On the afternoon of Monday, November 27, 2000, a boy died in Peckham, in south London. His death produced a murder trial of four other youths that ended in acquittals, a review of how that case had been prosecuted, a reopened inquiry, and finally two more trials of a pair of brothers who had been questioned and released within days of the death.
Danny Preddie was 12 at the time, and his brother Ricky was 13. Both lived in Peckham. In August 2006, at the Central Criminal Court in London, the Old Bailey, a jury convicted them of the boy's manslaughter. They had been acquitted of his murder and of assault with intent to rob at an earlier trial that April. On October 9, 2006, each was sentenced to eight years' youth custody. They had denied every charge.
The Metropolitan Police began a murder inquiry. In the days after the death several teenagers were arrested and questioned, the Preddie brothers among them, and by December 2, 2000, all had been released without charge.
In June 2001, police charged four other teenagers with murder. All four denied it, and because they were juveniles their names were protected by the court. They stood trial at the Old Bailey from January to April 2002. The judge ruled the evidence of a young prosecution witness unreliable and directed the jury to acquit two of the defendants; the jury found the other two not guilty of all charges. None of the four was ever convicted of any offense in connection with the death.
The Attorney General then asked the Director of Public Prosecutions to review how the Crown Prosecution Service had handled the case. His summary, published on December 9, 2002, concluded that the original decision to charge the four youths had been correct and that continuing with the case on the evidence then available had been the right course. The murder inquiry stayed open.
In November 2003, the Metropolitan Police announced a review of the evidence using new scientific techniques. That review identified evidence linking the Preddie brothers to the boy's death that the original examination, which had found nothing of value, had missed. For the first time since 2000, investigators had evidence that tied the two brothers, rather than the four youths tried in 2002, to the death.
On January 5, 2005, officers arrested three young men from Peckham. Two days later all three were charged with the boy's murder. Two were the Preddie brothers, then 16 and 17, who could not be named because of their age. The third had also been questioned in 2000. All three had been between 12 and 14 when the boy died, and all three later pleaded not guilty.
The trial opened at the Old Bailey in January 2006. Each defendant faced charges of murder, manslaughter and assault with intent to rob, and the prosecution put the new evidence at the centre of its case. On April 3, 2006, the jury acquitted the third defendant of all three charges. The next day it acquitted both brothers of murder and of assault with intent to rob, but it could not reach a verdict on manslaughter and was discharged on that count. Two days later, on April 6, it was confirmed that the brothers would be tried again.
The retrial opened in late June 2006, and the question before the new jury was narrower. Murder and assault with intent to rob had been settled by acquittal; the only issue was whether each brother was guilty of manslaughter. On August 9, 2006, the jury convicted both Danny Preddie, then 18, and Ricky Preddie, then 19. Both were now adults and could be named. The verdict came almost six years after the death, at the third trial to deal with it.
On Monday, October 9, 2006, the judge sentenced each brother to eight years' youth custody for manslaughter, a fixed term to be served partly in custody and partly in the community on licence.
Ricky Preddie was the first of the brothers to leave custody, released on licence in September 2010. On March 13, 2011, he was recalled for breaching his licence after he was seen in Southwark associating with gang members. Danny Preddie was released in September 2011, after serving five years of his sentence. Ricky was released again on January 25, 2012, and sixteen days later, in February 2012, he was recalled a second time for associating with gang members in Peckham. He was later released once more.
Ricky Preddie was later sentenced to four years' imprisonment at Harrow Crown Court in February 2020 for causing serious injury by dangerous driving, and given a suspended sentence at Isleworth Crown Court in the summer of 2024 for further driving offenses.
The brothers denied all charges throughout. They were acquitted of murder and of assault with intent to rob by the jury of April 2006, and a second jury convicted them of manslaughter in August 2006. The convictions are for manslaughter alone.
The four youths tried in 2002 were acquitted, two on the direction of the judge and two by the jury, and the third defendant tried in 2006 was acquitted of all charges. None of those five was convicted of any offense connected with the death.
November 27, 2000: A boy dies in Peckham, south London.
December 2, 2000: By this date every teenager questioned, the Preddie brothers among them, has been released without charge.
June 2001: Four other teenagers are charged with murder.
January to April 2002: The four are tried at the Old Bailey; two are acquitted on the judge's direction and two by the jury.
December 9, 2002: The Director of Public Prosecutions publishes a summary of his review of the prosecution.
November 2003: The Metropolitan Police announce a review of the evidence using new techniques.
January 5, 2005: Three young men are arrested in Peckham.
January 7, 2005: The three are charged with murder.
January 2006: The trial opens at the Old Bailey.
April 3, 2006: The third defendant is acquitted of all charges.
April 4, 2006: The brothers are acquitted of murder and assault with intent to rob; the jury is discharged on manslaughter.
April 6, 2006: A retrial on manslaughter is confirmed.
June 2006: The retrial opens.
August 9, 2006: Danny and Ricky Preddie are convicted of manslaughter.
October 9, 2006: Each is sentenced to eight years' youth custody.
September 2010: Ricky Preddie is released on licence.
March 13, 2011: Ricky Preddie is recalled.
September 2011: Danny Preddie is released.
January 25, 2012: Ricky Preddie is released again.
February 2012: Ricky Preddie is recalled after 16 days.
February 2020: Ricky Preddie is sentenced at Harrow Crown Court for causing serious injury by dangerous driving.
Summer 2024: Ricky Preddie receives a suspended sentence at Isleworth Crown Court for driving offenses.