Over three Saturdays and a Friday evening in April 1999, London was hit by a run of explosions aimed, the courts later found, at the city's black, Bangladeshi and gay communities. The first came in Brixton, in south London, on April 17. The second came in east London a week later, on April 24. The third, in Soho on the evening of Friday, April 30, killed three people: Andrea Dykes, John Light and Nicholas (Nik) Moore. Many others were seriously injured.
The man responsible was David James Copeland, a 22-year-old from Cove, near Farnborough in Hampshire. He was arrested within days of the Soho explosion. In February 2000 he admitted the three explosion offenses and offered to admit manslaughter on the ground of diminished responsibility, but denied murder. The prosecution would not accept the manslaughter plea, the case went to trial at the Central Criminal Court in London, and on June 30, 2000, a jury unanimously convicted him of all three murders. He received life imprisonment on every count. In 2007 a High Court judge fixed the minimum term he must serve before he can be considered for release at 50 years, less the time he had spent on remand, and in 2011 the Court of Appeal dismissed his challenge to that term.
Copeland came from Cove, a district of Farnborough in north Hampshire. He was 22 at the time of the explosions.
He had no previous convictions for violence, a point his counsel later pressed on the Court of Appeal. His politics were another matter. In the years before 1999 he had been a member of the British National Party and then of a smaller group, the National Socialist Movement. After his arrest he told police that he had acted alone. The High Court in 2007 found that his offenses were motivated by racialist and homophobic ideology, and treated that as one of the features that made the case so grave.
The first explosion came in Brixton on Saturday, April 17, 1999, in south London. No warning was given. On April 26 the Home Secretary gave the House of Commons the count of injured: 39 members of the public and three police officers. Many of those hurt in Brixton were seriously injured, among them a small child.
Several far-right groups claimed the attack in the days that followed. None of those claims proved true; the man responsible was working alone.
A week later, on Saturday, April 24, a second explosion went off in east London, in the heart of the city's Bangladeshi community. Again there was no warning. The Home Secretary told Parliament that six people were injured. The injuries in this second incident were generally less serious than those in Brixton.
By then the Metropolitan Police had linked the two incidents, both on a Saturday and both without warning. The inquiry was made the first priority of the whole force, and the anti-terrorist branch took the lead.
The early suspicion, in the press and inside the inquiry, fell on the organized far right. That was the wrong direction. The answer would come not from any group but from a picture. Detectives released closed-circuit images of the man they believed was responsible for the Brixton explosion, and the case began to turn on whether anyone in London would recognize him.
The third explosion came on the evening of Friday, April 30, 1999, in Soho, in the West End of London. It was the deadliest of the three. Three people were killed and several more were seriously injured, some of them with injuries that changed their lives permanently.
Those three deaths turned a campaign that had already injured dozens into a triple murder inquiry, and they are the three murders on which the jury would later return its verdicts.
The timing of the third explosion was not accidental. The Court of Appeal later found that Copeland had brought it forward because he feared that his arrest was close. He was right: within days of the Soho explosion he was in custody.
The break came from recognition. A man who had seen the released images told police that he believed Copeland was involved. A second person who recognized the face passed information to the police as well.
Copeland was arrested in Hampshire in the first days of May 1999, within days of the Soho explosion. He admitted the explosions at once and said that he had carried them out on his own. He was charged with the three murders. In interviews he again said that he had acted alone and admitted that he had been planning the attacks for three years. He was held on remand from then until his trial; the High Court later calculated his time on remand at 13 months and 26 days.
Copeland first appeared to plead at the Central Criminal Court on February 24, 2000. He pleaded guilty to three counts of causing an explosion likely to endanger life, one for each of the three incidents. To the three counts of murder he pleaded not guilty, but he offered to plead guilty to manslaughter on the ground of diminished responsibility.
The prosecution did not accept the manslaughter plea. The question whether he was guilty of murder or only of manslaughter therefore went to a jury.
The trial was heard at the Central Criminal Court before the Recorder of London and a jury. The issue was narrow. Copeland did not dispute that he had caused all three explosions or that three people had died in Soho as a result. What the jury had to decide was whether his responsibility for those deaths was substantially diminished by an abnormality of mind.
The defense relied on psychiatric evidence that he was mentally ill. Psychiatrists called for the defense diagnosed paranoid schizophrenia. The prosecution's case was that, whatever his mental condition, his responsibility was not diminished to the degree the defense required. The courts later recorded that he did suffer from schizophrenia: a consultant psychiatrist at a high-security hospital in England diagnosed a serious psychotic illness, and the High Court in 2007 accepted that he suffered from a serious mental condition.
On June 30, 2000, the jury unanimously rejected the defense of diminished responsibility and convicted Copeland of all three counts of murder. For each murder the court imposed the mandatory sentence of life imprisonment. On each of the three explosion counts it passed a discretionary life sentence, with a specified period of fifteen years, less the time on remand, and all six life sentences were ordered to run concurrently.
Under the system then in force, the length of time a life prisoner would serve before he could be considered for parole was set by the Home Secretary, on the advice of the trial judge and the Lord Chief Justice. On July 11, 2000, the trial judge recommended a minimum term of 30 years. His report to the Home Secretary found no mitigating factors at all; on the other side of the scale it set the declared aim of the explosions, the hatred of the communities they were aimed at, and the long planning behind them. On August 8, 2000, the Lord Chief Justice agreed. The Home Secretary never fixed a term in Copeland's case before the law changed, and the 30-year recommendation stood as his tariff for the next seven years.
The change in the law came with the Criminal Justice Act 2003, which took the setting of minimum terms away from the Home Secretary and gave it to the judges. Prisoners whose terms had never been fixed by a minister, Copeland among about 700 others, had their cases sent to the High Court under the Act's transitional rules.
His case came before a High Court judge of the Queen's Bench Division in early 2007, and judgment was given on March 2, 2007. Copeland took no part. The solicitors who had acted for him withdrew, he was told of the procedure and did not reply, he asked for no oral hearing, and the court received no representations on his behalf. The judge decided the case on the papers: the trial judge's report, the sentencing remarks and the psychiatric reports. The judge found that the case was one of exceptionally high seriousness, with a whole life order as its starting point. He identified the aggravating features as the number of murders, the premeditation and planning behind them, sadistic conduct, and the fact that the offenses were motivated by racialist and homophobic ideology.
The transitional rules also limited the term the court could set to one the Home Secretary would probably have fixed under the old system. The judge found that ministers had at times set terms higher than those the judges recommended, and he concluded that the 30-year recommendation did not cap the term he could fix.
The only mitigating feature he found was Copeland's age, 22 at the time of the offenses, and he reflected it by reducing the whole-life starting point to a determinate term. He recognized that a whole life term in his case could have meant more than 60 years in custody. He fixed the minimum term at 50 years, less the 13 months and 26 days already served on remand, which left a period of 48 years, 10 months and 4 days to run from the date of sentence, and he held that this was not longer than the term the Home Secretary would probably have set. Copeland's serious mental condition, although accepted as a fact, was not treated as reducing the term.
Copeland appealed against the 50-year term. The appeal was heard in the Court of Appeal, Criminal Division, by a court of three presided over by the Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales, and judgment was given on June 28, 2011.
On appeal Copeland accepted the whole life starting point but said the High Court had given too little weight to three things: his mental disorder, his youth, and the absence of any previous convictions for violence. The Court of Appeal rejected each of them. It began with the classification. The High Court had found the case one of exceptionally high seriousness, and the Court of Appeal agreed that it plainly was: three linked and premeditated offenses, driven by racial and sexual prejudice, with a sadistic element the High Court had also found. It then turned to the transitional limit and held that a Home Secretary of the period would probably have fixed a term significantly longer than the judges' recommendation in a case this grave. Copeland, the court noted, had known that his minimum term had not yet been fixed.
On the mental disorder ground, the court accepted that a disorder falling short of the defense of diminished responsibility can in principle reduce a sentence, even after a jury has rejected that defense. On the facts of this case, though, the court held that his culpability had not been reduced in any way by the schizophrenia from which he suffered. On his youth, it held that the High Court had already reduced the whole life starting point to reflect his age, and that the allowance it had made was sufficient. The court added that the case would on any view have justified a whole life order. The appeal was dismissed, and the 50-year minimum term stood.
In October 2015, while serving his life sentences, Copeland pleaded guilty at Woolwich Crown Court to a further offense, committed against another prisoner while he was in custody. He received a further three years, of which he must serve at least half, on top of the life sentences and the 50-year minimum term already in place.
In 2015 Copeland was serving his life sentences in custody in England. He is not eligible to be considered for release by the Parole Board until the 50-year minimum term, less his time on remand, has run its course. If the Board ever releases him, he will remain on license for the rest of his life and may be recalled to custody at any time.
The far-right groups that claimed responsibility in April 1999 played no proven part in the explosions; Copeland told police he acted alone. The degree of his mental illness was the central dispute at trial. The jury rejected diminished responsibility, and the Court of Appeal in 2011 held that his schizophrenia did not reduce his culpability, but the courts also accepted that he suffered from a serious mental condition.
April 17, 1999: Explosion in Brixton, south London; 39 members of the public and three police officers injured.
April 24, 1999: Explosion in east London; six people injured.
April 30, 1999: Explosion in Soho; three people killed and several seriously injured.
May 1999: Copeland arrested in Hampshire and charged with murder.
February 24, 2000: Pleads guilty to three counts of causing an explosion likely to endanger life; denies murder and offers a plea to manslaughter on the ground of diminished responsibility, which the prosecution does not accept.
June 30, 2000: Unanimously convicted of three counts of murder at the Central Criminal Court; life imprisonment on each count.
July 11, 2000: The trial judge recommends a minimum term of 30 years.
August 8, 2000: The Lord Chief Justice approves the 30-year recommendation.
March 2, 2007: The High Court fixes the minimum term at 50 years, less 13 months and 26 days on remand.
June 28, 2011: The Court of Appeal dismisses his appeal against the minimum term.
October 2015: Pleads guilty at Woolwich Crown Court to a further offense committed in custody; three further years.