Dave Walker

Victims
2 men killed near Chadwick, Missouri, March 1887. Convicted of murder as chief of the Christian County Bald Knobbers; executed at Ozark, May 10, 1889
Years active
March 1887 (deaths); May 10, 1889 (executed)
Location
Chadwick and Ozark, Christian County, Missouri
Method
Murder, as chief of the Christian County Bald Knobbers, a vigilante band of which about 25 members took part
Status
Sentenced to death; Governor David Francis refused clemency; executed at Ozark, May 10, 1889, with his son and a second condemned member of the band

Dave Walker was the chief of the Bald Knobbers of Christian County, Missouri, a band of masked night riders who set out to police the morals of their hill-country neighbors. In March 1887, as the band was breaking up, about 25 of its men rode out to a family's place near Chadwick. When they left, William Edens and Charles Green were dead and two more members of the family had been wounded. Walker, his teenage son and two other members were convicted of murder and sentenced to death. On May 10, 1889, Walker was executed at Ozark, the county seat, together with his son and one of the other condemned men. The fourth had escaped from the county jail and was never brought back.

The deaths ended the Bald Knobber movement in Christian County. The story ran in newspapers across the United States, and neighbors who had put up with the band's punishments of men it called wayward fathers turned against it. Some 20 to 25 men were arrested, and the cases that followed sent most of the band's membership through the county courts at Ozark. The execution of a father and son on the same day, after the governor had refused pleas for the younger man's life, closed the case.

The Bald Knobbers began in Taney County, south of Christian County on the Arkansas line, under a leader named Nat Kinney. Their stated grievance was a court system that did not punish killers. Period newspapers counted 30 to 40 murders in Taney County between 1865 and 1882, and none ended in a conviction. The men who ran the county government were Democrats, some of them kin to the accused, and the Taney County band offered itself as the law-and-order answer to them.

In the summer of 1885, citizens of Christian and Douglas Counties, to the north, invited Kinney to help them start chapters of their own, and he did. The new chapters took the name and the methods of the Taney County group and turned them to very different ends. In Taney County the band had set itself against a local government that let killers go free. In Christian County it set itself against change.

The men who followed Walker were mostly poor subsistence farmers without political power, often Democrats and strict Baptists. They saw themselves as righteous men of God, and in Christian and Douglas Counties they enforced religious morals, not only the law. They wrecked bars. They punished men they judged to have neglected their families, and others they accused of keeping women outside marriage or of living as polygamists.

Their resentments were local and economic as much as religious. The railroad had reached Chadwick in 1883, and the town, named for a railroad official, became the shipping point for a company that cut railroad ties from the surrounding hills. The tie trade brought homesteaders and outside money, and it brought the illegal liquor sellers the band most wanted gone. The northern Bald Knobbers resented the newcomers and the tie company alike.

Walker was born in Kentucky in 1847 and came to the Ozarks as a grown man. He led the band, and his son, known as Billy, rose to be its second in command while still a teenager. The town they watched most closely was Chadwick, the new railroad boomtown at the edge of the hills. In Taney County the original Bald Knobbers disbanded in 1886. By early 1887 the chapters to the north were coming apart as well.

The first of the two dead was a young Christian County man who had spoken against the Bald Knobbers in public. The second dead man belonged to the same extended family. Both were living near Chadwick in the spring of 1887.

In March 1887 Walker called the band together to act against a man selling liquor without a license. No report on that man came in, and Walker adjourned the meeting. Afterward about 25 of its men, led by the younger Walker, rode to the family's place near Chadwick. Both men died there. Two other members of the family were wounded and survived. One member of the band also died. Dave Walker, the band's chief, was among the men who rode that night.

A surviving member of the family later identified the younger Walker as one of the band.

The two deaths turned the county against the Bald Knobbers. Neighbors who had tolerated the night rides would not accept what had happened near Chadwick, and the reaction carried well beyond Christian County. Across southwest Missouri the response amounted to a crackdown on the movement.

The Christian County sheriff took the men in one by one and held them in the county's new jail at Ozark. The first break came when one member confessed and named others; within about a week the sheriff had some 20 to 25 men in custody. Several of those arrested confessed in turn, and each confession widened the case.

The younger Walker was taken later and brought to the jail at Ozark, where his father was already held.

Four men were charged with murder in the first degree: Dave Walker, his son, an older member of the band, and that man's nephew. More than a dozen others faced charges of murder in the second degree. The rest of the men who had ridden with the band were charged with unlawful assembly.

The cases were tried at Ozark. Each of the four men charged with murder in the first degree was convicted of murder and sentenced to death. Father and son received the same sentence as the two other men. The four stayed in the Ozark jail while their case was appealed, and the death sentences stood.

The other defendants fared very differently. Most of the Bald Knobbers who came before the court on the charge of unlawful assembly were fined $50. A few were sent to the state penitentiary. Some were acquitted.

Several weeks before the date set for the execution, the older condemned man and his nephew left the Ozark jail through a door that a trusted inmate had left open on purpose. Dave Walker and his son had the same chance and refused to go. The older man was recaptured and returned to the jail. The nephew was never found.

Citizens of Christian and Taney Counties petitioned Governor David R. Francis for clemency. Their appeal centered on Walker's son, who was not yet 18. Francis, a Democrat, had been elected governor in 1888, and the decision whether the three men in the Ozark jail would live rested with him. He refused clemency.

Dave Walker was executed at Ozark on May 10, 1889, alongside his son and the older member of the band who had been recaptured. By July 1889 the law had executed three Bald Knobbers in Christian County, and the band that Walker had led was gone.

Missouri in the 1880s allowed the death penalty for murder. Executions were carried out in public and by the counties, not by the state. The three men condemned for the deaths near Chadwick were executed at the Christian County seat, where they had been tried and held, not at the state penitentiary. County executions lasted until 1937, when Missouri ended public executions, took executions away from county sheriffs and moved them to the state penitentiary. Clemency rested with the governor, which is why the petitions from Christian and Taney Counties went to Francis.

The son led the riders that night. The father's conviction rested on his part as chief of the band and as one of the men who rode with it. In one Ozarks telling set down in 1979, Walker told the men to get back on the road before trouble began, and they had already started forward. The court at Ozark convicted him all the same.

One of the four men sentenced to death was never recaptured after his escape from the Ozark jail. His later life and the date and place of his death are unknown.

Timeline

1847: Dave Walker is born in Kentucky.

1865 to 1882: Taney County, Missouri, records 30 to 40 murders without a conviction.

1883: The railroad reaches Chadwick, Christian County.

Summer 1885: Nat Kinney helps citizens of Christian and Douglas Counties form Bald Knobber chapters; Dave Walker leads the Christian County band.

1886: The original Taney County Bald Knobbers disband.

March 1887: Members of the Christian County band ride to a family's place near Chadwick; two men of the family die.

1887: After a member's confession, the Christian County sheriff arrests some 20 to 25 men within about a week; the younger Walker is taken later and brought to Ozark; Walker, his son and two other members are charged with murder in the first degree.

After the arrests: Walker, his son and the two other members are convicted of murder at Ozark and sentenced to death; most of the other men are fined for unlawful assembly.

Early 1889: Two of the condemned men escape from the Ozark jail; one is recaptured.

1889: Citizens of Christian and Taney Counties petition Governor Francis for clemency; he refuses.

May 10, 1889: Dave Walker is executed at Ozark with his son and the recaptured man.