Danny Heinrich

Victims
1 killing admitted in court, never charged. Convicted only of receipt of child pornography, 2016.
Years active
October 22, 1989
Location
St. Joseph, Minnesota (October 1989 abduction and killing, admitted); Cold Spring, Minnesota (January 1989 abduction of a survivor, admitted); Minneapolis, Minnesota (federal court).
Method
Shot (his own admission in federal court, September 6, 2016; never charged or tried for the killing).
Status
20 years and lifetime supervised release, November 21, 2016; appeal waived. Imprisoned in federal custody in Massachusetts as of January 2017 (release date March 28, 2033).

On the evening of October 22, 1989, a boy was abducted near St. Joseph, Minnesota. For nearly 27 years no one was charged. Investigators worked through tens of thousands of leads, and a reward went unclaimed. The man who would finally admit taking him lived in Paynesville, another town in the same county. His name was Danny Heinrich, and investigators had arrested and questioned him in early 1990, then let him go.

Heinrich admitted the crime on September 6, 2016, in a federal courtroom in Minneapolis. He was there to plead guilty to a single count of receipt of child pornography, and the plea agreement required him to say in open court what he had done in 1989. Asked whether he had abducted, assaulted and murdered the boy, he answered, "Yes I did." He also admitted the abduction and assault of a second boy, from Cold Spring, in January of that year. Those were admissions made under a plea agreement, not convictions. Neither crime was ever charged, and no court has convicted him of either. His only conviction is the federal count: on November 21, 2016, a federal judge sentenced him to 20 years, the most the law allowed for that count, and to supervised release for the rest of his life.

Daniel James Heinrich grew up in Paynesville, a small town in Stearns County in central Minnesota. He told a judge years later that he had left high school in the 11th grade. In 1982, while still living in Paynesville, he was working at the Jennie-O plant in Willmar. That February he enlisted in the Minnesota National Guard, and he served until November 1991, reaching the rank of specialist and leaving with an honorable discharge.

His early record was a small-town one. At 19, in 1982, he was charged with drunken driving. In 1984 he was charged with breaking into two Paynesville businesses, and he told the court he had been looking for cash after losing money gambling. In 1986 he was charged with drunken driving again and tried to run from the arresting officer. All three cases were misdemeanors.

By 1989 he had lived in downtown Paynesville for years and was working at Fingerhut in St. Cloud. He left that job on October 8, 1989, and began a new one on November 12.

The first of the two crimes Heinrich later admitted came in January 1989, in Cold Spring, another Stearns County town. A boy from Cold Spring was abducted and assaulted. He survived, and his case went unsolved for more than a quarter of a century. Investigators long suspected that it was connected to what happened in St. Joseph that October, and they kept the evidence from it.

The boy from St. Joseph was abducted near the town on October 22, 1989. In 2016 Heinrich admitted that he abducted, assaulted and killed him. The Stearns County Sheriff's Office led the investigation, working with the FBI and the state Bureau of Criminal Apprehension.

Heinrich was not the main suspect from the beginning, but his name surfaced early. Within 48 hours of the abduction a tip from Paynesville suggested a link to the St. Joseph case. Investigators did not follow up for two months.

Investigators questioned Heinrich in the months after the abduction, and he denied any involvement. He was placed in a photo lineup. Then, in early 1990, he was arrested in connection with the Cold Spring abduction and questioned by FBI agents. He again denied everything. The evidence available at the time was not enough to charge him, and he was released.

In 1991 a convicted sex offender gave an FBI task force information that pointed at Heinrich. The investigative file shows no follow-up. After that his name dropped out of the file for about 20 years, and the inquiry turned in other directions.

Around the 25th anniversary of the abduction, investigators began a full review of the case and looked again at Heinrich. Evidence held from the Cold Spring case was retested with technology that had not existed in 1989, and it was linked to him. The Cold Spring abduction itself could no longer be prosecuted, because the statute of limitations had expired. The link was still enough for a court warrant.

By then Heinrich had lived in Annandale for about eight years. On July 28, 2015, agents executed that warrant in Annandale. They found nothing that tied him to the St. Joseph boy. They did find a collection of child pornography.

Heinrich was arrested in Annandale in late October 2015. On October 29, 2015, he was charged by criminal complaint in federal court with five counts of possessing or receiving child pornography. The same day the FBI publicly named him a person of interest in the 1989 abduction. He had not been charged in that case. Heinrich, then 52, denied any involvement and was held in custody.

A federal grand jury later indicted him on 25 counts of possessing and receiving child pornography. He pleaded not guilty to all 25 and went on denying any part in the St. Joseph abduction.

In late August 2016, after months of denials, Heinrich agreed to confess. The agreement that his lawyers, federal prosecutors and the Stearns County Attorney worked out had two parts. First, he would give investigators a full account of the St. Joseph abduction, which he did that August. Second, he would plead guilty to one count of receipt of child pornography and, in open court, admit both the St. Joseph abduction and killing and the Cold Spring abduction and assault.

In return, no state prosecution would follow for either crime. The agreement recommended a sentence of 20 years. Heinrich waived his right to appeal the sentence, and the agreement left open his civil commitment as a sexual predator once the federal term ended.

On Tuesday, September 6, 2016, Heinrich appeared in the U.S. District Court in Minneapolis. He pleaded guilty to one count of receipt of child pornography. Then he described the events of 1989. He admitted the Cold Spring abduction and assault. He admitted abducting, assaulting and killing the St. Joseph boy, and said he had acted alone. He was never charged with either crime, and the admissions did not make him a convicted killer: they were part of the bargain on the federal count.

Heinrich returned to the federal courthouse in Minneapolis on Monday, November 21, 2016, and apologized. "I am truly sorry for my evil acts," he said, calling what he had done unforgivable. He said he had stayed silent for nearly three decades out of fear.

The court imposed the sentence the parties had recommended: 20 years in federal custody, the statutory maximum on the one count, followed by supervised release for life. By January 2017 Heinrich had been transferred to a federal facility in Massachusetts, and the federal listing at the time gave his release date as March 28, 2033. The plea left Minnesota free to seek his civil commitment when that term ends.

In September 2018 the Stearns County Sheriff's Office released more than 40,000 pages of its investigative file to the public.

The count Heinrich admitted falls under the federal statute on material involving the sexual exploitation of minors, 18 U.S.C. Section 2252. For a first offense, receipt carries a mandatory minimum of five years and a maximum of 20, so the 20-year sentence was the ceiling for the single count to which he pleaded guilty.

The St. Joseph killing was left uncharged by agreement. No state prosecution would follow, in exchange for the confession, his account of what happened and his guilty plea on the federal count.

Heinrich has never been tried for the St. Joseph killing or the Cold Spring abduction, and he has never been charged with either. His admissions were made under a plea agreement in a federal case about other conduct, and no jury has tested them. His only conviction is for one federal offense, receipt of child pornography.

Part of the investigative file, some 4,000 pages returned to the FBI on a judge's order, remains outside public view. The information given to the task force in 1991 came from a convicted sex offender and was never followed up, so its value is untested.

Timeline

January 1989: A boy from Cold Spring, Minnesota, is abducted and assaulted; Heinrich admitted this in 2016 under a plea agreement, and it was never charged.

October 8, 1989: Heinrich stops working at Fingerhut in St. Cloud.

October 22, 1989: A boy is abducted near St. Joseph, Minnesota; in 2016 Heinrich admitted, under a plea agreement, abducting and killing him; it was never charged.

Early 1990: Heinrich is questioned, placed in a photo lineup, then arrested in connection with the Cold Spring case, questioned by FBI agents and released without charge.

1991: Information pointing at Heinrich reaches an FBI task force; no follow-up is recorded, and his name leaves the file for about 20 years.

November 1991: Heinrich leaves the Minnesota National Guard with an honorable discharge.

Around the 25th anniversary: Investigators begin a full review of the case.

July 28, 2015: Agents execute a federal warrant in Annandale.

October 29, 2015: Heinrich is charged by federal complaint with five counts of possessing or receiving child pornography and named a person of interest.

Late 2015: A federal grand jury indictment charges 25 counts; he pleads not guilty.

Late August 2016: Heinrich agrees to confess and gives investigators his account.

September 6, 2016: He pleads guilty to one count of receipt of child pornography in Minneapolis and, under the plea agreement, admits both 1989 crimes in open court; neither is charged.

November 21, 2016: Sentenced to 20 years and lifetime supervised release on the federal count.

January 2017: Listed at a federal facility in Massachusetts, release date March 28, 2033.

September 20, 2018: The Stearns County Sheriff's Office releases more than 40,000 pages of the investigative file.