouver. They meant to collect another friend in Saskatoon on the way. They got no farther than that city.
The young woman who died that January lived and worked in Saskatoon. She died in the city on January 31, 1969, and the Saskatoon police investigated her death as a murder. For nearly three decades the wrong man carried the conviction for it, while the man who had in fact taken her life was convicted of other crimes committed in Saskatoon around the same time. Everything that followed, the campaign, the reference, the settlement and the inquiry, grew out of the loss of one young woman whose own life was cut short before any of it began.
The three travelers from Regina reached Saskatoon early on the morning of January 31. They were strangers to the city, and in the weeks that followed police attention settled on Milgaard.
The case against him was built from the statements of the young people around him. On March 2, 1969, the friend the group had come to Saskatoon to collect went to the police with an account implicating Milgaard. That friend was later revealed to have acted as a police informant and to have received a $2,000 reward. On May 24, 1969, one of the two companions from the road trip gave police a statement that was later shown to be untrue. The 2008 commission of inquiry pointed to a polygraph examiner brought in from Calgary, who it said may have pressured both of Milgaard's traveling companions into giving false accounts during police questioning.
On May 30, 1969, Milgaard was charged with murder and arrested.
Milgaard was tried before a jury in Saskatoon. The jury returned its verdict on January 31, 1970, a year to the day after her death, and found him guilty of her murder. He was sentenced to life imprisonment, with no eligibility for parole for ten years.
The appeal went quickly. On January 5, 1971, the Court of Appeal for Saskatchewan dismissed it. On November 15, 1971, the Supreme Court of Canada refused him leave to appeal. At 19 he had exhausted every ordinary remedy the law offered, and the conviction stood.
He served his sentence at Stony Mountain, the federal penitentiary just north of Winnipeg. In a 1995 interview he described what those years had been like: "You die a little each day."
In 1980 he escaped from Stony Mountain. He was at large for 77 days before the RCMP recaptured him. Inside, he started a prisoners' group that he called the Justice Group, an early sign of the cause that would occupy the rest of his life.
While Milgaard was beginning his sentence, the man who had in fact committed the crime was still in Saskatoon. Larry Fisher was arrested in September 1970 in connection with another offense. On December 21, 1971, he pleaded guilty to four sexual assaults and was sent to prison. He was released in 1980, and on June 11, 1981, he was convicted again, of further offenses that included attempted murder.
On August 28, 1980, Fisher's former wife went to the Saskatoon police and told them that he might have committed the murder. Police did not follow it up. The 2008 inquiry found that this tip could have led police to Fisher well before 1992. It was the single largest missed opportunity in the case.
Milgaard's mother never accepted the verdict. For more than a decade she led a campaign for his release, and in March 1983 she learned a fact that reshaped it: at the time of the death, Fisher had been lodging with the family of the very friend the three travelers had come to Saskatoon to collect.
On December 28, 1988, Milgaard applied to the federal Minister of Justice for a review of his conviction, the only route left to a prisoner whose appeals had run out. The application sat for more than two years. In February 1991 the minister dismissed it.
On August 14, 1991, a second application was filed, this time arguing directly that Fisher had committed the crime. It succeeded where the first had failed. On November 28, 1991, the federal cabinet ordered a reference, and the next day the Attorney General of Canada filed a reference in the Supreme Court of Canada asking whether Milgaard's continued conviction amounted to a miscarriage of justice.
The reference was unlike an ordinary appeal. Milgaard and the Attorneys General of Canada and Saskatchewan were heard through counsel, and in December 1991 the Court granted Fisher leave to intervene, so that the man who had in fact committed the crime sat as a party in the proceeding meant to decide whether Milgaard had been wrongly convicted of it. The hearings ran through the first months of 1992.
On April 14, 1992, a five-judge panel led by the Chief Justice delivered its answer. The Court concluded that the conviction should be quashed and that a new trial should be held. The reference was allowed, and the case went back to Saskatchewan.
Saskatchewan did not retry him. On April 16, 1992, two days after the ruling, the provincial government announced a stay of proceedings, and Milgaard left prison after about 23 years. A stay is not an acquittal, and no verdict of not guilty was ever entered. He walked out a free man whose name had not been cleared, and for five more years the murder charge remained, in law, merely suspended.
The answer came from the laboratory. On July 18, 1997, forensic testing excluded Milgaard and pointed to Fisher. The federal Department of Justice records 1997 as the year of his exoneration. The RCMP arrested Fisher.
Fisher went on trial in Saskatoon. On November 22, 1999, the jury convicted him of first-degree murder, and he was sentenced to life imprisonment. The Court of Appeal for Saskatchewan dismissed his appeal on September 29, 2003, and on August 26, 2004, the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed his application for leave to appeal. He died in custody at the Pacific Institution in Abbotsford, British Columbia, in June 2015, at the age of 65, while serving the life sentence.
On May 17, 1999, Saskatchewan's Justice Minister and Milgaard's counsel announced a compensation settlement worth $10 million in total, covering pain and suffering, lost income, out-of-pocket expenses and legal fees. The federal government agreed to contribute $4 million of it. It was the largest compensation package in Canadian history, and the province also issued Milgaard a formal apology.
The same announcement repeated the province's commitment to a public inquiry into the investigation of the 1969 death and Milgaard's conviction, to go ahead once it could no longer interfere with criminal proceedings. On September 9, 2004, after Fisher's appeals were finished, the government of Saskatchewan formally acknowledged that Milgaard was factually innocent.
Saskatchewan ordered the public inquiry on February 18, 2004, and placed it under a justice of the Alberta Court of Queen's Bench. Its report was released on September 26, 2008.
The report did not settle every question about why the conviction happened. It pointed to the polygraph examiner who may have pushed the two traveling companions into false statements. It found that the police had acted in good faith and that there had been no malfeasance, and it identified the unpursued 1980 report from Fisher's former wife as a chance that could have reached the real killer years earlier. Its handling of his mother's campaign was contentious: the report said that she, her lawyers, investigators and supporters had at times given the media information that turned out to be false. Its central recommendation looked forward. Parliament, it said, should create an independent body to review claims of wrongful conviction, an agency that could make costly commissions of inquiry unnecessary.
Milgaard was not in Saskatoon when the report was released. He spent his later years in Calgary, and he made the cause of the wrongly convicted his own. In 2015 he said: "The wrongful conviction review process is failing all of us miserably."
In 2019 he was appointed to an Independent Review Board Working Group ordered by the prime minister, and his group's written submission is cited throughout the federal Department of Justice's later report on a miscarriages of justice commission. About two years before his death he met the federal Justice Minister to press for an independent tribunal. To the end he worked on other people's cases. One of them was that of two Saskatchewan sisters convicted in a 1993 killing whose claims of wrongful conviction he championed; in December 2021 an application for ministerial review was filed on their behalf.
He died in a Calgary hospital on May 15, 2022, of complications related to pneumonia, after a short illness. He was 69, and he was survived by his wife and two children.
The independent body that the 2008 inquiry recommended, and that Milgaard had argued for since his release, came after him. The federal government introduced Bill C-40 on February 16, 2023, under the title the Miscarriage of Justice Review Commission Act (David and Joyce Milgaard's Law). The law was named for his advocacy and his mother's. It received Royal Assent on December 17, 2024. Milgaard did not live to see it pass.
The first provisions came into force on March 6, 2025, and the government announced that the commission's headquarters would be in Winnipeg, the city where Milgaard was born. As of that announcement the commission was not yet operating.
The law moved the review of convictions out of the Department of Justice to a standalone commission with the powers of a public inquiry.
Milgaard's innocence is not in dispute. After 1992 no court ever tried him again: the charge was stayed, forensic testing excluded him in 1997, the province acknowledged his factual innocence in 2004, and Larry Fisher was convicted of the murder in 1999, a conviction upheld on appeal.
What remains unsettled is why the 1970 conviction happened. The 2008 commission did not fully explain it. Its finding about the polygraph examiner was framed as a possibility, that he may have pressured the two traveling companions into false statements, not as an established fact, and it found no police malfeasance. Its account of his mother's campaign was contentious from the day the report appeared.
1952: David Milgaard is born; he grows up in Winnipeg.
January 31, 1969: The young woman dies in Saskatoon; Milgaard, 16, is passing through the city with two friends.
March 2, 1969: A Saskatoon friend gives police an account implicating Milgaard.
May 24, 1969: One of his traveling companions gives a statement later shown to be untrue.
May 30, 1969: Milgaard is charged with murder and arrested.
January 31, 1970: A Saskatoon jury finds him guilty; he is sentenced to life imprisonment.
January 5, 1971: The Court of Appeal for Saskatchewan dismisses his appeal.
November 15, 1971: The Supreme Court of Canada refuses leave to appeal.
December 21, 1971: Larry Fisher pleads guilty to four sexual assaults.
1980: Milgaard escapes from Stony Mountain and is recaptured by the RCMP after 77 days.
August 28, 1980: Fisher's former wife tells Saskatoon police he may have committed the murder; the report is not followed up.
March 1983: Milgaard's mother learns Fisher was lodging with the family of the Saskatoon friend in January 1969.
December 28, 1988: First application to the federal Minister of Justice.
February 1991: The first application is dismissed.
August 14, 1991: Second application, naming Fisher.
November 28 and 29, 1991: Cabinet orders a reference; it is filed in the Supreme Court of Canada.
April 14, 1992: The Supreme Court concludes the conviction should be quashed and a new trial held.
April 16, 1992: Saskatchewan stays the charge; Milgaard is released after about 23 years.
July 18, 1997: Forensic testing excludes Milgaard and points to Fisher.
May 17, 1999: A $10 million compensation settlement is announced.
November 22, 1999: Fisher is convicted of first-degree murder.
September 29, 2003: Fisher's appeal is dismissed.
February 18, 2004: Saskatchewan orders a public inquiry.
August 26, 2004: The Supreme Court of Canada dismisses Fisher's application for leave to appeal.
September 9, 2004: Saskatchewan acknowledges Milgaard's factual innocence.
September 26, 2008: The inquiry's report is released.
June 2015: Fisher dies in custody in Abbotsford, British Columbia.
May 15, 2022: Milgaard dies in Calgary, aged 69.
February 16, 2023: Bill C-40, David and Joyce Milgaard's Law, is introduced.
December 17, 2024: The law receives Royal Assent.
March 6, 2025: Its first provisions take effect; the commission is to be based in Winnipeg.