Daniel Rakowitz

Victims
1 death in Manhattan, 1989; not responsible (mental illness). Found not guilty of intentional murder and not responsible for depraved-indifference murder by reason of mental illness, 1991
Years active
August 19, 1989 (the death); September 16, 1989 (videotaped statement); January to February 22, 1991 (trial and verdict).
Location
East Village, Manhattan, New York City; South Texas.
Method
Charged with murder (intentional and depraved indifference) and tampering with physical evidence; acquitted on the ground of mental illness.
Status
Committed to a secure state forensic psychiatric hospital, 1991; transfer refused by a jury, 1995; 2004 jury found him mentally ill; still held there in 2012.

Monika Beerle died in Manhattan's East Village on August 19, 1989. The man charged with her death, Daniel Rakowitz, was a drifter from South Texas who had become a familiar figure in the streets around Tompkins Square Park, a man who told anyone who would listen that he was divine and that he would one day be president. In the summer of 1989 the two were sharing a place in the East Village. That August she was dead.

Rakowitz went to trial in New York State Supreme Court in Manhattan on two counts of murder and one of tampering with physical evidence. He refused to let his own lawyers plead insanity, and he spent his time on the witness stand insisting on his innocence. The jury deliberated for nine days. On February 22, 1991, it found him "not guilty of intentional murder and not responsible for murder with depraved indifference by reason of mental illness." The jurors could not agree on the evidence charge. Rakowitz was never convicted of anything in connection with the death. He was committed instead to the state's forensic psychiatric system, and two later juries heard his case for a move out of its most secure setting without his ever leaving it.

Rakowitz was born on December 24, 1960, and grew up in South Texas. He enlisted in the Army at 19. By 1981, police later said, he had left Texas for good. By about 1985 he was living in lower Manhattan, and by the late 1980s he had drifted into the crowd that gathered in and around Tompkins Square Park.

In August 1988 Tompkins Square Park became the scene of a riot between police and protesters, and Rakowitz first became known locally around that time.

She was looking for somewhere else to live in 1989 when she met Rakowitz.

By the summer of 1989 they were sharing a place in the East Village, and the prosecution's theory at trial was that he killed her because she was trying to make him leave.

She died on August 19, 1989, in the East Village.

The case broke open in September 1989. Rakowitz had been talking about the death to people around him, and word of what he was saying reached a neighbor, who alerted the police. Detectives from the New York Police Department's Ninth Precinct, which covers the East Village, found him in mid-September.

On September 16, 1989, at the Ninth Precinct, he gave detectives a videotaped statement about his relationship with her and about her death. He was charged with killing her. The statement he made that September became the center of the prosecution's case, and the jurors who decided it asked to see it again and again.

Rakowitz went to trial on three counts. Two charged murder under different theories, intentional murder and murder with depraved indifference. The third charged tampering with physical evidence.

His mental state was a question from the start. The doctors who examined him described a serious illness, schizophrenia of a chronic paranoid type, alongside what they called a borderline condition. Rakowitz rejected that view. He repeatedly refused to allow the lawyers representing him to enter a plea of not guilty by reason of insanity, and he insisted throughout that he had not killed her.

The case was tried before a justice of the New York State Supreme Court in Manhattan in early 1991. An assistant district attorney presented the prosecution's case.

The jury saw the videotape of the September 1989 statement and heard from the doctors who had examined him. In early February 1991 Rakowitz took the stand in his own defense.

He denied murder.

His lawyers, barred by his refusal from pleading insanity on his behalf, built their defense around his mental condition all the same, relying on the medical testimony to show the jury a seriously ill man.

The jury deliberated for nine days.

On Friday, February 22, 1991, they returned their verdict. On the first count they found Rakowitz not guilty of intentional murder. On the second they found him "not responsible for murder with depraved indifference by reason of mental illness." On the third count, tampering with physical evidence, they could not reach a verdict.

He would not go to prison. Rakowitz was committed to a maximum-security forensic psychiatric hospital in New York State, one of the two secure forensic hospitals the state ran, and he remained there for the decades that followed.

New York's rules for a defendant found not responsible by reason of mental disease or defect are set out in the state's Criminal Procedure Law. As soon as such a verdict is returned, the court must order the defendant examined by two psychiatric examiners chosen by the state's mental health commissioner, normally while he is held in a secure facility. After the examiners report, the court holds an initial hearing on the defendant's present mental condition, at which the district attorney must prove that he has a "dangerous mental disorder" or is "mentally ill."

The statute defines a dangerous mental disorder as a current mental illness that makes the defendant "a physical danger to himself or others." A defendant is mentally ill, in the statute's sense, when he needs in-patient psychiatric care that is essential to his welfare and his judgment is so impaired that he cannot understand that need. A finding of dangerous mental disorder leads to a commitment order of six months. A defendant found mentally ill but not dangerous is handled under the civil procedures of the Mental Hygiene Law. A defendant found to be neither is discharged.

Confinement does not end on its own when an order runs out. The commissioner must apply for a retention order before each period expires: a first retention order may run for up to one year, and later ones for up to two years each. A defendant held under a commitment or retention order may ask, within 30 days, for a rehearing and review of it.

The 2004 hearing in his case turned on the same two questions the statute sets: whether he was still mentally ill, and whether he was presently dangerous.

Rakowitz first tried to win a move in 1995. He argued at a sanity hearing before a jury that he had changed and should be transferred out of the secure hospital to a civil psychiatric center. The jurors were not persuaded, and he stayed where he was.

He tried again in 2004. That June, in State Supreme Court in Manhattan, a jury heard a new case about his current mental condition. Lawyers from the state's Mental Hygiene Legal Service represented him. The New York State attorney general's office and the Manhattan district attorney's office opposed his request. A ruling in his favor could have meant a move to a less secure psychiatric hospital or, in principle, discharge, although under state practice no forensic patient went straight from a secure hospital into the community; patients moved first to less secure facilities. Before the hearing the presiding justice explained that the jury's view would be advisory and that the court would make the final decision.

By then Rakowitz had spent 13 years in the secure hospital. He had never taken psychiatric medication, and he did not accept that he was mentally ill.

He testified himself in July 2004 and again denied the killing.

In July 2004 the jury found that he was no longer dangerous but was still mentally ill. He remained in the secure hospital.

Rakowitz never left the state's forensic system. In February 2012 he was still held in the secure forensic hospital in New York State to which he had been committed in 1991.

Rakowitz was never convicted of the death. The 1991 jury acquitted him outright of intentional murder and found him not responsible by reason of mental illness on the charge of murder with depraved indifference. The second finding did not clear him of causing the death; it held that he could not be held criminally responsible for it. He denied the killing at his trial and again in 2004, while admitting that he had struck her.

The videotaped statement he gave in September 1989 was the core of the prosecution's case. The jury that returned the 1991 verdict could not agree on whether he had tampered with physical evidence, and that count was left undecided.

Timeline

December 24, 1960: Daniel Rakowitz is born; he grows up in South Texas.

About 1985: Rakowitz is living in lower Manhattan.

Summer 1989: He and the victim are sharing a place in the East Village.

August 19, 1989: The death in the East Village.

September 16, 1989: He gives detectives a videotaped statement at the Ninth Precinct and is charged.

Early February 1991: He testifies in his own defense in State Supreme Court in Manhattan.

February 22, 1991: After nine days of deliberation, the jury finds him not guilty of intentional murder and not responsible for murder with depraved indifference by reason of mental illness; it cannot agree on tampering with physical evidence. He is committed to a secure state forensic hospital.

1995: A jury refuses his bid for a transfer to a civil psychiatric hospital.

June to July 2004: A new jury hearing in State Supreme Court in Manhattan finds him still mentally ill but no longer dangerous; he remains in the secure hospital.

February 2012: He is still held in the secure forensic hospital.