Dario Kordić never held a military rank. He was a party official from the small central Bosnian town of Busovača, a former journalist who rose within two years to become one of the most powerful Bosnian Croat politicians in the region. In February 2001 the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia in The Hague found that he had used that power to plan, instigate and order a campaign of persecution against the Bosnian Muslims of the Lašva Valley in 1993. The campaign's worst day came on April 16, 1993, in the village of Ahmići, where more than 100 Bosnian Muslim civilians were killed, among them 32 women and 11 children, and the village was destroyed.
Trial Chamber III sentenced him to 25 years. At the time he was the highest-ranking politician the tribunal had convicted. On December 17, 2004, the Appeals Chamber reversed a number of his convictions for particular places and dates but affirmed his responsibility for Ahmići and for most of the campaign, and it kept the sentence unchanged.
Kordić was born on December 14, 1960, and grew up in Busovača, a municipality in the Lašva Valley region, where his political career began. Before the war he worked as a journalist, and from 1985 he was employed by the Vatrostalna company in Busovača.
In 1991 he became President of the Croatian Democratic Union of Bosnia and Herzegovina, the HDZ-BiH, in the Busovača municipality. The party had been founded the year before as the Bosnian offshoot of the governing Croatian Democratic Union in Croatia. Kordić rose quickly. He became president of his regional party community and, from 1991 to 1995, served as president of the HDZ-BiH, the position the tribunal later treated as the source of much of his influence.
On November 18, 1991, Bosnian Croat leaders proclaimed the Croatian Community of Herceg-Bosna, which described itself as a separate political, cultural, economic and territorial whole inside Bosnia and Herzegovina. The tribunal found that among its aims was closer union with Croatia, and that it was meant in time to become part of the Republic of Croatia. Herceg-Bosna created the Croatian Defense Council, the HVO, as its executive and defense authority, and in each municipality a local HVO became the governing and military power.
Kordić became Vice-President of the Herceg-Bosna Presidency after its founding, and he kept the post when the community declared itself the Croatian Republic of Herceg-Bosna in August 1993. In deciding what he intended, the Appeals Chamber relied on his public statements of 1991 and 1992, among them his words at a meeting in Zagreb on December 27, 1991, and at a rally in Busovača the following month. From those statements and his wider conduct, it concluded that he sought a sovereign Croatian state within the territory of Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The Lašva Valley lies at the center of Bosnia and Herzegovina and takes in the municipalities of Vitez, Novi Travnik and Busovača, with Kiseljak to the south. During 1992 the HVO took over the municipal governments of Busovača, Vitez and Kiseljak. The tribunal found that these takeovers were generally peaceful, with armed resistance only in Novi Travnik and in Ahmići, but that they ignited the conflict between Muslims and Croats in the region. By the end of 1992 Kordić combined political and military authority. He had no formal place in the chain of command, the Trial Chamber found, yet he was closely associated with the military leadership and took part in the takeovers.
In January 1993 HVO forces attacked the municipality of Busovača, an assault the Trial Chamber found set the pattern for the attacks that followed. Civilians were killed, others were expelled, and their property was destroyed. The Trial Chamber found that Kordić, as a political leader with substantial military influence, was involved in planning and ordering these crimes, and the Appeals Chamber agreed that a reasonable court could have found that numerous civilians were targeted and killed in the town.
In mid-April 1993 the conflict in the valley turned into a coordinated offensive. On April 15, Kordić attended a meeting of the Bosnian Croat political leadership in Vitez at which, the tribunal found, the decision was made to launch an attack against the Muslims. The Appeals Chamber later affirmed that the meeting had approved an order to kill Muslim men of military age, expel civilians and destroy dwellings, and that this general plan covered the whole of the valley.
On April 16, HVO forces attacked Ahmići, and more than 100 Bosnian Muslim civilians were killed there. The same day the hamlets of Šantići, Pirići and Nadioci, the village of Večeriska and the town of Vitez came under attack. The Trial Chamber found that Kordić, as the senior regional politician, had taken part in planning the operation, and that his principal role was that of planner and instigator. The Appeals Chamber confirmed that he planned and instigated the crimes committed in Ahmići on April 16, 1993, and in Šantići, Pirići and Nadioci.
Not every death in the valley that month was laid at his door. The Trial Chamber found no evidence linking him to the killing of at least six people in Stari Vitez on April 18, which it attributed to HVO elements in Vitez, and it found that the deaths of 15 people in Zenica on April 19, although caused by the HVO, fell outside the common plan.
The offensive reached the Kiseljak municipality in April and again in June 1993. In June the village of Tulica was attacked; 12 people were killed and the village was destroyed. The Trial Chamber found that these attacks would not have been launched without the approval of the local political leadership, which it identified as Kordić. Rotilj, Han Ploča-Grahovci, Svinjarevo and Gomionica also came under attack that spring and summer, and across the region the court found a pattern of destruction and plunder and the deliberate targeting of mosques and other religious and educational institutions.
Hundreds of Bosnian Muslim civilians were detained. Kordić was found responsible for ordering the detentions and the establishment of detention facilities at Kaonik, at several sites in Vitez, at the Dubravica school and in Kiseljak. Because the camps were run by the military, the court did not hold him responsible for the treatment of the detainees.
The tribunal also examined the killing of 38 people in the village of Stupni Do in the Vareš area on October 23, 1993. It found that the village lay outside Kordić's sphere of authority and outside the common plan.
The tribunal's prosecutor issued the first indictment on November 10, 1995, naming Kordić with five other Bosnian Croats, among them Mario Čerkez, the commander of the HVO brigade in Vitez. It alleged that Kordić, as Vice-President of Herceg-Bosna, had overall leadership of the attacks on Bosnian Muslim civilians in the Lašva River area.
His surrender came out of negotiations between the President of Croatia and a United States envoy. On October 6, 1997, Kordić and nine other Bosnian Croats indicted for crimes in the Lašva Valley gave themselves up and were transferred to The Hague the same day, and he pleaded not guilty to every count. On September 30, 1998, the tribunal confirmed an amended indictment against Kordić and Čerkez alone, charging Kordić with 22 counts of grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions, violations of the laws or customs of war and crimes against humanity.
The joint trial opened before Trial Chamber III on April 12, 1999. The defense argued that the fighting in central Bosnia had been a civil war in which the Bosnian Croats were on the defensive, not a one-sided campaign of persecution. The Trial Chamber rejected that account. It found a campaign of persecution aimed at the Bosnian Muslims throughout the period of the indictment, orchestrated from Zagreb, led by the HDZ-BiH and carried out through the institutions of Herceg-Bosna and the HVO. It also found that Croatia's intervention made the conflict an international one, which brought the grave breaches provisions of the Geneva Conventions into play.
On February 26, 2001, Trial Chamber III gave judgment. It found that the evidence did not place Kordić in the highest echelons of the Bosnian Croat leadership and did not show that he conceived the campaign. As a regional leader, however, he had joined the common design of persecution by planning, preparing and ordering those parts of it that fell within his sphere of authority, and in every attack in which he participated he intended the crimes associated with it. He was convicted on the basis of individual criminal responsibility under Article 7(1) of the tribunal's statute and acquitted of superior responsibility under Article 7(3), because he was neither a commander nor a superior in the HVO and had no power to prevent the crimes or punish those who committed them.
The convictions covered persecutions on political, racial or religious grounds, murder, inhumane acts and imprisonment as crimes against humanity; wilful killing, inhuman treatment and unlawful confinement of civilians as grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions; and unlawful attack on civilians, unlawful attack on civilian objects, wanton destruction not justified by military necessity, plunder of public or private property, and destruction or wilful damage to institutions dedicated to religion or education as violations of the laws or customs of war. He was found not guilty on the remaining counts, among them the charges of taking hostages, using detainees as human shields and inhuman treatment in the camps, and extensive destruction of property as a grave breach.
The chamber imposed 25 years, with credit for the time he had spent in custody since October 6, 1997. It found no mitigating circumstances, though it took into account that he had not been found to be an architect of the persecution.
Both men appealed against their convictions, and the prosecution appealed both sentences. On December 17, 2004, the Appeals Chamber gave its judgment. It upheld the finding that Croatia had exercised overall control over the HVO, so that there had been an international armed conflict between Croatia and Bosnia and Herzegovina. Because the Trial Chamber had, in most instances, not made explicit findings on each element of each crime, the Appeals Chamber reviewed the crimes place by place and element by element.
Several did not survive. It reversed Kordić's convictions for wanton destruction and plunder in Novi Travnik in October 1992, finding that no reasonable court could have concluded that he intended those crimes so early. It reversed his convictions for the attacks on Vitez town and Stari Vitez in April 1993, for the Vitez Veterinary Station and Chess Club detention sites, for Merdani in January 1993 and for Lončari in April 1993, and it narrowed the convictions for Busovača, Večeriska, Nadioci and Pirići, Šantići, Rotilj, Han Ploča-Grahovci, Kiseljak town and Svinjarevo.
What remained was the core of the case. The Appeals Chamber found that Kordić had direct intent for the crimes in the April 15 plan and had accepted the likelihood of plunder and unlawful detention. It affirmed his convictions for Ahmići on every count the Trial Chamber had entered, for murder and wilful killing in Busovača, Nadioci and Pirići, Šantići, Rotilj, Han Ploča-Grahovci and Tulica, and for imprisonment and unlawful confinement at the Kaonik, Vitez, Dubravica and Kiseljak sites. It found that he had possessed the specific intent to discriminate required for persecutions.
Because his appeals had succeeded only for certain locations and never for any count in its entirety, the Appeals Chamber concluded that the picture of his criminal conduct had not changed substantially. It rejected both his challenge to the sentence and the prosecution's, and it affirmed the 25 years. Čerkez, his co-accused, had been sentenced to 15 years at trial; the Appeals Chamber reversed most of his convictions, imposed six years and ordered his immediate release.
Kordić served his sentence in The Hague and, from June 2006, in Austria, and was released early on June 6, 2014, after completing two-thirds of it.
Kordić has never accepted the judgment. He pleaded not guilty to every count, appealed every conviction, did not cooperate with the prosecution at any stage, and argued throughout that the fighting in central Bosnia was not a one-sided Bosnian Croat campaign. Both the Trial Chamber and the Appeals Chamber rejected that position.
The extent of his responsibility was narrowed on appeal. The Appeals Chamber reversed his convictions for the crimes in Novi Travnik in October 1992, for the attacks on Vitez town and Stari Vitez in April 1993, for two Vitez detention sites, and for Merdani and Lončari, and it removed individual counts at several other places. The Trial Chamber had already found no link between him and the deaths in Stari Vitez on April 18, 1993, in Zenica on April 19, 1993, and in Stupni Do on October 23, 1993. Those deaths form no part of his conviction.
The tribunal found that he was not among the highest echelons of the Bosnian Croat leadership and did not conceive the campaign, and that the campaign was orchestrated from Zagreb. The total number of people killed in the campaign was never fixed by the court. The Trial Chamber found that it ran into the hundreds and that the true figure might never be known.
December 14, 1960: Kordić is born; he grows up in Busovača.
1985: He begins working for the Vatrostalna company in Busovača.
1991: He becomes President of the HDZ-BiH in Busovača.
November 18, 1991: The Croatian Community of Herceg-Bosna is proclaimed; Kordić becomes Vice-President of its Presidency.
1992: The HVO takes over the municipal governments of Busovača, Vitez and Kiseljak.
January 1993: HVO forces attack Busovača; civilians are killed and expelled.
April 15, 1993: Kordić attends the political leadership's meeting in Vitez at which the attack is decided.
April 16, 1993: More than 100 Bosnian Muslim civilians are killed in Ahmići; Šantići, Pirići, Nadioci and Večeriska are also attacked.
June 1993: Twelve people are killed in Tulica in the Kiseljak municipality.
August 1993: Herceg-Bosna declares itself the Croatian Republic of Herceg-Bosna; Kordić remains Vice-President.
November 10, 1995: The first indictment is issued against Kordić and five others.
October 6, 1997: Kordić surrenders with nine other Bosnian Croats and is transferred to The Hague.
September 30, 1998: An amended indictment against Kordić and Čerkez is confirmed.
April 12, 1999: The trial opens before Trial Chamber III.
February 26, 2001: He is convicted and sentenced to 25 years.
December 17, 2004: The Appeals Chamber reverses several location-specific convictions and affirms the core convictions and the 25-year sentence.
June 2006: He is transferred to Austria to serve his sentence.
June 6, 2014: He is released early after serving two-thirds of the sentence.