On the evening of February 4, 1936, in the Alpine resort of Davos, a 26-year-old Jewish medical student named David Frankfurter killed Wilhelm Gustloff, the man who led the Nazi party's organization of Germans living in Switzerland. Shortly afterward he gave himself up to the Davos police and confessed. He told investigators that he had no personal quarrel with the party leader, that he had meant his act as a blow against Hitler, and that no one had sent him. Ten months later the Graubünden Cantonal Court, sitting in Chur, found him guilty of murder on every count and sentenced him to 18 years' penal servitude, the maximum the prosecution had asked for, followed by expulsion from Switzerland for life.
The case was never only a criminal one. Berlin turned the dead man into a martyr of the movement and sent its lawyers and journalists to Chur in force. Bern, caught between an angry neighbor and its own law, dissolved the party's Swiss organization within weeks of the killing and then insisted that the trial be conducted as an ordinary murder trial under cantonal law. Frankfurter served about nine years in Chur. In June 1945, a few weeks after the war in Europe ended, the Graubünden Grand Council pardoned him. He left Switzerland for Palestine, worked for decades in the public service of the new Israeli state, and died in Israel in 1982.
Frankfurter was born on July 9, 1909, in what is now Croatia, then part of Austria-Hungary. By the 1930s he was a citizen of Yugoslavia. In 1929 he went to Germany to study medicine, and he was still there when the National Socialists took power in 1933. Alarmed by the antisemitic violence that followed, he moved to Switzerland and continued his studies in Bern from the winter semester of 1933 to 1934.
His time in Bern was unsettled. He studied at the university there until July 1935, then left Switzerland for several months, and returned in the autumn. He did not go back to his courses. He took a room in Bern and lived quietly. He had shown no known interest in politics, belonged to no party, and was not known in the city's Jewish community.
At his trial he said that when he left Bern he had no clear plan, and that he had wanted mainly to get away and end his life. He blamed an article in a Nazi antisemitic weekly for driving him toward the act, and he spoke of an inner force that pushed him to take revenge for his people.
Davos in the 1930s was an international health resort with a large German population. After 1933 the Nazi party took control of the German expatriate community there, which made up roughly a quarter of the town's residents, and of the Swiss who sympathized with it. The party bought property in the town, including sanatoriums.
The man at the center of that effort had lived in Davos since 1917. In the early 1930s the party made him its Landesgruppenleiter, the leader of its national group for Switzerland, and after 1933 he drew more of his countrymen in the resort into the movement. Swiss authorities warned him repeatedly about his work organizing Germans in Switzerland in support of Hitler. To the German state he was a figure of real rank.
Frankfurter arrived in Davos on January 31, 1936, and took a hotel room. For several days he went to concerts and films. On the evening of Tuesday, February 4, he killed the party leader in Davos.
He did not take his own life. He went to the police in Davos and surrendered. Under questioning he was calm and composed. He confessed to traveling from Bern to Davos to carry out the killing. He said he bore the dead man no grudge and had chosen him as a way to strike at Hitler. He denied that any group had planned or ordered the act and said he had acted on his own will and for ideological reasons. Asked later why he had done it, he gave an answer that turned on his own identity as a Jew, and he told investigators that he had acted in protest against the antisemitic policy of the German Reich. Police in Graubünden opened an investigation.
The killing came two days before the Winter Olympic Games opened at Garmisch-Partenkirchen, which ran from February 6 to February 16, 1936. The regime in Berlin used the death at once for antisemitic propaganda, and the dead man was presented as a martyr of the party. Party newspapers held the Jewish people as a whole responsible. At the same time the leadership feared disorder that could damage the Games. On February 5, 1936, the office of the party's deputy leader sent a decree to the regional party leaderships ordering them to prevent individual actions against Jews. Large-scale reprisals against Jews in Germany did not follow that winter, held back by the approaching Olympic Games.
The German flag over the consulate in Bern was lowered to half-staff, and Germany marked the death with state honors.
Bern then acted against the organization itself. After weeks of pressure from Swiss newspapers, the Federal Council decided in mid-February 1936 to prohibit the activities of the party organization the dead man had led, and it moved quickly so the ban would take effect before a successor could be appointed. Germany protested the dissolution of its party organization in Switzerland. The Swiss government answered on March 1, 1936, in a note to the German envoy in Bern, that its action was entirely consistent with Swiss sovereignty.
Frankfurter was not a German citizen, and he was never handed over to Germany. He stayed in Swiss custody while the authorities of Graubünden prepared the case. The trial was set for Chur, the cantonal capital, at first for the autumn. A Zurich advocate took the defense, with a lawyer from Amsterdam assisting him. Swiss newspapers wrote that donations were arriving for the defense, and they described the prisoner as deeply depressed, a young man for whom everything seemed like a dream.
The trial slipped to December. In early November 1936 the Nazi party's own news service announced that an intensive propaganda campaign was being prepared around it.
The indictment, completed in the first days of December, charged Frankfurter with murder. The prosecution asked for the maximum the law allowed: 18 years' imprisonment, loss of civil rights, expulsion from the country and payment of the costs.
The trial opened in Chur on December 9, 1936. Some two hundred foreign journalists came, and nearly fifty of them were reporters from Nazi Germany.
Frankfurter did not contest what he had done. He confessed to every detail of the killing and said he had acted to avenge the persecuted Jews of Germany. When the court came to his state of mind, he again rejected the picture of a cold plan formed in Bern. He told the judges that he had arrived in Davos without having resolved to kill, and that he had left Bern intending to end his own life.
A psychiatric expert examined him. The expert found him fully responsible for his actions but diagnosed a reactive depression and recorded that he had been preoccupied with thoughts of suicide. Medical evidence of depression was part of the record before the judges.
The prosecution argued that the killing was premeditated. The defense built its case instead on the political background: it argued that the accused had acted in a state of intense mental excitement brought on by the Nazi persecution of the Jews, and it placed evidence of that persecution before the court.
The court did not accept that framing. It treated the case as a murder and declined to make the persecution of the Jews in Germany a ground for leniency.
The Graubünden Cantonal Court gave its judgment in mid-December 1936, at the close of the trial. It found Frankfurter guilty on every count of the indictment. It sentenced him to 18 years' penal servitude, the full term the prosecution had sought, and credited him with the eight months he had already spent in custody. On completing the sentence he was to be expelled from Switzerland for life, and he was ordered to pay the costs of the proceedings.
The court judged the case under the cantonal penal code of Graubünden, which did not recognize political murder as a separate offense. That is why the judges could, and did, set aside the political argument of the defense and look only at the act, the intent and the responsibility of the accused. The penalty followed the same law: the 18 years demanded by the prosecution was the maximum available, and the court imposed it.
The reaction in Germany was immediate. Newspapers there printed special editions. The German press, which had demanded the death penalty, attacked the judgment for its mildness and warned the Swiss authorities against an early release or pardon, and the German ambassador lodged an official protest with the Swiss government.
The same cantonal structure governed the end of the sentence. A pardon in Graubünden lay with the canton, not with the federal government: a petition went first to the cantonal executive, then known as the Small Council, and the final decision belonged to the Grand Council, the cantonal parliament.
Frankfurter served his sentence in the prison at Chur. He was regarded as a model prisoner. His years there coincided with the war, and his position was precarious: had Germany occupied Switzerland, he faced the prospect of being handed to the Reich for a Nazi show trial.
As the war in Europe ended, his case came back before the canton. On March 5, 1945, his lawyer submitted a petition for pardon to the Small Council of Graubünden. The cantonal judicial authorities recommended in May that he be released, and the Swiss press was almost unanimous in urging the Grand Council to agree. On May 18, 1945, Swiss radio announced that the pardon would go ahead.
On June 1, 1945, the Grand Council of Graubünden voted 78 to 12 to pardon him. The pardon released him from the rest of his prison term, but the expulsion stood: under the terms of the original judgment he was to leave Switzerland as soon as conditions allowed. He had served about nine years of the 18.
He walked out of the prison in Chur in the first days of June 1945. Crowds filled the streets as he went to the railway station carrying a small bag. He looked pale and bewildered. He said that he wanted to leave Switzerland and begin life again in a place where people could live and work without fear of persecution, and he thanked the prison warden and the warden's wife for the care they had given him.
Frankfurter left for Palestine. He arrived on an immigrant ship on Rosh Hashanah in 1945. He joined the Haganah, the Jewish underground defense force, and worked first as a clerk in the absorption department of the Jewish Agency. After the founding of Israel in 1948 he worked in the rehabilitation department for disabled people at the Ministry of Defense and later at the Ministry of Agriculture.
In 1946, with the help of the writer Schalom Ben-Chorin, he recorded his life story. A Hebrew version was published in February 1948 under the title Nakam, meaning revenge.
Switzerland lifted the entry ban against him in 1969. Frankfurter died in Israel in July 1982, after a long illness, at the age of 73.
Whether the killing was planned in advance was the main factual question at the trial. The prosecution argued premeditation, a plan formed in Bern weeks before the act. Frankfurter told the court that he had left Bern without a settled intention and had resolved on the act only in Davos. The court's verdict of murder on every count and its maximum sentence show that it did not accept his account as a ground for a lesser finding.
His mental state was examined but not found to reduce his responsibility. The psychiatric expert found him fully accountable while diagnosing a reactive depression with suicidal thoughts.
The German side claimed from the start, and again after the verdict, that others stood behind him. Frankfurter denied from his first interrogation that any group had planned or ordered the act, and no accomplice was ever charged.
The defense's claim that the dead man had worked toward the annexation of German-speaking Switzerland rested on documents the defense presented in court. The court did not rule on that claim, because it declined to weigh the political background at all.
July 9, 1909: Frankfurter is born in what is now Croatia, then part of Austria-Hungary.
1929: He moves to Germany to study medicine.
Winter semester 1933 to 1934: He continues his medical studies in Bern, Switzerland.
July 1935: He leaves his studies in Bern and later returns to the city without resuming them.
January 31, 1936: He arrives in Davos.
February 4, 1936: He kills the leader of the Nazi party's Swiss national group in Davos and surrenders to police the same evening.
February 5, 1936: The deputy party leader's office orders party leaderships in Germany to prevent individual actions against Jews.
Mid-February 1936: The Swiss Federal Council prohibits the activities of the party's Swiss national organization.
March 1, 1936: Switzerland rejects a German protest against the dissolution.
Early December 1936: The indictment charges murder and asks for 18 years.
December 9, 1936: The trial opens before the Graubünden Cantonal Court in Chur.
Mid-December 1936: Guilty on all counts; 18 years' penal servitude, eight months credited, lifelong expulsion and costs.
March 5, 1945: His lawyer petitions the Small Council of Graubünden for a pardon.
May 18, 1945: Swiss radio announces that the pardon will go ahead.
June 1, 1945: The Graubünden Grand Council pardons him by 78 votes to 12.
Early June 1945: He leaves the prison in Chur and then Switzerland.
Rosh Hashanah 1945: He arrives in Palestine.
1946: He records his life story with Schalom Ben-Chorin.
February 1948: The Hebrew account, Nakam, is published.
1969: Switzerland lifts his entry ban.
July 1982: Frankfurter dies in Israel.