Dave Rudabaugh rode with Billy the Kid for eight months in 1880 and was taken with him at Stinking Springs, New Mexico Territory, on December 23, 1880. A jury at Las Vegas, New Mexico, convicted him the next year of first-degree murder in the death of Antonio Lino Valdez, who died in the Las Vegas jail on April 2, 1880, and he was sentenced to death. The New Mexico Territorial Supreme Court accepted his appeal, which held off the execution, but the appeal was never argued. On December 3, 1881, Rudabaugh and six other men broke out of the Las Vegas jail, and he crossed into Mexico. He was killed in Parral, Chihuahua, on February 18, 1886, after two men died there in a quarrel laid at his door. No court ever tried those two deaths.
At his trial, the one man who saw the jail death, a prisoner held in the same cell as the friend Rudabaugh had come to visit, swore that Rudabaugh's companion, J.J.A., acted abruptly and without any warning, and that Rudabaugh was as surprised as he was. Rudabaugh testified that he had no advance knowledge of what his companion meant to do. The jury convicted him of first-degree murder all the same, and no higher court ever reviewed the verdict.
Rudabaugh was born in Illinois in 1854 and first came to official notice in Kansas. On January 27, 1878, six men tried to rob a train at Kinsley. The attempt failed and the men took nothing, and within weeks a sheriff's posse ran them down. Rudabaugh confessed, gave evidence for the state against his companions and walked free while they went to prison. He was then encouraged to leave Kansas.
He went south to Las Vegas, New Mexico Territory, and for about eighteen months he served as a city policeman there. On August 14, 1879, he and two other men robbed a stagecoach near Las Vegas; he later confessed and named his partners. By the spring of 1880 a friend of his, John J. Webb, was being held in the Las Vegas jail.
On April 2, 1880, Rudabaugh went to the jail with J.J.A. to visit Webb. During the visit the man on duty in the jail was killed. Rudabaugh and J.J.A. got away, and the posse that went after them did not catch them. That death became the charge that followed Rudabaugh for the rest of his life.
Rudabaugh had not met William Bonney, known as Billy the Kid, before 1880. After the jail death he joined him, and by the middle of October 1880 he was staying at Fort Sumner with the Kid and his associates. On October 16, 1880, he and two other men robbed a stagecoach north of Fort Sumner, and once again he later confessed and named the men who had been with him. On December 23, 1880, at Stinking Springs, Bonney and three companions, Rudabaugh among them, surrendered to a posse under the sheriff-elect of Lincoln County. Four days later the prisoners were delivered to the jail at Santa Fe.
Rudabaugh was returned to Las Vegas to answer for the death in the jail. He was tried there in 1881, convicted of murder in the first degree and sentenced to death, and by September 1881 he was held at Las Vegas awaiting execution. The New Mexico Territorial Supreme Court accepted his appeal, and the execution was put off while the appeal waited to be heard.
He did not wait with it. In September 1881 he tried to break out of the Las Vegas jail and failed. On December 3, 1881, he and six other prisoners escaped. He was never recaptured, and with no appellant in custody the territorial supreme court never heard the case. He made directly for Mexico and stayed there for the rest of his life.
On February 18, 1886, in Parral, Chihuahua, a quarrel left two men dead, and both deaths were laid to Rudabaugh. He was killed in Parral the same day by a local storekeeper.
Who caused the Las Vegas jail death is the central dispute. The only eyewitness at trial named J.J.A., Rudabaugh denied any advance knowledge, and the jury convicted him of first-degree murder; no appellate court ever ruled on that verdict.
The two deaths in Parral in February 1886 were attributed to him but never examined by any court.
A later magazine profile credits him with killing a deputy sheriff in New Mexico and with killing a man during his first escape attempt; other accounts of the case do not support either claim.
1854: Born in Illinois.
January 27, 1878: Failed attempt by six men to rob a train at Kinsley, Kansas; he later confesses and testifies for the state.
August 14, 1879: Robbery of a stagecoach near Las Vegas, New Mexico, which he later confesses.
April 2, 1880: A man on duty in the Las Vegas jail is killed during a visit by Rudabaugh and J.J.A.
October 16, 1880: Stagecoach robbery north of Fort Sumner, later confessed.
December 23, 1880: Surrenders with Billy the Kid and two others at Stinking Springs.
December 27, 1880: Delivered with the other prisoners to the Santa Fe jail.
1881: Convicted at Las Vegas of first-degree murder and sentenced to death; appeal accepted by the Territorial Supreme Court.
September 1881: A first escape attempt fails.
December 3, 1881: Escapes the Las Vegas jail with six other prisoners and goes to Mexico.
February 18, 1886: Two men die in a quarrel in Parral, Chihuahua, attributed to him in later accounts; he is killed in Parral the same day.